Open To Critisysm
Hodgie
Edited by Celestial Beaver: Changed thread title to give some sort of indication of what the thread is about. Please refrain from creating threads with the title "Been Thinking..."
Poll Added.
Allow the use of Allegiance Title Track skills in Alliance Battles.
Hodgie
Why are alleigiance skills not aloud in AB? I mean like you get them from ABing, so why can't you use them in AB? I know they are PvE skills but maybe that should be changed maybe so they can only be used in PvE and AB, but not any other PvP arena.
Open To Critisysm
Hodgie
Edited by Celestial Beaver: Changed thread title to give some sort of indication of what the thread is about. Please refrain from creating threads with the title "Been Thinking..."
Poll Added.
Open To Critisysm
Hodgie
Edited by Celestial Beaver: Changed thread title to give some sort of indication of what the thread is about. Please refrain from creating threads with the title "Been Thinking..."
Poll Added.
Pangarna Omega
That's actually a great idea.
If we use faction from AB to get the skills, why can't we use them to get more faction?
/signed
If we use faction from AB to get the skills, why can't we use them to get more faction?
/signed
Solas
It would ake AB pretty unbalanced as the person with a higher Faction rank ( not nessicarly form ab ing) would have a better skill then somone with a lower rank.
its grand the way ti is anyway imo
/not signed
its grand the way ti is anyway imo
/not signed
Pangarna Omega
Ab is already quite unbalanced. More kurzicks then luxons, skill and also the skills themselves.
It really couldn't hurt lol
It really couldn't hurt lol
Savio
You haven't been thinking if you want PvE skills in AB.
Tyla
Sometimes I wish I had one of the "At first I was like .. Then .. I lol'd" pictures stored on my imageshack account...
Hodgie
Fine then, but still why arn't the skills which u unlock with faction able to be used in the very thing u can get fraction from?
Arkantos
What a horrible idea. Why would you want to allow people to run around AB with save yourselves, aura of holy might, and the other skills?
/notsigned, for sure.
/notsigned, for sure.
chozodude
rofl but no, why else would they call it PVE skill 
Tosha
When I saw the title, I knew this was going to be wrong
Nah, just joking
I think it is a good idea from a RP perspective, but a bad one from a balance perspective. But Anet should have thought of this BEFORE introducing the skills, tis too late now
Nah, just joking
I think it is a good idea from a RP perspective, but a bad one from a balance perspective. But Anet should have thought of this BEFORE introducing the skills, tis too late now
MithranArkanere
You cannot use them in Ab because AB is PvP.
Plain and simple.
Plain and simple.
Curse You
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by MithranArkanere
You cannot use them in Ab because AB is PvP.
Plain and simple. |
MithranArkanere
There are NPCs even in GvG.
If you want non-NPC PvP then youll have to goto like RA and TA... and even there you'll find Priests sometimes.
PvP in GW is like that.
If you want non-NPC PvP then youll have to goto like RA and TA... and even there you'll find Priests sometimes.
PvP in GW is like that.
HawkofStorms
Well, that would settle the debate about AB not being real PvP once and for all wouldn't it
freaky naughty
Yea lol put an imbagon in ab it's genious ..../notsigned
wanmoke
/notsigned
Allegience skills are PvE skills and have no place in PvP. Yes, AB is PvP no matter how soft it is.
Allegience skills are PvE skills and have no place in PvP. Yes, AB is PvP no matter how soft it is.
Mesmer in Need
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by MithranArkanere
You cannot use them in Ab because AB is PvP.
Plain and simple. |
Fear Me!
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Talach_Ninneed
It would ake AB pretty unbalanced as the person with a higher Faction rank ( not nessicarly form ab ing) would have a better skill then somone with a lower rank.
its grand the way ti is anyway imo /not signed |
Curse You
Since Luxon/Kurzick titles can be farmed without ever doing AB, the whole argument for is nullified.
Sad thing is that I've seen them work on people. Me, I almost always have something that destroys them, or I just wait for a vital spell to wear off.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Mesmer in Need
Tell that to the 55's, shadow form sins, ans ss necros running around.
|
Lykan
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Pangarna Omega
That's actually a great idea.
/signed |
Do you have any idea of the concept of game balance?
/notsigned for obvious reasons
Div
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Mesmer in Need
Tell that to the 55's, shadow form sins, ans ss necros running around.
|
AshenX
The basic logic of the OP's idea holds up...the skills can be earned through AB so using them in AB makes sense. Unfortunately they just arent balanced for PVP. Giving that much of an advantage to someone who is more advance in the title than another player would be inappropriate. This is particularly true since the fastest way to advance your title (FFF) actually has nothing to do with AB.
Sorry
/not signed
Sorry
/not signed
wu is me
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by AshenX
The basic logic of the OP's idea holds up...the skills can be earned through AB so using them in AB makes sense. Unfortunately they just arent balanced for PVP. Giving that much of an advantage to someone who is more advance in the title than another player would be inappropriate. This is particularly true since the fastest way to advance your title (FFF) actually has nothing to do with AB.
Sorry /not signed |
Sethellington
SY! in alliance battles is kinda overkill don't you think?
Proff
/signed
Sure why not have chaos for the first couple hours it's released and then see it changed back to the way it was. Might make AB "fun" for a few mins.
Sure why not have chaos for the first couple hours it's released and then see it changed back to the way it was. Might make AB "fun" for a few mins.
MithranArkanere
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Mesmer in Need
Tell that to the 55's, shadow form sins, ans ss necros running around.
|
Farming builds are very easy to counter. If you don't want to, they'll keep using those builds there.
BlackSephir
Whoa, great example why GW devs shouldn't look at Sardecal!
Mitchel
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by MithranArkanere
[Chilblains], [Signet of Disenchantment], [Disenchantment], [Rending Touch], [Rending Aura]...
Farming builds are very easy to counter. If you don't want to, they'll keep using those builds there. |
I voted yes because I want m0ar imba shit in PvP.
Stormlord Alex
MithranArkanere
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Mitchel
I think only 1 and 4 are usable.
I voted yes because I want m0ar imba shit in PvP. |
Vale Todo
Theres no really telling how imbalanced this would make AB until it is tested, so how about ANet makes it legal to use Alliance skills in AB only for a weekend to see what happens ?
Stormlord Alex
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by MithranArkanere
All are usable, but you have to figure out how to use them.
|
They're not useable in the sense that they simply suck and are far inferior to other available enchant hate options. Especially Disenchantment - a horrible, unwieldy skill that really cannot do what enchant removal needs to do to save its life (hint - removing random enchants from a random target does nothing)
T1Cybernetic
I was gonna post some useful text but then i got high.
I was gonna post some counter argument, but then i got high.
I was gonna post some random snitz about ab but then i got high.
I was gonna post some counter argument, but then i got high.
I was gonna post some random snitz about ab but then i got high.
Curse You
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by MithranArkanere
[Chilblains], [Signet of Disenchantment], [Disenchantment], [Rending Touch], [Rending Aura]...
Farming builds are very easy to counter. If you don't want to, they'll keep using those builds there. |
Vilaptca
I think AB would be full of /W using SY!...it would be pretty lame.
/not signed
/not signed
Shayne Hawke
AB is so bad anyway.
/whatev
/whatev
FoxBat
It would be hilarious to try it as a weekend event.
yum
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by MithranArkanere
There are NPCs even in GvG.
If you want non-NPC PvP then youll have to goto like RA and TA... and even there you'll find Priests sometimes. PvP in GW is like that. |
Konig Des Todes
I think that only the NPCs should be able to use the kurzick/luxon skills. If players could, it would be way imbalanced, and then anet will have to nerf those skills. Although that is not a bad thing, there will be waaaay to many QQ'ers about SY! being nerfed, which if nerfed, it will be nerfed so much that it will be like hell freezing over. Only thing to thaw that would be to nerf Ursan too.
ShadowsRequiem
Leave the PVE skills for what they are MADE for PVE.
ffs.
ffs.