They're individually cheap, but people have big stacks of consumables. Values add up.
Here's what I've come up with:
Spiked Egg Nog -- 300 gold
Things that can be turned into Spiked Egg Nog -- proportional
Old-style (peppermint) candy canes -- 1000 or a little below before people started worrying about this Wintersday
New-style (lift 15% DP only) candy canes -- ??? Is anybody picking these up? The price "should" be 1/3 - 1/4 of the price of old-style candy canes, and similar to that of Spiked Egg Nog
Regular Egg Nog, Hunter's Ale -- 150
Candy Cane Shards -- not strictly speaking a consumable, but what the hey -- in their annual price crash. Passing through 100 gold around now.
F