Is it a bug or a 'feature' that any touch range spell ignores prot spirit?
from the wiki
[skill]Protective Spirit[/skill][skill]Enfeebling Touch[/skill][skill]Star Burst[/skill]
and the 'official wiki'
PS:Enchantment Spell. For 5..19..23 seconds, target ally cannot lose more than 10% max Health due to damage from a single attack or Spell.
enfeebling Touch:Skill. Target touched foe loses 5..41..50 Health and suffers from Weakness for 5..17..20 seconds.
(we can see why for enfeebling touch, as it a 'skill' and doesnt deal 'damage'
Star Burst: Elite Spell. Target touched foe and all nearby foes are struck for 7..91..112 fire damage. If more than one foe was struck, you lose 5 energy.
but again here, inconsistent... deals damage, and is a spell
so why is it BOTH skills go right through prot spirit?
touch spells and prot spirit
lennymon
Enko
from the wording, yeah looks like skills aren't protected or health loss/steal.
Starburst should be reduced by prot spirit and its weird that its not.
Starburst should be reduced by prot spirit and its weird that its not.
lennymon
that's what I thought too, I tried it again targetting the sickened servants (ele) in minister Cho's estate mission (there's one immidiately following the menagerie. I pin everything back, swap to 55 armor, get PS and aggro. Servant runs in, starburst, bam dead. There's no enchant removal, just goes right through it.
Get this though, [skill]Vile Touch[/skill] IS reduced... yes it's damage but it's a skill, not an attack or spell.
Edit nvm the 'official wiki' has vile touch as a spell now... which would make it exactly the same as star burst.
Get this though, [skill]Vile Touch[/skill] IS reduced... yes it's damage but it's a skill, not an attack or spell.
Edit nvm the 'official wiki' has vile touch as a spell now... which would make it exactly the same as star burst.
Jedi Battousai
Loss of health (i.e vampiric touch and the like) are not stopped by prot spirit. I don't see why Star Burst wouldn't be since it's straight damage. the Star Burst could be a bug, the loss of life/life steal is not.
Yichi
Lifesteal is armor ignoring and will negate Prot Spirit. Vamp gaze, touch, vamp strike, etc... (anything that says target loses life and not "takes damage") will go right through prot spirit. Star Burst should not go through it however.
Raven Darkbringer
I dunno but I tell you what, I LOVE to touch
lennymon
yeah, allready know about life steal, not even an issue here.
tested: lightning touch, 'prottable'
tested: lightning touch, 'prottable'
bluwolf
Is it maybe because your getting hit with Star Bursts AoE? Technically that is neither a spell or an attack. Just an idea.
Zui
Life stealing ignores all Prot, as Prot acts on "damage" and life stealing is not "damage."
As for Starburst, it shouldn't go through Protective Spirit. Are you sure you're testing this correctly? If you are, please post it as a bug (with screenshots) at the bug forum.
As for Starburst, it shouldn't go through Protective Spirit. Are you sure you're testing this correctly? If you are, please post it as a bug (with screenshots) at the bug forum.
HawkofStorms
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by lennymon
that's what I thought too, I tried it again targetting the sickened servants (ele) in minister Cho's estate mission (there's one immidiately following the menagerie. I pin everything back, swap to 55 armor, get PS and aggro. Servant runs in, starburst, bam dead. There's no enchant removal, just goes right through it.
Get this though, [skill]Vile Touch[/skill] IS reduced... yes it's damage but it's a skill, not an attack or spell. Edit nvm the 'official wiki' has vile touch as a spell now... which would make it exactly the same as star burst. |
Most likely, you were hit by a phyical attack that striped enchantment with the Afflicited Necros spamming Order of the Aposty (which can cause enchantments to be stripped but won't show up in the "reccently taken damage" bar since its done indirrectly). You have to hide behind walls and kill the necros first to eliminate that.
As for the others, shadow (enfeebling touch) and life drain damage (like vampiric touch) are not reduced. Vile touch is reduced because it deals cold damage.
You can always tell if ps will reduce the damage by the wording of the skill. If it says "target is struck for/takes xx damage" it can be reduced. If it says "target loses xx health" it bypasses protection spells like ps.
Curse You
Best way to test is with a good old Guild Scrimmage. Unfortunately, non of my guild mates are on right now.
ichigo_panty
If you are solo-ing, then Starburst will be reduced.
For PS to be active, you must be the target of the spell or attack.
If Starburst isn't used on you but you are in the aoe range, you will not be protected.
The aoe damage is not consider a spell.
Notice the wording of PS. For it to work, you must be the target of the spell or attack. Therefore, if a firestorm was fired on your friend and you happen to be in the aoe range of the firestorm, PS won't work.
The 2 things that negate PS are Life Steal and AoE.
If there is an error somewhere, please correct me. Thank.
For PS to be active, you must be the target of the spell or attack.
If Starburst isn't used on you but you are in the aoe range, you will not be protected.
The aoe damage is not consider a spell.
Notice the wording of PS. For it to work, you must be the target of the spell or attack. Therefore, if a firestorm was fired on your friend and you happen to be in the aoe range of the firestorm, PS won't work.
The 2 things that negate PS are Life Steal and AoE.
If there is an error somewhere, please correct me. Thank.
lennymon
ok... I figured it out...
In the *mission* its not getting reduced, likely due to the aoe effect... you are correct. In the explorable it's reduced.
In the *mission* its not getting reduced, likely due to the aoe effect... you are correct. In the explorable it's reduced.
Enko
really? hmm learn something new every day i guess. didn't know that aoe wasn't covered by protective spirit.