Observation of a new guildwars player towards earning money

wsmcasey

wsmcasey

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Jul 2005

Right behind you.

HeRo

W/Rt

Quote:
Originally Posted by mr_groovy
I bought Guildwars Factions for a friend of mine. I showed him the basics, and gave him a little bit of gear. He made a warrior, as it is one of the easiest prof to start with.

I told him he should upgrade his Armor every chance he got, monestary, seitung harbor & finally in Kaneing Center.
He now has been playing for 40 hours, is lvl 20 and has almost done all the quests he can find before doing Vizunah Square. (Told him better to have max armor for that one).

And here's the problem, he still hasn't got the money to buy it. With max armor using 200 Iron & 32 Steel Ignots the price get's pretty steep. And he merchs all the stuff he can find, and uses expert salvage kit's on for materials also already.

Now I don't know if lootscaling has anything to do with it, as he travels with 8 all the time. But I know first hand that if you kill a lot of creatures in a near instant moment, the scaling bumps in and u get almost nothing.

Now take this example. I go farm 1/8 and kill 12 creatures in an instant. I usually get 0-3 drops. Now if i'm 8/8 I will get (0-3)/8 drops. (Better example kill tons of groups of margonites in HM with Battle of Turai's Procession, in a instant with during pre-nerf splinter weapon, netting also 0-3 items).

Yes you might tell me your calculations are wrong because of lootscaling you still get the 0-3 drops because lootscaling recognizes party size. But experiences differ.

So my question is do you Experience the same in the quantity of drops, or is this just a figment of my Imagination?

Ps keep it clean, refrain from ranting. And please don't steer the pvp vs pve thing.
Teach him to farm solo with a monk secondary. As he progresses thru factions, I would urge him to go with a ritualist secondary to cap "Vengful Was Kanai" on the Luxon side. My W/Rit has more flexibility than my Monk, Ele and Assasin when it comes to farming. I always find more areas that I can farm with him.

Point him in the direction of Guildwarsguru and have him set up an account. Then send him over to the farming section to research builds.

reverse_oreo

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Dec 2005

Scars Meadows [SmS] Officer (not recruiting)

Collectors armors and dont upgrade your armor every chance you get. Just stick with starter until you can afford the big stuff. thats what i do

wsmcasey

wsmcasey

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Jul 2005

Right behind you.

HeRo

W/Rt

Quote:
Originally Posted by reverse_oreo
Collectors armors and dont upgrade your armor every chance you get. Just stick with starter until you can afford the big stuff. thats what i do
I agree, though I didnt say it. Sticking with collectors armor is the way to go if you have the patience for collecting and finding the collectors. He could have saved enough for max armor easily.

reverse_oreo

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Dec 2005

Scars Meadows [SmS] Officer (not recruiting)

Quote:
Originally Posted by wsmcasey
I agree, though I didnt say it. Sticking with collectors armor is the way to go if you have the patience for collecting and finding the collectors. He could have saved enough for max armor easily.
When i first started this game, i did just the opposite and got every level armor i could get. Bad move. If you just save your money for one set of decent max armor you are much better off.

Martin Alvito

Martin Alvito

Older Than God (1)

Join Date: Aug 2006

Clan Dethryche [dth]

Making money in most RPG's is an exponential function of time invested (until you reach the most efficient farm/trade setup, anyway). At 40 hours you're still WELL within the range of setup time for this game.

I don't think I started making decent money until a couple of hundred hours in (bout two months in, on my War).

Could be worse; he could be playing WoW and need four to six months of hardcore play to reach max level.

fog_of_redoubt

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: May 2005

Quote:
Originally Posted by MagmaRed

I really wish the people who state "killing things fast reduces drops" would provide evidence to support that claim.
Evidence has been posted many times. If you don't want to believe it then fine don't believe it. IT IS 100% FACT.

Find a mob you can solo and mass kill, easiest way to see it is with Spiteful Spirit, then take that same mob and kill them one at a time solo. A perfect spot for this is the Zelnehlun Farm outside of Rilohon Refuge.

So where is YOUR evidence that all the people that claim this are wrong?????

fog_of_redoubt

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: May 2005

To the Original Poster.

I can't imagine enjoying this game if I had just started playing. Fortunately I have a full storage of cash, and 100k on each character. This is all from farming prior to the nerfs and loot scaling.

This game is NOT fun for new comers. Loot scaling failed to stop bots, and failed to make the game better for new comers.

As someone else said remember the way this franchise has been handled before spending money on GW2.

Sekkira

Sekkira

Forge Runner

Join Date: Apr 2005

Canberra, AU

Quote:
Originally Posted by korcan
there are 35 monastery credits worth of quests available on shing jea. that equals out to 3.5k. im sure its not too difficult to come up with the remaining cash for max kc armor.
Not to mention 20 imperial commendations @ 200g each + the various quests in between shing jea and vizunah that give 250g each.

Antheus

Forge Runner

Join Date: Jan 2006

Quote:
Originally Posted by fog_of_redoubt
Evidence has been posted many times. If you don't want to believe it then fine don't believe it. IT IS 100% FACT.

Find a mob you can solo and mass kill, easiest way to see it is with Spiteful Spirit, then take that same mob and kill them one at a time solo. A perfect spot for this is the Zelnehlun Farm outside of Rilohon Refuge.

So where is YOUR evidence that all the people that claim this are wrong?????
You also take more time killing them. Your earnings per hour are the same.

Quote:
I can't imagine enjoying this game if I had just started playing. Fortunately I have a full storage of cash, and 100k on each character. This is all from farming prior to the nerfs and loot scaling.
No, you can't. Just like you'd have hard time imagining anyone enjoying any game after giving up all your wealth and achievements. Money was much harder to make in the beginning. Making a solo monk cost 50k easily. And yet, everyone eventually got past the beginner stage and made money.

Quote:
This game is NOT fun for new comers. Loot scaling failed to stop bots, and failed to make the game better for new comers.
Jaded farmer?

There's plenty of newcomers. They are doing just fine, and have a much easier job than newcomers used to. Loot scaling only has meaning to some that relied on solo farming to make absurd fortunes. It has no impact on regular player. And even then, farms still exist, just like they always did. And almost all of them are considerably cheaper to run than they used to be, regarding the runes and equipment.

Crom The Pale

Crom The Pale

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Nov 2006

Ageis Ascending

W/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Keithark
he is new cannot vanquish

I did 8 areas in elonia this weekend and pu everything that dropped, 1/2 was done with h/h the other with 1 person and their hero's I made 22k....pitiful, that is like 3.7k/hr or something

By vanquish I was simply reffering to killing everything on the map as opposed to doing only a quest or what needed to be cleared to reach the next town.

pamelf

pamelf

Forge Runner

Join Date: Aug 2006

Australia

Lost Templars [LoTe]

Me/Mo

I never upgraded my armour every chance I got... I upgraded once, then waited until I got Max armour. Worked fine, and I didn't die more than other people. That's probably why your friend has no money...he's spent it all on useless armour upgrades he didn't need...

angmar_nite

angmar_nite

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Feb 2007

[SNOW] of [YUM]

E/

Salvage old armor?

manitoba1073

manitoba1073

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Jan 2006

ManitobaShipyards Refit and Repair Station

(SFC)Star Fleet Command,(TDE)The Daggerfall elite,(SOoM)Secret order of Magi

Quote:
Originally Posted by fog_of_redoubt
Evidence has been posted many times. If you don't want to believe it then fine don't believe it. IT IS 100% FACT.

Find a mob you can solo and mass kill, easiest way to see it is with Spiteful Spirit, then take that same mob and kill them one at a time solo. A perfect spot for this is the Zelnehlun Farm outside of Rilohon Refuge.

So where is YOUR evidence that all the people that claim this are wrong?????
you are wrong. Its not a AoE bug that reduces loot. Its a ToD bug( Timing of Death) that what happens is when you multipe things at once the loot assignment system hangs on its first step the selection of who gets the drop. Thus if you are soloing and now since you have LS it makes it seems worse. Its actually a left over bug from the OLD FoW drop bug thats still left over when Anet fixed it long ago.

but heres your proof and by what you are claiming then thi would never happen.



First picture 3 kills 3 drops.




Second picture 3 drops 4 kills all where kill at once using AoE.

Now back to the OP. Yes it is harder for new players now as all the essentials that are needed for armors and that is exactly what is effected by LS. Including collectors drops.

Winterclaw

Winterclaw

Wark!!!

Join Date: May 2005

Florida

W/

A thought just hit me. Are we going to have to buy 100-200 levels worth of armor in GW2? Are we all going to need 1 million plat plus per char in order to buy the max AL armor in that game, not to mention elite or that game's version of FoW/Vabbian?

pamelf

pamelf

Forge Runner

Join Date: Aug 2006

Australia

Lost Templars [LoTe]

Me/Mo

Quote:
Originally Posted by Winterclaw
A thought just hit me. Are we going to have to buy 100-200 levels worth of armor in GW2? Are we all going to need 1 million plat plus per char in order to buy the max AL armor in that game, not to mention elite or that game's version of FoW/Vabbian?
A very good point....

Kusandaa

Kusandaa

Forge Runner

Join Date: Jul 2006

N/Mo

I'll take my husband's case. He's relatively new to GW, but not to MMORPGs (he's been playing D2 online since 2000, so 7 years). In only a few days of playing, he already outgrew the learning curve. He's getting bored of not being of a higher level, not having the skills and weaponry that he'd need... so cash is an issue for him.

Normally I'd tell the people to play through the game and get cash, save for max armor instead of buying stuff every town... since cash is hard to come by these days. But he's my husband and I can see him (literally) get bored of having to kill all these foes for a measly 100g, while he has skills, weaponry and another character to sustain.

What we did:

1. I paid for his Droks armor and a few runs; he's getting bored, might as well help him level up fast before he goes nuts. He's past the learning curve of where he is level-wise (15, in Kryta), time for him to move on. 15k won't kill me anyways.

2. I told him to work on ONE character at a time. He doesn't have the means to sustain multiple characters yet, like most of us are doing (I guess, after 2 years). He's gotta deal with one, a ranger, that needs skills so he can learn farming runs (FoW, UW, ToPK - he's a Proph-only guy so far). So once he's settled, and made a few more k's... he'll be able to do the same with his ele (farm, make money, get ran around, work on a new character).

I think this... lack of cash... comes from loot scaling, since I have no idea why he's having such a hard time coming across cash, which isn't a good experience for him. I don't recall having such problems, or maybe I didn't NOTICE it, since I hadn't played online RPGs before (but been gaming since I'm 4 and I'm 22) and had nothing to compare it.

Buster

Buster

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Jan 2006

Elona

Clan Eternal Legion

D/W

I haven't made a new character in over a year but as I recall, even in prophecies getting to max level is easy. Making money on the other hand has changed since loot scaling and end game greens which has decreased the value of greens dropped by bosses.

CHunterX

CHunterX

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Sep 2005

Washington

W/E

You all act like hes a veteran player starting a new character. New players don't know about all the quests. New players don't know the return rate for trading Imperial Commendations is highest with Superior Salvage. New players don't know the best builds. New players don't know the best farming spots.
You can talk all high and mighty about soloing mobs in the UW, and vanquishing zones in a timely manner, but how the hell is a new player suppose to find out about these things, and more importantly, if he can't even afford armor, how's he suppose to afford skills to run these builds?

Kusandaa

Kusandaa

Forge Runner

Join Date: Jul 2006

N/Mo

Quote:
Originally Posted by N8mare
OMG, what's the problem? if u can afford buying GW, u can afford spending some money on buying the gold from some korean websites or ebay. The worst thing that could happen is 72hrs ban - far better then spending a month trying to farm the gold. AN has nerfed everything that could help u to get rich (Lenin's school?) - so I don't care about their mental problems with GOLD
It's still against the EULA. I've never resorted to this and I make cash quiet easily, you just need the good spots.

kobey

kobey

GW Retiree

Join Date: Nov 2005

Sg Unknown [KATE]

W/

In the past, when you get lucky, you get gold runes from armor drops. eg. monk sup runes are like 15-20k, sup vigor are like 70k and warrior absorption runes are 100k at trader.

Well, now they don't make a difference, everything cost the same

Abnaxus

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Nov 2005

Europe

Keepers of Chaos

My very 1st character was a necro which I created in May 2005, I was able to make armors only in Beetletun and Amnoon Oasis, played N/Me blood magic + domination, with some unbelievable builds including life siphon, well of blood, empathy, chaos storm and energy surge (until I capped life trasfer lol), pugged the whole game in a period in which necros were accepted only in some desperate teams, did THK at 6th try, and completed the game with Amnoon armor.

Only after that I was able to collect enough gold to get Droks armor, essentially farming with an ele and a warrior.

Those remain my best times in GW, times for heroes ...

eeks

eeks

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Jul 2006

Sydney, Australia

Lubricated Volcano Love [Club]

Rt/Mo

Hmm. My boyfriend's been playing for about a month, and has made enough money to get himself max armor for three characters with reasonably expensive dyes. Additionally, he also salvages items, and sells stacks of materials for reasonable prices to people and is therefore doing well for himself.

Another friend I got into Guild Wars made 40k within a month, during the Dragon Festival by selling tokens.

The last friend I got into Guild Wars, hasn't gotten a grasp at selling items properly yet, but is consistent, with around 10k always on her character.

I guess it just depends on whether new players can see, and take opportunities to make decent money, and how fast their learning curve is.

reetkever

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Dec 2005

Mo/E

I've been telling this since the week after loot scaling kicked in. In most cases1,5K armor is way too expensive for the average starting player.

The quest rewards and drops just don't net one enough cash.

As for the drops when killing all at the same time - This is true for me, too. Killing monsters one by one really seems to improve the drops a little bit.

Rathcail

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Jan 2006

Quote:
Originally Posted by CHunterX
New players don't know the return rate for trading Imperial Commendations is highest with Superior Salvage.
New player would find out if they talk to the quartermasters and look through the available items.

Too much to ask?

Schroedinger

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: Nov 2007

Quote:
Originally Posted by ValaOfTheFens
He needs collector armor. In Factions getting max collector armor is somewhat bothersome because you will inevitably need Venerable Mantid Pincers and the Mantids in question are only in 3-4 mobs outside Nahpui Quarter. I couldn't find a way to farming it(I was only setup for 55 farming at the time and some have Gaze of Contempt) solo so I did it with just 3 heroes(henchs would have been fine). This only yielded 1-2 Venerable Mantid Pincers per run but it was cheaper than buying them(I once saw someone selling them for 500g each). As a Warrior your friend should have minimal trouble soloing the Mantids and getting alot more Pincers than I did.

In general, I advise your friend to just play the game. I used to think that loot scaling was a joke but I have to say that I was completely wrong. The only thing I get less of is crafting materials.

Schroedinger: When you get to Diessa Lowlands you'll want a full group. Trust me on that one. PM me in-game if you need any help!!
I'll let you know! So far we're through to Pakin Sq., and peeling off to do skill quests. A bit of a hiccup: my wife's laptop is running base Intel graphics chipset, so we need to acquire a graphics card that actually works with GW so she stops getting killed by the most feared monster in any RPG: The BSoD.

Still no cash issues, we both upgraded armor in Ascalon City and our storage is packed with craft materials and cash (First plat!)

Antheus

Forge Runner

Join Date: Jan 2006

Quote:
As for the drops when killing all at the same time - This is true for me, too. Killing monsters one by one really seems to improve the drops a little bit.
Does it also increase the time needed "a little bit"?

phan

phan

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Nov 2006

phantasmagoria

Quote:
Originally Posted by VinnyRidira
Good grief, 40 hours to get to level 20 in factions. It is so easy to do in 8 hours with all the Kaineng quests also gathering enough money to get 80 armour for a warrior.
You don't get the point .. he's new to the game how in fock sake's can he get level 20 in 8 hours ? ...

btw : i would enjoy reaching level 20 on your first char .. its the best time in your guildwars history ..


ps ; vinnyridira .. your ss armor sucks on warrior .. lalalalala