Half the threats are pointless rants, the other half are things that will never happen. A net's community managers prolly gave up long ago checking this forum between the people that want to be able to bring 8 heroes, those that want more skills to be super buffed for the only reason that they think nobody cares about balance in pve.
Too many ppl ask for things that will never happen
http://www.guildwarsguru.com/forum/s...php?t=10293960
http://www.guildwarsguru.com/forum/s...php?t=10295942
Since ppl cant be realistic why let them spam a forums with ideas that will NEVER be implemented in gw 1.
Even though a net said they wont let gw 1 down, ppl should realize that doesn't mean they'll get a couple of devs to work on stuff that will take a long time to code so that a couple of ppl can enjoy it. Its a company, companies aim to make money, making the client happy is only one more way to make money. But why should they implement stuff that will make only like 50 ppl happy?
Now if your suggestions are for GW 2 post them there http://www.guildwarsguru.com/forum/s...php?t=10214062
and let ppl that have real suggestions post, not random ideas that popped in your head last time you were taking a crap.
Close suggestions forums
beaverlegions
Kattar
So wait...you're ranting about people ranting?
That makes sense.
That makes sense.
Jetdoc
If you close the suggestion forums, people will just spam their ideas in Riverside.
Most people that post suggestions here realize that 99% of them aren't going to be implemented. But it doesn't hurt to ask (and actually can be therapeutic to get them off your chest).
Most people that post suggestions here realize that 99% of them aren't going to be implemented. But it doesn't hurt to ask (and actually can be therapeutic to get them off your chest).
beaverlegions
So wait...you're ranting about people ranting?
That makes sense.
cant hide nutting from you genius
That makes sense.
cant hide nutting from you genius
beaverlegions
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Jetdoc
If you close the suggestion forums, people will just spam their ideas in Riverside.
Most people that post suggestions here realize that 99% of them aren't going to be implemented. But it doesn't hurt to ask (and actually can be therapeutic to get them off your chest). |
oliverrr1989
I kinda agree people do post the most idiotic ideas on there, and sometimes I wonder how the hell they can convince themselves they have good ideas. Having said that, if it was gone I'd miss the lulz and +1s far too much :P
Kattar
I say that because ranting isn't allowed here. Neither is ranting about people who rant. Threads may hang around for awhile, but eventually get closed and/or deleted.
GG
GG
beaverlegions
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Katsumi
I say that because ranting isn't allowed here. Neither is ranting about people who rant. Threads may hang around for awhile, but eventually get closed and/or deleted.
GG |
btw even some forums mods think suggestion forums should be shot and burried
http://www.guildwarsguru.com/forum/s...=1#post4013057
Kattar
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Savio
Is the suggestions forum finally closed?
*checks* Nope, it's not. Closed. |
Again, GG.
Tyla
/Signed to remove +1's from this forum, until the day every idea is decent.
I want my lolz...
I want my lolz...
SmokingHotImolation
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by savio
Is the suggestions forum finally closed?
*checks* Nope, it's not. Closed. __________________ Q&A Supermoderator Forum Rules | Public Spell Checker | Punctuation guide |
He didnt post this because he wants Sardelac closed, but because some guy posted a suggestion thread in riverside. Thats why he was sarcastic about asking if Sardelac was closed. But nice try.
On topic:
I dont see why there anything wrong with coming up with ideas? Do you think that those who does it honestly thinks that because they make a thread here, the idea will be implemented in GW? Noone is that stupid, even here.
beaverlegions
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Katsumi
That was sarcasm, since someone posted something in Riverside that belonged in Sardelac. Just like Jetdoc said.
Again, GG. |
Having half the threads turning into flaming trolls wars, having to monitor all these threads about ppl wanting gw to be easier even though there is alrdy an easy mode. The rest of the threads being about adding useless stuff to gw when all the dev are busy making gw 2 a game that will last longer than gw 1.
If you truly believe that the suggestion forums has brought even one good change to gw or to the way the community works, please show an example if you can i'll stop arguing. Nothing good ever came out of this part of the forums.
And if ppl start spamming other place with retarded idea, simple solution: ban
Alex the Great
if u close suggestion forum, what will i get to laugh at?
Kook~NBK~
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by beaverlegions
Half the threats are pointless rants...
|
joshuarodger
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by beaverlegions
hmm if that was really true suggestion forum might be a interesting and full of good ideas, instead its a kids playground.
btw even some forums mods think suggestion forums should be shot and burried http://www.guildwarsguru.com/forum/s...=1#post4013057 |
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by SmokingHotImolation
Epic lulz.
He didnt post this because he wants Sardelac closed, but because some guy posted a suggestion thread in riverside. Thats why he was sarcastic about asking if Sardelac was closed. But nice try. On topic: I dont see why there anything wrong with coming up with ideas? Do you think that those who does it honestly thinks that because they make a thread here, the idea will be implemented in GW? Noone is that stupid, even here. |
/signed for this thread being closed
beaverlegions
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by SmokingHotImolation
Epic lulz.
He didnt post this because he wants Sardelac closed, but because some guy posted a suggestion thread in riverside. Thats why he was sarcastic about asking if Sardelac was closed. But nice try. On topic: I dont see why there anything wrong with coming up with ideas? Do you think that those who does it honestly thinks that because they make a thread here, the idea will be implemented in GW? Noone is that stupid, even here. |
You were saying? Some ppl manage to fail even at ursan, some ppl get scammed everyday.
This is guild wars we have some great ppl but we also get all the kids that are too cheap to buy wow, the computer nerds that need something to play for free during their mmo's downtime, the kids that are too young to get a credit card and pay monthly fees...
Kattar
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by beaverlegions
Having half the threads turning into flaming trolls wars
|
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by beaverlegions
And if ppl start spamming other place with retarded idea, simple solution: ban
|
beaverlegions
honestly i wouldn't cry if i get banned, this thread might make the mods realize that this part of the forum is just making the forums slower and is utterly pointless
o and its not like making one thread to complain is spam
o and its not like making one thread to complain is spam
oliverrr1989
Oh yeah I forgot to add I like cookies.
Kattar
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by beaverlegions
o and its not like making one thread to complain is spam
|
beaverlegions
hmm:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spam_%28electronic%29
Thought there was some notion of quantity in spam.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spam_%28electronic%29
Thought there was some notion of quantity in spam.
Operative 14
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by beaverlegions
...
o and its not like making one thread to complain is spam |
Tyla
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by beaverlegions
And if ppl start spamming other place with retarded idea, simple solution: ban
|
) got banned for stupidity. 
Kattar
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by beaverlegions
o and its not like making one thread to complain is spam
|
Lasareth
Quote:
| Half the threats are pointless rants |
This isn't even in the right forum. This forum is for in-game suggestions, not forum suggestions. And the fate of this forum has been considered many times already. What you see now is a result of that consideration.