Member left the guild and it doesn't show up on status tab

1 pages Page 1
teenchi
teenchi
Lion's Arch Merchant
#1
We had an officer leave the guild last night and the status tab hasn't updated. Does this mean he deleted his account or is there a known problem?
Carth`
Carth`
Desert Nomad
#2
Arenanet decided the feature where you can see who left the guild was a bad idea, so they removed it with the big Nightfall update.

Quote:
Originally Posted by GuildWiki Notes
The guild status tab no longer displays when members leave the guild.
teenchi
teenchi
Lion's Arch Merchant
#3
Thanks for the update. Aww man, that stinks. As a guild leader, I try to catch up with the people who leave and ask them why so I know where I can improve things in the guild. What a bummer.
Qual
Qual
Krytan Explorer
#4
yea as an officer in a guild I must agree with you.
Carth`
Carth`
Desert Nomad
#5
I agree too. I used to check the Guild Status every day to see who had left. Now you just have to remember how many are in your guild and compare the number to what it last was.
Sofonisba
Sofonisba
Desert Nomad
#6
If it was detrimental to morale (people see someone leave, they wonder "what's going on here, is there something I should know??"), then perhaps it would be better to allow officers only to see members leave the guild.

We have one member who guild hops quite a bit, looking for Luxon guilds to donate faction to, etc, but he always comes back. I'm sure it confuses the other members who don't know the story.
Syndren
Syndren
Lion's Arch Merchant
#7
I completely agree with the above post. Please make this into a petition (ask a mod to move to the suggestions place) so I can
/sign

EDIT: gah stupid me.... for people who are wondering the petition is here:
http://www.guildwarsguru.com/forum/s...29#post2173229