Stop the Insanity

Ohtar Nimloth

Ohtar Nimloth

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: Nov 2005

Nato Corps

R/Me

Greetings all:

You know just this morning I was checking the popular Gw Forum Sites and it seems the number one topic being posted is something along the lines of "the trading system sucks" or "why trading bots should be banned"...and it makes me think.

My point is the name of the game is Guildwars, this implies that the game is based on teamwork...after all america is put up against the other regions to gain favor and gw ladder rating as well as personal rank...but I hardly never see anyone playing like a team...the problem with the trade system is not due to Anet's incompetence, its due to player greed. Everyone want to pay less than something is worth and sell things for more than they are worth...

In my guild and with my ally guilds we never sell anything to members, and we freely gift items to people we play with...I personally enjoy farming green items in hope of that elusive bullwark, but not so i can sell it for mad cash, i farm for it because i know the guy i give it to will return the favor....

I think americans should stop the madness of the race to earn godly gold and start playing like one big guild...veteran players should always train new players and freely gift items they need..it will come back to us when america dominates the ladder, especially when factions is released.

The market value for items we need will be greatly decreased if we just give them to who needs them...you will not need 15k for a bow string, you will need zero gold..everyone can make a difference. next time you get something you need, give to somone who could use it...it will come back to you ten fold

~Ohtar Nimloth
NATO Corp Officer

MMSDome

MMSDome

Raged Out

Join Date: Sep 2005

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ohtar Nimloth
Greetings all:

ey are worth...
next time you get something you need, give to somone who could use it...it will come back to you ten fold

~Ohtar Nimloth
NATO Corp Officer
if we need it why would we give it away to someone else who needs it? I really dont understand what you mean. And giving stuff away free is cheating yourself because everyone needs money, thats by selling stuff people need. If we did that in real life we would get no where.

twicky_kid

twicky_kid

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Jun 2005

Quite Vulgar [FUN]

Quote:
Originally Posted by MMSDome
if we need it why would we give it away to someone else who needs it? I really dont understand what you mean. And giving stuff away free is cheating yourself because everyone needs money, thats by selling stuff people need. If we did that in real life we would get no where.
Its called karma.

If i have a newby and they ask for any items I immediatly tell them "find the collector for the item you need and I'll give you upgrades."

GET OUT OF THE DIABLO MENTALITY.

This is about the only game in the past 10 years that is not item dependant. That's going to be some hard habit to break. Like telling some one that's smoked for 10 years that he has to quit.

MSecorsky

MSecorsky

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Jun 2005

So Cal

The Sinister Vanguard

Me/

Quote:
Originally Posted by twicky_kid
This is about the only game in the past 10 years that is not item dependant. That's going to be some hard habit to break. Like telling some one that's smoked for 10 years that he has to quit.
It's amazing how difficult such a concept is for so many to grasp.

Loviatar

Underworld Spelunker

Join Date: Feb 2005

Quote:
Originally Posted by MSecorsky
It's amazing how difficult such a concept is for so many to grasp.
super junk purples i salvage or go to merchant.

anything halfway decent i cant use i give away.

i have all the gold i will need.

compare a few k gold to someone who says *THANK YOU* and actually means it

i will take the thanks any time.

i gave a nice gold to a brit in the int district and he said Blimy thats nice what do you want for it?

when i said its a gift just click accept he was very happy.

put a game gold price on that.

Clusmas

Clusmas

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Jul 2005

Brisbane, Australia

n/a

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ohtar Nimloth
The market value for items we need will be greatly decreased if we just give them to who needs them...you will not need 15k for a bow string, you will need zero gold..everyone can make a difference. next time you get something you need, give to somone who could use it...it will come back to you ten fold
But alas, you will still need ~2 million for a full set of fissure armour.

twicky_kid

twicky_kid

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Jun 2005

Quite Vulgar [FUN]

Quote:
Originally Posted by Clusmas
But alas, you will still need ~2 million for a full set of fissure armour.
1.2 million now. This is exactly what this post is about in the first place. That items are completely useless compared to knowing stategy and skills.

Ohtar Nimloth

Ohtar Nimloth

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: Nov 2005

Nato Corps

R/Me

Thanks for the replies:

I am not implying that you should give away something you need, im saying you should gift the things you dont need...does anyone need 6 Victos Bullwarks? Ah, but you think "yeah but i need the money for x or y..." What i am trying to say is you will not need that money because the items will be gifted to you....

as far as FOW Armor goes, I have FOW Armor and i earned it through farming and questing for good items just like everyone else...ive found probably 4 Sup Absorbtion Runes and a couple of Superior Vigor Runes wich i did not give away...I sold superior abs for 15k and a sup vigor for 5k....to real people who needed them.

i am not saying give everything away and become ghandi....im just saying we should spam the trade chanel a couple of times when we find something good before we sell to the merchant or traders...instead of asking 15k for something just take 5k or 2k....

Karma will bring everthing back to you 10 fold...you think im just lucky to find 4 sup abs? led alone the quantity of other items ive gotten....

and why we are on the subject...maybe I should start my own auction house of things to give away, instead of guild storage it will be american Gw player storage

unienaule

unienaule

I dunt even get "Retired"

Join Date: Aug 2005

Fifteen Over Fifty [Rare]

There's no karma mechanic in Guild Wars. Sorry, but it just doesn't work that way. Sure, good things happen to some nice people, but they also happen to bad people too. "The rain falls on both the evil and the righteous."

Lord Iowerth

Lord Iowerth

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Sep 2005

Atlanta, GA (#guildwarsguru FTW!)

Biscuit Of Dewm [MEEP]

R/Mo

And also something else to think about ... if you are often broke, and don't really get good drops (which is my own curse, but it doesn't bother me): giving away your help is ALWAYS free and greatly appreciated to new players 99% of the time.

I actually saw some (insert GO RED ENGINE here) offering his help in the early ascalon missions for a price. Look, these just-out-of-sear newbies don't have money, how can that be profitable in the least? Furthermore, I think that's just in bad taste ... if you truly want to help, great, but don't charge people. If it's money you're after, go farm or merchant

kimo the healer

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Oct 2005

ucsb

E/Me

Let me get this straight.
You don't sell anything, you give it away.
and
Somehow you manage to get FOW armor?
I reckon, someone gave you 140 ecto and 140 shard?

Looks like you sell, just like everyone else.
I'm no rocket scientist, but something don't add up.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Ohtar Nimloth
Thanks for the replies:

I am not implying that you should give away something you need, im saying you should gift the things you dont need...does anyone need 6 Victos Bullwarks? Ah, but you think "yeah but i need the money for x or y..." What i am trying to say is you will not need that money because the items will be gifted to you....

as far as FOW Armor goes, I have FOW Armor and i earned it through farming and questing for good items just like everyone else...ive found probably 4 Sup Absorbtion Runes and a couple of Superior Vigor Runes wich i did not give away...I sold superior abs for 15k and a sup vigor for 5k....to real people who needed them.

i am not saying give everything away and become ghandi....im just saying we should spam the trade chanel a couple of times when we find something good before we sell to the merchant or traders...instead of asking 15k for something just take 5k or 2k....

Karma will bring everthing back to you 10 fold...you think im just lucky to find 4 sup abs? led alone the quantity of other items ive gotten....

and why we are on the subject...maybe I should start my own auction house of things to give away, instead of guild storage it will be american Gw player storage

heavy metal rules

heavy metal rules

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Dec 2005

cape cod, ma

{bkr} bad karma ressurection

W/

love the op, when i was in my guild, and the members that were always there alot and helped out each other, and we'd gvg or help each other. anytime i got a gold max weapon, or something that they need. i gave it to them for nothing, and i've given some coin away to some people not alot of gold, because i feel that some should earn it not beg for it. but if there not asking for alot why not.

I've got alot saved up for ch.2 so if they need some coin that isn't going overboard, why not its just a game.

Loviatar

Underworld Spelunker

Join Date: Feb 2005

Quote:
Originally Posted by kimo the healer
Let me get this straight.
You don't sell anything, you give it away.
and
Somehow you manage to get FOW armor?
I reckon, someone gave you 140 ecto and 140 shard?

Looks like you sell, just like everyone else.
I'm no rocket scientist, but something don't add up.
let me get you a calculator then.

how do you know that he did not get those ectos/shards as drops?

you have no idea of his play style , time spent, or even what areas he frequents.

gold?

maybe he picked it up from drops,

maybe he salvaged and sold junk like the rest of us?

4runner

4runner

Banned

Join Date: Oct 2005

Cali!!!

cdxx/the420th.com

Mo/N

salvage,salvage,salvage!! There are 4 peeps in our guild who hold salvaged materials!! Try 5000 wood planks, 3ooo iron ingots, 2600 steel ingots, 4000 tan hides, 1200 fur squares, 900 bolts of silk. this is how you fund a guild!!! Oh yah 210 shards, 680 ectos!!!
The list goes on!

We give each other everything from crystalline swords to that rare insightful staff!

Friends and Guildies FTW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

kimo the healer

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Oct 2005

ucsb

E/Me

so you're assuming he got the equivalent of 1.2 mill from farming for ectos and shard + picking up loot and selling junk items to merchant.

All the good items, he gifts. Because he doesn't need.

That sounds good and all, but not very realistic.

Lampshade

Lampshade

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Jun 2005

USA

Xen of Onslaught

Quote:
Originally Posted by unienaule
There's no karma mechanic in Guild Wars. Sorry, but it just doesn't work that way. Sure, good things happen to some nice people, but they also happen to bad people too. "The rain falls on both the evil and the righteous."
Quoted for Truth

awelcomecomatose

Academy Page

Join Date: Sep 2005

CHICO

Axes Of Evil [AoE]

N/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ohtar Nimloth
Greetings all:

You know just this morning I was checking the popular Gw Forum Sites and it seems the number one topic being posted is something along the lines of "the trading system sucks" or "why trading bots should be banned"...and it makes me think.

My point is the name of the game is Guildwars, this implies that the game is based on teamwork...after all america is put up against the other regions to gain favor and gw ladder rating as well as personal rank...but I hardly never see anyone playing like a team...the problem with the trade system is not due to Anet's incompetence, its due to player greed. Everyone want to pay less than something is worth and sell things for more than they are worth...

In my guild and with my ally guilds we never sell anything to members, and we freely gift items to people we play with...I personally enjoy farming green items in hope of that elusive bullwark, but not so i can sell it for mad cash, i farm for it because i know the guy i give it to will return the favor....

I think americans should stop the madness of the race to earn godly gold and start playing like one big guild...veteran players should always train new players and freely gift items they need..it will come back to us when america dominates the ladder, especially when factions is released.

The market value for items we need will be greatly decreased if we just give them to who needs them...you will not need 15k for a bow string, you will need zero gold..everyone can make a difference. next time you get something you need, give to somone who could use it...it will come back to you ten fold

~Ohtar Nimloth
NATO Corp Officer
You do realize you are hoping for a bunch of americans to create a utopian communist society.

Loviatar

Underworld Spelunker

Join Date: Feb 2005

Quote:
Originally Posted by kimo the healer
so you're assuming he got the equivalent of 1.2 mill from farming for ectos and shard + picking up loot and selling junk items to merchant.

All the good items, he gifts. Because he doesn't need.

That sounds good and all, but not very realistic.
lets see.

the gold crafting cost isnt that high it is the materials.

if he had one of the early invinci monks and got stuff before the nerfs.

not to forget if he was lucky enough to get ectos at 100-300 during the price reset.

i consider anything junk that the average buyer turns their nose up at which can add a few k per run.

over months that adds up especially if 2-4 hours a day is put in

Ensabah Nur

Ensabah Nur

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Jul 2005

State of Confusion

Army Of Apocalypse (AOA)

R/Mo

For the record Americans are not the only ones guilty of this behavior so please stop bashing Americans. Many players from around the globe buy/sell/trade thereby adding to the problem(s).

Personally I give as much away as I can to guildmates/friends and allies(Guildmates & Allies often do the same for each other), if none of them need/want it I can often be found in Post Ascalon giving Greens, Golds & Purples, away to level 8 or less players/strangers to help them out(you'd be surprised to discover how many people think "free stuff" is a scam also how many people don't understand what level 8 or less means) , but for those that trade with me they are grateful and it brings a smile to my face to help others. Whatever I can't give away (there have been times) I salvage or sell back to the game. Only once in my history of GW have I bought from another player and that was to get our guilds Celestial Sigil. Oh, I'm American.

EternalTempest

EternalTempest

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Jun 2005

United States

Dark Side Ofthe Moon [DSM]

E/

I love promoting Collector items or how to get green and Anet has done a great job at giving players what they need. I will teach any new player with questions about not needing "gold" items due to these alternatives.

I too love giving stuff away, there are a lot of good items that are not worth much due to "non-max" but in the hands of a new character but it's very hard to give away. You know how hard it was to give a way green hammer (worth 500 gold)and a not so max but nice shield, I had to almost force it on someone.

I do need things that farming can buy (pve) side, I still need weapon upgrade and rune unlocks, and I do want sup vigor for my pve character but don't have the 80+ plat (or around there) required to get it.

4runner

4runner

Banned

Join Date: Oct 2005

Cali!!!

cdxx/the420th.com

Mo/N

last time i checked a sup vigor was selling for 36k in droks!!

Loviatar

Underworld Spelunker

Join Date: Feb 2005

Quote:
Originally Posted by 4runner
last time i checked a sup vigor was selling for 36k in droks!!
34k now.

i bought a couple just in case.

sup asorb is 70k now instead of 100k

all other sup runes are diving also some as low as a couple hundred for tactics axe mastery and a bunch of others

Radeon Moto

Pre-Searing Cadet

Join Date: Feb 2006

Hic

N/Me

I totaly agree with you if i have something that a friend or guildie needs its theirs free of charge but i still sell to people i dont know
also i am all for helping the new guy

JiggyFly

JiggyFly

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Jan 2006

So-Cal

Forsaken Wanderers [FW]

Mo/

This immediately made me think of communism, and it just made me think that it would never work for one reason. There's no insentive to farm for things, people wouldn't farm for 4 bulwarks and give away 3 they would just farm 1 and take whatever else they got from others. People would stop farming altogether because there's no point in farming items if noone is going to buy them.

And guess what happens if let's say 25% of the people follow this rule, they'd farm less because of course the rewards they get from others would be less than what they would have gotten from farming so they farm less, then what happens to prices with less of each item in the market..they skyrocket.

You think stuff is expensive now, while pretty much everyone is either ettin farming, 55 hp monk farming, or griffon farming, prices are going down. Hell, the less people farm the less influx of items and the higher the price.

So in my opinion a more probable solution would be to get more people to farm since 20 people are going to try and sell a Bulwark it's going to be alot lower than if one person i sselling one.

Siliconwafer

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Oct 2005

Australia

Shameful Spirits

I believe an underlying critical analysis of the mentality of many Guild Wars players would reveal a largely irrational urge to earn the most wealth; even through seemingly repetitive processes such as farming-that can be attributed to the mindest produced from living in a largely capitalistic world (which emphasises already the survival trait of "hoard the most important stuff and you'll live").

But hey, it's only an anecdotal observation, from playing with a young guildie of mine, who has the biggest urge to go out and hoard gold and various virtual items, for no other reason than the fact that he can. I personally can't understand how this urge can keep him farming for hours-even though he admits it's horribly boring.

Quote:
Originally Posted by MMSDome
if we need it why would we give it away to someone else who needs it? I really dont understand what you mean. And giving stuff away free is cheating yourself because everyone needs money, thats by selling stuff people need. If we did that in real life we would get no where.
How does everyone need money in GW? From my point of view, the largest cost of a necessity is outfitting a warrior for PvP (~300k). FOW armour costs more, I can't grasp the strength of the motive that would propel someone to hoard that much money.

I don't know. I can't understand it, but for those who do it, that's fine by me. I think GW is one of the first MMO's to put less emphasis on money; but still, I think if it were possible to get all the perfect items and equipment in 20 hours (but perhaps still had an equivalent of fissure or something), people would still farm.

Or maybe I'm just a dirty communist

Sagius Truthbarron

Sagius Truthbarron

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Jun 2005

Animal Factory [ZoO]

A/

And people are willing to steal for Fissure armor...

I give away loads of gold to anybody if I have it. If I get a few k in one day, I give it away most of the time. One time someone was asking in Tombs D1 for money for his Guild Hall, and I gave him 30k. I just didn't need it.

Look, people, its not real money. Nobody is proud of you (except yourself, perhaps) for spending 2,000 hours of your life raking together millions of fake gold to buy fake 2 million dollar clothing.

Sure, some people might go 'Ooooh, never seen that before'. But it ends at that point. Nobody likes you for it, nobody cares. Its fake. Stop being cheap.

Quote:
Originally Posted by MMSDome
If we did that in real life we would get no where.
And you get somewhere from hording in real life? Even the richest people will die one day, and nobody will care. They might have a big tomb, and that's all. They might make their children rich and establish a rich lineage, but do you think their children, or even they, will care who made them that way? No.

Where do you think that puts the middle class? Do you think anyone passing your tomb stone will say 'Hey, that guy had a nice car!'?

Money is only good for how and where you use it, nothing more. Yes, some very rare people do give freely in real life too. Somehow, they manage not to die of starvation.

Battle Torn

Battle Torn

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Aug 2005

Scotland

W/Mo

I think it all boils down to what kind of person you are. Its no secret there are some greedy people out there and worse...scammers who deliberately try to trick you for profit. Ive given away too many items to mention and always seem to attract the lost soul who doesnt even know about runes of holding let alone attribute points or farming and usually spend time helping them out. I have met some pretty cool people this way and the reputation you build up as these people mention you to their friends is a nice thing to have because people genuinely value your opinion.

Its not hard to give something decent to people who are in need...you are never going to give ecto or a godly fellblade to a newbie anyway so why bother about a near perfect short sword with low requirements when its probably only worth 4k these days anyway? typically there is only a trade in upgrades and perfect rare skin weapons etc and newbies wont be needing these anyway. My storage is full of decent weapons that I give away regularly because I can make more farming than I can selling them.

The Herbalizer

The Herbalizer

<3 Ecto

Join Date: Jul 2005

Quote:
veteran players should always train new players and freely gift items they need..it will come back to us when america dominates the ladder, especially when factions is released.
I will never do that again to people I do not know. I have had so much grief from people I have helped bugging me every second of my time in-game for free stuff or help. It has got so bad I set my status to do not disturb most of the time.

Renegade ++RIP++

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Feb 2006

I don't hand out money just for nothing. I earned it through play, not farming just regular play, and so should some others. Heck I haven't had any special weapon untill i found one. And tbh i didn't need one. If i had the dropped items i took the items from the collectors. Heck the only reason why i have 1mill+ now is because of some people willing to pay for greens, for not paying excessive prices for stuff like looks... i really don't care if my toon wears 1.5k or 15k or fow armor. But if I could reach it by doing quests like clearing the underworld or finishing all the missions and bonusses etc in stead of the same old same old boring reruns of uw to get some dumb ectos... or farming ettins or... just to get money to buy it. then no thanks it ain't worth my time.

The only things i did buy was a chaos axe since I liked the look. Didn't use it for anything else.

The handing out policy is all nice and dandy, but it sends the wrong message namely hey you don't have to work for what you want. no need to get creative we will just throw it in your lap. In stead of the message, be happy with what you have and adapt with what you have. Since that is exactly where skill comes into play. People that adapt to circumstances with what they have without relying on stuff just being thrown into their lap.

Just like i let my guildmates try the missions first on their own and after they tried it go and help them by giving them pointers how to solve it. So they actually understand why something works and not just do the mindless behaviour... Same reason why i consider running to be one of the worst activities in the game since it lets people skip their learningperiod and learn how to adapt to different circumstances with their toon by relying on hteir strengths, nullifying their weaknessess or at least not exposing them in stead of taking advantage of overpowered items...

Gonzo

Gonzo

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Feb 2006

Netherlands

Defenders of the Blackblade [DotB]

W/

I find the looks of my char more important then if I have 1k or 1000k in my storage. Sitting on all that money is just pointless and I would rather have a char that I think looks good.
At this point, every time I get to 15k I get another part of my 15k glads armour. Feel no need for FoW warrior armour, because I think it looks like crap.

Renegade ++RIP++

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Feb 2006

i consider my toon with 1.5k armor to be ok looking.seeing as the changes to the 15k or fissure armour are in my view not that great to warrant that expenditure.

But we will see what factions will bring.

AxeMe

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Aug 2005

Atlanta

HEX

W/

Quote:
Originally Posted by The Herbalizer
I will never do that again to people I do not know. I have had so much grief from people I have helped bugging me every second of my time in-game for free stuff or help. It has got so bad I set my status to do not disturb most of the time.
That happened with me as well and is the reason I no longer give stuff away.

It's a real shame since I actually enjoyed doing that. But, as is true with you, the constant messages asking for more ended up (1) becoming constant and nagging (2) despite the fact that it shouldn't have done this it actually made me feel guilty when I didn't give the person something every time they asked (that, I'll admit is my own fault) and (3) I begin to wonder if I was encouraging people not to play the game ... the free items, free cash, free runs and escourting them through missions didn't do much to encourage them to develop as players.

Divinus Stella

Divinus Stella

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Nov 2005

Wales

Steel Phoenix

Why do you care what everyone else thinks of your cash, you mentioned if your rich irl then nobody will think more of you for it, but nobody will think any more of you if your not rich, or even if you give free money away, people are rich for their own benefit, if they enjoy having a lot of cash makes them happy why should they care if noboy else loves them for it.

Same goes for guild wars, people play guild wars for fun, its fun having a lot of cash, its fun having decent armour, i dont play guild wars in the hope that everyone will love me for it, i play it for fun.

quickmonty

quickmonty

Ancient Windbreaker

Join Date: May 2005

To the OP.... I like the way you think.

For me it's just about the "Thank You" you get from people, wether it be for items, gold or time given. That is the basic premise of my guild .... helping others. If you are a loyal guild member that has helped others, I will gladly give you the gold for your Drok's armor, or give you that superior rune you need if I find it while farming.

When not helping or advancing my own characters I do some farming so I have the gold and items to help out others, and to buy vanity armor for my characters.

To all you "nay sayers" ...... play the game as you like, but don't put down others that are charitable.

LifeInfusion

LifeInfusion

Grotto Attendant

Join Date: May 2005

in the midline

E/Mo

I don't bother farming. Anything I don't plan to use I give away if I cannot sell it.

Sometimes it is more satisfying to give it away than spend 10hours looking for people to buy it.

Ohtar Nimloth

Ohtar Nimloth

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: Nov 2005

Nato Corps

R/Me

Again:

I appreciate the interest in my post and glad to see members of this and the GW community sharing your thoughts.

1) I received the kind of responses i assumed i would....you guys are entitled to horde your gold and save every gold piece, however you attain them...it is your right...

2) Just to make sure everyone understands what the Original Post was about...there are two key words "Need" and "Want"...these are for you to determine..personally I "need" a max armor to compete in GvG and PvP and survive the Environment...but I "wanted" Fow armor...so for awhile I farmed to get it...once I got it i gave away the extra 3 shards and ecto I had to someone who "wanted" them.

3) I knew this post would end up being about my character more than the character of GW players...just goes to back up my point that people are mostly concerned about themselves, and rightfully so its just a game.

Note to Kimo the Healer....Actually I did get 90% of my shards and ecto from farming mid-level items and selling to the merchant...ive been doing it since the game came out..15 minute farming runs at 3k each...do the math...oh and I dont give away any vanity items...I typically include superior Vigors and Absorbtions in this category...ive been running majors since the game came out...havent needed a sup yet...

one last note...Thanks to all who responded, praised the concept of "gifting" and criticized it, just goes to show there is a community, I would just like to see it spread to more doing and less talking about it....

Thanks to ALL