Does it exist?

Oofus

Oofus

Forge Runner

Join Date: Feb 2006

I could tell you, but then I'd have to kill you.

Cold Hard [CASH]

Ooo it's all wet and shiny! I wanna touch it.

take_me

take_me

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Mar 2006

Europe

Country Roads [HOME]

If have a question about the rarity of gold Wooden Bucklers with req. Strength.
It obviously exists, but after searching for some time, I've never seen another one with req Strength in gold.

Even the wiki states, that req Strength can only be found at collectors.

Pleikki

Pleikki

WTB q8 15^50 Weapons!

Join Date: Nov 2006

???oo ???ugs ???lan [?????????]

Atleast -andy- Has gold dual mod i can name from someone whos active, there been a few over the years but only handful and most crap

They Drop in starter island Cantha HM especially , but are really rare

take_me

take_me

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Mar 2006

Europe

Country Roads [HOME]

Ah okay, so that's where I have mine from (a crappy single mod one). Thanks for the clarification.

dreaming in digital

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Sep 2015

by a locked chest

GW1 let science dissolve [ACID] GW2 why cant I use this trading[POST]

Me/W

OS jeweled chakram(stone) with domination as the req.

Wiki seems to imply this can exist, but I cant remember ever seeing one.


EDIT: I'm looking for jeweled chakram with the stone skin. Sorry didn't notice I put an extra character in the link.

http://wiki.guildwars.com/wiki/Jeweled_Chakram_(stone)

Pleikki

Pleikki

WTB q8 15^50 Weapons!

Join Date: Nov 2006

???oo ???ugs ???lan [?????????]

Yes there are few even perfect moddeds

They can be farmed in HM Ascalon from gargoyles and rarely from charr mesmers

Same goes for OS wooden chakrams

oh yea right im not sure if understood u right, but if u mean "stone chakram" in OS not jeweled with stone skin?

IAL

IAL

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Jun 2006

W/Mo

A +11 Q6 Div inscr offhand exists (standard skin) - not sure about rarity but been around for some time (these days I'm not), never seen another one and I got more than a few hours logged. Probably in the hands of a since long gone player formerly in [LC].

It's possibly that it's semi-common (bug or similar and/or I'm wrong) and I'm wasting time for others but for me I asumed it was close to a unique if not fully unique in GW.

dreaming in digital

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Sep 2015

by a locked chest

GW1 let science dissolve [ACID] GW2 why cant I use this trading[POST]

Me/W

Quote:
Originally Posted by IAL View Post
A +11 Q6 Div inscr offhand exists (standard skin) - not sure about rarity but been around for some time (these days I'm not), never seen another one and I got more than a few hours logged. Probably in the hands of a since long gone player formerly in [LC].

It's possibly that it's semi-common (bug or similar and/or I'm wrong) and I'm wasting time for others but for me I asumed it was close to a unique if not fully unique in GW.


I haven't had a r6/11 divine offhand, but they should drop anywhere with mobs around level 15(that can drop insc stuff of course). They seem to be about the same rarity as gold r7/15 armor shields. I've had this and a few other r6/11 foci in snowman's lair NM.

system.fan

system.fan

Grotto Attendant

Join Date: Aug 2008

"???oo ???ugs ???lan [?????????]" | Retired in "Teh Academy [PhD]"

Mo/A

Quote:
Originally Posted by IAL View Post
A +11 Q6 Div inscr offhand exists (standard skin)
Actually those are pretty common (especially in EotN).
You could try farming the snowman dungeon for example...
had at least 2 or 3 q6/11inscr offhands there, not sure which attributes tho (but since some of the snowman are monks divine is possible too).


/Edit:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pleikki View Post
Maguuma chests (lvl18) aldo drop q6 11e offhands os
true!

Pleikki

Pleikki

WTB q8 15^50 Weapons!

Join Date: Nov 2006

???oo ???ugs ???lan [?????????]

Maguuma chests (lvl18) aldo drop q6 11e offhands os

pawning jock

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Sep 2007

W/E

Soo now that this forum is coming to a close... I have to know, I just must know if anyone ever managed to pick up a worthy ball hammer!

Pleikki

Pleikki

WTB q8 15^50 Weapons!

Join Date: Nov 2006

???oo ???ugs ???lan [?????????]

Nope, Ball hammers never dropped gold/Purple

So neither don or kromp has one

system.fan

system.fan

Grotto Attendant

Join Date: Aug 2008

"???oo ???ugs ???lan [?????????]" | Retired in "Teh Academy [PhD]"

Mo/A

Not sure if this was already answered somewhere else (in this thread definitely not so far)...

But what about Noninscr Max Damage Tyrian Sickle (Victo's Skin)?

I think it was possible to get those in bugged Mausoleum quest 2010... but don't think I've seen one so far if I remember right. (only saw 2 tribal axes from mausoleum)
Anyone ever seen any other?

Also you think there would still be interest in close to max Sickles? like 6-25/26/27 blues?

Think I haven't seen anyone talk about / buy / sell those in years^^

Pleikki

Pleikki

WTB q8 15^50 Weapons!

Join Date: Nov 2006

???oo ???ugs ???lan [?????????]

I dont think max ones excist.. for q8 6-27 ordo or similar id see some intrest tho

trademeimfamous

trademeimfamous

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Nov 2014

Blashyrkh

IGN: Erd Beer Mund

R/

while tyrian sickle seems to be a little rarer than tribal axe to me and i do not know of an uninsc max dmg one existing, i do not see why they should not be possible to drop.
just like the other white/blue only skins theyre just very rare with good stats but due to hardmode they should definitely be possible.


-------------------------------------------------------


Quote:
Originally Posted by Pleikki View Post
Atleast -andy- Has gold dual mod i can name from someone whos active, there been a few over the years but only handful and most crap

They Drop in starter island Cantha HM especially , but are really rare
oh and since i just found one ima back this up with a screen

so far only found blue ones and i was kinda surprised, too bad it's slightly off of the -2st +30 i would have wanted on it

Pleikki

Pleikki

WTB q8 15^50 Weapons!

Join Date: Nov 2006

???oo ???ugs ???lan [?????????]

Quote:
Originally Posted by trademeimfamous View Post
while tyrian sickle seems to be a little rarer than tribal axe to me and i do not know of an uninsc max dmg one existing, i do not see why they should not be possible to drop.
just like the other white/blue only skins theyre just very rare with good stats but due to hardmode they should definitely be possible.

Well for my knowledge tyrian skins like tribal, sickle and ball hammer never been able drop max dmg white/blue atleast tyria/cantha

Not sure for nf/eotn where they drop insc gold tho

trademeimfamous

trademeimfamous

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Nov 2014

Blashyrkh

IGN: Erd Beer Mund

R/

not sure how much that counts/falls into the same category but i've got a tribal blade max dmg blue and have had white ones too

Pleikki

Pleikki

WTB q8 15^50 Weapons!

Join Date: Nov 2006

???oo ???ugs ???lan [?????????]

Tribal blades allways dropped max dmg yes, seen some max q8s even

Red Fireball

Desert Nomad

Join Date: May 2010

HSBC

W/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pleikki View Post
Well for my knowledge tyrian skins like tribal, sickle and ball hammer never been able drop max dmg white/blue atleast tyria/cantha
am I understanding this wrong...? I got a 6-28 q9 white tribal axe - farmed myself - they defo exist and still drop

Pleikki

Pleikki

WTB q8 15^50 Weapons!

Join Date: Nov 2006

???oo ???ugs ???lan [?????????]

Ahh yea lol i actually just forgot we spoke about that few weeks ago red xD

Oofus

Oofus

Forge Runner

Join Date: Feb 2006

I could tell you, but then I'd have to kill you.

Cold Hard [CASH]

Quote:
Originally Posted by system.fan View Post
But what about Noninscr Max Damage Tyrian Sickle (Victo's Skin)?
Dropped for me

Red Fireball

Desert Nomad

Join Date: May 2010

HSBC

W/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pleikki View Post
Ahh yea lol i actually just forgot we spoke about that few weeks ago red xD
:P all those do drop at gargoyles HM - and at high enough unid value they possibly yield max and even q9 (Ball, 2xTribal [not 100%sure about the sword here], Sickle)
it is like that: skin drops at a mob in certain blue or white (purple or gold) -> it can drop at the entire dmg range in blue and white (purple and gold) that the mobs lvl enables for that rarity at that wep type - which is up to max dmg even for whites/blues at lvl 22 and 23 (gargoyles) e.g.

system.fan

system.fan

Grotto Attendant

Join Date: Aug 2008

"???oo ???ugs ???lan [?????????]" | Retired in "Teh Academy [PhD]"

Mo/A

thanks @ oofus! =)
nice to see that those are able to drop max...

@Red:
So if I got it right - the "best" nonisncr sickle that could drop would be:
- blue
- max damage
- 12%(^50/stance/ench)... or is 13% possible for blue?

right?
I kinda like the skin and would love to get one of those just... well cause I like the skin^^

trademeimfamous

trademeimfamous

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Nov 2014

Blashyrkh

IGN: Erd Beer Mund

R/

Quote:
Originally Posted by system.fan View Post
- 12%(^50/stance/ench)... or is 13% possible for blue?
quite sure 12% is max for blue (which is why ikkis q7 felly is the best possible)




oh, also about a previous topic you're probably already tired of:

2nd one i've found in one day lol

dreaming in digital

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Sep 2015

by a locked chest

GW1 let science dissolve [ACID] GW2 why cant I use this trading[POST]

Me/W

no longer need info

Red Fireball

Desert Nomad

Join Date: May 2010

HSBC

W/

Quote:
Originally Posted by system.fan View Post
@Red:
So if I got it right - the "best" nonisncr sickle that could drop would be:
- blue
- max damage
- 12%(^50/stance/ench)... or is 13% possible for blue?
yes and q9 or q8 for tribal blade respectively. The problem is the chances: at unid values of 55g+ you have best chance they are max dmg (white/blue) (even tho I also found max white axe as low as 53g, hammer at 52g and sword at 51g. But on axe e.g. 55g yields the entire range of a 5-24axe up to a max dmg one, so the chance is still bad. So you´d need to know the chance for those values to drop from the mob (which is low at lvl 23 and 22 gargoyles), the chance for the wep to be max dmg at said values (which is slim even at the ultra rare 57g+ values), then the chance for an item to drop blue (which is like 5%-10% of all items dropping), for any item to drop at all (which is roughly 5%-10% according to my observations at gargoyles - each run I kill ~45 mobs and get 1-10 items, on average ~3), for an item to have q9 at said values (which is pretty good - like 25%), for the skin to be the desired (which is super low at those rare skins) and then for the inherent mod to be 12^50 (which is max for blue and extremely rare). So multiply all these and get the ever so slim chance for the item. My guesses would be in super low range: in 3 years of intense gargoyle farming I had 3 max tribal axes drop there, 1 was q9 and none was blue, so better start farming now in order to get that drop before gw shuts down in 10years or w/e^^

GhostKairi

GhostKairi

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Mar 2008

WTB Q8 Fire/ES Staffs And OS Crystallines!

Teh Academy [PhD] - Tomb of the collectors

E/

Quote:
Originally Posted by system.fan View Post
thanks @ oofus! =)
nice to see that those are able to drop max...

@Red:
So if I got it right - the "best" nonisncr sickle that could drop would be:
- blue
- max damage
- 12%(^50/stance/ench)... or is 13% possible for blue?

right?
I kinda like the skin and would love to get one of those just... well cause I like the skin^^
Try farming the Dryders at the entrance to Iron Horse Mines if you leave from Ice Tooth Cave. Theres like 3 bosses there that are easy to kill so its good for elite tomes, and I have typically found that they drop Sickles quite frequently in HM.

WowThatsMe

WowThatsMe

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Sep 2009

Australia

D/A

Wasn't sure where else to ask, and this may also be a stupid question. But can melee weapons drop with inherent HSR 10% (Let The Memory Live Again)?

MaxBorken

MaxBorken

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Jul 2009

London UK

Teh Academy [PhD]. Officer. Gentleman

W/N

Quote:
Originally Posted by WowThatsMe View Post
Wasn't sure where else to ask, and this may also be a stupid question. But can melee weapons drop with inherent HSR 10% (Let The Memory Live Again)?

Nope.

Thats just for spellcaster sticks. And that inscription can't be applied to melee weapons either.

Max

WowThatsMe

WowThatsMe

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Sep 2009

Australia

D/A

Quote:
Originally Posted by MaxBorken View Post
Nope.

Thats just for spellcaster sticks. And that inscription can't be applied to melee weapons either.

Max
It can be applied to insc melee weapons. I have one in my inventory right now. But it doesn't drop inherent?

Pleikki

Pleikki

WTB q8 15^50 Weapons!

Join Date: Nov 2006

???oo ???ugs ???lan [?????????]

No it doesnt drop, but yes u can add it on insc weapons

MaxBorken

MaxBorken

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Jul 2009

London UK

Teh Academy [PhD]. Officer. Gentleman

W/N

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pleikki View Post
No it doesnt drop, but yes u can add it on insc weapons
Heh. I never tied it, because.... Well why would you? If you're a melee class casting spells, grab a staff. Or a spellcaster class instead

Pleikki

Pleikki

WTB q8 15^50 Weapons!

Join Date: Nov 2006

???oo ???ugs ???lan [?????????]

Ive seen many PvPrs use 10hct+20ench from sword example with shield that they need for ar since many find 10hct more useful then +5e, and cant get 20% ench from 1 hand wand if thats neccesery

Zephyr of Light

Zephyr of Light

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Sep 2013

In Z-Way We Trust.

[PhD]-[?????????]-[pupu]

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pleikki View Post
Ive seen many PvPrs use 10hct+20ench from sword example with shield that they need for ar since many find 10hct more useful then +5e, and cant get 20% ench from 1 hand wand if thats neccesery
agreed, especially Condition Necromancers that utilize the 10hct / HSR in combination with +33% Poison / Bleeding.

Or but also rarely seen with +33% Crippling /w the spell "Return".

Oofus

Oofus

Forge Runner

Join Date: Feb 2006

I could tell you, but then I'd have to kill you.

Cold Hard [CASH]

Quote:
Originally Posted by Oofus View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by system.fan View Post
But what about Noninscr Max Damage Tyrian Sickle (Victo's Skin)?
Dropped for me
So I’d actually like to revisit this, since it seems to have flown under the radar for the most part here, and because I think it warrants further discussion. We all know that pre-HM there were NO max damage Tyrian Sickles, that’s not in dispute (I hope). When HM came out speculation ran rampant about the possibility of MAX damage(6-28) ones dropping, Do they? Could they? Should they? But nobody, to my knowledge, has EVER posted a picture of one, not even of one they claim to have personally seen, not even a fake. In all of Guru, Wartower, or anywhere else has there been another posted. Am I wrong? I’m not fishing for offers or trying to hype my little white axe(not that I would mind having gotten a real drop for the first time in ever), just.... it’s a max Sickle folks! No further discussion on that?
I know I've got a question; Are there others or am I the proud pappy of something unique?

When it fell for me I was unsure, due to long absence from the game, if these were regular drops now, but when an old-timer like me sees a Sickle in Tyria… he looks twice, at least out of habit. That was about a month ago, and I hadn’t gotten around to asking about it. Given that even System, who asked about them, and subsequent posters each with exceptional game-item knowledge, still questioning its existence, then the dozen or so requests to sell I’ve gotten so far, the brief research I ran through Guru threads, and a few inquiries to those in-the-know, AND the unexpected source of the drop, I’m of the mind that this is in fact the first documented sighting of a Sasquatch.
Reliable pic or it didn’t happen, sorry. (maybe I don’t float as a reliable source either, in which case I’m more then ok with any requests for ig verification)

If anyone’s interested in where it came from, I’ll hold off on revealing that. I’ll let you guess if you want and I will acknowledge a correct guess(be specific). I will tell you it did not come from any of the traditional sources of Sickles, it’s not any kind of bugged Mausoleum thing, and it is from the continent of Tyria.



Warehouse

Warehouse

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Jan 2014

Hiding Under Your Bed

Teh Academy [PhD]

A/

i suppose my guess will be the doppleganger

trademeimfamous

trademeimfamous

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Nov 2014

Blashyrkh

IGN: Erd Beer Mund

R/

about the tyrian sickles, they do drop in chos estate mission hm (alongside canthan sickles lol).
im relatively sure ive gotten some close to max dmg ones in secret lair of snowmen (hm) too.

GhostKairi

GhostKairi

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Mar 2008

WTB Q8 Fire/ES Staffs And OS Crystallines!

Teh Academy [PhD] - Tomb of the collectors

E/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Oofus View Post
So I’d actually like to revisit this, since it seems to have flown under the radar for the most part here, and because I think it warrants further discussion. We all know that pre-HM there were NO max damage Tyrian Sickles, that’s not in dispute (I hope). When HM came out speculation ran rampant about the possibility of MAX damage(6-28) ones dropping, Do they? Could they? Should they? But nobody, to my knowledge, has EVER posted a picture of one, not even of one they claim to have personally seen, not even a fake. In all of Guru, Wartower, or anywhere else has there been another posted. Am I wrong? I’m not fishing for offers or trying to hype my little white axe(not that I would mind having gotten a real drop for the first time in ever), just.... it’s a max Sickle folks! No further discussion on that?
I know I've got a question; Are there others or am I the proud pappy of something unique?

When it fell for me I was unsure, due to long absence from the game, if these were regular drops now, but when an old-timer like me sees a Sickle in Tyria… he looks twice, at least out of habit. That was about a month ago, and I hadn’t gotten around to asking about it. Given that even System, who asked about them, and subsequent posters each with exceptional game-item knowledge, still questioning its existence, then the dozen or so requests to sell I’ve gotten so far, the brief research I ran through Guru threads, and a few inquiries to those in-the-know, AND the unexpected source of the drop, I’m of the mind that this is in fact the first documented sighting of a Sasquatch.
Reliable pic or it didn’t happen, sorry. (maybe I don’t float as a reliable source either, in which case I’m more then ok with any requests for ig verification)

If anyone’s interested in where it came from, I’ll hold off on revealing that. I’ll let you guess if you want and I will acknowledge a correct guess(be specific). I will tell you it did not come from any of the traditional sources of Sickles, it’s not any kind of bugged Mausoleum thing, and it is from the continent of Tyria.



The farm I posted drops them frequently, however I believe I am one of very few to ever consider farming those mobs xD I had frequent max sickles in HM but since they where all white I just merched them. I am surprised you had such offers to sell on a white one!

The things I want to discover and understand are things like the gold pre Mausoleum Tribal Axe that Chop Chop The Panda used to own. Like where the hell did something like that drop? There must be some source for these weapons that we all claim is impossible to drop max gold?

Im going to do some investigating into farms like the one I posted on more rigorous terms and try to find something special xD

dreaming in digital

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Sep 2015

by a locked chest

GW1 let science dissolve [ACID] GW2 why cant I use this trading[POST]

Me/W

...so happened to find this. Any better r8 gold tribals out there?

edit: I guess this is the only known r8 then. If this is nothing unique please let me know. There is pretty much no data on old guru threads I could find.

T1Cybernetic

T1Cybernetic

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Sep 2005

Wakefield, West Yorkshire, Uk, Nr Earth

Alternate Evil Gamers [aeg]

N/

Quote:
Originally Posted by dreaming in digital View Post
...

Perfection