As seen by the number of people who used All Chat as a channel for trading, with the upcoming diligence, there needs to be a more efficient manner in which people can handle sales. Since we now know the in game auction house is not going to be coming, here is my suggestion.
Have a "Sell" channel where people can post goods, and a "Buy" channel where people can post what it is they want to buy.
Secondly, it is my opinion that the red is a lot harder to read, especially when chat is going by so fast. If there was anyway the two channels could have something that stands out a little bit more, that would be great.
2 channels for trade, and color of chat
qwe4rty
Splatter Mcnasty
/sign /sign /sign /sign
This is a brilliant idea! With this change, I could go into a town and turn off all the Sell chat, allowing me to only see people who are looking to buy something, and vice versa...
This is a brilliant idea! With this change, I could go into a town and turn off all the Sell chat, allowing me to only see people who are looking to buy something, and vice versa...
Twinsoul
It's a wonderful idea, but I can see people simply expanding their spamming to ANOTHER channel, in addition to the ones that are already used.
Kool Pajamas
I'll /sign to this though most spamming is selling so I dont know how much it will really help with the spam in one chat channel.
Majestic
/sign and /sign one more time
Hyper.nl
/signed
I just hope that not everyone will shut down trade chat, otherwise it gets useless anyways. But since that's not the case with th current channel, it think it will be fine.
I just hope that not everyone will shut down trade chat, otherwise it gets useless anyways. But since that's not the case with th current channel, it think it will be fine.
khaeti
I actually suggested the idea of separate buy/sell trade channels and different colors for them when Gaile Gray was in Kamadan one day about a month ago, but I don't know that she even saw it with all the spamming of "Say Hi to So-and-So" going on...all the silly spam when Gaile is around makes it kind of hard to ask questions or make decent suggestions.
freekedoutfish
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by qwe4rty
As seen by the number of people who used All Chat as a channel for trading, with the upcoming diligence, there needs to be a more efficient manner in which people can handle sales. Since we now know the in game auction house is not going to be coming, here is my suggestion.
Have a "Sell" channel where people can post goods, and a "Buy" channel where people can post what it is they want to buy. Secondly, it is my opinion that the red is a lot harder to read, especially when chat is going by so fast. If there was anyway the two channels could have something that stands out a little bit more, that would be great. |
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Hyper.nl
A market zone is not the solution. As trader I don't only want to trade with other traders, but also hope that bypassers will read my trade message and make the trade if they want. If course, I only use the trade channel for my WTB/WTS messages, but many don't do this.
|
By doing that, they think they are loosing potential customers. But instead of respecting the fact we dont want to trade, they think its acceptable to ram their trade messages down our throats in the local chat.
Traders will always use the local chat, because they know not everyone listens to the trade ones.
Div
Would be nice to have separate buy and sell channels, but how many people are actually going to respect that?
karunpav
/signed, but yeah, I agree with holy. I doubt many people will use it properly, even with the stricter enforcement
deadman_uk
/signed completely!!
Bad Abbot
The reason people use All Chat to trade is to advertise to a wider audience. Spamming trade messages in All Chat works, otherwise the practice wouldn't be so widespread and rampant. Your solution merely splits the existing chat.
Sellers started spamming in All Chat because players turned off the trade channel. Now people turn off the public channel, too. Adding more channels to spam "WTS" won't solve anything.
Sellers started spamming in All Chat because players turned off the trade channel. Now people turn off the public channel, too. Adding more channels to spam "WTS" won't solve anything.
Patrick Smit
/signed, but i have to agree with the people above that the mentality of some will not be able to deal with such a "high" degree of organization.
Thomas.knbk
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Bad Abbot
The reason people use All Chat to trade is to advertise to a wider audience.
|
GUESS WHAT MORON! PEOPLE CLOSE TRADE CHAT BECAUSE THEY'RE NOT INTERESTED IN TRADING.
pisses me off
Aera Lure
To help with fast scrolling text when buying I simply scroll upwards a bit. Pauses the text flowing by and then I scroll down and scan through it at a more reasonable pace. I never miss anything on channel that way. I'm sure most people do that, but when I read the OP's comment about the text going by so fast being hard to read, I began to wonder.
As for the split into two channels, no I suppose I wont sign onto that, logical as it sounds. Already have enough people with lack of common sense to simply use the trade channel for WTS/WTB and, no, I dont want to make it more "complicated."
One thing I would like to see though is an adjustment to the display of the Trade channel text. A nice thing about the All Channel is the names are in yellow and the text is in white. On a two line message that wraps, its FAR easier to scan that quickly because you have the name in yellow as your visual key point to where the next message begins. Like a paragraph indent - works the same way.
I suggest taking the names as displayed in Trade channel and making them bolder and a bit brighter. Currently they are not bold and are the same color as the message text on channel and it is therefore a bit harder to scan. It would do wonders for quick scanning of the channel and I have no idea why a designer long ago didnt do that...
As for the split into two channels, no I suppose I wont sign onto that, logical as it sounds. Already have enough people with lack of common sense to simply use the trade channel for WTS/WTB and, no, I dont want to make it more "complicated."
One thing I would like to see though is an adjustment to the display of the Trade channel text. A nice thing about the All Channel is the names are in yellow and the text is in white. On a two line message that wraps, its FAR easier to scan that quickly because you have the name in yellow as your visual key point to where the next message begins. Like a paragraph indent - works the same way.
I suggest taking the names as displayed in Trade channel and making them bolder and a bit brighter. Currently they are not bold and are the same color as the message text on channel and it is therefore a bit harder to scan. It would do wonders for quick scanning of the channel and I have no idea why a designer long ago didnt do that...
stocksmd
From someone that is having a hard time reading thru the trade channel. My suggestions to ANET is to use the code they put in for WTB and WTS flags going directly into trade channel to color code them in two different colors. Then you would have three different colors in the trade channel:
Red/Pink - People who do not want to use the standard WTB/WTS notation
Color 1 - WTB Posts
Color 2 - WTS Posts
Don't know how simple this would be but a new tab would not be needed.
Thanks for the consideration.
Red/Pink - People who do not want to use the standard WTB/WTS notation
Color 1 - WTB Posts
Color 2 - WTS Posts
Don't know how simple this would be but a new tab would not be needed.
Thanks for the consideration.
Dark-NighT
/SIGNED, seriously that would help a lot, and at certain times a day there are quite a lot of buyers, most of them get ignored or their message doesnt stand out with the WTS spam, i also agree on a color change, this color we have now is horrible when running in kaineng center to your storage, the texture of the floor is somewhat in the same color as the trade chat.
A buy and a Sell channel, ohh we could use that, it doesnt matter if people turn it off, only people that are trading and want to buy something without spamming wtb have them on anyway, like i do. its that simple i want something i turn on trade chat, when im done its off.
One of the better ideas about trading.
Again /signed
A buy and a Sell channel, ohh we could use that, it doesnt matter if people turn it off, only people that are trading and want to buy something without spamming wtb have them on anyway, like i do. its that simple i want something i turn on trade chat, when im done its off.
One of the better ideas about trading.
Again /signed
Div
They should just let us choose the color for the different chats instead of having predefined ones. That'd solve a lot of other complaints on this forum (about how they hate reading pink trade text and white text is cooler).
Yawgmoth
Even with major visual improvements, trading based only on spamming a certain channel is the most primitive and time consuming way to do it. With the current state of the market it wouldn't help much.
But anyway,
/signed, because this is an improvement and any improvement is good
although i know they could do more if they only wanted.
But anyway,
/signed, because this is an improvement and any improvement is good
although i know they could do more if they only wanted.
MithranArkanere
Pretty useless.
WTB and WTS are english only.
In diffenrent languages, different starting tags are used.
Two trade channels is a better way.
One to sell, one to buy.
WTB and WTS are english only.
In diffenrent languages, different starting tags are used.
Two trade channels is a better way.
One to sell, one to buy.
Diddy bow
/signed for seperate buy/sell and perhaps keep the current as a "general trade" channel. Also give the new ones wtb and wts as defaut example
Some Wammo:WTS:gold sword!.
somthing like that. I suppose it could be a little complex but easy to get used to.
Some Wammo:WTS:gold sword!.
somthing like that. I suppose it could be a little complex but easy to get used to.
Yawgmoth
Just think of the potential abuse of having 2 separate channels!
"Some Wammo: (WTB):====SELLING PeRFeCT GREEN Something====="
As selling to people who WTB is far more efficient than selling through spamming your own WTS, I expect lots of people who came to the town to sell their crap to have the (WTS) channel disabled, because of the scrolling speeed. Spamming your WTS on the WTB channel would reach more potential buyers, just like spamming it on (!All) chat.
"Some Wammo: (WTB):====SELLING PeRFeCT GREEN Something====="
As selling to people who WTB is far more efficient than selling through spamming your own WTS, I expect lots of people who came to the town to sell their crap to have the (WTS) channel disabled, because of the scrolling speeed. Spamming your WTS on the WTB channel would reach more potential buyers, just like spamming it on (!All) chat.
Yol
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Bad Abbot
The reason people use All Chat to trade is to advertise to a wider audience. Spamming trade messages in All Chat works, otherwise the practice wouldn't be so widespread and rampant
|
stocksmd
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by MithranArkanere
Pretty useless.
WTB and WTS are english only. In diffenrent languages, different starting tags are used. Two trade channels is a better way. One to sell, one to buy. |
Two trade channels can be abused. [But not totaly against - easier to read]
Linking the buy and sell tags to colors would guarantee the post was color coded properly [and multiple colors would greatly help the reading of the posts].
Although there would be a few idiots
to use "WTB WTS ......." posts,so ANET might need to set rules similar to enforcment they just started.