Paragon DPS

LifeInfusion

LifeInfusion

Grotto Attendant

Join Date: May 2005

in the midline

E/Mo

We do care what autoattack damage is. It is zero investment on your skillbar.

If you want to complain about scaling of Paragon [email protected] nonelite attack skills (other than Cruel Spear/Wearying Spear/Blazing Spear) that's different than arguing for more attack damage/DPS. It already does more damage than swords not using Galrath/Body Blow/Final Thrust/Standing Slash/Dragon Slash/Quivering Blade seeing how cripslash->Gash is +19 or so unlike Eviscerate-Executioner's Strike. Keep in mind with a 33% IAS (especially Soldier's Fury) those Paragon skills will charge quicker than sword's 7-8 adrenaline (Blazing spear is 6, spear of redemption is 3, holy spear is 4, wild throw is 7, wearying spear is 3, cruel spear is 7) and you don't even need to worry about kiting, just miss/dodge.

Hell, even Axe mastery has a handful of skills that have +19 or less: Agonizing chop, Axe Rake, Axe Twist, Critical Chop/Penetrating Blow/Penetrating Chop/Swift Chop/Whirling Axe/Cyclone Axe. It's just that Axe is known for Eviscerate +29 (used to be +38) followed by Executioner's Strike/Body Blow. Hammers are used for knockdowns, but other than Forceful Blow/Mighty Blow/Heavy Blow/Renewing Smash (PVE) they don't have more than +19 either.

If it bothers you so much, you have Anthem of Envy (+20ish at moderate command) + "Find their Weakness!" (which is expensive but more + damage than any melee attack).

The moment that Paragons get +38ish on attacks with no drawbacks like weakness (Wearying Spear) or insane cast time (Unblockable throw; Mighty Throw) then there's zero reason to run a Warrior or Dervish for their weapons, whose attack damages get +38 (Power Attack/Body Blow/Galrath Slash/Executioner's Strike) and +25 respectively (Victorious Sweep/Radiant Scythe with full energy/Zealous Sweep), Reap Impurities (+52), Pious Assault in PVE (+48). It hurts the warrior the most, honestly, since they already need cancel stances to switch groups effectively (whereas Dervishes can just use IMS+IAS).

If you recall, rangers' attack skills were nerfed due to r-spike.

Khomet Si Netjer

Khomet Si Netjer

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Apr 2007

The Angelic Guard

P/

Quote:
Originally Posted by LifeInfusion View Post
We do care what autoattack damage is. It is zero investment on your skillbar.

If you want to complain about scaling of Paragon [email protected] nonelite attack skills (other than Cruel Spear/Wearying Spear/Blazing Spear) that's different than arguing for more attack damage/DPS. It already does more damage than swords not using Galrath/Body Blow/Final Thrust/Standing Slash/Dragon Slash/Quivering Blade seeing how cripslash->Gash is +19 or so unlike Eviscerate-Executioner's Strike. Keep in mind with a 33% IAS (especially Soldier's Fury) those Paragon skills will charge quicker than sword's 7-8 adrenaline (Blazing spear is 6, spear of redemption is 3, holy spear is 4, wild throw is 7, wearying spear is 3, cruel spear is 7) and you don't even need to worry about kiting, just miss/dodge.

Hell, even Axe mastery has a handful of skills that have +19 or less: Agonizing chop, Axe Rake, Axe Twist, Critical Chop/Penetrating Blow/Penetrating Chop/Swift Chop/Whirling Axe/Cyclone Axe. It's just that Axe is known for Eviscerate +29 (used to be +38) followed by Executioner's Strike/Body Blow. Hammers are used for knockdowns, but other than Forceful Blow/Mighty Blow/Heavy Blow/Renewing Smash (PVE) they don't have more than +19 either.

If it bothers you so much, you have Anthem of Envy (+20ish at moderate command) + "Find their Weakness!" (which is expensive but more + damage than any melee attack).

The moment that Paragons get +38ish on attacks with no drawbacks like weakness (Wearying Spear) or insane cast time (Unblockable throw; Mighty Throw) then there's zero reason to run a Warrior or Dervish for their weapons, whose attack damages get +38 (Power Attack/Body Blow/Galrath Slash/Executioner's Strike) and +25 respectively (Victorious Sweep/Radiant Scythe with full energy/Zealous Sweep), Reap Impurities (+52), Pious Assault in PVE (+48). It hurts the warrior the most, honestly, since they already need cancel stances to switch groups effectively (whereas Dervishes can just use IMS+IAS).

If you recall, rangers' attack skills were nerfed due to r-spike. no one goes into battle with empty skillbars, I don't consider this a serious argument.

re: rspike, I don't think anyone on gwguru would make the argument that rangers are overpowered in PvP *or* PvE. Anet has been quick to nerf paragons and rangers but they have allowed Shadow Form abuse to continue for years... what's going on with their balance team?

what you say about bonus damage is true but I think you are missing the main reason why spears are lacking in PvE. certain spear skills deliver excellent damage and effects for their cost, for example Spear of Lightning, Vicious Attack, Wild Throw, Blazing Spear. However this is still not enough to make paragons outdamage any other weapon, even with 14+ spear mastery. Why? It is because other professions can attack faster, attack multiple times, have AoE damage and conditions, have primary attributes that increase damage (str, crit) and have self-buffing (signet of strength, critical eye, WotA, preparations). There's nothing the paragon can do about weapon speed or primary attribute but if some skills were changed then he would have more of a chance against the competition, even though he would still be an inferior damage dealer for all the reasons I already mentioned.

as some common examples, consider jagged/ff/death blossom, hundred blades/whirlwind, vow of strength AoE damage builds, and splinter barrage. This is the competition, and paragon pales in comparison to them. I'm not saying that the paragon should be able to out-damage any melee profession... this is not possible for reasons I've already mentioned. however, I don't think it is unrealistic to expect the paragon to be on par with the ranger.

LifeInfusion

LifeInfusion

Grotto Attendant

Join Date: May 2005

in the midline

E/Mo

Quote:
Originally Posted by Khomet Si Netjer View Post
no one goes into battle with empty skillbars, I don't consider this a serious argument.

re: rspike, I don't think anyone on gwguru would make the argument that rangers are overpowered in PvP *or* PvE. Anet has been quick to nerf paragons and rangers but they have allowed Shadow Form abuse to continue for years... what's going on with their balance team?

what you say about bonus damage is true but I think you are missing the main reason why spears are lacking in PvE. certain spear skills deliver excellent damage and effects for their cost, for example Spear of Lightning, Vicious Attack, Wild Throw, Blazing Spear. However this is still not enough to make paragons outdamage any other weapon, even with 14+ spear mastery. Why? It is because other professions can attack faster, attack multiple times, have AoE damage and conditions, have primary attributes that increase damage (str, crit) and have self-buffing (signet of strength, critical eye, WotA, preparations). There's nothing the paragon can do about weapon speed or primary attribute but if some skills were changed then he would have more of a chance against the competition, even though he would still be an inferior damage dealer for all the reasons I already mentioned.

as some common examples, consider jagged/ff/death blossom, hundred blades/whirlwind, vow of strength AoE damage builds, and splinter barrage. This is the competition, and paragon pales in comparison to them. I'm not saying that the paragon should be able to out-damage any melee profession... this is not possible for reasons I've already mentioned. however, I don't think it is unrealistic to expect the paragon to be on par with the ranger. Other professions "can attack faster, attack multiple times, have AoE damage and conditions"?

Aggressive Refrain/Soldier's Fury makes spears just as fast. Except for Critical Agility and elite WoTA, sins don't have an IAS. Rangers have Lightning Reflexes and Never Rampage Alone basically unless you're investing in Beast Mastery or using a terrible elite (Expert's Dexterity) or forgoing a prep (Rapid Fire). Warriors must resort to Flail or Burst of Agression WE bars (Frenzy on a warrior is pretty difficult to do in PVE without a ER prot and/or cancel stance). Dervishes are broken at the moment with Heart of Fury /Pious Fury/Onslaught , but that's just because they got mega-buffed (not a word, I know).

Dual Shot/Twin Moon Sweep/Sun& Moon Slash doesn't do +damage so I'm assuming you're counting stuff like EDA, 100B, Conjures, GDW, SoH, Preps. Then you need to count Anthem of Envy and stuff like that. There's nothing stopping you from going P/E for conjures.

AOE damage is the only point of contention for other professions.

The only non-damage conditions that are useful enough for a ranged character are cripple/blind/weakness, of dubious usefulness in PVE for killing things. Poison/Bleeding are laughable in PVE (~6-8DPS). Paragons can apply Deep wound (and burning, dazed, cripple, and bleeding), so I consider them fully capable. Dervishes only recently got Cracked armor.

The Paragon running 2-3 attack skills instead of 3 to 5 on a warrior bar can still support the party due to not needing IMS (frees up 1 slot)... you can run 12+1+1 Spear, 9+1 Command, 9+1 Leadership or similar. Assassins and warriors tend to run 13 in primary attributes, so there's not nearly the same flexibility. Unless mobs are being instagibbed, autoattack damage applies *free* DPS.

Fox Fangs + Death Blossom are the only damage skills in assassins' daggermastery that are on quick recharge with high +damage (Wild Strike + Golden Fox Strike too). +33 on Fox Fangs isn't much more than Paragons' +20s when you consider the +7-10 on base damage (although for HM PVE you could argue there's a difference). It's just that death Blossom is a dual attack so that's why +43s seem to be a big deal. Both of those skills are split for PvP.

100B isn't even worth comparing. Vow of Strength has it beat pretty much. 100B on its own without the Whirlwind attack PVE skill isn't doing much, it's similar to +13-15 or so on most mobs, +6 or 9 at worst (on my warrior in HM that's what I've seen). The only thing it has going for it is AOE and MoP/Barbs triggers.

Splinter barrage is done better on a Rt/R or R/ and Rt/ combination anyway, so I don't see what you're getting at. The Ranger needs a significant Expertise investment unless a zealous bow is used with a decent sized enemy group and Ranger IASes suck with attack skills (plus they cost 10+energy except Heket's Rampage).

Seems like what you're looking for is AOE (100B without AOE is pretty crap, Death Blossom, Whirlwind attack/Barrage are AOEs with medium +damage). Dragonslash is only high damage due to FGJ! recharging it. You could achieve similar results to Dragon slash single-target with Focused Anger/Soldier's Fury + FGJ! + Spear of Redemption/Holy Spear albeit for about half the +damage. If you have some way to curb the Weakness (the only malus) on Wearying Spear, there's your damage (3strikes of adrenaline with Soldier's Fury or Aggressive Refrain+Focused Anger/FGJ is easy). Recovery + -20% Weakness shield + Purifying Veil or something.

If Paragon DPS is so crap, why were they run in last month's PVP mAT (in playoffs no less) by GN?
http://www.gw-memorial.net/nav/b_mat_i.php?id=618

P.S. signet of strength is utter crap. Even Warriors would rather use I am the strongest, which is available to Paragons too.

carnage-runner

carnage-runner

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Aug 2006

Canada, B.C. Vancouver. aka.. amazing.

[Sith]

W/Me

Just for the wins and stuff... I'm hitting about 80-100 DPS on my para. I'm using Conjure Frost on the weapon for bonus damage, and "Go For The Eyes" to activate Vicious Attack. Spear of Fury to charge Adren, then Stunning Strike to make it all happy. Couple that with I Am The Strongest... You can maintain a high DPS as a paragon. Get a GDW on that, and you've got a pretty solid damage dealer..
If you're going solo, take Sniper Support, Finish Him, or You Move Like a Dwarf as some added damage. If you have 2 para spear chuckin sob's, take GDW and keep it up on eachother for Mega damage awesome.

Also... 7th and 8th slot are optional but I like AoS for the perks, and either Bladeturn Refrain, or Anthem of Envy. I hit around 125 damage as a max in HM with this bar. Average about 85-90 damage per spear. It's pretty solid, and it's fun. I run Sup Spear and Minor Command to boost stats.

But it's irrelevant really... Para's are there for Buff's atm. Spear damage is not up to par to be considered a viable build.

Khomet Si Netjer

Khomet Si Netjer

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Apr 2007

The Angelic Guard

P/

Quote:
Originally Posted by LifeInfusion View Post
Other professions "can attack faster, attack multiple times, have AoE damage and conditions"?

Aggressive Refrain/Soldier's Fury makes spears just as fast.
No, they're not. Swords, Axes and Daggers all attack faster, and Scythes attack at the same speed while doing more damage and potentially hitting 3x as many targets (thus 3x as much damage). Bows attack slower but still win out over spears because they can hit 2,3,4 or 7 targets at once... thus 2-7 times as much damage as the spear, potentially.

Quote: Originally Posted by LifeInfusion Except for Critical Agility and elite WoTA, sins don't have an IAS. Rangers have Lightning Reflexes and Never Rampage Alone basically unless you're investing in Beast Mastery or using a terrible elite (Expert's Dexterity) or forgoing a prep (Rapid Fire). Warriors must resort to Flail or Burst of Agression WE bars (Frenzy on a warrior is pretty difficult to do in PVE without a ER prot and/or cancel stance). Dervishes are broken at the moment with Heart of Fury /Pious Fury/Onslaught , but that's just because they got mega-buffed (not a word, I know). No one has to work hard to get a good IAS unless he is a warrior or paragon. The warrior IAS are all crippled because of pvp concerns and the paragons likewise. Dervish, Assassin and Ranger have it quite easy by comparison.

Quote: Originally Posted by LifeInfusion Dual Shot/Twin Moon Sweep/Sun& Moon Slash doesn't do +damage so I'm assuming you're counting stuff like EDA, 100B, Conjures, GDW, SoH, Preps. Then you need to count Anthem of Envy and stuff like that. There's nothing stopping you from going P/E for conjures.

AOE damage is the only point of contention for other professions. It doesn't have to do +damage... isn't it clear that 2 sword attacks or 2 arrows does twice as much damage as one? Other professions all have this ability, paragon does not, and that's why paragon damage is mediocre at best. If you haven't seen this concept in action go try Barrage or Whirlwind Attack sometime.

BTW one of the paragon builds I tested was P/E. It is not enough damage to keep up with the other weapons. What's worse, other professions can also load up Conjure and do even more.

Quote: The only non-damage conditions that are useful enough for a ranged character are cripple/blind/weakness, of dubious usefulness in PVE for killing things. Poison/Bleeding are laughable in PVE (~6-8DPS). Paragons can apply Deep wound (and burning, dazed, cripple, and bleeding), so I consider them fully capable. Dervishes only recently got Cracked armor. BURNING. Blinding. Crippling. Cracked Armor. These are all useful, and dervish can inflict all of them with AoE effects now.

If the ranger and paragon are supposed to be masters of condition spreading (as a perusal of their skill set might indicate) then they are quite poor at it compared to the new dervish.

Quote: The Paragon running 2-3 attack skills instead of 3 to 5 on a warrior bar can still support the party due to not needing IMS (frees up 1 slot)... you can run 12+1+1 Spear, 9+1 Command, 9+1 Leadership or similar. Assassins and warriors tend to run 13 in primary attributes, so there's not nearly the same flexibility. Unless mobs are being instagibbed, autoattack damage applies *free* DPS. Oh dear. Autoattack dps is not important in any way shape or form... anything can out-heal it, even with Healing Signet and the like.

Quote:
Fox Fangs + Death Blossom are the only damage skills in assassins' daggermastery that are on quick recharge with high +damage (Wild Strike + Golden Fox Strike too). +33 on Fox Fangs isn't much more than Paragons' +20s when you consider the +7-10 on base damage (although for HM PVE you could argue there's a difference). It's just that death Blossom is a dual attack so that's why +43s seem to be a big deal. Both of those skills are split for PvP.

100B isn't even worth comparing. Vow of Strength has it beat pretty much. 100B on its own without the Whirlwind attack PVE skill isn't doing much, it's similar to +13-15 or so on most mobs, +6 or 9 at worst (on my warrior in HM that's what I've seen). The only thing it has going for it is AOE and MoP/Barbs triggers.

Splinter barrage is done better on a Rt/R or R/ and Rt/ combination anyway, so I don't see what you're getting at. The Ranger needs a significant Expertise investment unless a zealous bow is used with a decent sized enemy group and Ranger IASes suck with attack skills (plus they cost 10+energy except Heket's Rampage).

Seems like what you're looking for is AOE (100B without AOE is pretty crap, Death Blossom, Whirlwind attack/Barrage are AOEs with medium +damage). Dragonslash is only high damage due to FGJ! recharging it. You could achieve similar results to Dragon slash single-target with Focused Anger/Soldier's Fury + FGJ! + Spear of Redemption/Holy Spear albeit for about half the +damage. If you have some way to curb the Weakness (the only malus) on Wearying Spear, there's your damage (3strikes of adrenaline with Soldier's Fury or Aggressive Refrain+Focused Anger/FGJ is easy). Recovery + -20% Weakness shield + Purifying Veil or something. Thanks for proving my point... you've just outlined various options for every profession to deal a lot of damage involving self buffs like Vow of Strength, 100 blades, WotA, Glass Arrows and multi-attack skills like Whirlwind Attack, Barrage, Death Blossom, etc. Paragons don't have access to any of that and that's why their damage is bad in PvE. Single target damage is not enough... if it were, you could say that Eviscerate axe warriors would be just as good as 100blades warriors, and they are not. Not in PvE anyway.

Quote:
If Paragon DPS is so crap, why were they run in last month's PVP mAT (in playoffs no less) by GN? http://www.gw-memorial.net/nav/b_mat_i.php?id=618 In PvP you are almost always attempting to spike single targets, and the paragon's single target damage is pretty good. The rules and goals are different. Also notice that they are using the paragons for utility like stance removal, enchant removal, energy regen, and condition/hex removal. If they were interested in pure damage they would be taking more melee.

Quote:
P.S. signet of strength is utter crap. Even Warriors would rather use I am the strongest, which is available to Paragons too. I was talking about profession skills only, it's pointless to include PvE skills in this discussion since all players have equal access to them and heroes don't.
BTW I agree that signet of strength is pretty bad, but it's still more than the paragon has.

Quote:
Originally Posted by carnage-runner View Post
Just for the wins and stuff... I'm hitting about 80-100 DPS on my para. I'm using Conjure Frost on the weapon for bonus damage, and "Go For The Eyes" to activate Vicious Attack. Spear of Fury to charge Adren, then Stunning Strike to make it all happy. Couple that with I Am The Strongest... You can maintain a high DPS as a paragon. Get a GDW on that, and you've got a pretty solid damage dealer..
If you're going solo, take Sniper Support, Finish Him, or You Move Like a Dwarf as some added damage. If you have 2 para spear chuckin sob's, take GDW and keep it up on eachother for Mega damage awesome.

Also... 7th and 8th slot are optional but I like AoS for the perks, and either Bladeturn Refrain, or Anthem of Envy. I hit around 125 damage as a max in HM with this bar. Average about 85-90 damage per spear. It's pretty solid, and it's fun. I run Sup Spear and Minor Command to boost stats.

But it's irrelevant really... Para's are there for Buff's atm. Spear damage is not up to par to be considered a viable build. Well said... especially the part about spear damage not being up to par. I think anyone that has played paragon for a while and compared it to other professions will realize this. I have one of every profession so it's pretty easy for me to compare their differences.

There's two other things I want to point out for other readers.
#1) you are using PvE skills to make the paragon useful. I believe that the paragon should have better skills so that he can do well without having to use PvE skills, the way that Panic mesmers and SoS ritualists and assassins and dervishes and rangers are useful without relying on PvE skills. PvE skills make things better but no profession should require them in order to be useful.
#2) "para's are there for buff's atm". This is only true for Save Yourselves (a warrior PVE skill) and There's Nothing To Fear (a paragon pve skill). If you want serious damage buffing you bring Orders, Mark of Pain, Splinter Weapon, and Strength of Honor, because nothing the paragon has can compete with them. This is wrong and it needs to change... paragons were supposed to be the best at attack buffing, based on what we can see of their skillset. GFTE, Anthem of Envy, Anthem of Flame, etc. are all decent but they are all much less effective than the competition, and that's the problem.

I realize that this is a hopeless quest, but I want Anet to fix these imbalances and give Paragons something to do besides Imbagon. In fact I wouldn't mind if they change the skills around so that Imbagon becomes much weaker than it is now... but first they have to improve the paragon skills so that they are competitive.

LifeInfusion

LifeInfusion

Grotto Attendant

Join Date: May 2005

in the midline

E/Mo

Quote:
Originally Posted by Khomet Si Netjer
View Post
No, they're not. Swords, Axes and Daggers all attack faster, and Scythes attack at the same speed while doing more damage and potentially hitting 3x as many targets (thus 3x as much damage). Bows attack slower but still win out over spears because they can hit 2,3,4 or 7 targets at once... thus 2-7 times as much damage as the spear, potentially.


No one has to work hard to get a good IAS unless he is a warrior or paragon. The warrior IAS are all crippled because of pvp concerns and the paragons likewise. Dervish, Assassin and Ranger have it quite easy by comparison.


It doesn't have to do +damage... isn't it clear that 2 sword attacks or 2 arrows does twice as much damage as one? Other professions all have this ability, paragon does not, and that's why paragon damage is mediocre at best. If you haven't seen this concept in action go try Barrage or Whirlwind Attack sometime.

BTW one of the paragon builds I tested was P/E. It is not enough damage to keep up with the other weapons. What's worse, other professions can also load up Conjure and do even more.


BURNING. Blinding. Crippling. Cracked Armor. These are all useful, and dervish can inflict all of them with AoE effects now.

If the ranger and paragon are supposed to be masters of condition spreading (as a perusal of their skill set might indicate) then they are quite poor at it compared to the new dervish.


Oh dear. Autoattack dps is not important in any way shape or form... anything can out-heal it, even with Healing Signet and the like.



Thanks for proving my point... you've just outlined various options for every profession to deal a lot of damage involving self buffs like Vow of Strength, 100 blades, WotA, Glass Arrows and multi-attack skills like Whirlwind Attack, Barrage, Death Blossom, etc. Paragons don't have access to any of that and that's why their damage is bad in PvE. Single target damage is not enough... if it were, you could say that Eviscerate axe warriors would be just as good as 100blades warriors, and they are not. Not in PvE anyway.



In PvP you are almost always attempting to spike single targets, and the paragon's single target damage is pretty good. The rules and goals are different. Also notice that they are using the paragons for utility like stance removal, enchant removal, energy regen, and condition/hex removal. If they were interested in pure damage they would be taking more melee.



I was talking about profession skills only, it's pointless to include PvE skills in this discussion since all players have equal access to them and heroes don't.
BTW I agree that signet of strength is pretty bad, but it's still more than the paragon has. Swords/Axes attack marginally faster if you're assuming 33% IAS (soldier's fury). 0.8911 sec for them rather than 1.005 for spear. (~11% but spears have a higher damage range) Spears still attack faster than hammers (1.1725) or any bows. Assuming a Dervish is using Heart of Fury/Pious Fury, 1.125 is the same for Aggressive Refrain.

Rangers' IAS "have it easy", but the only one that sees use is Lightning Reflexes which is on 1/3 uptime. WoTA is gimping your elite, critical agility takes a PVE slot.

Bows only have a handful of skills with multi-hit (Dual shot, Forked arrow, triple shot, Barrage, volley). Since they attack roughly 1/3 slower even with the fastest refire rate, and preps other than Glass arrows add about +10 at best, I'd say it's fair. Compare Burning Arrow with Blazing Spear and tell me that Paragons aren't better. Multi-hit (i.e. dual shot) isn't what is hurting the Paragon. It's the lack of buffs (preps) and AoE. If you run Anthem of Envy+GFTE it's pretty much a damage boost. Without Barrage and balled mobs, Rangers' damage fails hard due to attack speed. So as I was saying, all you're doing is arguing for more AoE on Paragons (Like Mesmers complained about before).

In Hard mode, multi-hit means you do double of autoattack damage without critical that's really rather low: at most 19 or so on 100 armor assuming 15>50 customized and 26 on 80 armor caster mobs. Double strikes with critical from sins do an extra 33 on 60 armor or 17 on 100 compared to one strike. Hardly anything to write home about in Hard mode.

I ran eviscerate+ body blow +whirlwind on my pve warrior over 100B most of the time when I used to play it. Why? I'd rather spike a target for 200 in HM than do a pitiful 7-15 damage PBAoE. The only difference is if you run EBSOH (dumb if your team kills fast due to recharge) or MoP (on a hero that's pretty hard to do). Even with barbs, unless your target is dying in over 10 seconds then it's still less than +38*2 + 100 deep wound. 100B has no access to deep wound unless you waste 2 slots on sever-gash.

The most popular PVE builds atm are single target high damage: SoS, AP callers.

If autoattack DPS is irrelevant then we'd run Demonic Flesh blood necros with Dark Pact, Touch of Agony/Wallow's Bite, or Blood of the aggressor. It's 40+ damage armor ignoring after all. In fact, with SoH and conjures, autoattacks do matter because they are about 1/4 to 1/3 of the damage. SoH is the only one Paragons can't use anyway.

TBH if someone is going for pure spike they'd run A/P with sundering weapon on midline or some sort of caster like E-surge+MindWrack+Shatter Delusions or ShellShock+Invoke. The 2 Paragons apply non-kitable pressure from spear DPS and can swap targets on the fly when the enemy prot monk puts up Guardian/Shielding Hands. The dominant builds are all pressure. Spears have non-kitable, target swapping goodness. Hence why warriors and Dervishes spear things until they can get in melee range to build adrenaline.

If anything, as before, all I think you're suggesting is Paragon should have AoE skills and SoH + Dervishes need a nerf.

Haggis of Doom

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: May 2009

TGB

W/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Khomet Si Netjer View Post
If you want serious damage buffing you bring Orders, Mark of Pain, Splinter Weapon, and Strength of Honor, because nothing the paragon has can compete with them. This is wrong and it needs to change... paragons were supposed to be the best at attack buffing, based on what we can see of their skillset. GFTE, Anthem of Envy, Anthem of Flame, etc. are all decent but they are all much less effective than the competition, and that's the problem.
I disagree with this.

Para buffs do not need to compete with anything if they're decent enough, which they are. Why? Because there is no mutual exclusivity.

Splinter Weapon competes with GDW. Orders compete with Conjure (and competed with the old AoHM). But para buffs definitely DO NOT compete with anything at all.

It would be ridiculous for someone to say SoH competes with Orders or GDW, since people would just ask: "why are you not bringing all of em already? " The same thing can be said about para stuff.

Now, why are the Paragon buffs "weaker"? Simply because they are chugging spears at the same time. +1 platform to be buffed. You can say that a necro can also chug spears, but we both know that the Paragon will chug many, many more spears while having higher base dmg, which makes them a more "proper" platform.

I also disagree with the "insignificance" of autoattack dmg. It's free, therefore it's there. Bringing a skill that causes bleeding may be ineffective due to its low DPS, but autoattacks do not waste your bar space in any way, hence their low DPS should not be an issue. Fact: multiple sources of free low DPS = high DPS Play a minion master and you'll see.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Khomet Si Netjer View Post
Oh dear. Autoattack dps is not important in any way shape or form... anything can out-heal it, even with Healing Signet and the like. It doesn't really make sense when it's not your ONLY source of damage. ESurge is easily out-healed by Heal Area. Yeah, this means bringing only Esurge and trying to kill a group of monsters that have Heal Area won't work too well, but that doesn't prove anything about whether ESurge is a bad damage skill or not.

You're basically claiming that 120 DPS is not better than 100 DPS (random numbers here), because 20 DPS can be easily out-healed.

As things are now, the only reason people prefer melees for DPS is SoH. There is no strong reason to buff Para buffs. What the Para does need however, is a Motivation rework. On AoE: if you're not balling it's not very significant (it depends on the area ofc). If you're balling, you're better off running some gimmicky 100b + MoP anyways.

Khomet Si Netjer

Khomet Si Netjer

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Apr 2007

The Angelic Guard

P/

Quote:
Originally Posted by LifeInfusion View Post
Swords/Axes attack marginally faster if you're assuming 33% IAS (soldier's fury). 0.8911 sec for them rather than 1.005 for spear. (~11% but spears have a higher damage range) Spears still attack faster than hammers (1.1725) or any bows. Assuming a Dervish is using Heart of Fury/Pious Fury, 1.125 is the same for Aggressive Refrain.

Rangers' IAS "have it easy", but the only one that sees use is Lightning Reflexes which is on 1/3 uptime. WoTA is gimping your elite, critical agility takes a PVE slot.
... we've already discussed this, but I will spell it out. If I already attack faster with swords, axes, daggers, etc. AND I hit multiple foes with my attacks (S&M, triple chop, whirlwind, death blossom), then I am doing multiple times the damage that spears can do. Things like Whirlwind Attack and Barrage depend on having multiple foes clustered together. Skills like Dual Shot, S&M slash, and Death Blossom do not, they always deliver multiple hits no matter what. I don't think this should be a difficult concept for anyone, and you don't have to take my word for it either... go look at the DPS numbers I worked up and compare them. If you have better builds to compare I would love to see them. The fundamental problem is still there and can't be fixed without skill updates.

re: rangers, even if we ignore the beast mastery skills we still have Expert's Dexterity, Rapid Fire, and Lightning Reflexes. The first two are (nearly) permanent IAS with no drawbacks, the latter can have its duration doubled with Dwarven Stability so it's still a good option. All this is missing the point though, with sufficient multi-attack skills at your disposal you don't really need IAS. Splinter Barrage doesn't normally use it or need it, 100blades/Whirlwind/MoP doesn't need it, Jagged/FF/DB doesn't need it. Dervishes didn't really need it before or after the update since their scythe attacks are delivering multiple attacks by default and they have faster-than-normal attacks besides... never mind all the new AoE stuff they have now. The multi-attack skills allow one to get many hits in a small amount of time and that is what matters the most. People bring IAS to get more hits in less time but with multi-attack skills the effect is even greater. For example... Bow with +33% IAS might go from 2s down to 1.5s, so my ranger could shoot 4 arrows in 6 seconds with a fast IAS. However with Volley I can shoot the same 4 arrows in 2 seconds or 12 arrows in 6 seconds with no IAS at all.

Quote: Bows only have a handful of skills with multi-hit (Dual shot, Forked arrow, triple shot, Barrage, volley). Since they attack roughly 1/3 slower even with the fastest refire rate, and preps other than Glass arrows add about +10 at best, I'd say it's fair. Compare Burning Arrow with Blazing Spear and tell me that Paragons aren't better. Multi-hit (i.e. dual shot) isn't what is hurting the Paragon. It's the lack of buffs (preps) and AoE. If you run Anthem of Envy+GFTE it's pretty much a damage boost. Without Barrage and balled mobs, Rangers' damage fails hard due to attack speed. So as I was saying, all you're doing is arguing for more AoE on Paragons (Like Mesmers complained about before).
Blazing Spear is great, I wouldn't care to argue about that one. And finally we agree on something, the lack of buffs and AoE hurts paragons relative to all other professions. :-\ I make this argument because it's true... and as you pointed out, mesmers had the same issue. They were a pvp-balanced profession with great single target skills... and they were pretty terrible in PvE, because single target skills are relatively ineffective when you face huge mobs and the average lifespan of any red dot in the mob is 5-10 seconds. So mesmers got some AoE options and they are pretty good now. I want the same sort of update for paragons. Their other skills also need some work but this thread concerns DPS so i'll leave it at that.

re: dual shot, forked arrow, etc. I will make the argument that the lack of such skills does hurt the paragon... as I pointed out above, dual attacks and skills like Dual Shot, S&M slash, Twin Moon Sweep, etc. are great because they always do at least twice the damage of normal attacks, regardless of whether anything is balled up. More attacks in less time = win.

re: "only a few attack skills"... it doesn't take many attack skills to make a big difference. Barrage, Volley, Whirlwind and Death Blossom are all spammable and they make a huge difference to their respective professions.

Quote:
If anything, as before, all I think you're suggesting is Paragon should have AoE skills and SoH + Dervishes need a nerf.
Paragon should have AoE skills... no question. All other professions can inflict AoE damage, even the monk.

Strength of Honor favors melee because ranged attackers can't use it... and melee attackers already do more damage than the ranged attackers, why imbalance this further? I don't recall suggesting that SoH be nerfed but you raise a good point.

I don't think dervishes need nerfing, I have been enjoying playing my dervish since the update. They can deliver massive amounts of AoE damage with the right builds and that is fine, imo they were always meant to be crowd control melee... the scythe does this inherently without even considering the added damage from skills. And warrior and assassin have AoE damage too so they aren't left out in the cold.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Haggis of Doom View Post
I disagree with this.

Para buffs do not need to compete with anything if they're decent enough, which they are. Why? Because there is no mutual exclusivity.

Splinter Weapon competes with GDW. Orders compete with Conjure (and competed with the old AoHM). But para buffs definitely DO NOT compete with anything at all.

It would be ridiculous for someone to say SoH competes with Orders or GDW, since people would just ask: "why are you not bringing all of em already? " The same thing can be said about para stuff. It matters because you have a limited number of slots in your party, and if paragon buffs are weaker than anyone else then you will take a different character instead of the paragon. Yes, the paragon buffs do stack nicely with Splinter Weapon, etc. but is it enough to earn the paragon a slot when I could add a minion bomber, a panic mesmer, a MoP/barbs necro, etc? Paragon skills are currently too weak to earn a place on any team except for PvE skill abuse (SY/TNTF) and except for those who love paragons (like me) who will take paragon heroes despite their weaknesses.

Quote:
Now, why are the Paragon buffs "weaker"? Simply because they are chugging spears at the same time. +1 platform to be buffed. You can say that a necro can also chug spears, but we both know that the Paragon will chug many, many more spears while having higher base dmg, which makes them a more "proper" platform. This is bad logic. SoS rits can throw Splinter Weapon around and do great damage with spirits at the same time. Smite monks can put Strength of Honor on everyone and deliver good damage from RoJ and other skills at the same time. Necromancers can support with Mark of Pain, Barbs, etc. and deliver good damage with Spiteful Spirit, Feast of Corruption, etc. So clearly the other professions do not have any requirement that they do minimal damage to make up for their strong support abilities. Why should the paragon be any different? The bottom line is that paragon skills are weaker than the competition.

Quote:
As things are now, the only reason people prefer melees for DPS is SoH. There is no strong reason to buff Para buffs. What the Para does need however, is a Motivation rework. On AoE: if you're not balling it's not very significant (it depends on the area ofc). If you're balling, you're better off running some gimmicky 100b + MoP anyways. Motivation does need a rework, at least we agree on something.

People prefer melee because it has strong multi-attack capability, which translates to much more damage in less time. SoH only adds to this since the bonus damage applies to each and every attack.

Lastly I will make the argument that AoE damage is always important, it isn't hard to get 2-3 foes together in PvE, even with no special effort made to ball things up. Casters will naturally bunch up together and melee will bunch up as well (usually right in your face, lol).

LifeInfusion

LifeInfusion

Grotto Attendant

Join Date: May 2005

in the midline

E/Mo

I still think you overrate dual attacks. See what I wrote above.

Quote:
multi-hit means you do double of autoattack damage without critical that's really rather low: at most 19 or so on 100 armor assuming 15>50 customized and 26 on 80 armor caster mobs. Double strikes with critical from sins do an extra 33 on 60 armor or 17 on 100 compared to one strike. Hardly anything to write home about in Hard mode. Expert's Dex/Rapid Fire are overrated. The former is elite and not maintainable unless you're pumping serious expertise (unlike WoTA) and the latter prevents you from using Glass Arrows/Read the Wind/Expert Focus (+10ish to 20ish armor ignoring). Aggressive Refrain is better/Soldier's fury gives added adrenaline for cheap adrenal attacks.

Motivation needs a rework, in fact I posted suggestions this or last week on the official wiki. But spear damage cannot be suddenly pumped to have AoE and splash of 6 or 8 leadership with 11+ command/11+ motivation. That's broken, since every other class is pushing major points (6+ attributes) in energy management (Soul reap, inspiration) or stuff like strength, expertise, or critical strikes. If some skill like Holy Spear was made to hit 1 extra target depending on every 2 ranks of leadership maybe.

Have you tried wearying spear with soldier's fury + conjure? That'd probably push numbers if you have recovery on a N/Rt and a -20% weakness shield or something.

And Mesmers were overbuffed tbh. 100+ armor ignoring damage on 5-10 cooldown (6 every 10 if you run keystone sig) is pretty lame when 100+ AOE elemental stuff is on 9+ cooldown.

Haggis of Doom

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: May 2009

TGB

W/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Khomet Si Netjer View Post

Khomet Si Netjer

Khomet Si Netjer

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Apr 2007

The Angelic Guard

P/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Haggis of Doom View Post
This is what I would run if I wanted a buffed physicals team:

http://img846.imageshack.us/img846/1...heroteam2c.jpg

3 physicals is about the minimum to justify Orders, and melee AI is horrible. You can ofc sub Vicious Attack for Volley here (I still haven't tested bow para heroes).

This is what I would run on a generic caster, if I was too lazy to figure out something to synergize better with my own build:

http://img98.imageshack.us/img98/1221/caster1.jpg

Paras earned their place in both
how is spirit spam and minion bombing a "physical based team"?

secondly, if you have melee at all you would probably be better off with more melee and an SoH monk... more damage and more condition/hex removal too. your warrior has both whirlwind attack and cyclone axe so he can deliver big damage with SoH and Splinter. The paragons can't deliver on the same level, at least not with spears.

re: bow paragons, I have tested them quite a bit and they work great. It's a bit tragic that paragons are more effective using another profession's weapon (and one that attacks more slowly at that). but using the bow allows the paragon to get multiple attacks with volley or barrage, which means multiplying base damage, multiplying buff damage, and multiplying adrenaline gain. win/win/win, even if the attack speed is slightly slower, the number of targets hit is usually much greater. (4-13 targets hit in 6 seconds, vs. a constant 5 hits with spear)

http:://wiki.guildwars.com/wiki/User:Khomet/Kway

Quote:
Originally Posted by LifeInfusion View Post I still think you overrate dual attacks. See what I wrote above.
I guess I am not seeing the text you referred to.
re: dual attacks the key issue is not how much weapon damage the dual attack delivers but how much buff damage it delivers. In other words Dual Shot may do 25% less base damage per arrow but that is not really important if I have +50 damage and Splinter Weapon applying to each arrow on top of the base damage. Stated in a different way, dual attacks have the effect of doubling your damage output, and multi-attack skills like Whirlwind and Barrage can do even more. With 33% IAS you can attack ~50% faster than normal but with dual attacks you can attack 100% faster than normal. Assassins are probably in the best position to take advantage of this because of the recharge on Death Blossom, but Warriors (or /W) aren't far behind because Whirlwind can charge very quickly if it is hitting multiple targets. Dervishes get to hit multiple targets without any skills at all so they can deliver huge damage. Ranger does well too because Volley and Barrage can hit so many and because they are spammable.

Quote:
Expert's Dex/Rapid Fire are overrated. The former is elite and not maintainable unless you're pumping serious expertise (unlike WoTA) and the latter prevents you from using Glass Arrows/Read the Wind/Expert Focus (+10ish to 20ish armor ignoring). Aggressive Refrain is better/Soldier's fury gives added adrenaline for cheap adrenal attacks. I still think you are looking at this the wrong way... Barrage rangers have never needed IAS, delivering 7 hits in 2 seconds is quite enough. Look at the Manlyway build (http://pvx.wikia.com/wiki/Build:Team_-_FoW_Manly_Spike) and notice that neither the Warrior nor the Dervish variant have IAS. They don't need it because they are using AoE damage + multi-attack skills. Attacking all adjacent is much better than any IAS can deliver unless you are only hitting one foe. It doesn't hurt to have both, but if you have to choose one then multi-attack capability wins. (from PvE point of view) note: the manlyway team is probably getting free IAS from Celerity anyway, but most of their damage is coming from AoE and muti-attack skills, not from any IAS effect.

Quote:
Motivation needs a rework, in fact I posted suggestions this or last week on the official wiki. But spear damage cannot be suddenly pumped to have AoE and splash of 6 or 8 leadership with 11+ command/11+ motivation. That's broken, since every other class is pushing major points (6+ attributes) in energy management (Soul reap, inspiration) or stuff like strength, expertise, or critical strikes. If some skill like Holy Spear was made to hit 1 extra target depending on every 2 ranks of leadership maybe. I don't understand what you are saying here. Paragon almost always has high leadership just to be functional, and unlike most other professions he is almost always in a 3-way attribute split (spear + leadership + command or motivation). All current spear skills other than Spear Swipe scale with Spear Mastery so I don't get your meaning.

Quote:
Have you tried wearying spear with soldier's fury + conjure? That'd probably push numbers if you have recovery on a N/Rt and a -20% weakness shield or something. Haven't tried this yet but I will get back to you. My instinct is that DPS will suffer because of weakness but the weakness will get less and less important as the number of attack buffs (EBSOH, Orders, Splinter/GDW, etc) increase. With base damage 14-27 you can expect an average of 21 damage, reduced to 1/3 of that because of weakness, so 7 damage on average. But Wearying spear adds +34 damage @ 12 spear instead of the typical +17, so it will actually do more than the other spear attacks, even with weakness applied. O_o (21+17=38, 7+34=41) The weakness would also reduce weapon damage and crit chances and bonus damage slightly so this is not completely accurate.

Quote:
And Mesmers were overbuffed tbh. 100+ armor ignoring damage on 5-10 cooldown (6 every 10 if you run keystone sig) is pretty lame when 100+ AOE elemental stuff is on 9+ cooldown. Maybe. But are mesmers too strong, or are elementalists too weak? Many (most?) of the ele skills have been around since Prophecies and their cost, recharge, etc. are based on "balance" from that time period... the ranger's traps and spirits also suffer from age, they were designed a long time ago and they have not been modified to keep up with the times. 30s-45s recharge on stances? really?
To be honest I'm not familiar with the terminology here. While I kind of suspect physical teams are allowed general purpose midlines, I'll just give you this one since I don't know better

If the player was a ranger or para, would you give me the cookie and say the para heroes have earned their place in the team? (I take it as a good sign that you haven't commented on the caster team, hehe)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Khomet Si Netjer View Post
if you have melee at all you would probably be better off with more melee and an SoH monk... more damage and more condition/hex removal too. Monk heroes are pretty crappy at keeping up 3+ copies of SoH while having a worthwhile bar at the same time, so here's what I propose (if we are to disregard the crappy melee AI ofc):

http://img163.imageshack.us/img163/5582/dervphysway.jpg

The derv hero builds are hastily thrown together, just to give an idea of what they're supposed to do. Erfshakurr wars, Locust's Fury sins would make good choices too.

The SoS/resto is sadly still there, as we can all agree it's just that good. However, if you wish it gone, some MoP could be put in its place. I do feel that, while MoP synergizes greatly with VoS, in non-ball situations its use is erratic at best, even when micro'ed. Splinter Weapon can ofc be replaced by GDW on the player's bar.

Khomet Si Netjer

Khomet Si Netjer

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Apr 2007

The Angelic Guard

P/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Haggis of Doom View Post
http://img163.imageshack.us/img163/5582/dervphysway.jpg

The derv hero builds are hastily thrown together, just to give an idea of what they're supposed to do. Erfshakurr wars, Locust's Fury sins would make good choices too.

The SoS/resto is sadly still there, as we can all agree it's just that good. However, if you wish it gone, some MoP could be put in its place. I do feel that, while MoP synergizes greatly with VoS, in non-ball situations its use is erratic at best, even when micro'ed. Splinter Weapon can ofc be replaced by GDW on the player's bar.
That looks very good, and 5 physical attackers definitely qualifies as a physical-based team. :-)

I realize that it may come across like I am bashing paragons. I am not. I love paragons, my main is a paragon, he is GWAMM and 50/50 in the hall of monuments. So I have spent quite a lot of time playing paragon, and my opinions are based on a lot of experience. What I want is for paragons to be able to do well at any of their roles, which to my understanding is the following:

Offense: Spear mastery for direct damage and physical attack buffing for indirect damage. Spear mastery is okay in PvP but weak in PvE because the paragon has no multi-attack capability or self buffing and all of their IAS skills give them caster level armor. Physical attack buffing is much weaker than the other professions, see below for proof. Grade: C

Defense: This includes skills like Stand Your Ground, They're On Fire, Angelic Bond, Defensive Anthem, etc. Defensive skills for paragons are generally good though some are fairly useless (Bladeturn Refrain, Angelic Protection, Brace Yourself) and some have been nerfed into uselessness. The PvE skills TNTF and SY outshine anything in this category but that's to be expected. Grade: B

Support: Everything in Motivation plus miscellaneous skills like Hexbreaker Aria and Incoming/Fallback. These have generally been nerfed into uselessness. Aside from Incoming/Fallback the finales are the only decent skills here because they become stronger with shout frequency, so teams with multiple paragons get the most benefit. Other than these the skills are too weak and their recharge is much too long. Grade: F


re: attack buffing, consider the math.
Anthem of Envy @ 15 gives +25 damage to one attack. Can be used every 8 seconds (roughly) with normal adrenaline gain under IAS... 6s to gain adrenaline, 1s to activate, 3/4s aftercast. Also, I'm being very generous with the paragon, as having 15 command is highly unlikely... unlike other professions the paragon will usually be in a 3 way attribute split. Perhaps 11/10/10 plus runes.
Order of Pain @ 15 gives +16 damage to *every* attack. In six seconds this could be at least 16x6 = 96 damage per character that benefits from it. This is already 4x better than Anthem of Envy, and the advantage is even greater with multi-attack skills like Barrage and Whirlwind attack as well as most any assassin or dervish build.
Strength of Honor @ 15 gives +25 damage to *every* attack. In 6 seconds this is already 150 bonus damage, which is 6x better than Anthem of Envy. SoH damage also multiplies when you have multi-attack skills, dual attacks, scythes, etc.

But wait! What about Anthem of Flame? It gives 3s burning and can be used every 10 seconds, so this translates to +42 damage (14x3) for each affected character. This is probably better than Anthem of Envy, but some foes are not affected by burning and the burning has no effect if the target is already burning. Also, this can only be used every 10 seconds, and Orders/SoH can exceed 42 damage in 2-3 hits. Over the entire 10 seconds they will provide several times more damage than Anthem of Flame.
But wait! What about Go For The Eyes! This skill is great and it really has no equivalent in other professions. GFTE has no activation time so it doesn't hurt the paragon's DPS, instead it *increases* DPS, and it doubles as energy management. win/win/win. I consider GFTE the best of the attack buffs but it's still not enough to compete with Orders/SoH.

I'm not going to get into Splinter Weapon, Mark of Pain, etc. because their damage depends on number of adjacent targets... but as you can see from the math above, the physical attack buffs from the other professions are several times stronger than what the paragon can provide so it is no wonder that these other professions are preferred over the paragon in this role.

LifeInfusion

LifeInfusion

Grotto Attendant

Join Date: May 2005

in the midline

E/Mo

How do you account for the fact that Anthems are unstrippable, trigger finales/refrains, and can't be shattered/interrupted by spell interrupts other than power block/drain/leech/spike?

Orders also require an investment in some sort of HP return, since 17% HP every 6 seconds is steep. You can't do anything else when pumping orders for the most part because you use it on recharge if you want it to be max damage. Command is also a better attribute than Blood, at least for PVE. Blood has a bunch of vampiric stuff and blood ritual/blood is power/dark fury/blood bond/Spoil Victor.

SoH on the other hand requires energy management if you are to put it on 2-3 melee. N/Mo, Mo/ blessed signet, etc. Smiting is also pretty lame for the most part. You have RoJ, reversal of damage, smite hex, smite condition, castigation signet for energy.

Anthem of envy also triggers on spirits; it's not something you have to build around, you just slap it on unlike Orders/SoH. It's rather easy to push +20 damage on Anthem of Envy.

You can argue for anthems not to have aftercast, I posted a suggestion on GW wiki for that. However, saying that the (offensive) anthems are completely useless is pushing it.

Kaida the Heartless

Kaida the Heartless

Desert Nomad

Join Date: May 2006

N/

Sigh. Alright, here goes:

Paragon's are more consistent but less potent. They will put out a more consistent amount of damage that is harder to disrupt (like any ranged vs melee instance). Furthermore, melee classes are (and have always been) the damage kings in this game. Why is it fair to expect a Paragon to output the same DPS as a warrior without any of the drawback? Is it really balanced to give a Paragon a ranged powernuke that they can pop off immediately every time a group is balled, where a Warrior or Dervish has to position themselves?

Paragon's sacrificed their potential for massive AoE damage in favor of Party Buffs. It would be like making a thread in the Warrior section complaining that the only party protection they offer is Save Yourselves and Protectors Stance with no ability to increase team damage. Each class performs a slightly different role.

With that said, I do think Paragons may need a tiny nuke here and there, as well as instant "yell" time on many more of their skills, but I feel, for the most part, that they are performing their role very well.

pingu666

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Jul 2006

guildhall

[DETH]

with orders you do need to build a team around it, cant use avatars and gain a advantage :/ paragons buffs do pretty much work for whatever damage mod, damage type altering skill being used by your group. plus enchants can be a good or bad thing.

i suspect the much desired barrage type elite for spears isnt in there because of adrenaline gain, which is a shame. would make a great pve skill

Khomet Si Netjer

Khomet Si Netjer

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Apr 2007

The Angelic Guard

P/

Quote:
Originally Posted by LifeInfusion View Post
How do you account for the fact that Anthems are unstrippable, trigger finales/refrains, and can't be shattered/interrupted by spell interrupts other than power block/drain/leech/spike?
Ummm... you are seriously considering interrupts and enchantment stripping as a defense against something that is re-applied party wide every 6 seconds? I'm not trying to be rude but this is completely futile.

Shouts, Anthems, Weapon Spells, Orders, and the new Flash Enchantments fall into a new category of skills that are mostly unstrippable. In the case of Orders or Flash Enchantments you can strip them but since they are reapplied almost instantly it is pointless. Enchant stripping is only useful for long-recharge enchantments. Granted, Strength of Honor is strippable, and its recharge time and energy cost are long enough that stripping is an inconvenience... but people still take it because it is much stronger than anything the paragon can offer.

Quote:
Originally Posted by LifeInfusion View Post Orders also require an investment in some sort of HP return, since 17% HP every 6 seconds is steep. You can't do anything else when pumping orders for the most part because you use it on recharge if you want it to be max damage. Command is also a better attribute than Blood, at least for PVE. Blood has a bunch of vampiric stuff and blood ritual/blood is power/dark fury/blood bond/Spoil Victor.
...

Blood has health gain built into the same attribute!
Besides that, having a monk throw WoH on you every 15 seconds is not any great burden.

Quote:
Originally Posted by LifeInfusion View Post
SoH on the other hand requires energy management if you are to put it on 2-3 melee. N/Mo, Mo/ blessed signet, etc. Smiting is also pretty lame for the most part. You have RoJ, reversal of damage, smite hex, smite condition, castigation signet for energy.
How fortunate that monks maintaining enchantments can have infinite energy with Blessed Signet!

Quote:
Originally Posted by LifeInfusion View Post Anthem of envy also triggers on spirits; it's not something you have to build around, you just slap it on unlike Orders/SoH. It's rather easy to push +20 damage on Anthem of Envy.

You can argue for anthems not to have aftercast, I posted a suggestion on GW wiki for that. However, saying that the (offensive) anthems are completely useless is pushing it. There is no point in bringing a paragon to buff physical damage when Orders and SoH are 4-6 times stronger or even more. The only way this works out is if you have a team of paragons all buffing each other, then it is worthwhile.
Otherwise... necromancer and ritualist and monk win hands down.


Quote: Originally Posted by Kaida The Heartless Sigh. Alright, here goes:

Paragon's are more consistent but less potent. They will put out a more consistent amount of damage that is harder to disrupt (like any ranged vs melee instance). Furthermore, melee classes are (and have always been) the damage kings in this game. Why is it fair to expect a Paragon to output the same DPS as a warrior without any of the drawback? Is it really balanced to give a Paragon a ranged powernuke that they can pop off immediately every time a group is balled, where a Warrior or Dervish has to position themselves? I'm not talking about competing with warrior/dervish/assassin DPS, this is impossible for reasons I have already mentioned, namely mass AoE, strength, and crit strikes. No one reads anymore...

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kaida The Heartless
Paragon's sacrificed their potential for massive AoE damage in favor of Party Buffs. It would be like making a thread in the Warrior section complaining that the only party protection they offer is Save Yourselves and Protectors Stance with no ability to increase team damage. Each class performs a slightly different role. The paragon doesn't have any party buffs worth bringing, that is the whole point. (!!) The damage-boosting skills from the necromancer, ritualist, and monk are multiple times stronger than what the paragon brings to the table.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kaida The Heartless
With that said, I do think Paragons may need a tiny nuke here and there, as well as instant "yell" time on many more of their skills, but I feel, for the most part, that they are performing their role very well. Their only role in the meta is PVE skill abuse. None of the paragon skills see use in common team builds other than Focused Anger whose only purpose is to boost adrenaline flow to pump out Save Yourselves more quickly. You think this is the proper role for a paragon?

Quote:
Originally Posted by pingu666
with orders you do need to build a team around it, cant use avatars and gain a advantage :/ paragons buffs do pretty much work for whatever damage mod, damage type altering skill being used by your group. plus enchants can be a good or bad thing. Orders works with any physical damage, which is to say any weapon. If you are dealing elemental damage that is your own problem... it is completely under your control. Strength of Honor works with any melee weapon regardless of damage type, so it would work with any of the Avatars.
You should be able to work either of these into a physical team very easily.

Quote:
Originally Posted by pingu666
i suspect the much desired barrage type elite for spears isnt in there because of adrenaline gain, which is a shame. would make a great pve skill You're right, it works very well. My paragon team "Kway" has paragons with shortbows; they use Volley to deal more damage and gain more adrenaline than any spear wielding paragon.

juventas

Pre-Searing Cadet

Join Date: Feb 2011

Poor Khomet, all alone. But I agree with you. Paragons are woefully underpowered.

Lanier

Lanier

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Jan 2010

[Pink]

P/

Overall, I agree that paragons are underpowered. I am fine with the spear damage, as I am happy with the amount of damage I can pump out with a spear. What I want is to be able to actually support the party with skills besides SY and Tntf. For a support profession, one would think there would be some useful support skills...

iToasterHD

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Dec 2007

We Need Therapy [NOW]

Rt/

The real question is, how likely do you think they will do anything for the Paragon? I know people like to throw around that statement that there will be no more big updates regarding skill changes. Think that rules out any updates for the Paragon?

Sabres Phoenix

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: Feb 2011

Reign Of Judgement

P/

We can all hope, wait, pray and see what they come with. The inequities in the current skill "balance" are clear to most people. Surely A-net will try to rectify this - for not just Para but the other classes that are lacking too - before the beta for gw2 comes out.

Our Virus

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Jan 2011

The Capital [Para]

P/

I understand you are not relying on conditions for dmg, but for paragon hero builds or many pvp builds that is how alot of dos can be given. Apply poison along with anthem of flame plus any spear atk can give great dps to one target and also spread the poison for the foes you will kill next. Serpents Quickness is a great way to get those offensive shouts and chants to recharge at a more reasonable time, while not affecting your ims/ias because those ate most likely echos. If you see this as hard energy then try throwing TPiY or Scavengers Focus on there, may be a waste of an elite but dps is the issue not how you achieve it. Hope this helps.

Apache215

Apache215

Academy Page

Join Date: Feb 2011

A/E

Although, I'm not sure what my DPS is, I've used a P/R build that works quite well. Strike as One combined with blazing spear, SoL, and other powerful spear skills dominates with the amount of degen and slow movement.