Site Suggestions from forum users and fans

Lord Feathers

Lord Feathers

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Jan 2007

ROAR - Rangers of Ascalon Return

R/P

Well so this thread actually goes in the right place and gets what it is intended to do done I've started this discussion so folks can come forward with complaints and suggestions on how to improve the site / forums in general. Much of this is more then likely done in " Staff Only " areas or through private PM's but I know there are folks out there with some constructive ideas / complaints that would help this site and its staff. I'll start by the two biggest areas I find fault with.

1.) Site Speed - This is currently being worked on according to the admin but is probably turning off a lot of users to the site.

2.) Forums - There is way too much whinning and flaming in these forums. Now with the size of these forums and the vast number of posts there has already been suggested the idea of a ZERO TOLERENCE on flaming. Honestly this should be implemented. If the only thing in the post is a jab at starting a flame war is it policy to ban that user ? I think this would greatly help the moderators myself.

Discussion of " Not liking the way something is " this is great it helps with ideas and in making the game better at times. GURU and the community has in fact been listened to at times with some of the suggestions, but these posts need to be moderated toward a constructive criticism and not simply a bitch fest. Sorry about the cursing but that's exactly what it boils down to and not allowing this degenration in threads with a few warnings or perhaps bans in my opinion would increase and not decrease the forum users and help some of your MODs with the head aches that come with that job.

3.) Keeping the lights on - Every site costs something be it money or time to run. Porn or the advertisment of cheats for any game exspecially GW is in poor tatse. Your Elite Program - earns folks a few perks but what exactly do those drawings earn you ? If you've given out something really neat include that in your description. It's probably not the best idea since this is motivation by GREED but it might land the site more money to help it run and I have no idea what that entails this is simply a suggestion. Does the site have to meet a certain amount to run each year or period ? I know the adds placed on the site probably help with that but is there a gap that has to be filled ?

a. ) Maybe open up something in ventari's corner and advertise there for your upgraded users showing what could be won.

Fan Site - Good point brought up by Inde that no matter what type of site one has there will always been complaining. People will come to the site because of Guild Wars and the forums and even the advertisments should reflect that. You want discussion in those boards and you want them active it will move your ability to gain advertisers if this is how the site runs through money gained there. I feel that it should be moderated though to a point where Fans and customers ( advertisers ) alike see a site and forum boards that are a TOOL and ASSET to the game and not something that looks like Recess is out. This will move both the site woes and forums woes forward.

This is just my two cents worth and I would happily discuss anything else folks can think of to help make things better.

Malice Black

Site Legend

Join Date: Oct 2005

Nothing wrong with this forum. Flaming etc is just part of forum life, it gets dealt with when needed. Flaming is down now, compared to a while back.

Trakata

Trakata

Crimson King

Join Date: Jun 2006

Resplendent Makuun

Song of the Forsaken

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lord Feathers
Porn or the advertisment of cheats for any game exspecially GW is in poor tatse. Not really sure what this refers to. Guru sponsors no pornographic ads that I've ever seen. If you're referring to the porn spammers we get, we have absolutely NO tolerance for it, and delete all such threads and ban the spam bots as soon as we see them.

Elementer Masta

Elementer Masta

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Aug 2005

Texas

Leet Pwnzorxz of Pwnington [PWND]

P/

In my opinion, the only thing this forum is in dire need of, is a search engine that doesn't suck.

Bowman Artemis

Bowman Artemis

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Jan 2006

Gold Coast, Australia.

Overclockers Australia [OCAU]

Search and a mod team built to ensure that there is always someone available (think time zones) to deal with porn spammers and gold sellers etc.

Malice Black

Site Legend

Join Date: Oct 2005

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bowman Artemis
Search and a mod team built to ensure that there is always someone available (think time zones) to deal with porn spammers and gold sellers etc. Never happen.

This isn't a job, we don't have to be here 24/7. I certainly would not mod if I was required to be on at a certain time, for a certain length of time. I do this on my own free will, if it becomes like a job, I'd quit, along with 99% of the other mods. Then GL with this forum without mods, you don't realize how much work goes into keeping this place running.

As for gold seller spam, it is hardly offensive, and porn spam threads can been seen from a mile off. Neither of these threads ever have to be open by a user, yet people do, then complain about it.

Bowman Artemis

Bowman Artemis

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Jan 2006

Gold Coast, Australia.

Overclockers Australia [OCAU]

Quote:
Originally Posted by Malice Black
Never happen.

This isn't a job, we don't have to be here 24/7. I certainly would not mod if I was required to be on at a certain time, for a certain length of time. I do this on my own free will, if it becomes like a job, I'd quit, along with 99% of the other mods. Then GL with this forum without mods, you don't realize how much work goes into keeping this place running.

As for gold seller spam, it is hardly offensive, and porn spam threads can been seen from a mile off. Neither of these threads ever have to be open by a user, yet people do, then complain about it. Malice,

I wasn't criticising the current moderation team, I don't expect you (or anyone else) to be here 24/7, but this is a suggestion thread. I was giving my view of an ideal situation. I really do appreciate all the work that the GWG team put into the site and I understand that, being a voluntary position, there won't always be someone around.

Regarding the porn spam threads, it's mainly when I'm reading through a proper thread and I come across a post like that that is the most offensive.

I'm not sure what criteria GWG uses in selecting their moderators, I was just adding my $0.02 regarding geolocation of the different administrators/moderators, I didn't intend to say that "x must be on at y times or else" but rather "It might be a good idea to recruit people from various places in the world so that there is at least one person on most of the time". Thinking back on it, this is probably how it's set up, but I thought I'd add it in anyway.

-Dan.

EDIT: Looking back on my earlier post, I did word it badly. My apologies.

Inde

Site Contributor

Join Date: Dec 2004

Actually, we have many euros and US on the mod team. We should have coverage at all hours. During early morning it may take a bit longer, but I've see some pretty bad threads shut down within an hour so that leads me to believe we are adequately looked after even it's 4am in the morning where I am.

We currently have people on staff from the netherlands, singapore, hong kong, poland, us, UK, canada and more. If you think you see a problem though please please let me know what times you feel may be lacking and the forum. Thanks!

Malice Black

Site Legend

Join Date: Oct 2005

Thats because 4am your time is around 10am my time :P And I spend far too much time here.

We do pretty much have 24/7 coverage, however most super mods are US based, which means some threads will take time to disappear if a section mod isn't available.

Age

Age

Hall Hero

Join Date: Jul 2005

California Canada/BC

STG Administrator

Mo/

I would suggest a PvE party build section or team build forum like those in the Gladiator Forum.I know there is PvX but some of those are to great so it would be good for those who play roles post some good team builds.