some questions on power trading

its bad to sin

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Jan 2009

probably behind you

Mercenaries Of Grenth [MoG]

P/W

so at the moment i have bout 250k or so and was wandering a few things about power trading.

1. what are some things i should look to invest in.

2. is it better money power trading with the amount i have right now or would small farming like doa or feather farming be better.

3. if 250k is not enough what is a good target to start power trading at

EDIT: might add a few more questions in here soon

Jinkies

Jinkies

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Nov 2008

Korea

Peace And Harmony [PnH] War Machine [WM]

DoA farming is btter until you have a sizeable amount to work with, I'd say 750-1250e at least.

Truth is you can powertrade with even 100k, but the more ecto you have to trade with the easier it becomes for several reasons.

1) You can buy more items to work it, less money = you don't always have the money to buy an item if you see a good deal.
2) Higher priced items means bigger profit pull, you can make say 10-40e per item, instead of competing for 5-10k
3) The demand for higher priced items is higher than cheap items, everybody wants an Oni, nobody wants an elementalst sword.

TBH it's not even hard to make 750e, 2 days of dungeon running, or a few days of DoA and you are there

Also, everyone says there are certain items better to invest in than others, I would say avoid B Day minipets but other than that everything is fair game, if you limit what you powertrade you are limiting profit you can make.

People who trade everything will make more profit than people who only invest in very popular/high demand items

its bad to sin

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Jan 2009

probably behind you

Mercenaries Of Grenth [MoG]

P/W

yes the only minis i was looking at was like kunnas and mallyx and what not untill i get higher amounts.

from seeing yout mini pet thread i can tell u might have done a little power trading over the years thank you for the help

Zahr Dalsk

Grotto Attendant

Join Date: Aug 2007

Canada

Wait, people are doing DoA again? Tell me more.

Daeheru

Daeheru

Academy Page

Join Date: Aug 2008

Hawaii

W/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Zahr Dalsk View Post
Wait, people are doing DoA again? Tell me more.
I haven't heard of ppl "doing" doa and it's been awhile since i've checked it out. but there are builds that you can use to run it, so maybe it's become popular to just get runs for it now. I'll have to check it out soon.

Jinkies

Jinkies

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Nov 2008

Korea

Peace And Harmony [PnH] War Machine [WM]

DoA runs have always been popular in German districts, and if you are in an active guild it's common to have several runs a day. If you aren't well I guess you are out of luck because pugs fail at DoA

Eragon Selene

Eragon Selene

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Feb 2007

USA

[eF]

R/A

Quote:
Originally Posted by its bad to sin View Post
yes the only minis i was looking at was like kunnas and mallyx and what not untill i get higher amounts.

from seeing yout mini pet thread i can tell u might have done a little power trading over the years thank you for the help
I would possably avoid those mini pets as well, even though those are not B-day ones....they are very common.

Although Kuunas did spike before and are back down to 55-60e it make take time for them to get to 100e again.

I made the bulk of my ecto investing into rare minis and sitting on them. Over time you make more then buying a mini naga for 1100e and selling it 2 days later (or even hours) for 1150. I can make 50e in a night running dungens.

My 1st big buy/trade was almost my bigged mistake. I bought a mini Zed @ 500e and then sold him for 600e a month later. I got scared will all the people trying to unload them, though Anet might release more, and sold mine. Today hes 3000e+.

Unless you need your money, buy a rare mini and sit on it. I bought mini Yetti 200e and Naga 250e, sat on them for 6 months and sold them for 1300 for the set. Took 800e of that and bought a Oni, could get 1600e easly for him and will only go UP in vallue. All of this started with the ecto I made in DoA from arms.

To buy and trade weapons I recommend sticking to Q8 non inscribables, Eternals, BDS, Obi blades but I have found more times then not weapons go down in value over time. EXCEPT for Q8's or old school weapons. But unless you are on your game with the pricing its easy to over pay.

my 2 cents

its bad to sin

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Jan 2009

probably behind you

Mercenaries Of Grenth [MoG]

P/W

ty every1 for your help. yea i wanted to stay away from wepons for the most part and stick with high end minis what are some good low end to start with maybe like
500e or lower


yea right now im doing some 3 many foudnary with my cuzin for some money

Martin Alvito

Martin Alvito

Older Than God (1)

Join Date: Aug 2006

Clan Dethryche [dth]

Above poster is a classic example of fallacious reasoning. Future performance does not always equal past performance. Rare minis probably will continue to increase in value in the long term, but the current run up in prices is probably about done for a while. Prices in these markets tend to plateau, then spike when external factors (dupe, easy ectos) make hardcore farmers broadly richer than they were previously. We should hit a plateau again fairly soon.

Further, there's an opportunity cost of just sitting on your resources. The larger your pool of resources, the more you can skim in values working that pool of resources. Spending 250 ecto and sitting on it for 6 months to gain 400 ecto is dumb if you could have made 50 trades skimming ten ecto per iteration during that six month period.

Your best bet with a small pool of resources is to start putting that money to work, but not act like a power trader. Spend a few minutes in High End daily looking for deals and snatch them up when you can afford them. Relist and sell those items at a profit. Spend the remainder of your GW time farming until you have that 4-6 stacks of ecto to work with.

You can sell minimally in Kamadan AD1 (jump in, spam two or three times, leave and go play the game some more), but if you're hunting for deals you pretty much have take up residence. Good purchase deals don't last more than a few seconds in-game; they tend to last a bit longer on the forums.

Jinkies is off on the amount of time it will take you to make money, A stack of ecto is +/- 1.3 million gold. At a very efficient 100k per hour, it'll take you 13 hours to make a stack of ecto. Unless you plan to forego RL and sleep, it'll be on the order of weeks rather than days to crank out that much capital.

Zahr Dalsk

Grotto Attendant

Join Date: Aug 2007

Canada

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jinkies View Post
German districts
Ah, thanks. I'll have to take a look there.

Jinkies

Jinkies

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Nov 2008

Korea

Peace And Harmony [PnH] War Machine [WM]

Quote:
Originally Posted by Martin Alvito View Post
You can sell minimally in Kamadan AD1 (jump in, spam two or three times, leave and go play the game some more), but if you're hunting for deals you pretty much have take up residence. Good purchase deals don't last more than a few seconds in-game; they tend to last a bit longer on the forums.

Jinkies is off on the amount of time it will take you to make money, A stack of ecto is +/- 1.3 million gold. At a very efficient 100k per hour, it'll take you 13 hours to make a stack of ecto. Unless you plan to forego RL and sleep, it'll be on the order of weeks rather than days to crank out that much capital.
I would actually say you are better off trading in Kamadan District 2, or Lion's Arch district 1. Most people in D1 Kamadan are looking for "serious" buyers, players in other districts, or less busy towns are, in my history, more likely to offer better prices.

Also, 13 hours a day may seem like alot but many dedicated runners play at least that much per day on weekends. Not only that but your profit varies by dungeon you run.

Obviously you won't become a millionaire fast from running CoF, but runs such as Duncan, which go relatively fast and cost upwards of 25k per person can provide a steady income exceeding 350k per hour.

KageNoShi

KageNoShi

Academy Page

Join Date: Nov 2009

In the shadows.

[SIGH]

A/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jinkies View Post
Obviously you won't become a millionaire fast from running CoF, but runs such as Duncan, which go relatively fast and cost upwards of 25k per person can provide a steady income exceeding 350k per hour.
Takes time to learn the Duncan run though(those Restless dead get me every time) but I have to agree it took me a whole month to make a million gold from just running CoF till I learned to do SoO, but theres also speed clears which can cost a little gold(for cons,etc.) but you end up making a large profit in the end, however thats more a case of dumb luck; except UWSC which I don't really see too many people doing anymore*cough cough*. Oops I rambled a bit there...

Martin Alvito

Martin Alvito

Older Than God (1)

Join Date: Aug 2006

Clan Dethryche [dth]

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jinkies View Post
I would actually say you are better off trading in Kamadan District 2, or Lion's Arch district 1. Most people in D1 Kamadan are looking for "serious" buyers, players in other districts, or less busy towns are, in my history, more likely to offer better prices.
Agree when looking to buy, but not when looking to sell. When you want to sell an item, you go where people expect to have to pay value to get what they want. This assumes that you're buying and selling the sort of items that get resold in D1 Kama, of course. As a rule, people in LA1/Kama2 don't have hundreds of ectos laying around waiting for a use.

Please note that the way you do this is pop in for a few seconds to spam and then do another farming/dungeon run. You can afford to be very patient that way. Then just suck it up and suffer some boredom when it's time to reload inventory.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jinkies View Post
Also, 13 hours a day may seem like alot but many dedicated runners play at least that much per day on weekends. Not only that but your profit varies by dungeon you run.

Obviously you won't become a millionaire fast from running CoF, but runs such as Duncan, which go relatively fast and cost upwards of 25k per person can provide a steady income exceeding 350k per hour.
Sure, but how fast do you fill the bus? In my experience, going north of 150-200k/hour with reload time is a challenge. I suppose that if you were available constantly you'd get a rep that would keep sending business your way... but most of us aren't willing to invest that kind of time or stay focused on a single activity all day.

Ex: About a year and a half ago, I'd run Sepulchre HM at 10k/pop because I could dual client it in 10-11 minutes and pocket everything. However, it took 5-10 minutes to reload the bus (despite referrals) and another 90 seconds to get there. When all was said and done, you were looking at around 130-180k/hr. Obviously, that rate isn't sustainable now because of lack of demand.

So sure, if everything went perfectly (everyone pays on time, you never make a mistake, and you already have six waiting when you go back to town), you could knock that out twice an hour and pocket 360k at 30k per. But is that realistic?

Gift3d

Gift3d

Forge Runner

Join Date: Feb 2007

Las Vegas

Enraged Whiny Carebears [oR]

W/E

you can power trade with any amount really. say if you start with 100k you can maybe make 5-10k at a time. if you go with a few hundred ectos you can make a lot more per trade.

the more you use to trade with the more you'll make out if it, generally.

prey monkie

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Mar 2009

[OhNo] Mallyx and Friends

Mo/

1. Powertrade lessons from Jinkies cool^^
2. DoA is alive? its like Urgoz xD u have to b in a DoA guild + get some good tanks( without good recall and sliver tanks its a fukking pain + fail)
3. i defintly agree on the fact that people in spamadan ae1 are lowballers but i still make money there. for low end items i sometimes go to kaining center. people have no idea what they are buying and how much its worth
4. party points drunkard sweet points is always easy money. u can sell party points in stacks easy for 250g a point. while people sometimes sell for 150g or 200g. same with drunkard i sold 3 min alcohol in stacks for 425g each no problem while i bought them for 250g(event tho) now it would b like 300g) with party points etc u can ask more for stacks
5. see yah in kamadan ae1 xD

Lifestyle

Academy Page

Join Date: May 2009

R/Mo

Quote:
Originally Posted by prey monkie View Post
3. i defintly agree on the fact that people in spamadan ae1 are lowballers but i still make money there. for low end items i sometimes go to kaining center. people have no idea what they are buying and how much its worth
I buy tomes in Kaineng center and sell them in Kamadan ;>

Marzipan Marci

Marzipan Marci

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Jun 2009

In my own dimension.

Golden Eternity [金金金金]

W/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jinkies View Post
I would actually say you are better off trading in Kamadan District 2, or Lion's Arch district 1. Most people in D1 Kamadan are looking for "serious" buyers, players in other districts, or less busy towns are, in my history, more likely to offer better prices.
It's interesting, but why is that?

joshuarodger

joshuarodger

Unbanned

Join Date: Jan 2008

Trinity of the Ascended [ToA] -- IGN: Swirly

Mo/

to be honest, the best/easiest to get rich is to buy items that can be traded for party points and alcohol at halloween and wintersday. about a month before this last halloween i started buying decayed orr emblems. i bought about 225 stacks of them for anywhere between 9k and 15k per stack. i then traded 3 emblems for 1 party point when the halloween collectors arrived. even if i had bought them all at 15k per stack this comes to 180g/point. i then sold those points for 250gold per point just by placing a thread in high end, 2 days later they were gone and i had made about 2 million profit. this was my first big investment and it really paid off for me

Eragon Selene

Eragon Selene

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Feb 2007

USA

[eF]

R/A

Quote:
Originally Posted by Martin Alvito View Post
Above poster is a classic example of fallacious reasoning. Future performance does not always equal past performance. Rare minis probably will continue to increase in value in the long term, but the current run up in prices is probably about done for a while. Prices in these markets tend to plateau, then spike when external factors (dupe, easy ectos) make hardcore farmers broadly richer than they were previously. We should hit a plateau again fairly soon.

Further, there's an opportunity cost of just sitting on your resources. The larger your pool of resources, the more you can skim in values working that pool of resources. Spending 250 ecto and sitting on it for 6 months to gain 400 ecto is dumb if you could have made 50 trades skimming ten ecto per iteration during that six month period.
Example of why I disagree with this:

I bought a mini Oni 2 months ago for 805 ecto. I saw the "need" for these was low at the time and they had sold for 1000e only a week before. I had an offer for it yesterday of 1600e. Thats 795e proffit. Do that making smaller trades proffiting 5-10e each. Keep in mind your not always going to make money in a trade. The more you make the greater the risk of lozing money as well.

If you have 500e to work with min grawls are rare enough to invest in. They go for 250-280e right now. I would advise waiting until closer to the wintersday event. People tend to sell stuff CHEAP during those events because they need money for event items. Also if you ave up you might be able to pick up a mini polar bear when someone gets one. Those tend to sell cheaper during or around the event and go up over the year.

AlsPals

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Mar 2007

Sellin hot stock tips for pro[fit]

Me/E

This late in the games life, sitting on minis seems fruitless. I dunno, guess some people still love powertrading enough to care.

Martin Alvito

Martin Alvito

Older Than God (1)

Join Date: Aug 2006

Clan Dethryche [dth]

Quote:
Originally Posted by Eragon Selene View Post
I bought a mini Oni 2 months ago for 805 ecto. I saw the "need" for these was low at the time and they had sold for 1000e only a week before. I had an offer for it yesterday of 1600e. Thats 795e proffit.
That's an outlier and you know it.

I can regale you with stories of buying 1000e items and instantly reselling them for 1500e+, or buying 10k items and instantly reselling them for over 100k. Proves nothing about whether trading > buy and hold.

The real question is which method makes the most money over time. Under almost all circumstances, you're better off putting your money to work than sitting on things. You can't take advantage of those 1000e -> 1500e moments if all of your assets are tied up already. Also, the fact that your mini Oni just doubled in value should alert you that sitting on minis probably isn't a real hot idea right now. The price of that Oni won't double again in the next two months.

its bad to sin

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Jan 2009

probably behind you

Mercenaries Of Grenth [MoG]

P/W

so im going to look into power trading party/sweet points untill i get some more money. which do you think that i would make more money on?

snowman relic

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Feb 2009

your just a meatsheild to me

N/Mo

im thinking on buying decayed orr emblems for 12k (116 stacks) but im pretty sure party points are only 150g per point so wont i be losing mony?

**EDIT**

i did some math and its telling me ill only make about 49k (more then what i started with) is that accurate or am i off?

Strife17

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Jul 2008

Mo/

116 stacks x 12k = 1392k

party points = 200gp each~

116 stacks= 116x250= 29 000 orr emblems

Takes 3 orr emblems for 1 party point: 29 000 / 3 = 9666,67 ~9666 party points

9666 x 200 = 1933k gold

so you would make about 550k

which is sickass lame, considering the time you would need to buy the 116 stacks lol

snowman relic

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Feb 2009

your just a meatsheild to me

N/Mo

lol id just be glad to be making mony again ive been ina slump fora little while being to lazy to farm again + i have a couple accounts i can set up at different placed to spam buying

imnotyourmother

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Mar 2008

in a house

The Knitters Guild

W/R

ah, grind wars continues.

ok I am going to add my 2 cents. I know that my 2 cents is not a lot to power trade on but I'll give it a shot.

Facts:

1) The game is in the twilight of its fame.
2) No more games or expansions until GW2 now reported for late 2010 or 2011.
3) Most people will be trying very hard to fill their halls BEFORE GW2 hits
4) Speculation will run ramped when the beta comes out
5) You will not be able to transfer wealth from GW1 - GW2 unless the chest is added in the HoM
6) You will be stuck with tones of ectos cause everyone will be in GW2 - well I will be there and at that point not caring about who has stacks of ectos.

its bad to sin

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Jan 2009

probably behind you

Mercenaries Of Grenth [MoG]

P/W

this thread can be closed i started with 250k i now have a 4 armbraces and about 200k so thank your every1 for your help =]

packe

Pre-Searing Cadet

Join Date: Jul 2009

How do you run duncan? There's any guides on youtube?

Snow Bunny

Snow Bunny

Alcoholic From Yale

Join Date: Jul 2007

Strong Foreign Policy [sFp]

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jinkies View Post
Also, 13 hours a day may seem like alot but many dedicated runners play at least that much per day on weekends. Not only that but your profit varies by dungeon you run.

13 hours/day may seem like a lot?

No, it doesn't seem like a lot, it's bloody way too much.

Night Life

Academy Page

Join Date: Jan 2010

right behind you

Mercenaries Of Grenth [MoG]

P/W

with duncan being such a good money making run there not making vids cuz as soon as u make vids the price drops ALOT