Radiant vs. Survivor

2 pages Page 2
Don Zardeone
Don Zardeone
Wilds Pathfinder
#21
Paradon with DP and no extra energy can't cast agressive refrain until DP is lost. I may throw an attunement rune on my pees, or stop dying.
bhavv
bhavv
Furnace Stoker
#22
I have radiants and 112 energy on my elly

For heroes though, I'll take armor boosts first, and survivor insignias second.
Kaida the Heartless
Kaida the Heartless
Desert Nomad
#25
Didn't read much of the rest of the thread, but your Runes and Insignias should be balanced between +Health (usually via Runes) and +Armor (usually via Insignias).
Showtime
Showtime
Forge Runner
#26
All my heros on my mains have sup vigors and use max weapons since they were cheap to outfit earlier. I try balance it out so there is'nt a glaring target with less HP. Casters generally use staffs.

Survivors on anyone I don't want targeted or to bring up HP to rest of groups.

Para bip runs centurions but will be trying survivors for the drop. (Damn, those runes are 2100 now lol.)

Torm on my necs, but you're done if you run into heavy holy damage. Then survivors obviously.
My mm heros run survivor or mm insigs.

Blessed on healers/prot.
I like anchorites on my smiters/roj monks.

Radiant only on my main/rangers since they hardly get targeted. Also I will spam skills til I'm out of mana to finish groups faster. Hardly happens. Things tend to die quickly. Vs cold etc is great in some builds.

Now what about vitae or attunement? I usually have 1 or 2 slots left and prefer Vitae's though seems like a waste of space either way lol.
GranDeWun
GranDeWun
Wilds Pathfinder
#27
Higher max energy is relevant for necromancers, otherwise armor is the best choice. With a 7 hero team, chances are you are always under an enchantment...just sayin'.
Dzjudz
Dzjudz
Furnace Stoker
#28
I never use Radiant on heroes, ever. Armor insignia if there are appropriate ones (i.e. Centurion for para, Prodigy for mesmer), otherwise Survivor (necros usually).

Never use attunement either, always vitae.
K
Kunder
Desert Nomad
#29
+max health and +max energy are useless unless you plan on dieing or running out of energy otherwise.

+armor lowers damage, which simultaneously prevents you from dying while causing you to need less healing. If everyone wears blessed insignia's its essentially a +19% to the healer's energy EFFICIENCY. +armor is better defense than +health while being energy MANAGEMENT at the same time, which is the best thing you can add to your armor. The effect scales up even better the more armor you have. Guess what happens when most of your casters are sitting at +20 armor just because of armor + weapon bonuses? Yay, my stupid Healing Burst monk hero who can't manage spells for crap is now 41% more efficient. Isn't that just awesome? Its almost like a free Healer's Boon that also affects DF. What does extra health and energy do for you? A big flat 0%.

TL;DR, unless you have a REALLY good RED ENGINE GORED ENGINE GORED ENGINE GORED ENGINE GOing reason to run something else (if you need to ask whether your reason is good, its probably bad), run whatever gets the largest dependable +armor for your build.
distilledwill
distilledwill
Forge Runner
#30
Just gonna throw my hat into the ring - Survivor/Armour all the way. The consensus of the community is that energy management > larger energy pool.

With + energy and less health your heroes (in a sustained battle) will run down their energy supply and then die.

With + health/+armour and energy management skills your heroes (in a sustained battle) will maintain a decent energy pool and have the health to back it up.

I have to admit that I usually run Survivor on my heroes except in the following cases:

Paragon: + Armour under a shout
Dervish: + Armour under an enchantment
Necro: 1 Bloodstained for faster minion making
Amy Awien
Amy Awien
Forge Runner
#31
Quote: Originally Posted by distilledwill View Post ... The consensus of the community is that energy management > larger energy pool. It's not about an extra spell or skill, the larger pool makes e-management more efficient, the larger buffer means you're e-management will waste less energy due to 'overfilling' the buffer. It's the same reason a larger health pool means less overhealing and thus more efficient healing.

Quote:
Necro: 1 Bloodstained for faster minion making Especially necro's, who have no control over the moment their energy gets a refill, benefit from a larger energy pool.
W
Why?
Frost Gate Guardian
#32
frankly, it doesn't matter. People obviously have very strong opinions, but for 90% of pve areas, it really doesn't matter.

Elite areas might be another story, but no one has posted their all hero team elite area builds yet.
Wenspire
Wenspire
Wilds Pathfinder
#34
For HM PvE, radiant on all except your tank. Because no matter how much life/armor you have as a sqishy, it will usually come down to around 10 hits before you are dead because of having protective spirit or shelter being in play.
distilledwill
distilledwill
Forge Runner
#37
Quote: Originally Posted by Amy Awien View Post It's not about an extra spell or skill, the larger pool makes e-management more efficient, the larger buffer means you're e-management will waste less energy due to 'overfilling' the buffer. It's the same reason a larger health pool means less overhealing and thus more efficient healing. If your energy is being filled to the max by that energy management skill, then it doesn't matter a whole lot if you waste 5 or so energy in doing it, the result is the same: your energy is maximum - I'd rather take the trade off of higher health.

For example:
My hero has 30e and 600hp. My hero maintains almost maximum energy almost all the time. My hero has 100 more health than yours.
Your hero has 50e and 500hp. Your hero maintains almost maximum energy almost all the time. Your hero has 100 LESS health than mine.

There is no doubt that having a large energy pool AND good energy management will mean your hero has mad energy skillz - but overall it won't perform any better than a hero with good energy management on its own.

Quote:
Especially necro's, who have no control over the moment their energy gets a refill, benefit from a larger energy pool. Its true that the necros energy can sometimes be difficult to predict, but its well documented that soul reaping is one of the best energy management tools out there. This, coupled with other energy giving skills (Signet of Lost Souls, Foul Feast) makes the necro one of the heroes with the most energy to play with. Thats why everyone uses them for EVERYTHING. Thats why they can endlessly spam rit heals and discord. Taking energy runes/insignias on them would be a waste (see the above paragraph).
House Silvermoon
House Silvermoon
Lion's Arch Merchant
#39
radiant and survivors sux, armor wins guild wars. i kno its 2k11 and game is dead but srsly if there is one thing everyone should kno its this.
P
Plutoman
Krytan Explorer
#40
Match it to the build, class, and purpose.

Those that should be attacked having lower health, sometimes significantly lower to compensate for the increased aggro of casters. Casters that need to have significantly higher health to avoid being attacked need survivor runes (ie, healers). Casters that run in the middle, will vary. Some need a larger energy pool so the energy management is 100% efficient (if you have a mesmer regaining 21 energy in one go, is at 20 energy, and maxes at 35, you are losing the value on skills). Some don't need extra energy.

I'll balance runes with the builds intended for a hero, the purpose they play, and the class they're using. General answer? It depends.

Just sayin', armor doesn't win the game. Planning does. Armor is the best choice for conserving health though, when you've considered all factors.