Dervish in name only

kaptaincu

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: Aug 2009

Queensland

Australian confederates [AC]

IMHO dervish is the best looking char going round, and being that I play for enjoyment and not to be one of the 'elite' like the majority of children out there- I get alot of flack for my builds.
My current is a D/R with
apply poisen
spike trap
3R intrups
melandu shot
troll
and a free slot for anything

I have runes giving 604health and 37energy

I find it very useful in FA JQ AB RA

I know it will be blasted by the 'elite'
but maybe someone will get a kick out of it.

Chocobo1

Chocobo1

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Sep 2007

New Zealand

CoA

N/

You deserve the flack. You gain absolutely nothing for running a Ranger bar on a Dervish. You don't have expertise, so there is no way you could play the bar as effectively on a ranger, and running a trap in PvP is just bad. Why contribute to the amount of bad players out there, try getting a good bar. You'll win more and be far more effective, which generally people find to be enjoyable.

Also people might stop hating on your builds.

kaptaincu

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: Aug 2009

Queensland

Australian confederates [AC]

Thx for proving my point.

I have fun, that's why I play.

Hope you enjoy GW or do find yourself raging at others in game too much?

Breakfast Mc Rit

Breakfast Mc Rit

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Apr 2008

[Sin]

Me/

How is he raging in any way? He's merely stating the truth. While you may have fun playing with what you have, people have to put up with a less effective player on their team, which ends up hampering their own playing experience.

Xsiriss

Xsiriss

Jungle Guide

Join Date: May 2008

The reason peopel rage at you is because you'll just draw back the team. We have fun through playing well and winning,like most gamers. You want to use traps? Make a ranger and stop trying to bash us when you're the one ruining it for us.

If you understood game mechanics properly you'd probably see why (expertise cutting energy cost,gaining higher WS attribute for more damage etc....).

Nechrond

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Oct 2009

Netherlands

Utrecht Usurpators

D/

Really, don't do this in RA. It's fine (well, still bad, but more acceptable) in AB, FA or JQ, but doing it in RA, where there's only 3 guys to compensate for you, is really lame.
Besides, if you really play for fun only, you should stay out of RA anyway. It's a simple arena, the only fun to be had there is winning.

Kattar

Kattar

EXCESSIVE FLUTTERCUSSING

Join Date: Mar 2007

SMS (lolgw2placeholder)

Me/

If you have fun, why do you care what people think of your build?

But surely since you've posted here about this whole situation, you don't care what people think...

Right?

aeligos

aeligos

Academy Page

Join Date: Jan 2010

USA

Fortituro Et Fides

wrong kattar

he doesn't care what people think, but only what YOU think...

...like me! i mean the only reason i post anything on GURU is because i want to know what YOU think, not so much to just get my thoughts out in the open....to express me-shelf, to vent...... nah, none of that jive. all i want to know is what a particular person may think about what i have on my mind.

o.o

and he IS having fun with that build... there is no "ifs" about it.

[...clears throat...]

-.-

Not Listing it Here

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: Jan 2010

Honestly, I would say play what you have fun with and forget about other people.
You like the way the Derv toon looks, but really likes bows...go to it.

People can bitch if they want, oh no you hurt 'the team'. But nothing in this game aside from perhaps HA is a team game. If people were so worried about 'the team', then monks would only take healing or prot skills into FA. Team has 8 players, 4 are monks and none has anything other than the Jesus Beam going on. As I only play FA, 90% of the time you wait 10 minutes to get in and once you do you have 1 leecher, 2 leavers and 2 bitchers. The other 3 are trying to win. I would rather have you playing what you like than the first 5 on that list.

Good luck out there.

Jarge

Academy Page

Join Date: Dec 2006

England

Queen and Country [QC]

P/W

Quote:
Originally Posted by kaptaincu View Post
Thx for proving my point.

I have fun, that's why I play.

Hope you enjoy GW or do find yourself raging at others in game too much? I'd like to call you selfish, but that would be a personal attack and would land me with a ban. There is a reason that a meta exists, you are doing nothing but limiting your and your team mates' chances of winning by playing that bar on that profession.
It's not a case of "raging", it's a case of you ignoring the information available and relying on your team mates to win. You may as well be leeching for all the effectiveness of that bar.

There is a reason that Dervishes use scythes and enchantments. There is a reason that Rangers use high-energy skills (like app poison).
It's not even a case of you not being aware that the bar sucks anymore, you are simply choosing to limit your and your team mates' chances by running an inferior bar because you find it fun. What about your team mates? You should consider them too.

aeligos

aeligos

Academy Page

Join Date: Jan 2010

USA

Fortituro Et Fides

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jarge View Post
I'd like to call you selfish, but that would be a personal attack... Everyone is selfish...even god, most of all. He created us so that we may worship him. He created the world --as brutal as it may be-- so that we would reach out to him for forgiveness & repentance from that which he had given us.

But to say that the derv-in-name-only is "leeching"??

....WOW!

-.-

sonofthort

sonofthort

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Mar 2006

The Legends Of Melee [SSBM]

Mo/

you sound pretty selfish to me. As long as you are having fun, it doesn't matter how terrible you are and how negatively you effect others. You can have just as much fun playing the build with a ranger. You will have better defense, better ability to spam your attacks, and you will actually be helping your team mates. I agree, you should play for fun, but not at the expense of others.

maxxfury

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Apr 2006

[DVDF] Gp

Me/A

Some class combinations lend them selves well to running a 2ndry bar..example N/rt resto, Me/e fc nuker..but this brings NOTHING to the table in that regard.

And it wont just be the "elite" who blast you for this, it will be anyone who knows anything about gw classes, skill bars and synergy.. People will vary with how they reply to you about it, some will be productive others will just call you a noob.

When you learn a little more about gw (as it seems you are kinda new?) you will gain more fun with better designed and developed bars. Guild wars is a learning experience...and very often taking advice from people who may be veterans, elites or just plainly know more about the game can really help you. I wish you luck in your endeavors and future leanings in guildwars!

Chthon

Grotto Attendant

Join Date: Apr 2007

I'm not sure if OP is a troll or a moron (leaning towards troll), but leaving this thread open serves no purpose in either case. In either case, OP is just going to keep defending this awful build no matter how detailed and well-reasoned the criticisms become. In either case, OP is never going to listen and learn what's wrong with this build and how to make a better one. In either case, the build is so bad that it doesn't offer anyone else a chance to learn anything because its flaws just aren't relevant to other people's builds.

Damian Manson

Academy Page

Join Date: Dec 2007

D/

i dont know if this is sideing with the op or not but we all must remember that the reason they play that build is because for a reason that is to them the way they have fun it may well be letting the team down it also may well be a terrible build to alot of us interested in builds to that regard but as said this is what they have fun with so why not let them be and let them graze on the field they choose to graze in no matter how bad it may afect others as long as the op has fun with there :P d/r build thats the main point in a team is it not :S

maxxfury

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Apr 2006

[DVDF] Gp

Me/A

my sarcasm detector has to work REALLY hard here some days :P today it assploded :P oops my bad :P

Axel Zinfandel

Axel Zinfandel

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Sep 2007

Northeastern Ohio

LaZy

P/W

If you're playing dervish you might as well try to work -with- the profession rather then slapping a ranger bar on it.. like..

Throw Avatar of Lyssa on with Attacker's Insight and Eternal Aura along with some fast activating bow attacks and go crazy..

Or slap Zealous Vow, comfort animal, a few pet attacks, scythe (or bow if you insist on using one).

Kind of along the same lines is why would -love- to roll a ranger, but they suck in PvE, so instead I hop on my Assassin and abuse Disrupting Accuracy

Lanier

Lanier

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Jan 2010

[Pink]

P/

Wow... this thread is kind of rediculous...

Honestly OP, if you are having fun, then keep at it. Do what is fun for you. Who the hell cares if you are slightly less effective than a primary Ranger? its not like FA, JQ, RA, and AB are serious business anyway? In fact... Guilds wars is... Just a game! thats right, it was actually created to have fun in! I know this may be a novel concept to many people out there but it is no big deal whether or not you win any given RA match. Your first born isnt going to die if you lose.

So go have some fun. This is only a game after all.

sonofthort

sonofthort

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Mar 2006

The Legends Of Melee [SSBM]

Mo/

I love the it's just a game mentality, but you are using it the wrong way. Look up the definition of a game, and you will see that it is about completing a goal, hence, if all you want to do is have fun, there are plenty of ways to have fun. If you want to have fun through a game, you should focus on actually being good at the game since that's the point (along with having fun). Imo "it's just a game" should be used when people are more concerned with titles and all that fancy stuff instead of just having a good time playing.

Bobby2

Bobby2

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Jun 2007

Delayed in order to meet ANet's high standards

[MaSS]

W/E

RA: you can pull this sh*t here, since matches are quick to restart when your team loses. If your team manages to garner a win despite of you, the smart ones will leave anyway.

FA/JQ: lasts for a considerably longer time and has more players, most of 'em wanting to win. They are rightfully going to consider you a handicap and you deserve every flame you get from them. Accept it; it comes with the territory of your fun.

AB: a rare situation in which you yourself are not the only one to blame. People should ask for builds when team building, so all 4 of your team are at fault. The 8 other people are rightfully going to consider you a handicap and you deserve every flame you get from them. Accept it; it comes with the territory of your fun.

Conclusion: you like it when people get mad at you. You are a griefer. Griefers are kinda sad.

Chthon

Grotto Attendant

Join Date: Apr 2007

To clarify something:

There's nothing wrong, per se, with the attitude "I just wanna have fun and I find <insert crap build> really, really fun."

However:
1. My conception of fun doesn't involve sucking at GW. So, I don't want you in my team. As long as you stay out of RA/AB/FA/JQ where I can't boot you when I realize what a tard you are, what you do outside of my party (and without effect on the game economy) is no concern of mine. You'll find a lot of people, especially on these forums, share my view.
2. Builds like this have no place on the forums. Anyone can make a crappy-but-"fun" build all by themselves, without any help from you. It's making good builds that's a challenge. The dialogue here is about "here, I think this is a good build," "yes, that is a good build; but wouldn't this be better?," "no, I don't think that's a good build; here's why," "I know this isn't a good build; please help," and "you're right; that's not a good build; here's help."

Lanier

Lanier

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Jan 2010

[Pink]

P/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Chthon View Post
To clarify something:

There's nothing wrong, per se, with the attitude "I just wanna have fun and I find <insert crap build> really, really fun."

However:
1. My conception of fun doesn't involve sucking at GW. So, I don't want you in my team. As long as you stay out of RA/AB/FA/JQ where I can't boot you when I realize what a tard you are, what you do outside of my party (and without effect on the game economy) is no concern of mine. You'll find a lot of people, especially on these forums, share my view.
2. Builds like this have no place on the forums. Anyone can make a crappy-but-"fun" build all by themselves, without any help from you. It's making good builds that's a challenge. The dialogue here is about "here, I think this is a good build," "yes, that is a good build; but wouldn't this be better?," "no, I don't think that's a good build; here's why," "I know this isn't a good build; please help," and "you're right; that's not a good build; here's help." 1. Yes, I am aware that a lot of people on these forums share your view. Im also not saying that my conception, or anyone else's conception, or the OP's conception for that matter (though i cant really speak for him) of fun is sucking. Im simply saying that we shouldnt knock on the OP for doing something that he finds "fun", as everyone has a different view on what is "fun".

2. I do agree with this point. Im not quite sure why the OP chose to post this.

And as for games being about "completing a goal"... this definitely is not the case. People play games to have fun. I mean if I wanted to complete a goal or try to accomplish something, I would do it in real life where it actually matters. Im not advocating bad play, im just saying that people dont necessarily play this game to be good, and people definitely dont play low end PvP for that purpose. Competitive play is more in the area of GvG and HA, not AB and FA and stuff.

kaptaincu

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: Aug 2009

Queensland

Australian confederates [AC]

Wow-some people take this game WAY too seriously!!!

Better not post my D/E(full Eskills)

it is a game right?

Axel Zinfandel

Axel Zinfandel

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Sep 2007

Northeastern Ohio

LaZy

P/W

Aye. The elitist "Run something good or GTFO" mentality is why I don't play PvP

in fact, I think you should go out there, play what you like in PvP, and then laugh at how angry people get.

Arrogant Bastard

Arrogant Bastard

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Aug 2009

Your mom's house

E/

Ironically, many of the people who refuse to run "mainstream" builds act elitist themselves.

_Nihilist_

_Nihilist_

Will Bull's Strike for $!

Join Date: Apr 2006

Isle of the Dead

Quote:
Originally Posted by OP
apply poisen
spike trap
3R intrups
melandu shot
troll
and a free slot for anything

I have runes giving 604health and 37energy

I find it very useful in FA JQ AB RA

I know it will be blasted by the 'elite'
but maybe someone will get a kick out of it. You're running a Dervish primary with all Ranger skills in FA/JQ/AB/RA why? For an additional 25hp (Dervish Chest Armor bonus)? To swap Expertise for Mysticism (which doesn't do you a bit of good with the skills you're running)? To lose the ability to increase your attributes with runes? To lose +30AL vs Elemental damage (Ranger Armor bonus)?

You aren't getting blasted by the 'elite', you're getting blasted by people with common sense and an understanding of game mechanics. There's a difference.

Kopa The Demon King

Kopa The Demon King

Academy Page

Join Date: Mar 2010

Forever Knights

D/

short and sweet
If you want to play a ranger build, play a ranger.

If you want to go bow on a dervish here is a list of suggestions
-Drop the traps theyre useless and a waste of energy in PvP
-Drop your bow attacks to only 2, POSSIBLY 3 (at the max)
-Replace apply poison for poison tip signet and use Barrage+your zealous bow
-Bow skills with zealous bow should include |Barrage|Volley|MAYBE dual shot

-Use a zealous bow if you dont use Zealous vow or whatever its called
-Maintain your energy with DERVISH enchantments and replace troll unguent with Mystic regeneration or faithfull/watchfull intervention.

(thats about all i can say)
Skill combos
(No zealous bow)
Poison tip signet|Zealous vow|Volley|Dual shot|Needling shot|
(Zealous bow)
Poison Tip signet|Barrage|Volley|Needling shot|

(heals can be used in combo with Faithful intervention, a perma enchant and a nice heal when it procts, and Mystic regen +3-4 health regen PER ENCHANT)

Descriptives
Lyssa or grenth are nice in place of zealous vow, but not for PvP.

If you MUST run a dervish ranger go volley/dual shot with zealous vow to back you up as you will gain energy for each hit you make

IF NOT then maybe use
|Poison tip signet|Barrage|Volley|Dual shot + a zealous bow...

though i will say you're running up a tree i tried to climb for a while now. I had something with Ebon dust aura, but that doesnt work anymore because its strictly Melee


Useing a Zealous Bow and your dervish skills to up your attack speed and energy gain would be about all that you could do, try and work WITH the class, you're gunna want mainly dervish skills with a slot open for Poison tip signet, and two bow attacks.


Honestly though, You may have fun but you are hurting the team horribly and also increacing the negative outlook for dervish players.

Dervish ranger Bow sucks because the dervish doesnt have any form of energy management with bow skills. Ranger skills work because rangers have expertise

Necros have buit in energy management and eles have a mass of energy

Necros have a few skills that cause damage when the opponent takes physical damage, and the bow would help keep the range, and possibly pin down to keep them from getting close

Eles with mark of rodgort|Poison tip sig|Barrage| and a firey bow can effectively burn/poison spam masses of enemies to death

A dervish doesnt have much that will help you, youre left with raw bow dmg, and a few attack speed increaces+ an energy devouring build.

If you HAVE TO play a ranger on a dervish be smart about it. Dervish bow is gone because EDA is gone...and rangers could use EDA anyways, and since they have expertise theyre better at it.