DELL
IntelTM PentiumTM 4 Processor 630 with HT Technology (3.0GHz, 800 FSB, 2MB L2 cache)
Microsoft® Windows® XP Home Edition
512MB Dual Channel DDR2 SDRAM at 533MHz (2x256MB)
17" (16.0"vis) Monitor
160GB6 Serial ATA hard drive
128MB PCI ExpressT x16 (DVI/VGA/TV-out) ATI RadeonT X300 SE
90-Day Limited Warranty4 and At-Home Service5
OR
ALIENWARE
Processor
AMD Athlon™ 64
3200+ Processor
Operating System
Microsoft® Windows®
XP Home Edition
Memory
1GB Dual Channel DDR
SDRAM PC-3200 400MHz
Hard Drive
160GB 7200 RPM
SATA w/8MB Cache
Graphics Processor
ATI RADEON™
9500 SE 128MB DDR
Sound Card
Integrated 5.1 Audio
Both have a Smiliar Price. Which is better?
Which Comp is better!
TheCrusader
Principa Discordia
The Alienware one.
TheCrusader
Ok 
Zine
Just make your own...Like i'm doing, just for this game. Yes, it's sad but I needed an upgrade here soon anyways. The Alien Ware is better (Rechecked the RAM) hands down.
Edited
The only thing that is iffy is the video card. I'd upgrade it to a GeForce 6200 if you could possibly.
Edited
The only thing that is iffy is the video card. I'd upgrade it to a GeForce 6200 if you could possibly.
TheCrusader
Ok so which is better Alienware or Dell. And no I can't make my own PC. I'm only 14.
Zine
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by TheCrusader
Ok so which is better Alienware or Dell. And no I can't make my own PC. I'm only 14.
|
TheCrusader
Well good for you. But honestly I don't care. I did not ask about making my own comp, I asked which of those two comps is better. If you dont have a suggestions then don't bother posting in this thread.
ElRey
the second, but i dont want u to suffer through that card. Get a NIVIDIA Gefore 6800 from Newegg.com and insert it in there. Its easy enough, i should kno, im 12 and i made a laptop already.
Zine
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by TheCrusader
Well good for you. But honestly I don't care. I did not ask about making my own comp, I asked which of those two comps is better. If you dont have a suggestions then don't bother posting in this thread.
|
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16814145118
Principa Discordia
The Alienware is much better, because it has a better processor and larger amount of RAM. The Dell has faster RAM, but the difference between 512mB of RAM and 1Gb of RAM is as wide as the Grand Canyon, and DDR400 is fantastic anyway.
Other than that, my only issues with that Alienware are the graphics card and the operating system. The 9550 will play games pretty well, but as it's an SE I think that the memory on it is cut down from 128bit architecture to 64bit architecture, which is plenty slower. Also, it's not a big deal, but if possible try to get XP Pro instead of XP Home, you won't regret it.
Other than that, my only issues with that Alienware are the graphics card and the operating system. The 9550 will play games pretty well, but as it's an SE I think that the memory on it is cut down from 128bit architecture to 64bit architecture, which is plenty slower. Also, it's not a big deal, but if possible try to get XP Pro instead of XP Home, you won't regret it.
TheCrusader
Is a Geforce fx 5600 a good graphics card? Cause I have that in my closet and I can put it in if it is better than the Radeon.
TheCrusader
Help Please!
Principa Discordia
The GeforceFX 5600 is better than the Radeon 9500 SE as the SE has 64bit memory and not 128bit memory, but don't expect much performance from either.
TheCrusader
Ok Thanks. 
demonblade
Never ever get Dell, that's my suggestion. Get the Alienware, their computers are known for gaming.
termite
I've used a couple of Dells for gaming and they were just fine. The thing between the two computers mentions is that they both have good parts except for the video card. It's really pointless to have all that ram and a high speed cpu if you're gonna have a value priced video card.
Loviatar
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by TheCrusader
Help Please!
|
the amount of momory may be either 128/256 mb but the BUSS it uses to transfer data is a crippled 64 bit buss so they could have a budget card
the 6200 suggested is a prime example of that crap and gaming sites warn people away from that card as an example along with the ati se cards
all agree that the present best card for the money is the nvidia 6600 GT
check the price difference at the price checker at both places to swap the 6600GT for the card you have now
Dirkiess
What was the reason you decided on looking at these two PC's?
Ok, i know you want a Gaming machine or you wouldn't be going for power. Is there another reason? Or do you just have a stack of cash and really don't care?
Also, Principa Discordia, was there reasoning in XP Pro over Home Edition. As far as I'm aware, all you need to make the Home Edition into Pro Edition is on the CD, it's just not installed when you install XP.
Please, anyone correct me if I'm wrong, but it's something i learned a while ago. For the life of me, can't remember where, but i think is was PC Pro magazine in the UK. Don't even ask me to find the article either.
Ok, i know you want a Gaming machine or you wouldn't be going for power. Is there another reason? Or do you just have a stack of cash and really don't care?
Also, Principa Discordia, was there reasoning in XP Pro over Home Edition. As far as I'm aware, all you need to make the Home Edition into Pro Edition is on the CD, it's just not installed when you install XP.
Please, anyone correct me if I'm wrong, but it's something i learned a while ago. For the life of me, can't remember where, but i think is was PC Pro magazine in the UK. Don't even ask me to find the article either.