I've tested the bar in various HM zones and it is without a doubt the fastest SY-spamming build I've ever seen. That doesn't mean it's necessarily the greatest PvE-build in the history of GW, however. I find that it's still inferior to a d-slash warrior because although it can spam SY faster and more consistently, it doesn't have KD. You could add KD with [brawling headbutt], of course, but then you'd be out of PvE-only skills, because [critical agility] and obviously ["save yourselves!" (luxon)] are indispensable.
As for the attack skills--I agree that they don't do too much damage and that [golden phoenix strike] won't give you any double-strikes, but the combination DOES make sure that [critical agility] recharges endlessly (as long as it's not stripped), and the recharges are long enough that you're not constantly using them. If anyone has better ideas about what could go in those two slots, I'd be glad to hear them--but they have to be regular sin or war skills, not PvE-only skills. I wouldn't write off [critical defenses] quite as readily as most other people in this thread (because you're going to be taking a ton of hits), but then of course you're going to be doing even less damage.
Finally, to whoever said the build needs a buff: last I checked, [asuran scan] and [ebon battle standard of honor] are buffs. Between those two, I'd go with the latter. But, again, it would mean that you're going to be short on KD.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Paul Dawg
Why not something like this?
[locust's fury]["for great justice!" (pve)][critical agility][critical eye][golden phoenix strike][critical strike]["save yourselves!" (luxon)]
... and then an open slot for whatever you'd like, [sunspear rebirth signet], [critical defenses], [pain inverter], [asuran scan], [ebon battle standard of honor], you name it. Just attack normally, and throw in [golden phoenix strike][critical strike] for assured critical hits whenever they're available.