PC old school non max dual modded shields

They are not max armor, but since they are dual modded I am interested if they are worth anything.

1.

Crude Shield
armor: 12
req: 6 tactics
received physical damage -5 (20% chance )
illusion magic +1 ( 20% while using skills )

2.

Bladed Shield
armor: 12
req: 4 strength
health + 42 ( while in a stance )
received physical damage -2 ( while in a stance )

Merch em both

I would not merch the crude shield.... imo can get 5-10k, max armor you can get not meeting req is 8ar, I think this would work just the same

other shield I would merch