~Ursan Blessing and balance~

Bryant Again

Bryant Again

Hall Hero

Join Date: Feb 2006

Quote:
Originally Posted by RTSFirebat
1. I like UB because it gives me a chance to do areas which otherwise my character class could not do very easily.

2. I like UB because it allows elite areas to be done in much shorter spaces of time.

3. I don't like UB because my "insert item or gold thing here" is worth less because of it.

4. I don't like UB because I or someone else has worked hard for something and I don't like the idea of people doing things easier then me.
5. I love UB because it finally got my warrior friend to quit his bitching and moaning about Shards of Orr!

Quote: Originally Posted by RTSFirebat
I just hope A.net balance UB and not nerf if into nothingness... And that's probably my biggest concern right now. Balance and still keep it decently useful, not useless.

[DE]

[DE]

Hugs and Kisses

Join Date: Oct 2005

Scars Meadows

Quote:
Originally Posted by RTSFirebat
I just hope A.net balance UB and not nerf if into nothingness... Well the last time they nerfed PvE skills (TNTF and SoL) they did a pretty good job of keeping them usable. So I assume it will be the same for UB

angmar_nite

angmar_nite

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Feb 2007

[SNOW] of [YUM]

E/

Quote:
Originally Posted by RTSFirebat
1. I like UB because it gives me a chance to do areas which otherwise my character class could not do very easily.
Fair enough. Or you could be creative and make your own build and work with guildies and friends. (The same thing you tell us who don't want to ursanway to do)

Quote: Originally Posted by RTSFirebat 2. I like UB because it allows elite areas to be done in much shorter spaces of time. Bad reason. They are meant to be hard. If the most EFFICIENT and effective normal builds can't do them at a certain speeds, for one skill to come along and say "fast forward" is most certainly overpowering.

Quote: Originally Posted by RTSFirebat
3. I don't like UB because my "insert item or gold thing here" is worth less because of it. Others get more of what we have working less for it. Since they have more, they become richer while being less skillful.

Quote:
Originally Posted by RTSFirebat
4. I don't like UB because I or someone else has worked hard for something and I don't like the idea of people doing things easier then me. If we worked hard why shouldn't they? What if survivor was dropped to rank 1 is 2000 exp rank 2 is 50k and rank 3 is 100k?
people doing it otherwise.

lord dragon

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Sep 2007

R/

Quote:
Originally Posted by angmar_nite
Fair enough. Or you could be creative and make your own build and work with guildies and friends. (The same thing you tell us who don't want to ursanway to do)



Bad reason. They are meant to be hard. If the most EFFICIENT and effective normal builds can't do them at a certain speeds, for one skill to come along and say "fast forward" is most certainly overpowering.



Others get more of what we have working less for it. Since they have more, they become richer while being less skillful.



If we worked hard why shouldn't they? What if survivor was dropped to rank 1 is 2000 exp rank 2 is 50k and rank 3 is 100k?
people doing it otherwise. I am assuming you meant played hard. The definition or work does not apply here. It is a game. As for getting it easier, I am one that has it, done it the way you said, had the feeling of acomplishments. That is over now for me. I hope the rest get what they want as easy as they can. Guess I am not nearly as selfish as some.

angmar_nite

angmar_nite

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Feb 2007

[SNOW] of [YUM]

E/

I have every right to be selfish. I WANT what I have to have more value. And I am not "over" with the elite dungeouns and missions. Therefore, while you already have all your 1337 gear, I am still working on it.

Atra Culpa

Atra Culpa

Academy Page

Join Date: Jul 2007

Manchester, England

Servants Of Fortuna [SOF]

N/

Quote:
Originally Posted by angmar_nite
Bad reason. They are meant to be hard. If the most EFFICIENT and effective normal builds can't do them at a certain speeds, for one skill to come along and say "fast forward" is most certainly overpowering.
Referring that to what was already said earlier.

Quote:
Originally Posted by mcsumo
Somewhere on these forums is a thread showing several people completing DoA, beating Mallyx and discussing times. I believe SMS still hold the record with 2 hrs 8 mins for a run of all 4 areas. They did this with an ingenious build idea that Racthoh came up with. Hats off to them, they are good.

Even the best bear team isn't going to beat that time. (qft)

The thought to use UB for farming crossed my mind when i first discovered the skill playing through GWEN but i never really thought about it enough to do anything with it other than use it casually in PvE. This was before the Farming started. Since then, I have used UB for DoA areas and in some others. It's a good way for first timers and scrubs like myself to learn the areas and their features mobs etc. and i intend to move on from UB asap, simply because I want to improve my own game. That and tbh it gets boring quickly.

This isn't going to apply to everyone who plays GW though because most people want 'l33t gear' etc. Though I figure none of the people in here fit under that category.

If the general gripe here is about imbalance in PvE then complain and ask Anet to remove all PvE onlys, like the skills and consumables, instead of raging on about one skill just because it sticks out slightly more than the rest of them.

Avarre

Avarre

Bubblegum Patrol

Join Date: Dec 2005

Singapore Armed Forces

Quote:
Originally Posted by Atra Culpa
If the general gripe here is about imbalance in PvE then complain and ask Anet to remove all PvE onlys, like the skills and consumables, instead of raging on about one skill just because it sticks out slightly more than the rest of them.
That is and has always been my viewpoint. I can't go around saying UB needs to be taken out while "Save Yourselves!" makes a joke of the game.

I think it's relevant, so I'll bring across one of my earlier posts here (left in the quotes because they sum up a lot of the counterarguments);

Quote: Originally Posted by assassin shaun /not signed

no way if u want to have the same power amount as everyone else then unlock the skills ureself and stop moaning!
Guild Wars was meant to be about skill, not time.

This is how the original idea went;

Play with your skillbar.
Area too hard.
Tweak your skillbar with other skills of equal power.
Another area too hard.
Improve as a player, playing your build better to beat things
Success!

This is how the game is slowly going instead;

Play with your skillbar.
Area too hard.
Add lolzpve skills to skillbar.
Everything dies!
...no player improvement...
Halp how2beat Chromatic Drakes, they are too hard!

Quote:
Originally Posted by Star Gazer
option d) remove QQers from the game and let people play the way they want to Why don't you stop supporting the degeneration of Guild Wars into yet another generic MMO and let people play the game they wanted to play in the first place, a game of skill > time? ANet would not have shifted into a more PvE-grind mindset without the support of people who believe that work->easy victory is fun. I don't understand how you can be so hypocritical with your statement and not spontaneously combust.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Alex Dimitri
We finally have at our disposal skill that can make counter to HM spikes of foe`s and some people want to make it disapear, i don`t understand did u become Masochist along the way, i shure the hell feel underpowered when i got spiked by bosses that make 400-550dmg even ordinary footman in HM make huge damage, and DoA is story for itself.Plus the first time some people can actually get in teams!!! And YES i`m passionate about defending UB even if i don`t actually use it (used it only during the quest in GW:EN).
Good skill that definetly shouldn`t be nerfed !!!! Protective spirit. Look into it sometime, run more versatile skillbars, and stop relying on broken skills to win the game for you.

Why even play the game if there's no challenge and no incentive to develop as a player? Do you play it like a graphic novel? Do you like to make pve numbers get bigger?

In summary, the only way to nerf this skill (and quite a few other offender PvE skills) would be to remove them from the game and feed the person who implemented them to a large bear.

I feel it goes without saying if you use these kind of PvE skills and still lose, you should never have gotten past Thunderhead Keep. It's nice and all of Anet to give ridiculously broken skills like this to people so they can smash areas, but whatever happened to skill being important? SMS running into 3 mobs at once, going afk, and then winning because of "Save Yourselves!" is not skill. Running around with a pack of bears blowing things up and understanding the value of build structure is not skill. There is no reason to have any equip-restricted skill in the game as they are by principle not balanced to the rest of the game, and balance is the backbone of creating anything built on player skill.

Yes, this also means the out-of-balance effects to add difficulty without any thought (monster skills, zone effects) are a terrible addition to PvE and should be removed. Consumables, too, are ridiculous - although things like the candy canes I am willing to look past since they are mistake erasers rather than boosts - they won't win a map for you, but they can keep a small mistake from wasting a lot of time and causing frustration.

angmar_nite

angmar_nite

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Feb 2007

[SNOW] of [YUM]

E/

Thunderhead keep... Haha. I doubt half of these guys ever gone up against all those enemy waves 2 years ago.

DivineEnvoy

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Sep 2005

Me/P

Quote:
Originally Posted by Avarre
Guild Wars was meant to be about skill, not time.

Why don't you stop supporting the degeneration of Guild Wars into yet another generic MMO and let people play the game they wanted to play in the first place, a game of skill > time? ANet would not have shifted into a more PvE-grind mindset without the support of people who believe that work->easy victory is fun. I don't understand how you can be so hypocritical with your statement and not spontaneously combust.

Protective spirit. Look into it sometime, run more versatile skillbars, and stop relying on broken skills to win the game for you.

Why even play the game if there's no challenge and no incentive to develop as a player? Do you play it like a graphic novel? Do you like to make pve numbers get bigger?

In summary, the only way to nerf this skill (and quite a few other offender PvE skills) would be to remove them from the game and feed the person who implemented them to a large bear.

I feel it goes without saying if you use these kind of PvE skills and still lose, you should never have gotten past Thunderhead Keep. It's nice and all of Anet to give ridiculously broken skills like this to people so they can smash areas, but whatever happened to skill being important? SMS running into 3 mobs at once, going afk, and then winning because of "Save Yourselves!" is not skill. Running around with a pack of bears blowing things up and understanding the value of build structure is not skill. There is no reason to have any equip-restricted skill in the game as they are by principle not balanced to the rest of the game, and balance is the backbone of creating anything built on player skill.

Yes, this also means the out-of-balance effects to add difficulty without any thought (monster skills, zone effects) are a terrible addition to PvE and should be removed. Consumables, too, are ridiculous - although things like the candy canes I am willing to look past since they are mistake erasers rather than boosts - they won't win a map for you, but they can keep a small mistake from wasting a lot of time and causing frustration. I am sick of the selfishness of you people. Honestly, why in the world are you so strict about the these morals with skill matters over time? Guild Wars is basically over, you know it, I know it. So what if Anet is willing to continue to support it? You know hardly a soul will be on the server as Guild Wars 2 is out. Why can't the casual players have their moment in the sun just for this short period of time before it's all gone?

If you are so skillful with the given fundamentals, like about twenty players have said: GO PLAY PVP. Have you considered that there are players who started the game late, who do not own a certain campaign and who don't have enough time to play? I had to tell a friend of mine who started when Nightfall was released that he can't play in Hero's Acsent, because he doesn't have all the skills and the rank. Do you know how crappy his heroes's skills are? No, you don't. However, with the existence of Ursan Blessing, I can bring him the good news that he can play in Hard Mode. Sounds quite a hardship isn't it, and have you ever considered for people like that? No, you didn't, because you only want the game for yourself.

Lastly, there is no way for Anet to remove the Pve-only skills; they were part of the package of the product. Truly, this is getting annoying. I am basically repeating what I have been said in the thread for the last 10 times, because people are just not getting it. Also, back in 2004, I purchased a storm bow 15% more damage while enchanted, and requires 13 marksmenship for 100k and an ecto (it was 10k an ecto back then). A bow like this is only 10k or even elss right now, so don't complain that your "work" will be degraded with the existence of Ursan; they will be degraded sooner or later anyways. You know what? I don't care. All I care about is the experience I share with the kindreds I have who are willing to play with me. Guild Wars is only a game; it's not life, where is queer and what not, so leave it be.

reverse_oreo

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Dec 2005

Scars Meadows [SmS] Officer (not recruiting)

Quote:
Originally Posted by DivineEnvoy
Why can't the casual players have their moment in the sun just for this short period of time before it's all gone? Ok, get this through your head. TWO MORE YEARS BEFORE GW2 COMES OUT. Short period of time? They have had 2 years to get to the point where the "elitist" Pve players are. And they have another two to get some skill and beat a hard area without using a very overpowered skill.

I didnt bother reading the rest of your post because this sentence made me "ROFLMAYO"

DivineEnvoy

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Sep 2005

Me/P

Quote:
Originally Posted by reverse_oreo
Ok, get this through your head. TWO MORE YEARS BEFORE GW2 COMES OUT. Short period of time? They have had 2 years to get to the point where the "elitist" Pve players are. And they have another two to get some skill and beat a hard area without using a very overpowered skill.

I didnt bother reading the rest of your post because this sentence made me "ROFLMAYO"
Quote:
Originally Posted by Me on post 289
Have you considered that there are players who started the game late, who do not own a certain campaign and who don't have enough time to play? No, you didn't, because you only want the game for yourself. I find it very difficult to get it through my head.

Shaz

Shaz

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Aug 2005

Scars Meadows [SMS]

Just because someone joined the game late, doesn't mean they should use overpowered skill to get through the game. Learn it like the rest of us, unless they want to stay bad. Like someone said earlier in this thread, this isn't about nerfing the skill so other can't enjoy it, it's about changing the skill so it isn't imbalanced so that the game isn't lame. Who want to play a FPS game that one shot kill? (aside from the headshot sniper gun of course )

trobinson97

trobinson97

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Mar 2006

Guildless :(

R/

Quote:
Originally Posted by reverse_oreo
Ok, get this through your head. TWO MORE YEARS BEFORE GW2 COMES OUT. Short period of time? They have had 2 years to get to the point where the "elitist" Pve players are. And they have another two to get some skill and beat a hard area without using a very overpowered skill.

I didnt bother reading the rest of your post because it made too much sense and there was no way I could counter it without sounding like a guy completely obsessed with hinging my own self worth on things I accomplish in a video game"ROFLMAYO"

Fixed.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Diven Envoy I am basically repeating what I have been said in the thread for the last 10 times, because people are just not getting it. Agreed. At least we know Gaile has passed the concern on. There's really no point in arguing anymore. All we can do is hope that Anet listens to the majority in this case. At this point all you have are people who'd rather flame you than come with legitimate counter points. It's all they have left.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Divine Envoy
back in 2004, I purchased a storm bow 15% more damage while enchanted, and requires 13 marksmenship for 100k and an ecto (it was 10k an ecto back then). A bow like this is only 10k or even elss right now, so don't complain that your "work" will be degraded with the existence of Ursan; they will be degraded sooner or later anyways. You know what? I don't care. 100% agreed. It's all pixels.

Avarre

Avarre

Bubblegum Patrol

Join Date: Dec 2005

Singapore Armed Forces

Quote:
Originally Posted by DivineEnvoy
However, with the existence of Ursan Blessing, I can bring him the good news that he can play in Hard Mode. Sounds quite a hardship isn't it, and have you ever considered for people like that? No, you didn't, because you only want the game for yourself. You can play in Hard Mode without any PvE skills at all. Once you realize that, and gain the capability to not be tethered to specific one-dimensional broken skills, you'll be able to enjoy the game more by playing in any way you want, rather than sticking to a ridiculous cookie-cutter that doesn't allow you to run actual skills. A player would be better off learning about the game and then being able to fully experience it on their own terms, with all the diversity the game offers.

If all you care about is completing things and getting material rewards over anything else, then all I can do is pity you.

manitoba1073

manitoba1073

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Jan 2006

ManitobaShipyards Refit and Repair Station

(SFC)Star Fleet Command,(TDE)The Daggerfall elite,(SOoM)Secret order of Magi

Ok, I'm tired of biting my lip on this subject.

Abusing the same game mechanics will make almost any skill overpowered. The skill is not itself that is overpowered its the fact you are using 3/4 of a team or more of them using.

Other people are finally getting a chance to enjoy the areas of the game alot of us pros have enjoyed. It DOES NOT decrease any acheivement we have already. It only allows others a chance to share in it.

Finally if you guys want to prove its overpowered then PM me in game and if you can solo this area I know without dieing then you can say its overpowered.

Only a few requirements are to be meet.

1. All areas in all 3 chapters must be open.
2. No consumables of any kind.
3. only skill on your bar must be UB
4. No dieing
5. You will be solo

Now keep you guys honest on it I'll be the only other person in the group. Unless ofcourse you guys are scared of a few lvl 14-lvl 18 creatures with a couple of bosses at lvl 20.

Akuma

Akuma

IRC W H O R E

Join Date: Feb 2006

Australian Trolling Crew HQ, rightful leader and administration

Yale University [Snow]

W/

No 'dieing'?

k, I can do that with A RELATIVELY HIGH LEVEL OF SKILL

RhanoctJocosa

RhanoctJocosa

Legendary Korean

Join Date: Aug 2006

The Benecia Renovatio [RenO]

W/

Quote:
Originally Posted by manitoba1073
Ok, I'm tired of biting my lip on this subject.

Abusing the same game mechanics will make almost any skill overpowered. The skill is not itself that is overpowered its the fact you are using 3/4 of a team or more of them using.

Other people are finally getting a chance to enjoy the areas of the game alot of us pros have enjoyed. It DOES NOT decrease any acheivement we have already. It only allows others a chance to share in it.

Finally if you guys want to prove its overpowered then PM me in game and if you can solo this area I know without dieing then you can say its overpowered.

Only a few requirements are to be meet.

1. All areas in all 3 chapters must be open.
2. No consumables of any kind.
3. only skill on your bar must be UB
4. No dieing
5. You will be solo

Now keep you guys honest on it I'll be the only other person in the group. Unless ofcourse you guys are scared of a few lvl 14-lvl 18 creatures with a couple of bosses at lvl 20. That is hardly a "test" of whether something is overpowered or not. For example, Grenth Dervishes back when NF was released couldn't solo anything but they were obviously overpowered... Maybe you should just stop posting, or something.

Crom The Pale

Crom The Pale

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Nov 2006

Ageis Ascending

W/

The simple fact here is that people wish to dictate how other play the game, it has been this way since GW first started.

If you dont run the skills I want you cant be in my party....

Now people find UB overpowered only because it works with little effort. Many other skills and skill combos have greater power when used with some skill and party team work.

This is tantamount to saying if your not in a guild with experianced, active people you do not deserve to play in any elite zone.

This skill is know to almost everyone now, no matter what change is made be it small or large many people will be upset.

fallot

I'm the king

Join Date: Nov 2005

Aussie Trolling Crew: Grand Phallus and Chairman Pro Tempore

Quote:
Originally Posted by manitoba1073
Abusing the same game mechanics will make almost any skill overpowered. The skill is not itself that is overpowered its the fact you are using 3/4 of a team or more of them using.
In an almost exclusively team game, that fits the definition of overpowered.

Quote:
Originally Posted by manitoba1073
Only a few requirements are to be meet.

1. All areas in all 3 chapters must be open.
2. No consumables of any kind.
3. only skill on your bar must be UB
4. No dieing
5. You will be solo How does that prove anything (except your total disconnect from reality) ?

DivineEnvoy

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Sep 2005

Me/P

trobinson97:
Nice fix there and thanks for the understanding. I notice the flames as well; however, I would like to finish what I have started: to protect a game I like.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Avarre
You can play in Hard Mode without any PvE skills at all. Once you realize that, and gain the capability to not be tethered to specific one-dimensional broken skills, you'll be able to enjoy the game more by playing in any way you want, rather than sticking to a ridiculous cookie-cutter that doesn't allow you to run actual skills. A player would be better off learning about the game and then being able to fully experience it on their own terms, with all the diversity the game offers.

If all you care about is completing things and getting material rewards over anything else, then all I can do is pity you.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Me on post 289
Have you considered that there are players who started the game late, who do not own a certain campaign and who don't have enough time to play? I had to tell a friend of mine who started when Nightfall was released that he can't play in Hero's Acsent, because he doesn't have all the skills and the rank. Do you know how crappy his heroes's skills are? No, you don't. I'm surprised that these are the lines right before what you have quote. My friend only has Nightfall and Eye of the North, and it's very difficult to construct a well-balanced monk build let alone for normal mode. It was not balanced for him in the first place, because he does not have all the campaigns. He's a university student, and he can only play once or twice a week. What should he do? Force him to buy them all? Force him to play more? So what if he wants to play Hard Mode with Ursan Blessing, so that he can actually play Hard Mode, despite his current situation? What makes you believe that you have the rights to control how others are playing the game?

I'm sorry, but all I care is that my friends are having fun. So what if completing things and getting rewards is what we considered as fun? How's that any of your business? What makes you think you have the rights of judging us?

Avarre

Avarre

Bubblegum Patrol

Join Date: Dec 2005

Singapore Armed Forces

Quote:
Originally Posted by DivineEnvoy
I'm surprised that these are the lines right before what you have quote. My friend only has Nightfall and Eye of the North, and it's very difficult to construct a well-balanced monk build let alone for normal mode. It was not balanced for him in the first place, because he does not have all the campaigns. He's a university student, and he can only play once or twice a week. What should he do? Force him to buy them all? Force him to play more? So what if he wants to play Hard Mode with Ursan Blessing, so that he can actually play Hard Mode, despite his current situation? What makes you believe that you have the rights to control how others are playing the game? I'll address this because it's a valid point. In December there was a tournament where only Nightfall and Core skills were allowed. The fact that it even existed is proof that with only Nightfall, you can make a build. Especially for PvE.

What you lose as a monk without the other two chapters, in terms of viable skills:

Prophecies;
Kiss
RC

Factions;
Spirit Bond
Gift
Signet of Rejuvinattion

What you still have in Nightfall/core/EotN (well balanced monk setup)

Light of Deliverance / Zealous Benediction, both solid monk elites for different styles of play and areas.

Reversal of Fortune, the key monk skill.

Protective Spirit, reducing mass damage in Hard Mode.

Guardian/Shield of Absorption, efficient small prots.

Words of Comfort, direct target 5e heal.

Dismiss Condition, condi removal and heal.

Holy Veil and Cure Hex, strong hex removals.


Basically, all the components of a balanced monk build are still there. No real major restrictions on play are on your friend. Would he learn this if he relied on Ursan?

bungusmaximus

bungusmaximus

Forge Runner

Join Date: Jul 2006

Guild Of Handicrafted Products [MaSS]

W/Mo

Quote:
Originally Posted by DivineEnvoy
I am sick of the selfishness of you people. Honestly, why in the world are you so strict about the these morals with skill matters over time? Guild Wars is basically over, you know it, I know it. So what if Anet is willing to continue to support it? You know hardly a soul will be on the server as Guild Wars 2 is out. Why can't the casual players have their moment in the sun just for this short period of time before it's all gone?

Quote: Originally Posted by DivineEnvoy If you are so skillful with the given fundamentals, like about twenty players have said: GO PLAY PVP. Have you considered that there are players who started the game late, who do not own a certain campaign and who don't have enough time to play? I had to tell a friend of mine who started when Nightfall was released that he can't play in Hero's Acsent, because he doesn't have all the skills and the rank. Do you know how crappy his heroes's skills are? No, you don't. However, with the existence of Ursan Blessing, I can bring him the good news that he can play in Hard Mode. Sounds quite a hardship isn't it, and have you ever considered for people like that? No, you didn't, because you only want the game for yourself. I cleared Urgoz' Warren while I didn't even find out yet what attribute points were, being a little social goes a long way (Hello team I am an enormous noob so show me around a bit). I still don't get it why a game should be balanced around people that are baed. And you can play in HA at any time, you just won't win halls. Competitive PvP means there will be...competition.

Quote:
Originally Posted by DivineEnvoy
Guild Wars is only a game; it's not life, where is queer and what not, so leave it be. Yeah but if it wasn't for GW, that why would we be on this forum in the first place. Stop saying from people that discuss the game on guru that they have no life. There really isn't anything else to discuss on a game forum now is there?

lishi

Forge Runner

Join Date: Jul 2005

You know? i changed my idea.

UB is fine. If someone want a decent game they can just not use it.

Plus i think they need restore the item duplication bug. Seriusly if you dont like it you can easly not use it.

Wait that would be only for hardcore player who can understand the exploit i suggest a duplication window ingame. dont forget the shurtcurt too.

manitoba1073

manitoba1073

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Jan 2006

ManitobaShipyards Refit and Repair Station

(SFC)Star Fleet Command,(TDE)The Daggerfall elite,(SOoM)Secret order of Magi

It actually proves alot. The fact that the skill itself isnt overpowered. The problem is that the majority of players won be in full groups of UB. They will be themselfs and H/H. That will be the vast majority. 1 UB in the group is not over powered.

Like any other skill in game you add multiples and they all are overpowered.

Ok Akuma looks like the first one PM in game anytime you're on. Tarn Vedre

Lishi- You're being retarded if you are trying to compare UB with duping. And making a great case for your side though

Fallout- and what game have you been playing? Really GW hasnt been a Team game for a long time. Oh I get it you're afraid to take that big bad bear agaisnt some lvl 14 - lvl 18's if you're alone.

lishi

Forge Runner

Join Date: Jul 2005

Quote:
Originally Posted by manitoba1073
It actually proves alot. The fact that the skill itself isnt overpowered. The problem is that the majority of players won be in full groups of UB. They will be themselfs and H/H. That will be the vast majority. 1 UB in the group is not over powered.

Like any other skill in game you add multiples and they all are overpowered.

Ok Akuma looks like the first one PM in game anytime you're on. Tarn Vedre

Lishi- You're being retarded if you are trying to compare UB with duping. And making a great case for your side though

Fallout- and what game have you been playing? Really GW hasnt been a Team game for a long time. Oh I get it you're afraid to take that big bad bear agaisnt some lvl 14 - lvl 18's if you're alone. Im not comparing UB with duplication, i want underline the fact "you dont like it, dont use it" is not a good justification of not fixing something.

ryanryanryan0310

ryanryanryan0310

Desert Nomad

Join Date: May 2006

Scars Meadows [SMS]

Quote:
Originally Posted by trobinson97

Agreed. At least we know Gaile has passed the concern on. There's really no point in arguing anymore. All we can do is hope that Anet listens to the majority in this case. At this point all you have are people who'd rather flame you than come with legitimate counter points. It's all they have left. Legitimate counter points:

1) Ursan blessing overpowered!

2) Players in the game shouldn't rely only on ONE skill.

3) Hardmode can still be done without any PvE only skills.

4) Whats the point of playing a game where you just press two buttons.

5) When they nerf Ursan learn to adapt and overcome.

Edited by RTS - Don't try to be clever and turn this into a real flame fest. No other warnings will be even.

RTSFirebat

RTSFirebat

The Humanoid Typhoon

Join Date: May 2005

UK

Servants of Fortuna [SoF]

R/

Look this thread is already chalk full of flame and hate, don't turn this into a off topic discussion about some random forum users.

Don't give us a reason to shut this flame fest down, I've deleted any puts in relation to the user hate, you know who you are. So don't so it.

Njall

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: Apr 2005

Fellowship Of The Grim

W/R

Ursan is overpowered.. but it's damned cool to be able to go in DoA without being bored to death. I play a Warrior. I hated the f.....g Obsidian tanker build. Now I can go in DoA and have some fun.


Btw, speaking of balance.
I'm a warrior, max armor 80+20 vs physical.. I go in Depths of Destruction and use Dolyak Signet... Power attack from a destroyer hits for about 250 damage. Where is balance ?

tmakinen

tmakinen

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Nov 2005

www.mybearfriend.net

Servants of Fortuna [SoF]

E/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Njall
Ursan is overpowered.. but it's damned cool to be able to go in DoA without being bored to death. I play a Warrior. I hated the f.....g Obsidian tanker build. Now I can go in DoA and have some fun.
Hating Obsidian tanking is good for you but you can go to DoA with a warrior and have fun without UB as well, you'll just have to bring the proper team build.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Njall
Btw, speaking of balance.
I'm a warrior, max armor 80+20 vs physical.. I go in Depths of Destruction and use Dolyak Signet... Power attack from a destroyer hits for about 250 damage. Where is balance ? In having an enfeebling necro and a prot monk on your side, never leave an outpost without them

Atra Culpa

Atra Culpa

Academy Page

Join Date: Jul 2007

Manchester, England

Servants Of Fortuna [SOF]

N/

Quote:
Originally Posted by ryanryanryan0310
2) Players in the game shouldn't rely only on ONE skill. What you're forgetting is that while UB itself may be only one skill, it replaces your entire skill bar and whatever utility it may have had with other skills. These skills may be spammable (with the aid of consumables and/or skills from another person's bar) but they still require more than one player to be playing UB and other players to keep them up to work effectively.

Take a look at Searing Flames for example. It's a mob job. 3 or 4 people with an SF bar in a teambuild (sounds like the build up to a bad joke) in PvE makes the game QQ. it's using the overpowered skills en mass to essentially steamroll whatever gets in the way. UB is just another one of the skills that allows this.

IMHO the best way to fix this is to affiliate the bear form with something of a warrior class where blinding affects you and adrenaline is required for skill activation thus providing more hex counters to it as well, forcing a better team build rather than mindless aggro, 'tank n spank' (Love that phrase Racthoh!!)

trobinson97

trobinson97

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Mar 2006

Guildless :(

R/

Quote:
Originally Posted by ryanryanryan0310
Legitimate counter points:

1) Ursan blessing overpowered!
Lots of the PvE only skills are overpowered, that was pretty much expected when Anet announced them.
Quote: Originally Posted by ryanryanryan0310 2) Players in the game shouldn't rely only on ONE skill. Players can rely on however many skills they want, you didn't buy their game, so you shouldn't speak for them.

Quote: Originally Posted by ryanryanryan0310 3) Hardmode can still be done without any PvE only skills. It also can be done with PvE only skills, so your point is what, HM can be done in many different ways? If so, I agree. I don't agree that one way should be nerfed, especially if it has no bearing on pvp and real balance (especially when the main reason is "They're doing it in less time than I did and making me sad').

Quote:
Originally Posted by ryanryanryan0310
4) Whats the point of playing a game where you just press two buttons. The point is, if you enjoy it, go for it. You bought the game, press as many buttons as you want, as long as you're staying on the right side of the ToS, have fun.

Quote:
Originally Posted by ryanryanryan0310
5) When they nerf Ursan learn to adapt and overcome. Not a legitimate counter point, we'll leave it at that.

lord dragon

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Sep 2007

R/

Quote:
Originally Posted by angmar_nite
I have every right to be selfish. I WANT what I have to have more value. And I am not "over" with the elite dungeouns and missions. Therefore, while you already have all your 1337 gear, I am still working on it. And with prices coming down, you will be able to get it sooner rather then later. I think the whole the prices should remain high argument is kinda funny to be honest. High prices makes me richer. When you have all the gold I have, it doesn't matter anymore.

The point that everyone seems to miss is the more people can attain the more they will play. When the elitist few who feel they are ENTITLED to do it only one way and have the answer for all, is when the game becomes single player.

I wish you luck in your argument, you will just make me richer. I will still argue for the other side as I see where keeping prices high is wrong. But then again, I am not selfish I guess.

bungusmaximus

bungusmaximus

Forge Runner

Join Date: Jul 2006

Guild Of Handicrafted Products [MaSS]

W/Mo

Quote:
Originally Posted by lord dragon
And with prices coming down, you will be able to get it sooner rather then later. I think the whole the prices should remain high argument is kinda funny to be honest. High prices makes me richer. When you have all the gold I have, it doesn't matter anymore.

The point that everyone seems to miss is the more people can attain the more they will play. When the elitist few who feel they are ENTITLED to do it only one way and have the answer for all, is when the game becomes single player.

I wish you luck in your argument, you will just make me richer. I will still argue for the other side as I see where keeping prices high is wrong. But then again, I am not selfish I guess. And what even makes stuff more funny is that a regular computer game doesn't change, hell, if they would all of a sudden change, say, HALO that way I bet there would be screams. GW however is constantly changing pretty radically, hence all the discussion.

RTSFirebat

RTSFirebat

The Humanoid Typhoon

Join Date: May 2005

UK

Servants of Fortuna [SoF]

R/

This whole argument about prices going down is kind of bull. Armbraces of Truth still cost over 100K + xx ectos, I did a search of the High End forum today. People can't claim prices are going down without proof. Which is hard to come by.

Onyx gems for example have been coming down in price since day 1 of EotN, but does it have anything to do with UB? Hardly, just because more and more people are getting their hands on them.

Karia Mirniman

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Feb 2007

Quote:
Originally Posted by yesitsrob
No, not quite.

You're not level headed, and you have to come as close to cheating as is possible to have a chance because of how bad you actually are at Guild Wars, if you think Ursan is fine you obviously fail at balance.

Understand this, we choose not to use said skill, but we don't think scrub nobodies should be able to succeed beacause of said poorly designed skills either WHAT ASTONISHING ARROGANCE.

So the thousands of Level 20 players who have played sufficiently long enough and become skilled enough to reach Drakkar Lake and complete A Hunter's Pride are SCRUB NOBODIES.

My guild drops people like you when they appear. Elitism and selfishness does nothing for the game or the community.

lord dragon

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Sep 2007

R/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Karia Mirniman
WHAT ASTONISHING ARROGANCE.

So the thousands of Level 20 players who have played sufficiently long enough and become skilled enough to reach Drakkar Lake and complete A Hunter's Pride are SCRUB NOBODIES.

My guild drops people like you when they appear. Elitism and selfishness does nothing for the game or the community. Thank you! That needed to be said.

bungusmaximus

bungusmaximus

Forge Runner

Join Date: Jul 2006

Guild Of Handicrafted Products [MaSS]

W/Mo

Quote:
Originally Posted by Karia Mirniman
WHAT ASTONISHING ARROGANCE.
So the thousands of Level 20 players who have played sufficiently long enough and become skilled enough to reach Drakkar Lake and complete A Hunter's Pride are SCRUB NOBODIES.
Yetis is putting it a little bluntly, but to be honest I have to agree with him (I would have used other terminology then 'scrub nobodies' however). The majority of the community just isn't too good at the game. People tend to have lives too, and some just hate playing a long time on end. Most of those players, however, just don't bother with elite content because they know they are baed and they accept the consequences and have fun in the easier areas.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Karia Mirniman
My guild drops people like you when they appear. Elitism and selfishness does nothing for the game or the community. Regular posters here do enough for the community, they help people become less baed by answering the same numbnuts questions over and over again. What strikes me about Guru is that many arrogant people here are also pretty helpful. Now that also needed to be said

Bottom line:

Tere's a hundreds of relatively easy areas in the game and relatively few hard ones. Is it really worth screwing up game balance because bad players want to do these few hard areas at all cost? imho it isn't.

Crom The Pale

Crom The Pale

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Nov 2006

Ageis Ascending

W/

These Elite zones were never meant to be limited to only a handfull of highly skilled players.

They were meant to be end of game content for anyone that had reached the need point to gain access.

PvE skills and consumables are a means of allowing the casual gamer that is not in a big guild a chance to enter these zones and have some fun.

It does not prevent anyone from taking there guild in with there favorite team build and playing as they wish to.

Any area of a game that can only be accessed by 5% of the player base is a bug that needs more attention.

beanerman_99

beanerman_99

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Apr 2005

In the clouds

[Sage]

E/

Using Ursan Blessing in DoA does NOT automatically equal "GG".

Last night I was trying to get my ele into the Foundry and I wanted to go as a SF/MS nuker. Its what I think my ele is made to do best. Instead, I was laughed at and called a "noob" for wanting to go with these skills and told "there are no balanced teams here anymore, go Ursan or leave". I was like, wtf? Its seems that GW is full of "damned if you do, damned it ya don't".

So, I bit the bullet and put on Ursan and joined up with a group that was 6 Ursans and 2 monks. We get to room 3...barely...and it we were "pwnd" rather quickly. We tried about 5 times in a row and same thing happened in room 3. I asked if I could switch to SF/MS and was told if I did that I would get kicked. I left the group.

Point is Ursan does NOT mean an automatic win. I did the City with Ursan and it was quick and fun. I did the Veil with a balanced team and it was long, but fun. Both times I got to do what I do best and thats Nuke. Its my personal choice not to use Ursan and I still enjoy the game.

theblackmage

Academy Page

Join Date: Jun 2005

Quote:
Originally Posted by beanerman_99
So, I bit the bullet and put on Ursan and joined up with a group that was 6 Ursans and 2 monks. We get to room 3...barely...and it we were "pwnd" rather quickly. We tried about 5 times in a row and same thing happened in room 3. Wow, that mirrors my experience with ursan in foundry almost perfectly. For a sec, I thought you were quoting me, but forgot the quote tags . This cannot be totally random occurances, people. UB =/= EZ mode, get over it. Granted, using UB is better than my first shot at DoA(What's this place? 2players+6heros that we used vs Abbadon should be fine. How hard could this place be? *insta-wipe*), thus it is an effective way to learn the area, so you know what to do and what to not do when you try w/ a balanced group. Is learning how to do something in a 2-step process vs 1-step (learning the area and how to use your skills in said area at the same time) really that bad?