Please notify us when a Guild Member has left the guild

1 pages Page 1
BigTru
BigTru
Jungle Guide
#1
Why not? It says in the guild status screen when we get a new member or when a member has been kicked. Why not when they leave?
Carinae
Carinae
Forge Runner
#2
/signed
yarddog
yarddog
Wilds Pathfinder
#3
/signed
T
The Unknown Enemy
Frost Gate Guardian
#4
/signed
onilink
onilink
Wilds Pathfinder
#5
/signed, although there could be a problem with angry pms "why did you leave" etc.
Alotia Slipfeet
Alotia Slipfeet
Frost Gate Guardian
#6
/signed plain and simple
Wrath Of Dragons
Wrath Of Dragons
Burninate Stuff
#7
/ya cool
T
Timofmars
Ascalonian Squire
#8
I think this could make it hard for some guilds to exist. If a few people leave the guild, it could be demoralizing. The remaining people might join the bandwagon. Or if you join a guild whose most recent actions are all people leaving, you might start with a bad impression of the guild.

It's similar to being random-invited to a pvp group, and when you join, you see all the people in the district are also invited.

For more organized and tighter-knit guilds, they will know when someone leaves since they know everyone (and the person leaving would probably let them know about it anyway).

If anything, maybe only the guild leader and maybe the officers should see who has left.
Age
Age
Hall Hero
#9
I have had a lot of leavers in my guild and believe me I know how it feels especailly the time you spent with them.I think we all know who has left or not and it can be seen in the guild status.I would have to say that today players are looking for guild to get them power leveled or their armor.This is just another way to exploit the game exploiting guilds.I will /sign it but I know who has come and gone.
Retribution X
Retribution X
Desert Nomad
#10
/Signed. then i know when ppl i like leave my guild.
kdhoney44
kdhoney44
Frost Gate Guardian
#11
/signed
Don Vito Corleone
Don Vito Corleone
Frost Gate Guardian
#12
/signed

and it will be nice if a box opens for the member who decided to leave to write a comment about why he is leaving.
A
Alisa Nesho
Ascalonian Squire
#13
/signed
benmanhaha
benmanhaha
Krytan Explorer
#14
/signed

I thought they had this already but I guess I was mistaken.
Killin_Frenzy
Killin_Frenzy
Frost Gate Guardian
#15
/signed
Age
Age
Hall Hero
#16
RE. Should they pay back the 100g you gave them as an invite?
Ensabah Nur
Ensabah Nur
Frost Gate Guardian
#17
/signed

As a guild leader who updates the guild/clan website(s) roster weekly it would be great to know who has left just as we know who has joined in the guild status window. it would help us keep records easier.

EDIT :
Quote:
Originally Posted by Age
RE. Should they pay back the 100g you gave them as an invite?
This has been brought up before(not sure if here @ GURU) but I say yes, departing members should pay the game 100g for leaving/quitting a guild as a recruiter does for getting them in. /signed
TheLordOfBlah
TheLordOfBlah
Jungle Guide
#18
Quote:
Originally Posted by Timofmars
I think this could make it hard for some guilds to exist. If a few people leave the guild, it could be demoralizing. The remaining people might join the bandwagon. Or if you join a guild whose most recent actions are all people leaving, you might start with a bad impression of the guild.

It's similar to being random-invited to a pvp group, and when you join, you see all the people in the district are also invited.

For more organized and tighter-knit guilds, they will know when someone leaves since they know everyone (and the person leaving would probably let them know about it anyway).

If anything, maybe only the guild leader and maybe the officers should see who has left.
Then make a button that says "Clear Guild History"
Soul Shaker
Soul Shaker
Krytan Explorer
#19
The 100g fee was only to stop random guild invites to people who just don't want one.

100g...big woop

Otherwise, /signed.
Ensabah Nur
Ensabah Nur
Frost Gate Guardian
#20
Quote:
Originally Posted by Soul Shaker
The 100g fee was only to stop random guild invites to people who just don't want one.

100g...big woop

Otherwise, /signed.
Then a 100g fee to leave a guild might slow/stop all the people just joining guilds looking for handouts???
As you stated 100g...big woop

*we now return you to your regulary scheduled thread.....