Necros and Elementalists healing?

dansamy

Chasing Dragons

Join Date: May 2005

Lost in La-La Land

LFGuild

Mo/Me

As a player who has played both E/Mo as full healer and Monk primary (boon prot or healing), I can tell you that in pve E/Mo healing is just fine with an intelligent player at the helm. Will a monk heal for more? Yes. Does that automatically mean better? No.

*****Warning - Long Anecdotal Story Follows*****

A couple of nights ago, I helped my brother-in-law for the Ring of Fire. We joined a random PuG (first mistake, lol!) that consisted of 2 WaMos, R/Me, N/Mo and a Mo/E. My BIL was on a Warrior and I was on a Monk. Normaly I boon prot, but for some reason I decided to go healing for this mission. We start the mission, after adding Cynn under the party leader's mistaken belief that we were in need of a nuker in order to finish the party. We begin. Immediately after loading, the N/Mo decides he has to go right now and leaves. (I can only assume mom/wife aggro.) The group decides to continue. Fine. We set about killing Mursaat and Jades. Unfortunately, it seems some of us have serious issues staying alive even with 2 monks. Concerned, I ask the usual "are you infused?" just to make sure. Some people buy new armor and forget to infuse it. Everyone's infused. So, the group continues but now I am more closely watching my partner monk. It doesn't take long to discover the source of our problems. Ether prodigy and Phoenix. On a monk/ele. I groan inside. This is going to be a very long (and most likely failed) mission. After much trying to get the other monk to also quit using Rebirth while we're still in the middle of fighting, I lose it. I tell them all the next one to rebirth anything before the fight is finished gets no healing from me. I also tell them to leave Cynn's sorry ass perma-dead, seeing as she is 60ed and instantly dies again anyway. In response to this, the other monk, whose only healing skills seemed to be heal party and healing breeze anyway, ragequits the group. Breathing a sigh of relief, I lay down the law for the now very small group of 3 Wa/Mos, 1 R/Me and me. Anyone caught ressing Cynn gets no healing. Anyone who fights alone, dies alone. Anyone who thinks it is a good thing to aggro the whole map and bring them to me, now the only source of healing, will find himself on my personal "Do Not Heal" list. One of the WaMos wants to quit and start over. I assure him that we will indeed get through this if he is smart and listens to my instructions. Proceeding onward, we finish the mission only with another death or two on the most deeply (60ed) dp'ed person. As we're killing the last boss, I send my BIL a whisper that he owes me a soda for the headache.

I have used both of my elementalists to heal through several missions when no healers were available. I trust my healing skill as an ele/monk far more than I trust Alesia or Danika. To those who insist on only a monk primary for their healing, I say think outside the box. The monk primary will heal for more hp per energy spent than a monk secondary, but if the player running it is as dumb as a box of rocks, you're better off with that ele or necro handling the healing.

Hephaestus Ram

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Jun 2005

None

W/E

Quote:
Originally Posted by ElinoraNeSangre
Am I the only person who's met more good PvE monks than bad?

I think it's more a combination of monk wannabes wishful
thinking, and bad players trying to rationalize why they
always seem to die even when they have two monks.

There's a lot of resentment toward monks because people
are so overly dependent on them, so maybe it's a good idea
for other professions to fill in on some of the healing. But...
both the elementalist and the necro are of much more use to
a group as an elementalist and necromancer respectively
than they could be as pseudo monks.

Sir Skullcrasher

Sir Skullcrasher

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Jun 2005

California

15 over 50 [Rare]

W/Mo

I found that the henchies monks on Ring of Fire mission does a decent job of healing you. I was in a group last night with two mesmer (i was one of them) along with six henchies. Finished the mission without dying that much.