Bortak's set Vs. Ghial's Staff Vs. The Nightbringer

Bortak's Bone Claw & Cesta (Prophecies)
Cold Dmg: 11-22 (Req. 9 Death)
Energy +12
HCT Death (20%)
HCT Death (20%)
Energy +5 (HP > 50%)
Death +1 (20%)

Ghail's Staff (Factions)
Dark Dmg: 11-22 (Req. 9 Death)
Energy +10
HCT Death (20%)
HSR Death (20%)
Energy +5
Death +1 (20%)

The Nightbringer (Nightfall)
Cold Dmg: 11-22 (Req. 9 Death)
Energy +10
HSR (20%)
HCT Death (20%)
HCT Death (20%)
Health +30

I'm just curious and interested to find out people's opinions on which one of these staves/set is the best choice for a Minion Master.

I'd say bortaks set because overall better nrg. even though +5 nrg^50 I rarely ever go under 50%hp. but thats just me.

I'd say bortaks set because overall better nrg. even though +5 nrg^50 I rarely ever go under 50%hp. but thats just me.

Bortak's. HCT beats HRT when it comes to Animate skills. Recharge on Fiends is 5s. BoTM is what like 5 as well? Since MM revolves around Fiends and BoTM, I see no reason to invest in recharge. HCT on Fiends tho makes hell of a lot difference, esp. when some1 else is exploiting corpses, or you face heavy interrupts. More nrg as well. And last but not least, +1DM is altho not a functional mode, the cherry on top for every MM out there.

To recap:

HCT>HRT
More nrg
+1DM

Bortak wins

+30hp for a necro is bad imo. i personally use bortaks claw and morgriff's scepter.

sorry for the double post just noticed it.