How to screw up a guild....is there a stop to this?

We got our guild hall about a week ago and it has come to my attention that ANYONE in the guild can do rated PVP. That means one person can do 6-7 battles with them and henchmen and lsoe on purpose to bastardize your guild rating.

Some people are going to say, "Well, you shouldn't have invited them". My suggestion is alot more controlling and veered towards game play.

Let the guild leader make customizable ranks in the guild (Kinda like wow) and let the leader assign certain permissions to that rank. Initiates for instance might only be able to LEAD pvp on unrated games but they could JOIN rated pvp if a member or officer was leading the group.

Another thing to go hand in hand with this is a guild bank. The leader can let everyone donate to it but have permissions set so that only certain ranks of people can take things out.

I'd like to see the guild hall be functional even outside of GvG battles. If we had a guild bank in there and some other things that would bring people together there when we werent GvGing that'd be awsome

Good idea to give guilds more depth than just a group of friends.

Those are awesome ideas. The first has been mentioned several times and I agree! Only certain people should be allowed to enter RATED battles in GvG so nothing happens, like in our guild, when you check who is on in your guild and realize someone fought and made you a sinking ship! I hate being a TITANIC!

I know they are working (high priority) on rankings within the guild but just wish they'd implement it soon! The gold idea is awesome too... guess we'll just have to wait and see.

UHHH suggestions forum guys?i think the question was hypothetical . . .

You can check my thread. I posted about this already.

Yes, there have been many many posts about this and each post I agree with. Again I use my saying, "For a game called Guild Wars, theres not too much emphasis on Guild"

I too mentioned this already on my thread, and a mentioned permissions and customizable ranks as well.

The more forums about this there are the higher chance it will be read and changed. The worst thing is that it gets deleted.

Actually the worst thing is more and more people start to disobey the rules and don't care because they have the same atittude ase you. Yes, that would be the worst thing.

guilds should be populated with people you've screened if you at all care about pvp ratings

if you allow someone to enter your guild and screw your pvp ranking then your ranking is a direct reflection of your leadership abilities. Nobody in my guild would ever do this. We screen people, have effective leadership, mutual respect between members, and don't let in ten year olds.

i'm glad i stumbled across this thread. it made me happy.

Of corse it's possible to do this now, but it would be much easier to "screen" ppl, if you can give them a beginner membership, where you can see how he performs.