Better Soul Reaping

Here's a Better one.

Soul Reaping
-For each 2 ranks, You gain 1 energy whenever a Creature Dies within you're Area(Ward Range).

Why not this one?
Anyway in the old soul reaping you gain energy only every 15 minutes and at max you can gain 48 energy.
While this one you can gain 8 energy per each dead creatures so in a party their are 6-8 creatures you can gain 48-64 energy.
But you can't kill a party immediatly so lets say their were 3 monsters killed so thats 24 energy. But you cast hexes and etc so if you're a hexer you might just spend at least 15-25 energy and if you're an MM you may spend 30-45 energy.
So what do you think^^?
But I feel theirs something wrong with this nvm I still think this is btter^^!

What if your not a minion master...
Yeah... that'd be great... i.. don't have any creatures.
I think Soul Reaoing is fine how it is, when stuff dies you get energy, i can't see how its broken or why it'd need fixing.
/not signed

I think Soul Reaping should the Monk's primary attribute, in all fairness they do need the mana.

.......-_-

Or, they could just learn to manage their energy....

Why does Soul Reaping need improving again? Its already the best energy management in the game and coincidentely has access to 1 of the best energy management skills in the game too (Signet of Lost Souls).

I'm sure it's 15 seconds and not minutes.

Exept expertise but you cant really compare them .

Im for the "just remove energy from spirits" approach. It punishes those who abuse soul reaping and deosnt hurt those who use it "properly".

Then again Like Evilsod says its fine the way it is.

/notsigned
I find soul reaping to be just dandy.