Abritrary Name Filter

2 pages Page 1
Snow Bunny
Snow Bunny
Alcoholic From Yale
#1
So, I recently purchased another online multiplayer game, and when prompted for a IGN, instead of my old standby, I Snow Bunny I, I sat around for a bit, and thought of the name "Tryangle". As simple as it was, I liked the ascetic of the name and decided I'd make a char on GW named T R Y A N G L E.

Oddly, it was denied, due to "Words not permitted in Guild Wars" Code=031. I quickly made "Try Angle", which was accepted. I've had this happen twice now with names that for the life of me could not possibly be offensive.

Has anyone else had this happen? Is it just me or is it a bit odd?
ArTy
ArTy
Lion's Arch Merchant
#2
Maybe the dev who did the name filter is pissed at "R Y A N" for taking his beers without asking
S
Swift Thief
Krytan Explorer
#3
Well, my "Bin Laden is Coming" was censored for some odd reason too.
tuna-fish_sushi
tuna-fish_sushi
Desert Nomad
#4
They banned almost anything with a space between every letter because it was really easy to type anything you want spaced out and its hard to filter that kind of stuff.
Saraphim
Saraphim
Jungle Guide
#5
I seem to remember a similar thread a while back came to the conclusion that a "G" with spaces either side gets blocked by the filter. I've seen a few people ingame with spaced out letters, so it is possible to do, just not with the G.

Thought so, search was my friend for a change.

Lol... I wonder what I posted in that thread, can't even remember but it got edited.
w
wu is me
Krytan Explorer
#6
=O "Gaile" and "Guild" are also prohibited.

guess it kinda makes sense tho, so, Gai Ie and Gui Id will have to do =P
Sab
Sab
Desert Nomad
#7
G is a very offensive letter.
garethporlest18
garethporlest18
Forge Runner
#8
Quote:
Originally Posted by ArTy
Maybe the dev who did the name filter is pissed at "R Y A N" for taking his beers without asking
I didn't steal any beers dammit!
Gaile Gray
Gaile Gray
ArenaNet
#9
In any game, you have a lot of people pretending to be staff members. It's called "impersonation," and it can be used to scam people of items, trash a guild, or steal an entire account.

We block the singular use of the letter "G" because we found that many people were using G M (name here) to try to pretend they are staff members at ArenaNet or NCsoft.

Sorry for the inconvenience, but I'm sure that you'll agree that preventing item scamming and account theft is a high priority and that we should address any potential abuse of the system that might allow players to be deceived.
t_the_nihilst
t_the_nihilst
Academy Page
#10
Quote:
Originally Posted by Snow Bunny
So, I recently purchased another online multiplayer game, and when prompted for a IGN, instead of my old standby, I Snow Bunny I, I sat around for a bit, and thought of the name "Tryangle". As simple as it was, I liked the ascetic of the name and decided I'd make a char on GW named T R Y A N G L E.

Oddly, it was denied, due to "Words not permitted in Guild Wars" Code=031. I quickly made "Try Angle", which was accepted. I've had this happen twice now with names that for the life of me could not possibly be offensive.

Has anyone else had this happen? Is it just me or is it a bit odd?

Hrmmm yeah, I tried to name my new PvE ele "Legendary Pink Dot." You know, after the band? I guess they assumed I was maybe a bot or something trying to advertise a website in-game, so I had to name her "Legendary Pink Dott." Not as good, but still good. Er... whatever.
Many people will make inappropriate character names and will only get in trouble if they piss someone off and get reported. Meanwhile, others will try to make characters with names that aren't offensive at all, and won't be able to. That's the way the cookie crumbles, I guess.
Faer
Faer
La-Li-Lu-Le-Lo
#11
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gaile Gray
Sorry for the inconvenience, but I'm sure that you'll agree that preventing item scamming and account theft is a high priority and that we should address any potential abuse of the system that might allow players to be deceived.
But why not block the use of "G M <xvariable>" instead? Or, what about a warning on the login screen or somewhere else noticeable to alert users to the problem? Simply blocking the singular use of the letter "G" in names is not going to be nearly enough to stop people from impersonating staff, and while it is a step to deter such action, I feel that perhaps different steps could have been taken that would have inconvenienced less users (though I am aware at how little an inconvenience not being able to use G by itself in a name is).
C
Chik N Nuggets
Krytan Explorer
#12
lol i made a ranger called "C U M" earlyer XD
Pleikki
Pleikki
WTB q8 15^50 Weapons!
#13
mm.. Im making new char next week.. will some of my new names will be censored aswell :d
Bryant Again
Bryant Again
Hall Hero
#14
Quote:
Originally Posted by Faer
But why not block the use of "G M <xvariable>" instead? Or, what about a warning on the login screen or somewhere else noticeable to alert users to the problem? Simply blocking the singular use of the letter "G" in names is not going to be nearly enough to stop people from impersonating staff, and while it is a step to deter such action, I feel that perhaps different steps could have been taken that would have inconvenienced less users (though I am aware at how little an inconvenience not being able to use G by itself in a name is).
It could be seen as G A for "game admin" or A M for simply "admin." Many possibilities.

Quote:
Originally Posted by t_the_nihilst
Hrmmm yeah, I tried to name my new PvE ele "Legendary Pink Dot." You know, after the band? I guess they assumed I was maybe a bot or something trying to advertise a website in-game, so I had to name her "Legendary Pink Dott." Not as good, but still good. Er... whatever.
Now that doesn't make much sense. Maybe "dot" has something to do with "bot?"
RhanoctJocosa
RhanoctJocosa
Legendary Korean
#15
Quote:
Originally Posted by Faer
But why not block the use of "G M <xvariable>" instead? Or, what about a warning on the login screen or somewhere else noticeable to alert users to the problem? Simply blocking the singular use of the letter "G" in names is not going to be nearly enough to stop people from impersonating staff, and while it is a step to deter such action, I feel that perhaps different steps could have been taken that would have inconvenienced less users (though I am aware at how little an inconvenience not being able to use G by itself in a name is).
But that would make too much sense.

Now we wait for Gaile to actually reply when it matters.
Desbreko
Desbreko
Lion's Arch Merchant
#16
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bryant Again
Now that doesn't make much sense. Maybe "dot" has something to do with "bot?"
It would be to stop things like Guildwarsguru Dot Com being used as a name to advertise a website.
cthulhu reborn
cthulhu reborn
Wilds Pathfinder
#17
Quote:
Originally Posted by Faer
But why not block the use of "G M <xvariable>" instead? Or, what about a warning on the login screen or somewhere else noticeable to alert users to the problem? Simply blocking the singular use of the letter "G" in names is not going to be nearly enough to stop people from impersonating staff, and while it is a step to deter such action, I feel that perhaps different steps could have been taken that would have inconvenienced less users (though I am aware at how little an inconvenience not being able to use G by itself in a name is).
Perhaps they also wanted to block G Spot and G String type of names. :P

Personally I am more annoyed that they would block the name Litany of Damnation which I wanted even though the game contains Damned Clerics. Kinda makes the censorship silly when you block it in character names but not for monsters or NPC's.
Yawgmoth
Yawgmoth
Furnace Stoker
#18
It's done wrong and needs a fix.

After doing some tests I'm sure the game would be able to block just all the "G M" and "G A" without blocking the single letter "G".

For example a word "Guild" and word "Wars" are allowed separately, but whole "Guild Wars" contains disallowed words!
You can go test variations of the F word, no matter how you split it with spaces it's disallowed. But take another disallowed word, like for example "Shit" (disallowed) and add spaces to make "S H I T" - this one is allowed by the system!
There's more! For some of disallowed strings the system disallows all longer strings that contain the shorter one, for example "Admin" is detected no matter where it is in the word, disallowing whole "Ogradminx" string. But some matter only if they are at the begining of the string! Like "Gm" disallowing any string that starts with those 2 letters - "Gmoragus" is not allowed but "Xgmoragus" is. And some words are disallowed only if it's a whole word with nothing added - example: "Nig" is not allowed but "Anig" or "Niga" is.

I see no technical reason of prohibiting the use of the single letter "G", while the system can be set up to just disallow "G A" and "G M".

It really needs a fix, else I won't be able to create the mighty team of:
"Mending Spiker A"
"Mending Spiker B"
"Mending Spiker C"
"Mending Spiker D"
"Mending Spiker E"
"Mending Spiker F"
"Mending Spiker G" <- now this guy's name is disallowed, sad.
"Mending Spiker H"
Jake_Steel
Jake_Steel
Lion's Arch Merchant
#19
There goes my OG "G Money" name...
tmakinen
tmakinen
Desert Nomad
#20
Quote:
Originally Posted by cthulhu reborn
Personally I am more annoyed that they would block the name Litany of Damnation which I wanted even though the game contains Damned Clerics. Kinda makes the censorship silly when you block it in character names but not for monsters or NPC's.
I usually substitute 'darn' for 'damn' to get around the filter, although in the above mentioned situation the result might not sound quite right

Filtered NPC/monster names are funny, too.

"----ed Cleric is using Bane Signet!"
"I am attacking Captain ----ang!"

In any case, the explanation for 'the evil G' kind of makes sense, but just kind of.