Raptor Farm or Vaetir Bombs

arturfel

Academy Page

Join Date: Mar 2008

P/W

hey guy wich is the better spot to farm? kill raptors or bombs vaetir?

kratimas

kratimas

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Dec 2005

Order of the Setting Sun

R/

They are both very easy and fast so, do some of one and when you get board with it, go do the other. I don't know that you could really say one is "better" then the other. They both have pros and cons.

exploiter

exploiter

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Jan 2008

ign Punk Isnt Dead

R/

vaettir shadow bomber is imo much more better if you are farming event items, probably for unids too

Orange Milk

Orange Milk

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Mar 2006

Ganking, USA

Retired

R/

I prefer Noob Island Factions Bird Guys to either of these.

But yeah, get bored and mix it up some.

absolutcrobi

absolutcrobi

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Jul 2006

Naked Pagans

Rt/Me

For halloween I spent almost the whole time doing nm raptors, with a sf sin using inferno pheonix and flame djinn's haste. Run around to get them all in one small group. smack em with the fire skills. Grab the good drops and repeat. About 3-6 ToT bags per run on average, and about 1 minute of time spent.

ShadowofWar

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Jun 2007

Draconus Reincarnatus [DRGN]

Mo/

Raptor farming takes about 1-2 minutes per run. (These are my best and worst times)
Vaetir farming takes 3-6 minutes per run. (These are my best and worst times)

Raptor farming has between 20-30 enemies depending on your run choice.
Vaetir farming has between 40-60 enemies depending if you have a quest or not.

Now (I am) assuming you have the ability to do both.... Assuming you can kill all the raptors and not just the 20 in the front of the cave and assuming you do not have the quest that limits the vaetirs to only 40. Assuming you kill all the enemies but with the worst possible times.

You can do 3 runs of raptors in the time it takes you to do 1 Vaetir run.
90 enemies vs 60 enemies. Therefore one would assume you would get more drops from doing raptor runs, event items or otherwise.

Now assuming you change the enemy count from having 30 raptors to 20 and keeping the vaetir number the same. 60 enemies vs 60 enemies. One would then assume the drops would be relatively the same, meaning 1 gold drop per 1 gold drop. (Of course theres anet who has their drop rate or w.e system so this is all speculation)

Anyway you would logically think to go with the run that gives the most enemies for the least time. So figure out what your capable of then get to it.

(Though i will admit Vaetirs is more fun :S)

A Simple Farmer

A Simple Farmer

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Oct 2007

ECTOS

E/

Better in what way?
Raptors are better because they have a boss, so a chance for an elite tome, it's quick as it's right outside so you can run people, there's a rare chest for scythes, excellent drops for event items, you're zoning into a town so you can run with a relatively full inventory.
Bombing is better if you are going to farm for more than 20 minutes (you have to run there). You'll get more gold items and event items if you do though. There's a couple rare skins, & a lot of crap but w title change you can now ID and drop like me

I'm sure there's a lot more I'm missing. On the con side, both are boring

gerg-nad

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Oct 2006

Minnesota

[OhNo]

I agree if you are going to stay a while Vaetir is likely better. Vaetir you gather up one half and kill, then the other and kill and it should take 2 minutes tops. Also you get Norn Points instead of Assuran.

I tend to mix it up, but Rapter farming was getting very old. As far as Sin tomes these are almost worthless and the elite is not much as well. The variety of weapons in Vaetir give spell caster stuff instead of just melee like Rapter, so that is a good change of pace as well as mesmer tombs are always good. If you like you can try doing the Dervish boss when you zone to get a Dervish tomb or other green.

Both are mindless once you have done it a number of times.

Golestandt

Golestandt

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Mar 2007

Sweden

[test]

W/

Farmed alot of raptors during halloween with my assassin, the last few days of it I decided to try out the vaetir farm. Got more golds/event items / hour than the raptor farm, definately going to hang out there this wednesday-sunday instead of doing raptors.

Huiboo

Academy Page

Join Date: Oct 2008

AofT

E/

A Raptor farm with 34 kills takes me like 1.5mins in average
A Veattir farm with 60 kills takes me 3mins.

So its pretty much the same kill per minute ratio.

But still i veattirs better.
Its not that boring since the runs take longer (less repetition), they do mesmer tomes which are worth more than sin tomes, they drop glacial stones and they drop more golds with better skins.


Also all in all with zoning and rezoning i think raptors take more than 1.5mins.

And Veattirs is more fun... BAAAAAM

oracle.delphi

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Apr 2008

ontario, canada

Steel Beasts

E/

what build do most people use for the vaetir farm anyways?

Fire The Nutter

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Mar 2007

UK

TFTK

R/

Vaettir bombing definitely ftw

Simple Farmers build is IMO the best
[build=Shadow Bomber;OwZS45PTSf8I6M0kIQpZ3lNQ]

From the posts on here and my experience I would advise the following

1) Zone in, grab bounty (if you want)
2) Close in on top (north most) group, 36 foes total
3) Cast up SF with 1,2,3 and then 7,8 to speed up
4) Agro all foes in that area and make it back to Budger, if you cant use 5 to teleport
5) Recast SF, just 3 this time
6) Bomb them quick as you can (ive mapped drop item to the ` key top left of my keyboard so I just mash space+`)
7) Pick up drops
8) 7+8
9) Run out
10) Use 8 to run back into zone

36 foes less than 2 mins and from trying raptors for 1hr vs Vaettirs for 1hr during Halloween, I know what ill be doing

If you want you can do the other 24 but you will slow things down

masta_yoda

masta_yoda

Banned

Join Date: Feb 2007

most hated players in the [game]

R/Mo

i dont even use anti kd to get to vaetirrs (cbf doing the quests) thats how easy it is, imo better for golds + event items 1-2 hours = 1 stack of events++ and 40+ golds/lots of dyes aswell/ around 30 glacial stones

and also ruby mauls drop quite often, salvage for rubies ftw, there like ectos

dilan155

dilan155

Desert Nomad

Join Date: May 2007

living room

N/

Vaettir much easier, raptor has a bit of luck involved.

CyclonicYoh

Academy Page

Join Date: Apr 2008

well there was some statistics posted awhile ago and i think doing hundreds of runs has proven it. Only farming the top group of about 36 i believe in less than 2 mins yields more in the long run that farming all 60. (which seems true after hours of testing)

and just unids alone without event items tallys up to about 42k and hour at 7 for 5k and i keep the stones and tomes and others too. with event items and the new title changes it takes about an hour to get around 210 event items.

Spiritz

Forge Runner

Join Date: Apr 2007

DMFC

I think ppl are getting confused - topic was for raptor or sin bombing and ele is being mentioned.
Both have pros an cons - specially as shadow bomber the run to get there first then its plain sailing but ......... with faster kills u do get less drops - get a shadow bomber to do several runs ( rezone ) and out of maybe 60 kills you will get maybe 5 - 10 drops for the mass killing ( i do 2 groups ) and ive had runs with 1 single drop.
Treat drops id say go raptors nm ( somehow u get more in nm ) but if you treat farming and want norn rep go shadow bomber and run south to olafstead area - if you have the asuran boss quest its a bonus but u can farm everything else and get treats as bonus.
I do a few runs and only return when im full of golds/runes/tomes/purples.

dilan155

dilan155

Desert Nomad

Join Date: May 2007

living room

N/

what i meant by luck is if you run with an ele then there is a need to watch the enchants, specially with the boss. he did not specify it as sin raptor farming but rather just raptor farming.

blackknight1337

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Jan 2007

USA

Mo/

IaU is a waste of a slot. Dash ftw. Also Shadow of Haste is pro...~2 min 15 sec for 60 foes.

And before people start arguing...I run without anti-kd and without a heal and do just fine. Return or ebon escape for teleporting to Budger also makes it faster, as you can get re-blocked using heart of shadow.

If you need IaU or heals with a 5-6 sec dash, then you are bad at timing.

Jade

Jade

Jungle Guide

Join Date: May 2005

Canada...... Eh!

Obviously there are pros and cons to each run. I have never done any Vaettir bombing myself, so don't take my word for it. But as I understand it, you have to leave from Sifhalla, talk to Budger, run south through Drakkar Lake, zone into Norrhart Domains, then north into Bjora marches, then back west into Jaga Moraine. Can this be right? Or does Budger spawn in Jaga Moraine east of Sifhalla? Because if you have to run all that way just to farm vaettirs with Budger, then I vote for raptors just for convenience sake.

Fire The Nutter

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Mar 2007

UK

TFTK

R/

Oh yer, convenience = raptors definitely but imo if you've got 1 hr to spend do the bombing. Budger does only spawn outside Sifhalla so you have to run through the zones listed. That said, you can get the run time down without major problems (build i posted is safest, tips above quicker) and once you're there its zone, loot, zone, loot.

Other advantage of bombing is the options. Got bored? pop out and kill Taameh the Frigid, insectoid skin scythe, elite derv tome options. Bored of the run there? Pop by Fenrir's cave, Elite Para tome, green shield and chance of the new hammer skin (cant rem name its one of the design ones).
Still bored? zone through to Ice Cliff chasms try for Ele, Ranger tomes + greens.
Still bored? Zone through to outside Olafstead, kill ice imps for ele tomes, clear the lake, elite ele tome, to the west another Derv boss (easy repeat farm by going to portal and back in).

So yer, I prefer bombing and thats after getting r8 asuran on my ele from just that, and r8-9 Norn on assasin but absolutely each to their own. Tried W/D raptors last night for a change, didnt like it even though its quick enough, D/W looks like too shame my derv is a new char. Oh and dont even consider Vaettir with Ele, its SOOO slow (yes farmed enough stones for 2 sets of gloves so i feel qualified to comment), same goes for Touch Resilient Ranger, yup it works but its not quick and most people are here for the greatest time vs profit margin (or possibly title grind time)

Best of luck to you all though this thanksgiving!

Amnel Ithtirsol

Amnel Ithtirsol

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Feb 2008

AU

League Of The Fallen

Mo/

r8 Asura, r7 Norn on my sin just from these two farms
During event weekends I've also found veattirs to be the better option.
All other times Raptors are better.

arturfel

Academy Page

Join Date: Mar 2008

P/W

Hey guys, anyone can give an Sin build to farm raptors?

ive been trying somes but they are to slow

the_pillo

Pre-Searing Cadet

Join Date: Nov 2008

Aerodyne Siege Corporation

A/E

not entirely sure how to put the pictures in but the build i use i can run there without dying. and it works for voltaic spear farming as well... now as for the question of which it would be. i would say that the raptor farming is not as good as the vattir for the simple fact of more drops and a better rate of gold drops.. not to mention with chatting with guild and alliance members i have come to find that the ration is a 4:1 for pies and a 4.3:1 for cider in vattir. so 4:1 is you get 4 pies per run approximately. there will be times when you get more or less.. while raptors generate a 2-3:1 ration on both. not to mention sin tomes are VERY cheap whereas mesmer tomes still sell for a decent price (200-500). all in all the vattir is better imo. while run is longer you can continuously farm and there is always taameh and his friends that drop greens,necro tomes, derv tomes. now the build goes as follows

Glyph of swiftness
Deadly Paradox
Shadow Form
Dash
I am unstoppable
Dark escape
Shadow step( i use deaths charge because i havent put in an ally 1cuz im lazy)
and a heal. i use the starter 1.. (+10 reegn for like 4-5 seconds)..

basically you want to use only your run skills and use shadow step whenever you get body blocked by the vattirs.

also as ive noticed MY PERSONAL drop rate is 5golds in vattir to every 1 in raptors. so.. decision is your own.

Khazad Guard

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Jul 2007

Australia

No Loitering In The Guild [Hall]

E/

For the Vaettirs I use:
[Glyph of Swiftness][Deadly Paradox][Shadow Form][Death's Charge][Death's Retreat][Shadow Refuge][Dark Escape][Dash]

-Death's Charge+Dash is for skipping the group of Modnirs on the way to Bjora's.
-Dark Escape is for gathering Vaettirs
-Shadow Refuge is for when I decide to run into a trap or get too close to an Avalanche
-Death's Retreat is for easy access to Keg Man and if you are lazy quickly teleporting to the Shrine Norn

My sin was created just to get Legendary Survivor (I am lazy...) by Shadowbombing so he doesnt have any PvE Skills at the moment. A note though for those going for R3 Survivor, two guildies were Shadowbombing and when they zoned into Bjora's a group of Mandragor quickly took them out before they could cast SF or run. I have done countless runs but I have never met this group, but both guildies said it was true so I'll believe them. So beware (take some h/h protection and just flag at the portal when farming)

The worse thing about Vaettirs is definately inventory. Without a direct 'staging area' like Raptors (Rata Sum) you need to decide what you want to keep. This of course isn't a problem if you just keep all the golds, tomes, glacials, and special drops but if you pick up every single white then err...

masta_yoda

masta_yoda

Banned

Join Date: Feb 2007

most hated players in the [game]

R/Mo

too above, its true fact that mandragors spawn on you at start of bjora, and also bring salvage kits / id kits while bombing loads of iron / steel / dust / tons of wood thats if ur not selling unids

blackknight1337

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Jan 2007

USA

Mo/

pretty rare is the spawn at start of bjora, but yes it does happen.

today had 2 elite sin tomes in like 5 runs of raptors on e/me...golds dried up a bit on vaetirr, but still making 50k+ an hour there, raptors have dropped horribly when i've done them on ele though.

Tom Swift

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Aug 2007

Just slightly over 2 mins for both groups of vaetirr. I do both because I seem to get most of my golds from the 2nd group. It would usually be just under 2 mins but it takes me about 20 seconds to pick up the holiday items because the dwarf keeps standing between me and the good stuff.

Yes the mandragors can have a a bad spawn in Bjora but since you will be killing lots of things the dp is minor (just be careful if you are going survivor)

I add in dwarven stability. With DS i am under dash almost all the way to the vaetirr and can extend dark escape long enough to gather the vaettirr more quickly (i found that using dash to gather the vaettir sometimes causes them to lose agro)

lordheinous

lordheinous

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Aug 2007

Tip for the mandragors at the beginning of bjora:

Only had it happen to me a couple of times, but what i did was just try to throw up sf (won't always work) and dash for the portal, then rezone back in.

CE Devilman

CE Devilman

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Jul 2006

hell

Do U Trust Anet

N/Mo

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dyo2f7ZVCnk&fmt=18

speed up keg farming:
assign keys to skills (drop-do it-ally nearest)

key 1 = ally nearest
key 2 = drop
key 3 = do it

.. use 2 fingers to press 2+3...at the same time (Woody Woodpecker on speed)

2:20 before rezone.

Metatail

Metatail

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Jul 2006

@^ Speed it up further, take "By Ural's Hammer" and hit them for 42dmg!

Icy The Mage

Icy The Mage

Forge Runner

Join Date: Apr 2008

Canada

E/

Or just be elite and run as E/A with a 12 Shadow Arts, almost - coverable SF.

Go for the left group, and by the time you aggro the most northern part of them, wait 5s, then shadow step back to Budgar, spam Space/F1, they'll start exploding about 1/2 second before SF drops, boom 50 dmg. they're all KD-ed = no dmg to you. (and if you believe in the superstition that low health = good drops, then you're in luck.) Same goes for the other group, go into the little crevice and death's charge to the closest vaettir after SF-ing up, then gather em all with Dark Escape, shadow step to Budgar and spam you kegs again; my runs take a little over 2:10 including zoning / rezoning time.