Right now, completing a book will give you 2,500 reputation points. So basically, completing 18 dungeons or 16 mission-like quests is worth 2,500 exp each? That's a little cheap. I think 5,000 should be given for the hero's handbook, maybe 10,000 for the dungeons, or 7,500. The current values are just too low, doing a huge amount of work like that should get you a decent reward.
Edit: Why this matters:
See, right now the R5 requirement for armor is controversial. Some argue that it should require effort to max armor, others argue that grinding random monsters is boring and not guild wars. If this was implemented, there would be two reasonable ways to get armor:
1. Go around killing things (current way, still more profitable)
2. Beat the story a few times and clear the dungeons (not as profitable, but not grind)
If anything, 2 would require more work then just running around killing things, and give less profit. However, it would give a reasonable alternative to grinding for titles, making everybody happy.
Make the books worth more!
Series
Azael Durge
you've obviosly not though of how this will effect the soci-economics of said quest have you?
Series
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Azael Durge
you've obviosly not though of how this will effect the soci-economics of said quest have you?
|
mazey vorstagg
/signed
I love doing the dungeons but when Reagar's crazy cloning lab gives you 3000 points for it alone it doesn't quite make sense for the book to only give you 2500 points towards rep.
I love doing the dungeons but when Reagar's crazy cloning lab gives you 3000 points for it alone it doesn't quite make sense for the book to only give you 2500 points towards rep.
Phoenix Tears
So, when I complete now my Story and my Dungeon Book and give them to the npcs for them, i get only 2500 Rep Points per book ?
To all races or only to the one race, that I give the book to?
When this is really all, then I'm disappointed from Anet, being so uncreative to give us players not something better for doing all the stuff, then only reputation ...
--------
I hope really, Anet will implement in future a lot more of those books, they are an interesting new (old) feature, which can be used for very much different things.
I want to see for example a Bestiary-Book ^^
To all races or only to the one race, that I give the book to?
When this is really all, then I'm disappointed from Anet, being so uncreative to give us players not something better for doing all the stuff, then only reputation ...
--------
I hope really, Anet will implement in future a lot more of those books, they are an interesting new (old) feature, which can be used for very much different things.
I want to see for example a Bestiary-Book ^^
MirkoTeran
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Series
Right now, completing a book will give you 2,500 reputation points. So basically, completing 18 dungeons or 16 mission-like quests is worth 2,500 exp each? That's a little cheap. I think 5,000 should be given for the hero's handbook, maybe 10,000 for the dungeons, or 7,500. The current values are just too low, doing a huge amount of work like that should get you a decent reward.
|
Series
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Phoenix Tears
So, when I complete now my Story and my Dungeon Book and give them to the npcs for them, i get only 2500 Rep Points per book ?
To all races or only to the one race, that I give the book to? When this is really all, then I'm disappointed from Anet, being so uncreative to give us players not something better for doing all the stuff, then only reputation ... -------- I hope really, Anet will implement in future a lot more of those books, they are an interesting new (old) feature, which can be used for very much different things. I want to see for example a Bestiary-Book ^^ |
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by MirkoTeran
So, your next suggestion will be so ectos drop in full stack since going in UW for just 1 is not interesting?
|
Bad troll is bad.
Marverick
It's missing a 0 at the end to make it worth it. Even then you need 8 books to fill up all 200,000, probably 5-6 including other stuff, and then the same thing for the other 3 races...
leeky baby
im not gunan swap my dudgeon book for 2.5k, i will keep it with all 18 dudgeons done, just beacause it worths more to see i have done all 18 then 2.5k points...
![[EW]Elendar](/static/static/../Img/avatar34583_1.gif){kind=avatar}
[EW]Elendar
printscreen is your friend
tenshi_strife
/signed for greater reward i mean 2.5k come on anet i get than that clearing one area which take what 40 mins -.- and filling books takes what 6 hours.... gg anet gg
odly
/signed
Now imagine how silly I feel for completing the main story line without having those books.
I think my inventory was full at the time and I only got arround to getting them now.
The Heroe's handbook apparently kept track of some things and is about half full.
The Dungeons Masters handbook is empty except for the last one.
Maybe the main story line dungeons like Golem etc didn't count ?
I'll have to do play some more to fill them :-) .
Anyway /singed the reward is a bit small imo.
There's bound to be some rewarding dungeon that give more points/time and people will just do the same one over and over again.
There's also bound to be one dungeon/mission you struggle with more than others and having to complete that one to get this little reward is going to annoy people.
Now imagine how silly I feel for completing the main story line without having those books.
I think my inventory was full at the time and I only got arround to getting them now.
The Heroe's handbook apparently kept track of some things and is about half full.
The Dungeons Masters handbook is empty except for the last one.
Maybe the main story line dungeons like Golem etc didn't count ?
I'll have to do play some more to fill them :-) .
Anyway /singed the reward is a bit small imo.
There's bound to be some rewarding dungeon that give more points/time and people will just do the same one over and over again.
There's also bound to be one dungeon/mission you struggle with more than others and having to complete that one to get this little reward is going to annoy people.
Ferret
/Signed...i agree it should be worth 5k to 10k for all the work you have to put in (especially for us people that dont get to play day of the week).
Peace,
Ferret
Peace,
Ferret
Stolen Souls
/signed. Yeah, should be worth a bit more :/
haggus71
/signed
The farmers could still farm, and those who took the time to go through all 18 dungeons and the whole story could get something worthwhile for their work.
It takes time to go through all the dungeons and the whole storyline, so doing them all 2-3 times would be enough to not get too tedious or repetitive. It would prove that Anet truly doesn't want this to be just an OCD grindfest. 7500-10k would be a good rate per book.
Yeah, I'm sure some will argue against it, saying how you should have to "work" for it. Like being a grind monkey is hard work. Pop in. Kill stuff. Pop out. Pop in. Kill stuff. Pop out. Pop in.....
Well, don't worry, monkeys. Anet will never in a million years do this. Tossers.
The farmers could still farm, and those who took the time to go through all 18 dungeons and the whole story could get something worthwhile for their work.
It takes time to go through all the dungeons and the whole storyline, so doing them all 2-3 times would be enough to not get too tedious or repetitive. It would prove that Anet truly doesn't want this to be just an OCD grindfest. 7500-10k would be a good rate per book.
Yeah, I'm sure some will argue against it, saying how you should have to "work" for it. Like being a grind monkey is hard work. Pop in. Kill stuff. Pop out. Pop in. Kill stuff. Pop out. Pop in.....
Well, don't worry, monkeys. Anet will never in a million years do this. Tossers.
MithranArkanere
Books should be a reward for helping friends.
Currently, players would usually never make the quests again. They give almost no rewards by themselves, and the 2,500 seem just a bad joke more than anything.
It's like: "Hey, you ran the Marathon! Here, take a cookie".
Since you can get 1000..2000 points (depending on luck with bonuses and area) in less than one hour by clearing areas, since it takes around 5..7 hours to fill a book, hero handbooks should give 5,000...10,000 points.
And Dungeon Guides should reward with 10,000..20,000 points.
Currently, players would usually never make the quests again. They give almost no rewards by themselves, and the 2,500 seem just a bad joke more than anything.
It's like: "Hey, you ran the Marathon! Here, take a cookie".
Since you can get 1000..2000 points (depending on luck with bonuses and area) in less than one hour by clearing areas, since it takes around 5..7 hours to fill a book, hero handbooks should give 5,000...10,000 points.
And Dungeon Guides should reward with 10,000..20,000 points.
MMSDome
/un-signed
you get enough rewards at the end of each dungeon...duh
you get enough rewards at the end of each dungeon...duh
Graphik Desine
/signed for the dungeon book only. just because i like to go in there with hench and heroes so i can do the entire dungeon experience by myself without going online and cheating and looking at where to go or do it with people that have done it already and know exactly what to bring.
not always do heroes and hench exactly perform well, which kinda made me sad when i found out i only would get 2.5k rep for it, after i worked so hard to finish because 60dp was my friend the whole time thru the dungeons first time thru lol
i really was expecting 5k for the dungeon book, since most of the dungeons are way worse to try to handle than the quests. even if everyone knows what they are doing after they've done it once, still the big rewards +5k dungeon book seems greatly pleasing for good teamwork and/or strategy.
i say if we all have the patience to go back and do these dungeons just for a 5k rep reward in the end, that would be WELL worth my time and i actually would do it. currently i don't, as 2.5k keeps me far away from those 60dp moments xD gotta love hench/hero teams that are not built for the occasion.
but for the quest book, 2.5k seems reasonable.
/not signed for the quest book. those are easy quests, just time consuming
not always do heroes and hench exactly perform well, which kinda made me sad when i found out i only would get 2.5k rep for it, after i worked so hard to finish because 60dp was my friend the whole time thru the dungeons first time thru lol
i really was expecting 5k for the dungeon book, since most of the dungeons are way worse to try to handle than the quests. even if everyone knows what they are doing after they've done it once, still the big rewards +5k dungeon book seems greatly pleasing for good teamwork and/or strategy.i say if we all have the patience to go back and do these dungeons just for a 5k rep reward in the end, that would be WELL worth my time and i actually would do it. currently i don't, as 2.5k keeps me far away from those 60dp moments xD gotta love hench/hero teams that are not built for the occasion.
but for the quest book, 2.5k seems reasonable.
/not signed for the quest book. those are easy quests, just time consuming
Maximumraver
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Phoenix Tears
I want to see for example a Bestiary-Book ^^
|
Lyllrik
/signed.
2.5k per book barely give me boost up to r4... Also, the rep you get in the dungeon is only deldrimor rep (wtf?). Which means even if I play dungeons I'd still have to kill mobs in Charr Homelands to get r5 Vanguard....
2.5k per book barely give me boost up to r4... Also, the rep you get in the dungeon is only deldrimor rep (wtf?). Which means even if I play dungeons I'd still have to kill mobs in Charr Homelands to get r5 Vanguard....
Explodie
Well i think they made them so low worthy because its something extra, you need to do the dungeons and quests anyway :P
So they made that you get a simple reward for things you already need to do ...
So i will not sign it, i do it very simple =)
When i get the first book, i put them in storage so i get new ones, then i put them in in storage, and then i put them all in inventory :P
Its not a bug, its not a exploid, its not a cheat >.>
2times book from asura
2times book from vangaurd
2times book from the norn
So i have 3 hero books and 3 mission book
So they made that you get a simple reward for things you already need to do ...
So i will not sign it, i do it very simple =)
When i get the first book, i put them in storage so i get new ones, then i put them in in storage, and then i put them all in inventory :P
Its not a bug, its not a exploid, its not a cheat >.>
2times book from asura
2times book from vangaurd
2times book from the norn
So i have 3 hero books and 3 mission book
Fallen Hunter
/signed
I think the reward for the hero's handbook shouldn't be increased too much, as it isn't too hard to fill. The dungeon handbook should definitely be increased to at least 5000, or even more. The effort required to fill that out is quite high, and it isn't currently worth it.
I think the reward for the hero's handbook shouldn't be increased too much, as it isn't too hard to fill. The dungeon handbook should definitely be increased to at least 5000, or even more. The effort required to fill that out is quite high, and it isn't currently worth it.
A11Eur0
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Explodie
Well i think they made them so low worthy because its something extra, you need to do the dungeons and quests anyway :P
So they made that you get a simple reward for things you already need to do ... So i will not sign it, i do it very simple =) When i get the first book, i put them in storage so i get new ones, then i put them in in storage, and then i put them all in inventory :P Its not a bug, its not a exploid, its not a cheat >.> 2times book from asura 2times book from vangaurd 2times book from the norn So i have 3 hero books and 3 mission book |
Evilsod
I'm not too fussed about the Hero Handbook giving 2,500. I wouldn't mind it been upped a bit but its ok as it is.
But the Dungeon Masters Guide... what a jip! 2,500 for clearing each dungeon once each taking anywhere between 30 minutes and several hours. Definatly at least 5000, 7,500 might be a bit much.
Hmm, that does sound like an exploit if you could get multiple books. I could quite easily fill my inventory up with 40 books, rush through all the primaries and turn them all in 1 at a time and recieve 100,000 points. You think that would be bannable?
But the Dungeon Masters Guide... what a jip! 2,500 for clearing each dungeon once each taking anywhere between 30 minutes and several hours. Definatly at least 5000, 7,500 might be a bit much.
Hmm, that does sound like an exploit if you could get multiple books. I could quite easily fill my inventory up with 40 books, rush through all the primaries and turn them all in 1 at a time and recieve 100,000 points. You think that would be bannable?
evenfall
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Explodie
So i will not sign it, i do it very simple =)
When i get the first book, i put them in storage so i get new ones, then i put them in in storage, and then i put them all in inventory :P Its not a bug, its not a exploid, its not a cheat >.> 2times book from asura 2times book from vangaurd 2times book from the norn So i have 3 hero books and 3 mission book |
JeniM
So i can get 2.5k for doing every dungeon for just the dwarfs (first title i'm working on)
OR
I can get ~2k in 10mins from the Lair of the Snowmen
Tough call but i think i'll go with the snowmen
Offtopic : i love lair of snowmen
OR
I can get ~2k in 10mins from the Lair of the Snowmen
Tough call but i think i'll go with the snowmen
Offtopic : i love lair of snowmen
MithranArkanere
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by MMSDome
/un-signed
you get enough rewards at the end of each dungeon...duh |
Once you make a dungeon, the next time you make that same dungeon the reward is reduced to 5..10% of the original reward.
Those books should at least have the rewards removed in the repetitions.
Sleeper Service
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by MithranArkanere
NO.
Once you make a dungeon, the next time you make that same dungeon the reward is reduced to 5..10% of the original reward. Those books should at least have the rewards removed in the repetitions. |
Effendi Westland
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Sleeper Service
where did you get that number from.
|
For Hero book, I don't know, I'm ok with 2.5k. But for the master dungeon book I think it should be more then 2.5k, it takes considerably more effort and the reputation gain after the 1st run is almost non-existant.
/signed