FoWsc and VoS
voltman135
The new update has been out for a few days now. Lots of people are saying how great dervishes work in FoW as a replacement for the 100b warriors.
OK, lets be honest, Does VoS really out perform 100b? or is it just some passing fad. I would like to here from someone whos has run both builds, not run WITH someone with each build but actually run both builds themselves and can attest to how they compare.
If played correctly dual 100b warriors in FoW works pretty much flawlessly. Heck, you can really do it with one if you have to, just takes longer. So, I am a little skeptical on they fact that a dervish out performes a warrior.
If it is true then I need to start getting my necro ready to run MoP, cuz I dont have a dervish.
OK, lets be honest, Does VoS really out perform 100b? or is it just some passing fad. I would like to here from someone whos has run both builds, not run WITH someone with each build but actually run both builds themselves and can attest to how they compare.
If played correctly dual 100b warriors in FoW works pretty much flawlessly. Heck, you can really do it with one if you have to, just takes longer. So, I am a little skeptical on they fact that a dervish out performes a warrior.
If it is true then I need to start getting my necro ready to run MoP, cuz I dont have a dervish.
Midget Minionmaster
I've ran both builds, and i would say that they are tied. I like running Vos better, but either one doesnt matter. I dont see 100b war being run out of Fowsc any time soon.
ErrantVenture
LOD has stopped running two 100b wars as a single dervish can do the job of both. PUGs might handle HB better but for experienced players the dervish is far superior.
Life Bringing
Iron Smerf
Quick pros/cons rundown of the 2.
100b
The good: Cannot get stripped Higher Armor The Bad:Less effective for cleanup Less energy for "prep" skills VOS:
The good:Effective for cleanup (holy dmg) Slightly more damage (sand shards) More energy The bad:Enchants can get stripped Less armor New concept, more messups These things are just general things. I've heard many of these complaints and excuses while pugging with each, and by personal experience. Each have there strengths. I personally find that taking one of each is the most effective way as they can support each others weaknesses.
100b
The good: Cannot get stripped Higher Armor The Bad:Less effective for cleanup Less energy for "prep" skills VOS:
The good:Effective for cleanup (holy dmg) Slightly more damage (sand shards) More energy The bad:Enchants can get stripped Less armor New concept, more messups These things are just general things. I've heard many of these complaints and excuses while pugging with each, and by personal experience. Each have there strengths. I personally find that taking one of each is the most effective way as they can support each others weaknesses.
Life Bringing
Quote:
Originally Posted by Iron Smerf
100b
The good: Cannot get stripped Higher Armor The Bad:Less effective for cleanup Less energy for "prep" skills VOS:
The good:Effective for cleanup (holy dmg) Slightly more damage (sand shards) More energy The bad:Enchants can get stripped Less armor New concept, more messups These things are just general things. I've heard many of these complaints and excuses while pugging with each, and by personal experience. Each have there strengths. I personally find that taking one of each is the most effective way as they can support each others weaknesses. VoS has terrible energy management
tipiak
Life, with puggies you need two 100b
I've run a bit with and without D PUGs, and the D never had the same builds. It was pretty good overall. But when a spike fails, D take more damage and it can be tricky when they spamming like hell with SS/Empathy/100b on their faces.
I've run a bit with and without D PUGs, and the D never had the same builds. It was pretty good overall. But when a spike fails, D take more damage and it can be tricky when they spamming like hell with SS/Empathy/100b on their faces.
Sydis
I've played both, I prefer using the Dervish more. They do a bit more dmg, and there is no lag when you spike like there is with a war.
Like everything Pug at your own risk, but for ally/guild Dervs should probably be preferred
Like everything Pug at your own risk, but for ally/guild Dervs should probably be preferred
Shanks R Us
I think the dervish is better, if you're using the right build. Conviction makes the forest cake, holy dmg makes undead easily, sand shards & ermites makes mobs fall, it's just overall better.
Gondrakif
I have done both and i think VoS is a bit better, that been said the difference is quite small so if i need a spiker i won't say no to a 100b.
@Life Bringing: no energy issues whatsoever
@Life Bringing: no energy issues whatsoever
Kaida the Heartless
As long as you are running a Zealous Scythe you shouldn't have any issues (that the Warrior wouldn't be having anyways). If you are second late on the spike with either, you are going to be pressed for energy.
loshon
100b still seems a bit better for pug/pubs in my opinion, just because of the really low spike time when done correctly.
But, as previously stated, they're just about equal. 1 of either will do fine.
But, as previously stated, they're just about equal. 1 of either will do fine.
Little Wibblets
I'm curious if anyones tested using a Warrior Axe build. The main skills would be Triple Chop, Cyclone Axe, and then Whirlwind Attack. These are three attack all adjacent skills you could chain. After the first two you should have enough adrenaline for Whirlwind.
As others stated earlier the main damage is not the attacks themselves but the attack of attacking all adjacent foes.
I was wonder what others think or is having multiple "attack all adjacent" skills just overkill and not good for clean up.
As others stated earlier the main damage is not the attacks themselves but the attack of attacking all adjacent foes.
I was wonder what others think or is having multiple "attack all adjacent" skills just overkill and not good for clean up.
Life Bringing
VoS and 100b both trigger MoP (1+mobsize) times. Those three skills that you mentioned trigger it a total of 3 times.
Little Wibblets
1+MOB Size times?
MOP is only on the one target, correct? Doesn't 1+Mob size mean that MOP would have to be on all the targets in the group?
MOP is only on the one target, correct? Doesn't 1+Mob size mean that MOP would have to be on all the targets in the group?
Life Bringing
No...100b and VoS both deal their physical damage per foe hit. If you hit 2 foes, the aoe damage from those skills triggers twice. If you hit 10 foes, the aoe triggers 10 times and so on. With triple chop, there is no additional damage packets, so the MoP target is only hit by physical damage once.
Kunder
How is Sand Shards not useful for smaller mobs? Its still 150 AoE, which turns into 300 AoE if you are using it right. Thats 300 AoE whenever mob size is less then that required for MoP to insta-kill things but still greater then 3 or 4.
Quote:
Quote:
jon comgree
VoS dervs can do the spike a bit slower but much better bc it packs in a bit more dmg and doesnt need MoP at all(only if u got 2 VoS from my experience). T3way uses 3 terras no MoP and 2 VoS dervs. And SandShards is my fav. spiking skill
[Nika]
Quote:
Originally Posted by jon comgree
VoS dervs can do the spike a bit slower but much better bc it packs in a bit more dmg and doesnt need MoP at all(only if u got 2 VoS from my experience). T3way uses 3 terras no MoP and 2 VoS dervs. And SandShards is my fav. spiking skill
You dont even need a 2nd dervish if you have a good spiker which has perfect equipment he can solospike with only ebsoh.
jon comgree
so ur saying 1 derv is as good as 200b w/ a MoP?
[Nika]
Yes i am saying; cuz a derv can use 2x Sandshards in 1 Spike if he got 2 Attackskills. That with Ebsoh makes crazy dmg.
Well the "only ebsoh + dervish"-case only exists on the big spikes at toc and shadows.
But if you run a A/Rt mt with splinter weapon or a A/R with eoe a derv can solospike..
Well the "only ebsoh + dervish"-case only exists on the big spikes at toc and shadows.
But if you run a A/Rt mt with splinter weapon or a A/R with eoe a derv can solospike..