PC on a bunch of Gold shields and off hands

I'd like to see if any of these are worthwhile...thanks

protective icon
en +12 req 13 protection prayers
armor +10 vs lightning attacks

defender
armor 16 req 13 strength
health +43 while enchanted

round shield
armor 16 req 10 tactics
earth magic +1 20%

Ornate Buckler
armor 16 req 8 tactics
reduces physical dmg by 5 19% chance

skeleton shield
armor 16 req 11 tactics
health +41 while in stance

reinforced buckler
armor 16 req 13 tactics
protection prayers +1 20% chance

Ornate Buckler
armor 16 req 8 tactics
armor +9 vs plants
health +44 enchanted

Thanks...

protective icon - merch
defender - merch
round shield - merch
Ornate Buckler - merch
skeleton shield - merch
reinforced buckler - merch
Ornate Buckler - ~5k imho

1. Merch
2. Merch
3. Merch
4. Merch
5. Merch
6. Merch
7. 6-10k~ or so