4 Attribute Shields (for GW2)

1 pages Page 1
Longasc
Longasc
Forge Runner
#1
Right now, we have 4 kinds of shields:

Tactics
Strength
Command
Motivation

Especially as a Warrior, you have the same kind of shield usually as a tactics and a strength variant, taking up storage together with the many helmets and so on.

Suggestion:

Make shields have

req. X (STR, TAC, COM or MOT)

or whatever attributes there will be in GW2.
Mitchel
Mitchel
Krytan Explorer
#2
/signed, just like we have with some staves
L
Limu Tolkki
Wilds Pathfinder
#3
/signed

They should be str or tac and com or mot. And not all of them. Some staves would have this too.
Onarik Amrak
Onarik Amrak
Forge Runner
#4
/signed

Would make things much simpler.
MithranArkanere
MithranArkanere
Underworld Spelunker
#5
There are already staves and focuses with 4 attributes.

Why not shields?
w
warcrap
Krytan Explorer
#6
/signed

eh wth sounds like an improvement.
Issac
Issac
Desert Nomad
#7
signed

good idea.
Woop Shotty
Woop Shotty
Wilds Pathfinder
#8
I bet they'll do it for some boss' green.
Lil Ferk
Lil Ferk
Academy Page
#9
sure

12 chars
Yawgmoth
Yawgmoth
Furnace Stoker
#10
as in GW2 there may be a completely different attribute or requirement system (for example level requirements) and we know nothing about it yet, we should concentrate on GW1.

And for GW1 this is a fantastic idea! (if applied well)

Some time ago I was thinking of ways to have some rare items be 'better' than an ordinary perfect but not affect balance and PvP. And this is such a cool way to do this!

How I'd like it to be done:

*Have Gold Shields (yes, only gold) occassionally (for example 20% chance)drop with a secondary requirement, always the other one of the same profession.
*both requirements should be separate - so a shield can drop with for example (Reqires 10 Strength, 11 Tactics)
*the "Master my Domain" inscription should ofcourse work on the attribute of the first requrement only, so the 2 attrib shields aren't functionally strictly better than 1 attrib.