W/E Conjure Axe

Elite should be eviscerate, not cleave. Get rid of both penetratings, and cyclone. Take an IAS, flurry for you as I wouldn't trust just anyone to use frenzy even with a cancel stance. Take executioner's chop and if you only have prophecies keep cyclone. And the more survivor insignia you have the better. I say you learn by doing and by making mistakes, so I think the OP should go ahead and bring frenzy along with sprint/rush. Also, [skill]cleave[/skill] and [skill]eviscerate[/skill] do pretty much identical damage but cleave has lower adrenaline requirement but doesn't do deep wound which does little in pve anyways since the whole group should be concentrating on one target and they die fairly quickly. But conjure flame at 9 will do an extra 14 damage so triple chop would be a good choice to get conjure to trigger more often. Another thing to consider is that in prophecies, there is the fire islands inhabited by fire element monsters and the shiverpeaks with ice element monsters, so I would think about going with [skill]conjure lightning[/skill]. I don't think there are any monsters in the game with a resistance to lightning (except rangers who have extra armor against all elements which you should have an extra axe to use to counter them anyways.)

So then how about this then:

[skill]conjure lightning[/skill]
[skill]Triple Chop[/skill]
[skill]Penetrating Blow[/skill]
[skill]Penetrating Chop[/skill]
[skill]Frenzy[/skill]
[skill]Rush[/skill]
[skill]Healing Signet[/skill]
[skill]Resurrection Signet[/skill] Definitely on the right track. My concern would be for Penetrating Chop and Penetrating Blow.. first of all, they're kinda redundant, and secondly it may be better to bring along an interrupt, Dismember, or Bull's Strike. There's lots of Axe skills that do more than just damage.

Looks pretty good! I'm more of a [skill]Flail[/skill] than a [skill]Frenzy[/skill] person, especially with HealSig and Frenzy being quite nasty for you at times.

Normally I'd say find room for [skill]Bull's Strike[/skill] as well, my choice would be the rez sig, but fleeing foes aren't THAT much of a problem...

*tries to avoid flame war*

EDIT: [skill]"For Great Justice!"[/skill] would still be sexier than rez sig Well you're right, in PvE Flail would be better than Frenzy if Kenpachi has Nightfall. Bull's Strike is kinda unnecessary in PvE as well, but owns in PvP. And the res is only really needed when with PUG groups or when you're doing a mission where you can't auto-res.