How come there were never any proph-only professions

I'd like to make a motion for the approbation of a new forum emoticon.

On the other hand the same people you quoted keep posting on the subjects with 70 pages or more knowing it goes nowhere. But you see it is all about the post counts. I wonder why those nice pictures of horse and emotes did not appear in the second already 7 hero thread to which Anets response is widely known...


At OP I think Anet did not consider making Prophecies special as they treated it as a basic campaign. In my opinion they thought that people will buy it to "start the story from the beginning" not for a new content. Anet is hiding this lack of special professions etc by adding Prophecies to their other campaigns/expansions.

So you have Prophecies and GWEN (so you can play with heroes). You have a platinum edition (all 3 in one) etc. I hardly ever see solo Prophecies anymore. So i guess instead of adding something there which will keep people owning other campaigns making buying it they just bundle it with other stuff. Skill packs just make Prophecies even less popular as a separate buying item. I noticed more people starts the game now from NF.

I don't think most people would really care all that much, and honestly do not think anet could expect a single additional sale of GW2 if they did this. With all due respect, you're not being very realistic from a business standpoint. Your money bought you the game you thought you were buying, and continued support from anet does not include revamping the oldest of the pve campaigns.

I hope they stop the "put things on top" behavior in GW2 expansions.
It's not nice when all the new pieces of content have something, and they do not update the old ones to have them too.
It's OK if something is exclusive to a campaign, but it's not when just just one or two are the only ones not having it, and everything new has it

RETROACTIVITY is the word.
Forget retroactivity and you completely destroy the 'one game' feel.
Without retroactivity, players feel like playing a different game with characters imported from other chapter of the saga.

It would be just great if there were a 'Prophecies Ultimate revamp pack' adding two new professions:
A third 'ranged' physical attacker, something like a 'sniper'(see: Sogeking) using slings and slingshots, and a third support/heal caster, the discarded 'Chronomage', able to do things like revert damage for allies and go back time for foes when they are healed.
Among other things, like challenge missions, explorable versions of mission areas, armors and skills for all '12' professions an revamps of the Titan quests and the Tombs to turn them into full fledged Elite missions.

Now it's to late, though. But we can always dream.

Exactly. If all the follow-up campaigns had unique classes to help repersent them, why not Proph. If you put in an important update (say inscribable weapons) and retroactively give all armor insignias, including proph armors, why not do the same for weapons as well? Another example is why is it that Nightfall has assassin armor and weapons when Proph doesn't? Mhenlo and Anton both spent a lot of time in Cantha... there are even char ritualists meaning they got some skills from cantha somehow, yet the people of LA don't despite being a major trading port? Asurans know how to make assassin and rit armor despite being underground for years. Norns know how to make it despite being a land-locked race. The ebon vangaurd despite being completely cut off from the rest of the human world know how to make assassin and rit armor and they even employ two assassins. Yet the people of LA are clueless, as are the dwarves in droknars who should have access to cantha via the tunnels.

Things like that really break the game for me.

Even if you limit the retroactivity to the people who have purchased the newer content, it would still be an improvement.


Yeah that would be great.

Better variety >>> lame retroactivity.

Every campagin should have unique feeling and elements in it, changing them for no reason other than just to make them alike a newer one is more often bad than good.
So the number of professions or skills or armors for them doesn't have to be equal just for the sake of being equal. Missions, quests, elite areas don't have to be redesigned to follow a model from just one campagin. Weapons dropping in different continents don't have to be the same. "More of the same" is a wrong way GW already followed too often. Better avoid that when possible, differences make things more interesting.