Elementalist better than Rangers?

There are some misguided individuals in my guild who think elementalists are better in PvP than rangers (with tiger's fury). I have tried reasoning with them and even showed some excellent posts from my ranger guru, Ensign.

Would someone please set the record straight that elementalists are obsolete already?

I think you are an ignorant nOOb. There is no "best" PvP profession. Now get over it. Go buy WoW if you want a game that have classes that are unbalanced.

Oh, that's cold.

Cold...but true.

Another jab from the peanut gallery. And not from a Star Wars fan this time. Ouch.

now we all know that the best, above all, better than anyone PvP class would have to be Darth Vader. C'mon, he's got that fricken choke you thing!

I don't know this Darth Carth character above outed me as an "ignorent noob." I was trying to keep that from my parents. Oh well, now I must embrace it.

Can you imagine the whining thread then... "It's not fair, the Jedi /Monk is impossible to kill. He chokes me from a distance and heals all the time, it's broken...."

Epinephrine, you are MY Yoda.

If they mean Pure Ele vs Pure Ranger in DPS only. I would say yes (but only by a small amount of DPS)

Then again, a ranger vs ele in a 1v1 I think the ranger would win. But there is never 1v1 so no point in discussing that.

Now, in overall utiltiy for disruptin and slowing the other team I like the ranger better. Than again, the earth line for Ele's adds lots of group defense and slows to the other team.

So in the end.. Bring one of each to the party. And if your guild doesn't like you, get another guild.

I am sorry that we are back on point again. I was getting into the whole Star Wars tagent.

Point well taken regarding the earth magic. Personally, I would take 2 rangers over a ranger and an ele to GvG. The extra DPS and disruption seems to be better as most enemies have more than one caster.

Why don't you just take a gander.

Wow, a link to your feel-good thread that generalizes everything. There are no exploits in the game? Even Necros make good primaries for PvP? All professions have the same DPS? Please. No one buys that sh*t.

*Sigh* Hopefully a moderator will close this for trolling, and the overall count of idiots has flown through the roof.

Ahh, yes. I am now trolling my own thread. Well, here's a thread for you where Ensign points out that Elementalists are becoming obsolete.

http://www.guildwarsguru.com/forum/s...ead.php?t=2256

Please do go on about how we are all idiots for pointing out imbalances in the game from a serious gamer whose tag is [Crap].