Random Arenas Guild, Good idea or Not?

SO, I was thinking today being bored in pve "What if an RA guild existed?"

There are several TA/GvG/HA Guilds but what about a guild that caters to those who REALLY enjoy the unpredictability of RA? I think a guild that brought RA lovers together might be kinda neat, it would be a forum of people who enjoyed the smaller overlooked pvp games in the game such as ascalon arena, shiverpeaks arena, ra, and the fort aspenwood and jade mine missions. Does this sound like something people might appreciate?

I would enjoy hearing all feedback negative or positive.

A novel idea.

Except usually the point of a guild is to play with people like you / you like. And you won't be able to do that unless you sync. With all the effort and time that it will take you to get in together, you might as well make a TA guild instead.

point of a guild is to play together and unless you get lucky and sync together I don't think it would be that fun

Average PVP Player says: "Why should I make the effort to sync or whatever when I can join a TA guild?"

Well the true GOOD TA guilds look at the average player and kills him/her LOL
just a little joke

Are there enough people out there who spend all their time in RA, to form a cohesive guild? I can't speak for everyone but RA is something I do to kill a little time here and there, unless it's a double faction weekend, when I might spend more time.

Syncing is stupid imho. Building a guild based on griefing - meh.

I'd not create an RA guild, cuz it's really hard to sync each other and if you leave the battles to many times you get temporary banned for like 5 mins or so from all kind of PvP.
And if you was going to suceed with the sync, you'd go straight into the team arena after 10 consecutive wins which would be where you'd be beaten if you got a good build in RA.

The point of RA is to play PvP solo, and occasionally sync with a friend. But if you make a guild solely to sync with people you know in RA, well, that just means you're not or think you're good to play TA

Perish the thought of joining a guild full of random arena people I was there a few times in the past and the people are just vile there in and out of battle. Same goes for PVP in general I don't know why their mentality changes once they get stuck into pvp. They just become mean arrogant asses that get off by using this BS leet speak and calling people noobs and saying they fail lol its kinda pathetic don't you think? Oh and the rank flashers are just the funniest edition to any pve environment. Before you say I actually do a bit of both so I'm not strictly into either. Just an observation I made not 100% of them are like that but a bigger majority are.

Even if you made a random arenas guild, it would become a TA guild.

The only way a guild would benefit people who play random 4v4 is if you got a crap ton of people with their ra builds in your gh and all /rolled 100, then the 4 highest rolls were one team, etc, then u scrimmaged. Which would be a horrible idea.

edit: and that guild would most likely turn into a ta guild, as has been said