I just noticed this after the update, and it wasn't doing this before. Now all my guildies ask whenever anyone leaves, and then maybe leave afterwards.
This update wasn't needed, and was perfectly fine before-hand, I don't mind seeing people leave, but this is causing practically a chain reaction in my guild, that is spinning out of control.
Point is, it wasn't needed and its messing with my guild.
Guild Status now shows when people leave.
Silly Warrior
EternalTempest
Actually, people have been requesting this feature before.
Carinae
I like the update. As a guild leader, I want to know when people leave. They have a right to leave, I have a right to know about it.
Why would it bother people in any guild?
Why would it bother people in any guild?
xiaotsu
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Silly Warrior
I just noticed this after the update, and it wasn't doing this before. Now all my guildies ask whenever anyone leaves, and then maybe leave afterwards.
This update wasn't needed, and was perfectly fine before-hand, I don't mind seeing people leave, but this is causing practically a chain reaction in my guild, that is spinning out of control. Point is, it wasn't needed and its messing with my guild. |
Wtf kind of guild are you in? O_O
Point is, it was needed and you need to rethink your guild.
Sir Skullcrasher
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Carinae Dragonblood
I like the update. As a guild leader, I want to know when people leave. They have a right to leave, I have a right to know about it.
Why would it bother people in any guild? |
Lasareth
It's absolutely handy to have and i'm surprised we didn't get it earlier. Thumbs up to the development team. I had almost forgotten this was requested 
Diablo???
lol, I'm also glad for this update. I use to send messages through the guild channel without knowing that no one is left online.... 
Malice Black
It's a grand idea!
xiaotsu
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Diablo™
lol, I'm also glad for this update. I use to send messages through the guild channel without knowing that no one is left online....
|
Eviance
LMAO xiaotsu!
Anyways yeah I'm glad they put it in, there were a few that left ours and we never knew cause the list is so long we just figured they were on vacation or something. Plus it helps us to figure out if they "left" or if there was a glitch that knocked them from the roster.
Anyways yeah I'm glad they put it in, there were a few that left ours and we never knew cause the list is so long we just figured they were on vacation or something. Plus it helps us to figure out if they "left" or if there was a glitch that knocked them from the roster.
HawkofStorms
LOL. Hi Silly (fellow alliance mate here).
I don't know why TAM's having a problem with that. It is a nice feature I think. Also, there have been DOZENS of threads in Sarleaic requesting this feature to be implimented. The response has been overwhelmingly positive.
http://www.guildwarsguru.com/forum/s...e+guild+status
http://www.guildwarsguru.com/forum/s...e+guild+status
Just what I could find real fast.
Perphas if the guild leader had some sort of option to turn it off...
Even so...
I don't know why TAM's having a problem with that. It is a nice feature I think. Also, there have been DOZENS of threads in Sarleaic requesting this feature to be implimented. The response has been overwhelmingly positive.
http://www.guildwarsguru.com/forum/s...e+guild+status
http://www.guildwarsguru.com/forum/s...e+guild+status
Just what I could find real fast.
Perphas if the guild leader had some sort of option to turn it off...
Even so...
GloryFox
Quote:
|
Perphas if the guild leader had some sort of option to turn it off... Even so... |
What are you running a cult?
I actually like this feature so I can speak to the person who left and make any improvements in my 80 persons Guild that I might need to make. Large guilds like mine are hard to manage at times. Especialy when people leave for unknown reasons. Sometimes they might leave because of personalities. If something like that is true then I need to know.
Eviance
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by GloryFox
Why?
What are you running a cult? I actually like this feature so I can speak to the person who left and make any improvements in my 80 persons Guild that I might need to make. Large guilds like mine are hard to manage at times. Especialy when people leave for unknown reasons. Sometimes they might leave because of personalities. If something like that is true then I need to know. |
Although I could think of a few I wish would have left without saying anything XD
Maria The Princess
to OP: you see......if i was goin to leave a guild,i would let my friends know and get then to change guilds with me (unless they dont want to) so even without this feature, these people would still leave the guild if they followed that person, so i dont see how can this feature bother
Griff Mon
I've left a few guilds due to inactivity or just plain incompatability, and it is just common courtesy to tell someone that you are leaving and why.
bigwig
Nobodys ever happy in this game. Nobody.
Shanaeri Rynale
No one's left my guild recently for me to test this, but it makes my forums teams job a lot easier, so we can easily switch people's access from members to friends or even deny altogether.
In short it's an excellent feature. Thanks.
In short it's an excellent feature. Thanks.
generik
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Silly Warrior
I just noticed this after the update, and it wasn't doing this before. Now all my guildies ask whenever anyone leaves, and then maybe leave afterwards.
This update wasn't needed, and was perfectly fine before-hand, I don't mind seeing people leave, but this is causing practically a chain reaction in my guild, that is spinning out of control. Point is, it wasn't needed and its messing with my guild. |
Gonzo
generik speaks true.
As an officer I'm glad with the option knowing that somebody left the guild.
As an officer I'm glad with the option knowing that somebody left the guild.
S_Serpent
I very nice feature all together, you can learn from it for the benefit off the guild.
Brustow
If people going to leave your guild, they're going to do it sooner or later. Rather than blaming GW, think about why people don't want to stay.
Caleb
Great addition, thanks!
Bane of Worlds
superb idea
very useful for officers and guild leaders
very useful for officers and guild leaders
Set
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Griff Mon
I've left a few guilds due to inactivity or just plain incompatability, and it is just common courtesy to tell someone that you are leaving and why.
|
MMSDome
if its gotten to the point that it annoys you your guild has a slight problem 
tomcruisejr
this is good so youll see worthless people who are always coming, going and coming back again (and then leaving again).
Gaile Gray
It really is a much-requested addition, and as a guild leader, I know it's helpful to those of us who like to keep track of our folks. It's sad to see someone leave, and to see a message to that effect. But I do believe it's even worse to not know their status at all, not want to appear pushy in asking, or to assume they're still part of the guild when in fact they've moved elsewhere.
Hephaestus Ram
If people leave your guild when they see that someone else left,
you really don't have much of a guild.
I'm a bit of a loner, but I'll try a guild if someone asks me and they
seem to be interesting. Sadly, 9 out of 10 guilds I've been in have
zero interaction after the initial welcome. Other than people begging
for runs or free equipment, they never have any kind of interaction at
all. I have no problem with leaving that type of guild without a word
of explanation.
I have had a couple guild leaders pm me and ask why I left. While I
was impressed that they even noticed, the only reason I'd stay in
one would be because I can play the game with people I know what
to expect from. Some guild leaders seem to collect members like
cord wood, that's not for me.
Anyway... I like this feature too, it's the first thing I look at now when
I join a guild. If the invite to leave ratio is close to 1:1, I'll just pm the
person that invited me, give him back his 100gp and be on my way.
you really don't have much of a guild.
I'm a bit of a loner, but I'll try a guild if someone asks me and they
seem to be interesting. Sadly, 9 out of 10 guilds I've been in have
zero interaction after the initial welcome. Other than people begging
for runs or free equipment, they never have any kind of interaction at
all. I have no problem with leaving that type of guild without a word
of explanation.
I have had a couple guild leaders pm me and ask why I left. While I
was impressed that they even noticed, the only reason I'd stay in
one would be because I can play the game with people I know what
to expect from. Some guild leaders seem to collect members like
cord wood, that's not for me.
Anyway... I like this feature too, it's the first thing I look at now when
I join a guild. If the invite to leave ratio is close to 1:1, I'll just pm the
person that invited me, give him back his 100gp and be on my way.