A neat item to offer, as a SECOND choice, either for your 1st anniversary or perhaps your 2nd or 3rd whatever, would be an item that can be added to ANY weapon, making it a require 9. This addon would not be tradeable or resable. It would be an alternate choice. Some people get a pet and say "oh, nice.. maybe I can sell it.." While others love their pets. I just think a secondary choice would be nice.
To recap this would be a weapon, staff, or wand, rod, etc addon. That changes say req 13, to req 9. Now, the catch is you cannot sell the mod OR a modded weapon. It would be considered customized. (this way people cannot get a rare sword with high req, and make it req9, and then try to sell it sell for a few trillion gold LOL).
Anniversary gift suggestion
Enchanted Warrior