Just check the OP's post at the bottom: "Last edited by FallenAngel_; Apr 29"
It's not up to date... it hasn't been updated since the first few hours after tonics appeared when there were still discussions and rumours. The list has since been compiled and edited on the wiki, links in post #67.
6th Year Tonic
Dzjudz
vader
And it never fails. Of all the tonics I got the crappiest one ... Acolyte Sousuke. 
D H U U U M
any one have a pic for shiro tonic ?
what amen mean ?? :3
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Ghull Ka
Ye gods,
Please deliver unto me a margonite tonic. So that I may praise thine glory with my bright purple see-through head. Amen. |
go cubs
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by vader
And it never fails. Of all the tonics I got the crappiest one ... Acolyte Sousuke.
|
Sold my sousuke for 60e when it came out, norgu was 20e then haha.
jazilla
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by go cubs
Not true, Norgu is by far the worst :0
Sold my sousuke for 60e when it came out, norgu was 20e then haha. |
Black Metal
first one -> white Olias =/
ShaJiexi
Ewww, Morgahn. Seriously.... who would want to turn into him?? Why bother with all the crappy whites.... just reduce the total number, 11 tonics (similar to number of minis normally introduced). Just...so...much....crap. Tahlkora, Morgahn? Seriously.... the design of the NPCs in the game is bad enough that I avoid them, why would I want to see more of them?
Adul
I got Tahlkora. What a waste of storage space.
It would have been a much better choice to introduce only [6..14] tonics but actually make all of them likable, in my opinion. Heroes that are visually very similar to what player characters can already look like are bad choices for transformation tonics.
Characters I would have liked to see include grawl longspear, charr axefiend, afflicted warrior, corsair weaponmaster, etc. You know, things that are humanoids yet still different enough.
It would have been a much better choice to introduce only [6..14] tonics but actually make all of them likable, in my opinion. Heroes that are visually very similar to what player characters can already look like are bad choices for transformation tonics.
Characters I would have liked to see include grawl longspear, charr axefiend, afflicted warrior, corsair weaponmaster, etc. You know, things that are humanoids yet still different enough.
??iljo
Friend gets rurik, and on 2nd acc hayda x2 (fffffffffuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu)
ashes
I wanna spam flare in Kuuna form! roar!
Rebelor
2 gwens and i have a kunnie tonic.
2 golds and a green
2 golds and a green
IlikeGW
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Adul
Heroes that are visually very similar to what player characters can already look like are bad choices for transformation tonics.
|
Mister_Smiley
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by IlikeGW
Yep they should have just done something totally awesome but non-tradeable. People were making stupid money off these lame things. It wasn't thought out well at all in terms of giving economic advantage (like 6 years need it?) and the majority of tonics being a buzz kill rather than a treat.
|
cosyfiep
Yeah I have a hoard of wallows since its the most popular mini for me to get for my first bdays --not being able to trade them or sell them would have meant a ton of trashed minis. (and yeah I have been playing for almost 6 years--not a single green mini have I gotten out of more than 100 bdays gifts opened--luck, where????) Some people just get good drops, while some of us get really bad ones (same goes for ANY gifts--be the nic, bday, wintersday etc).
Pistachio
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Black Metal
first one -> white Olias =/
|
Ixillius
Anyone else think they could make the mad king tonic just a tad bigger? :P
I'm really excited for next year now.
With the gifts gone off the trail of minies it could be nearly anything.
I'm really excited for next year now.
With the gifts gone off the trail of minies it could be nearly anything.
Killed u man
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Ixillius
Anyone else think they could make the mad king tonic just a tad bigger? :P
I'm really excited for next year now. With the gifts gone off the trail of minies it could be nearly anything. |
Not saying they're going to kill GW1, just saying that they'll just let GW1 run it's natural course with a maintainance build every now and then, but definatly no new content.
Dzjudz
Anton... I just want to trade it now 
.
.
Swingline
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Killed u man
I think GW2 will be in the stores this time next year.
|
Sookie
IMHO, GW2 will be released 1st Q-2012, maybe 2nd Q. I don't see it coming in before then. That will give them time to fix the mess that GW2 is becoming. 
AND....if they plan to have GW1 4-6 year players migrate over then they will surely create 1 last character class that is a magic wielder. That Commando...er, Engineer...has no place in a fantasy MMORPG.
Really ArenaNet...Rifles, grenades and Machine Gun Turrets? What in the world kind of game is this. Pistols were bad enough, but this ish is getting totally out of hand.
AND....if they plan to have GW1 4-6 year players migrate over then they will surely create 1 last character class that is a magic wielder. That Commando...er, Engineer...has no place in a fantasy MMORPG.
Really ArenaNet...Rifles, grenades and Machine Gun Turrets? What in the world kind of game is this. Pistols were bad enough, but this ish is getting totally out of hand.
Ixillius
That engineer reminds me so much of tf2. Sentry, dispensers(healing turrets), "rocket jumping".
I can see how the charr would end up with this though, but i agree its a bit too much.
Also they did say that they would not drop gw1. there will be a team working on gw1.
I can see how the charr would end up with this though, but i agree its a bit too much.
Also they did say that they would not drop gw1. there will be a team working on gw1.
Killed u man
I think people are jumping the bandwagon a bit too early on the: "Technology is shit, no weapons in GW2".
From a lore point of view: We already have fireworks, and the asuran have technology way above ours today. I know you can't compare our world to the GW-world, but the same logic can be drawn.
Even more so, I think that the weapons (and turrers) had a nice style to them. For some reason, a Charr engineer really seemed to work (Purely looking at visuals) so I really wouldn't say: "it totally doesn't belong there". It probably just looks that way because you've never seen it in GW1 (aside from da chopper in the april update) and your brain identifies guns with brainless shooters. Essentially, a gun is no different than a bow, with offcourse the obvious handicap it won't one-hit-kill people.
What I am worried about, is the balance of those turrets and guns. Anet might not realize it yet, but they're creating a vast database of mechanics, way larger than GW currently has, and we all know how the balance turned in GW. (And that's without all this new effects, race treats, etc)
From a lore point of view: We already have fireworks, and the asuran have technology way above ours today. I know you can't compare our world to the GW-world, but the same logic can be drawn.
Even more so, I think that the weapons (and turrers) had a nice style to them. For some reason, a Charr engineer really seemed to work (Purely looking at visuals) so I really wouldn't say: "it totally doesn't belong there". It probably just looks that way because you've never seen it in GW1 (aside from da chopper in the april update) and your brain identifies guns with brainless shooters. Essentially, a gun is no different than a bow, with offcourse the obvious handicap it won't one-hit-kill people.
What I am worried about, is the balance of those turrets and guns. Anet might not realize it yet, but they're creating a vast database of mechanics, way larger than GW currently has, and we all know how the balance turned in GW. (And that's without all this new effects, race treats, etc)
Lykan
Norgu......... really????? NORGU!!!!!!!?????
Swingline
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Lykan
Norgu......... really????? NORGU!!!!!!!?????
|
Can't wait till June and I get my first 6th b day present and I can rage for getting Sousuke/Norgu because almost everyone I know has gotten Sousuke or Norgu.
Lest121
I got Zhed Sunday..
Ghull Ka
I got a Tahlkora tonic.
Bleh.
The upside is that the person I adventure with most often is a female monk. I bet she'll get an Olias tonic for her 6th. Heh.
Bleh.
The upside is that the person I adventure with most often is a female monk. I bet she'll get an Olias tonic for her 6th. Heh.
dagrdagaz
Ok, this one time when i noticed 2 players trying to sell an EL Norgu tonic i PM'ed both of them the following:
"I'll buy it for 1g, hahaha, then i TRASH it, cos some things just should NOT be"
just couldnt resist doing that
"I'll buy it for 1g, hahaha, then i TRASH it, cos some things just should NOT be"
just couldnt resist doing that
axe
I got Olias, I tried to sell it for 50K and before I excepted anyones offer, I showed them how it would look, they all changed their minds LOL
Asia Skyly
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by dagrdagaz
Ok, this one time when i noticed 2 players trying to sell an EL Norgu tonic i PM'ed both of them the following:
"I'll buy it for 1g, hahaha, then i TRASH it, cos some things just should NOT be" just couldnt resist doing that |
For this reason alone, Norgu is now my tonic of choice!
Elri
I got Dunkoro...jus shows ya Buff....6 years of dedication get's you nought ;-)
Lykan
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Elri
I got Dunkoro...jus shows ya Buff....6 years of dedication get's you nought ;-)
|
Lest121
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Elri
I got Dunkoro...jus shows ya Buff....6 years of dedication get's you nought ;-)
|
My New Name
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Lest121
What sucks about the the El Hero, not in the elite armors.
|
goondaba
My first one was a EL Hayda. Not great but still made a few ecto off of her. Second one is the one I was praying for, EL Margonite! WOOT! Last year I thought Anet should give a glow to those that have been playing for so long so this tonic lets me glow in a different fashion! Totally stoked!
Dzjudz
They should make the hero tonics alternate armor forms every time you use them.
Hobbs
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by My New Name
indeed, that is why some of my buyers just refused to buy EL sousuke, it just looks like shit in regular armor
|
Lest121
so after checking wiki, Zhed doesn't do emotes, which makes him a dull and boring El...waiting for my other character to turn 6 later this summer hopefully he ain't garbage.
Hobbs
Zhed has an idle animation though, which is similar to emotes.
Golgotha
How much is Zhed going for roughly?
malevolence
got EL Livia yay , now to sell it...