The suggestion is indeed a good one, however, their is something you fail to realize. You can't please the masses.To win over a majority is the democratic way, but this isn't a democracy, this is a guild. The GL leads, the officers follow by doing the GL's will,and the lower guys follow suit. That is the way a guild is originally constructed. In a heirarchial system. Leader,officers,followers...in that order.To let them give input is nice, but the cape design is up to the guild leader in the end.In my guild,The League Of Alchemists, the leadership is split between 2 players. They have contrasting styles when it comes down to what the cape should look like.Recently, I was given the chance to make a cape for the guild. I made one, but a few grubbled about crossed swords and white lions, the stuff you see ALL OVER TYRIA.
So, I asked to be allowed total control of the guild in order to change the cape as how I saw fit. The request was granted and I remade the cape( I particularly have different taste than both leaders,so I never wore the cape unless it was PvP). Now most of the guild loves it, save the 2nd leader.I would not be surprised to find it changed as soon as he becomes leader for the week approaching.It would disappoint me,but not surprise me.Anyway,its a good idea, but in the end, it may be a waste of programming time.