Good Idea for Weapons

I have some Quick Ideas for some new weapons

1.
Dragons Fire Bow
11-22(Marksmanship 9)
Health + 20
Energy + 5
Energy + 5 (While Using a lvl 15+ Pet)

2.
Adez Silencer (Runner Bow)
11-22(Expertise 9)
Speed + 5
Reduces Dodge Recharge

3. Icebreaker
16(Strengh)
Reduces Ice Spikes On you
+5 Energy
+5 Armour

Hope u all like
Can u rate each Weapon out of 10 please

1. 7/10
2. 4/10
3. 5/10

why 1 not beastmastery? and why 20hp? green bow or what?

2... why a runner bow? rangers are already best runners.

3... to farm ids? lolz.

First of all... Bows are 15-28 damage. Personally I dont like the last 2 weapons at all, but the first one has potential. For some greens they could make some non-max stats but with 3 mods instead of 2.

So the bow would be...

15-28dmg req9 marks
+20 health
+5 energy
+5energy (while having a level 15+ pet)

It has some potential for some cool new greens... A third mod wouldnt be great of normal weapons though. Maybe they could find a way to implement it.

ok. The 3rd one is for running droks as i get annoying when ice spikes on you of ice golems

Speed +5? Wtf does that mean? This isn't Lineage 2 or something where the speed is actually a modifiable stat, only skills alter your speed in this game o_O And Dodge isn't the only speed skill, btw :/

So...
#1: Anyone using a pet shouldn't be using a bow, if they are, they shouldn't be having energy problems..I use my Drago's Flatbow with a BM build and I do fine...
#2: Doesn't make a single bit of sense, and a bow with extra speed(assuming you made it understandable and not +5) would be unbalanced..rangers are already fast enough...
#3: Umm...no?

1. 3/10 /// completely useless (for the reasons xiaotsu already pointed) and only applyable to greens since other bows DO NOT have 3 stats.

2. 0/10 /// +5 speed DOES NOT exist in GW, sorry ^^.

3. 0/10 /// WTF?!?!?!

Later.