Originally Posted by Zinger314
And for the 10 seconds each one of those skills are on recharge you...?
|
Edit: I've never been to the Deep :|
Njaiguni Blaze
Originally Posted by Zinger314
And for the 10 seconds each one of those skills are on recharge you...?
|
arcanemacabre
Gregslot
Originally Posted by lutz
Who cares what build you're running? If you're playing with friends and having fun, then that's the most important part.
Hell, I've run a bunch of cookie-cutter builds in DoA [you know, 1 OF Tank, 3 Nukers, 3 Monks, 1 BiP] and did City in 45 minutes on HM. It was fast. It was fun. Why? You played with the PEOPLE that made it fun. We'd screw up and have a laugh on vent, and the such, but for the most part we worked. This argument is stupid. |
Njaiguni Blaze
Originally Posted by Gregslot
I'll be creating a thread later to discuss the build, some people seemed to be very interested in this idea
|
Zinger314
Originally Posted by arcanemacabre
Now, what would you consider more fun (since this is a game, and should be solely about F-U-N): the same old builds, killing the same old predictable mobs, for the same old (but on very rare occasion decent) loot - OR - new, unique builds in random areas (some easy, some not-so-easy), for the sake of actually playing and not just grabbing loot? If you choose the former, enjoy your cookie-cutter builds. If you choose the latter, stop torturing yourself with cookie-cutter builds just because people say they're the best! (which I believe is what the OP is basically saying)
|
fenix
DFrost
Cebe
Originally Posted by Skyy High
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Zinger314
And Njaiguni Blaze's "holier than thou" attitude isn't negative?
|
allience
Cebe
Originally Posted by allience
remember there are different types of ppl and u can't say something is fun for everyone.
|
KTBFFH
greenchylde
Originally Posted by Zinger314
Would you rather complete The Deep in 2 hours with a well-crafted group or complete the Deep in 5+ hours with a lackadascial group?
|
Bryant Again
Originally Posted by allience
i think the thread maker is trying to label his vision of fun to everyone.
i understand that some ppl enjoy spending twice the time on a mission by playing with different builds. i know that there are ppl who care more for the experience of something than the reward. but don't try to apply that notion to everyone. for example if i were obliged to play that way, i'd just look for a different game. my idea of fun is efficiency. if i can do something in 1 hour for the same reward as doing it in 2, i'll have a lot of fun being efficient. i seriously enjoy getting something with the least amount of effort and many other ppl feel the same way too. remember there are different types of ppl and u can't say something is fun for everyone. |
Ouchie
rohara
reetkever
lacasner
Ouchie
Originally Posted by reetkever
Well, Urgoz and the Deep aren't as hard, but if you mean stuff like DoA, cookie cutter builds can't be avoided. If A-Net made monsters stronger instead of cheating, this could've been prevented, but against cheating monsters with annoying area effects, not many build options remain.
The problem with the Factions Elite missions, is that they take lots of time. People want to do the missions as fast as possible, and the better your skillset/weaponset is, the faster you can kill monsters. |
Corinthian
Perkunas
Originally Posted by Zinger314
It's ArenaNet's fault that the cookie-cutters exist, not the players'. |
MSecorsky
Originally Posted by Njaiguni Blaze
Hi, lemme introduce myself: I am Mr. Cookiecutter Hater.
I enjoy FoW alot and use my main char there, my mesmer. Usually I am the only mesmer around in the european server. Before I got my KoaBD title, I hardly got invited or got ppl to join, but I must say I am more useful than any Renewal Nuker, SS or Tank around there. Reason why? 3 skills: Hex Eater Vortex, Shatter Hex and Backfire. I don't know if you'd like to know some builds for the mesmer, if so, I'd be happy to give some. Usually you can't go wrong with the Domination Line, Res Chant and Auspicious Incantion in your build. Also, if you're doing one of these lite areas again, gimme a whisper. My IGN is Nolani Blaze. Greets, a fellow cookiemonster (I eat cookicutters) |
mazik
Originally Posted by Zinger314
It's ArenaNet's fault that the cookie-cutters exist, not the players'.
|
Gregslot
Yichi
Originally Posted by allience
i think the thread maker is trying to label his vision of fun to everyone.
i understand that some ppl enjoy spending twice the time on a mission by playing with different builds. i know that there are ppl who care more for the experience of something than the reward. but don't try to apply that notion to everyone. for example if i were obliged to play that way, i'd just look for a different game. my idea of fun is efficiency. if i can do something in 1 hour for the same reward as doing it in 2, i'll have a lot of fun being efficient. i seriously enjoy getting something with the least amount of effort and many other ppl feel the same way too. remember there are different types of ppl and u can't say something is fun for everyone. |
englitdaudelin
Originally Posted by Zinger314
Would you rather complete The Deep in 2 hours with a well-crafted group or complete the Deep in 5+ hours with a lackadascial group?
|
Tiny Killer
Originally Posted by Zinger314
Prove it.
|
Originally Posted by Zinger314
Give an example of a build and a scenario where a non-cookie cutter build would be, beyond a shadow of a doubt, superior to a cookie cutter build.
|
Amy Awien
Originally Posted by Corinthian
Why oh why oh why should or would anyone bother to use anything else than the very best and fastest one available?
|
zwei2stein
Originally Posted by Tiny Killer
You think you can demand things of me? I find that very humorous.
Based on many of your previous posts, I do not have enough time in this life to explain to you how a non cookie-cutter build would work. You will have to learn game mechanics from another source. |
Originally Posted by Amy Awien
But, as in the past, the current 'cookie-cutter' build is not the best. It never is.
And what is the best build? There is no objective and universal set of criteria that would enable one to compare builds and determine which build is better then another, let alone which is 'the best'. |
Gregslot
Amy Awien
Originally Posted by zwei2stein
Thats it, cookie haters are quite strange bunch - they praise builds for being effective and cool because they are not used by anyone, but once theese builds get recognized for their power and widely used they become hated asap.
|
Gregslot
Originally Posted by Amy Awien
Well, no, not exactly. There aren't any 'cookie' haters, just people who enjoy playing around with different builds and with enough inspiration and creativity to experiment with builds themselves. And they do not hate cookies, they just don't like it when the uninspired cookie lusers expect them to use these overused cookies again and again and again. That is just so boring, like chewing gum for too long.
|
Mylon
Originally Posted by Vyral
I still find it amusing to take my Ritualist down to the Deep to try to join a PuG group. It is almost invariably impossible. Even after posting the 6 Man Deep build on guildwiki (now, in unedited form on PvXwiki) I still couldn't get anybody to take a ritualist seriously down there. Yet my guild doesn't ever run without one. Today I was told by every PuG in a team I joined that my warrior needed Recall. I was trying a new trick to replace Recall and it works _flawlessly_. Yet the only reason that I didn't get booted from the team was that I was the leader of it. Our current 9 man HM build (still being optimized) uses a Ritualist _and_ a Paragon. Try finding a paragon in any other group. Yet we still make the run as fast or faster than any build containing elementalists (we don't use any) and at the beginning Room 2 clears itself _without_ needing to be rescued. The difference between our build and the cookie cutter builds is synergy. With synergy comes efficiency and speed. And its a lot of fun to play.
|
Superdarth
Originally Posted by Gregslot
I dont know about you, but i feel unconfortable by seeing people giving this bad image of the game for newcomers.
|
Yol
Gregslot
Bryant Again
Pwny Ride
Njaiguni Blaze
Originally Posted by Bryant Again
Cookie-cut builds are proof that Guild Wars PvE takes little to no skill to beat. That's my only real complaint against them.
|
Rockby Quickfoot
Krazi Bastid