Is grenth a good God??
roshanabey2
Does Grenth like his followers or does he just want to see everyone die??
Tatile
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by roshanabey2
Does Grenth like his followers or does he just want to see everyone die??
|
I wouldn't say he's "good" in the fluffy bunnies, presents sort of way, but he is "good" in a 'not Abaddon' way. Neutral is probably the best way to view him.
Edit: It annoys me to no end, only one question mark is needed to denote a question. Please do not use more than one. Two is far too many, three is asking for a beating. Use only one question mark.
Vicks
Grenth is a good guy, in the strictest sense of the word.
You can't blame the guy for being a bit cold when he's got the toughest job in the entire rift, can you? I mean somebody needs to shepherd the souls of the deceased, judge them, and oversee their eternal fate. And unless the rift is constantly expanding, I would imagine he's also in charge of determining when and how souls are reincarnated or returned to the planet's life force.
And if you are his devout follower, no doubt you'll get what you want. Although you'll have to make your dues with sacrifices of equal value, to level your balance.
You can't blame the guy for being a bit cold when he's got the toughest job in the entire rift, can you? I mean somebody needs to shepherd the souls of the deceased, judge them, and oversee their eternal fate. And unless the rift is constantly expanding, I would imagine he's also in charge of determining when and how souls are reincarnated or returned to the planet's life force.
And if you are his devout follower, no doubt you'll get what you want. Although you'll have to make your dues with sacrifices of equal value, to level your balance.
RedStar
Well, if I remember correctly, Grenth is better than the god before him (Dhuum I think), so I'll say that he's a good death god.
Avatara
good and evil is for mortals... I think the plans of the gods go a bit beyond that
gargytama
Well, to compare with the lore of Guild Wars Abaddon was an evil god, so the other five gods defeated him and locked him up.
Since Grenth's not defeated nor locked up and he gives us access to the Underworld we could agree with that he is a good god ^^
Since Grenth's not defeated nor locked up and he gives us access to the Underworld we could agree with that he is a good god ^^
arsie
The only time he is portrayed as not being neutral is during Wintersday. Besides the obvious Grinch references, why should Grenth be interested in making children's lives miserable?
Eldin
Grenth is neutral.
Just because a guy is in charge of the dead, he has to be considered evil? I mean, come on, SOMEONE has to do that job.
Plus, they said the God before him, Dhuum, was cruel and unjust, so Grenth is definitely better.
Also, Grenth's mindset during Wintersday is not just pure evil. I forget where it was, but one of the Wintersday NPCs I recall during Wintersday 2005 (goooooooood times) had even said something like "I feel Grenth should win this Wintersday. Even though I do not oppose festivities, winter should be a time of cold and sorrow in which we reflect upon blah blah blah".
A cold, sad winter doesn't necessarily symbolize evil.
Plus, Grenth gives us ECTOS! So he's good in my book.
Just because a guy is in charge of the dead, he has to be considered evil? I mean, come on, SOMEONE has to do that job.
Plus, they said the God before him, Dhuum, was cruel and unjust, so Grenth is definitely better.
Also, Grenth's mindset during Wintersday is not just pure evil. I forget where it was, but one of the Wintersday NPCs I recall during Wintersday 2005 (goooooooood times) had even said something like "I feel Grenth should win this Wintersday. Even though I do not oppose festivities, winter should be a time of cold and sorrow in which we reflect upon blah blah blah".
A cold, sad winter doesn't necessarily symbolize evil.
Plus, Grenth gives us ECTOS! So he's good in my book.
Randvek
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Avatara
good and evil is for mortals... I think the plans of the gods go a bit beyond that
|
Wintersday shows a malicious side of Grenth, but I wouldn't call him downright evil. If Grenth were truly evil, he would have gone the way of Abaddon, Dhuum, and Menzies. Even if you consider him evil, he's clearly Evil Lite: half the calories of pure evil!
Fangclaw
I've seen something like this in the last Wintersday... (2007)
The Avatar of Grenth said something about not opposing festivities; and that Winter is a time to reflect upon the nature of life... and Death, but obviously, mostly death.
The Avatar of Grenth said something about not opposing festivities; and that Winter is a time to reflect upon the nature of life... and Death, but obviously, mostly death.
Biostem
I always thought as Grenth as having the unenviable job of keeping track of all mortals' deeds while they're alive, so he can appropriately prepare for them when they do die. It's not so much a heaven/hell thing, but an issue of balance. From what I've gathered, a person's existence doesn't end when they die, but that's where Dwayna, Melandru, and Blathazar focus much of their attention, (while they're alive, I mean). Grenth has a lot of ground to cover, so to speak.
Free Runner
I'm willing to bet the Underworld as we see it when we first enter it is how Dhumm would of ran things. So going off that i would say Grenth is a good god (or like Eldin said: hes a neutral god) . But when you view the god of death you always believe they are bad.
English Warrior
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by roshanabey2
Does Grenth like his followers or does he just want to see everyone die??
|
The Meth
I would say that as grenth is supposed to be the god of justice he naturally makes him lean a bit towards good. But as the 'judger of souls' its his job be as neutral as possible, just as many necromancer and some ritualist skills require a sacrifice of your own life to return for power (ie you have to be prepared to bear the pain of your victim). Its said that Dhuum was a 'cruel and unjust god' which suggests that grenth is at the least not evil, if not good. In the UW many quests deal with saving good souls from places they shouldn't have gone to, which shows that he isn't indifferent to their fate.
Edit: Are things like wintersday really considered canon guild wars? I always thought they were more of a just for fun thing that weren't really in the guild wars world.
Edit: Are things like wintersday really considered canon guild wars? I always thought they were more of a just for fun thing that weren't really in the guild wars world.
Free Runner
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by The Meth
Edit: Are things like wintersday really considered canon guild wars? I always thought they were more of a just for fun thing that weren't really in the guild wars world.
|
-Old 3FL-
I'd say that Grenth is a badass, but a good one at the same time.
Holly Herro
Grenth is just god.
That's it.
That's it.
KalleDamos
Good and evil are a matter of perspective. To Monks, Grenths may be evil, to necromancers he may be good. But in truth Grenth is a God of Balance more than he is a God of Death. This is just my persepctive at least.
Longasc
Hades and Pluton had no negative connotation in greek/roman mythology either.
In norse mythology the goddess Hel was also more neutral, but was later depicted as the devil of the christian "hell". Hell is a place of punishment for us christians.
But the five gods of Tyria are only inspired by our culture(s). Grenth still gives us the creeps, but if his reapers call Dhuum "cruel and unjust", and we know Dhuum worked together with Abaddon who was not nice at all, it seems that we have a rather benevolent god of death.
In norse mythology the goddess Hel was also more neutral, but was later depicted as the devil of the christian "hell". Hell is a place of punishment for us christians.
But the five gods of Tyria are only inspired by our culture(s). Grenth still gives us the creeps, but if his reapers call Dhuum "cruel and unjust", and we know Dhuum worked together with Abaddon who was not nice at all, it seems that we have a rather benevolent god of death.
Olim Chill
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Tatile
I'd say Grenth, as the god of Death, is indifferent, as death itself is.
|
Stoneys Rock
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Olim lll
Agreed. The acts in which death is brought about are linked to morality, but not death itself.
|
Olim Chill
^Justice is blind, i.e. indifferent.