02 Feb 2007 at 08:33 - 5
The Apocrypha should be pretty easy - most likely there is a build issue. Not flaming or anything. I started with Prophecies, it allows a much shallower learning curve than Nightfall. I do not know how well I would have done starting in one of the other games. Especially now that some of the balance
has to come from those of us with tons of skills unlocked and thousands of hours in game.
Anyway, post your build. Tell us you primary class and secondary class, your attribute point spread, and your skills. If this is anywhere decent your tactics shouldn't matter that much yet - a little while longer before the whole skill thing really kicks in (and it definitely does). Right now everything should just die.
For example:
I'm a Dervish/Warrior
I have 15 in scythe mastery, 11 earth prayers, and 11 mysticism. Normally for telling others their build you would include how these numbers happen (such as the 15 is from a superior scythe and a head piece and would be written as 15 (11-3-1) however, we do not really need to know it as we are not trying to duplicate your build).
My skills are: Reapers Sweep[e], Victorious Sweep, Wild Blow, Heart of Fury, Armor of Sanctity, Mystic Regeneration, Conviction, Sunspear Rebirth Signet.
Most likely you will not have an elite (what the [e] means).
After that, we may need to see what heroes you are using and their build - for example Armor of Sanctity is pretty much worthless in my build above. It reduces damage from foes that are suffering from conditions and I apply no conditions (well, except for a few seconds when Heart of Fury ends) - however this is a build for a team with a Searing Flames ele and a "They're on fire" paragon - lots of burning and mobs with conditions so it makes sense. But, at this point, you should be able to go through the Apocrypha if you have a decent build.
And, lastly, this is the internet be prepared for some flaming. I use Reaper's Sweep as my elite, many here tell me I am an idiot for using it. However, for my play style it does consistently more damage over time than their advice. There will be reasonable people respond and some good advice come out of it.
In my experience GW took a little different way of thinking about builds and such. Once you get on the right track all will be well. More than likely I would guess you are spreading out too thin - at the least it was what I tried to do at first. Too many options and it is not obvious why it will not work at first.