Forum Survival after Release?

Lansing Kai Don

Banned

Join Date: Mar 2005

Kansas

I certainly hope these forums stay as lively as they are now, but I doubt it. I joined after a BWE and for some reason I got hooked and am unsure how often I will post when the release comes out. Especially if I have a PvE guild to manage. So REALISTICALLY who thinks the forums will suffer considerably a week after the release.

Lansing Kai Don

P.S. It just occurred to me that this great community is here in "preperation" for an unreleased game and I hope it doesn't disband, but realistically I think it lose alot of the current posters (I hope myself but you never know).

bobert

Core Guru

Join Date: Feb 2005

TX

R/Me

I'm sure after the first few weeks of release, the forum activeness will decrease in a little, but it might go up because of all the new comers. Either way it will even back out later.

Lansing Kai Don

Banned

Join Date: Mar 2005

Kansas

Wow your quick, I didn't even get the poll up bobert. Shoot I didn't even get to inhale. Grats, I'm along the same lines, hoping I come back after a break period but hey no promises people.



Lansing Kai Don

Ren Falconhand

Ren Falconhand

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Mar 2005

Passed out on my Keyboard from lack of sleep from playing GW too much

The Harpers

R/Mo

I hope to use this forum to get help for my budding guild and to find new members. I do not have a site yet But I am here to help take the edge off my GW Withdrawals) When I can play all the time I may have less time to post between my Guild and game but will try . hope to see everbody in game though

Ren

Nascent

Nascent

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Mar 2005

Calgary, Alberta, Canada

The Shi Mai

It could go one of two ways methinks. Either everyone will get closer because we can all play together and share our experiences, which is what I hope. OR, it'll drift apart cause with the game out everyone will go and do their own little thing. I hope for the first :P

Inde

Site Contributor

Join Date: Dec 2004

Forum traffic always goes up after game release. There are simply a lot more people looking for more information.

Lews

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Mar 2005

Seattle, Washington

R/E

I think it will still stay an active forum.

Lansing Kai Don

Banned

Join Date: Mar 2005

Kansas

Quote:
Originally Posted by Inde
Forum traffic always goes up after game release. There are simply a lot more people looking for more information. Inde, should I've made the timespan longer than a week. I'm unfamiliar with forum traffic (that's why I asked lol). I meant after the new edge of the game wears off (maybe a month) and everything settles down. I realize that right after a release of a game there will be a spike in your traffic amount, it was "right" after this spike (not on the downslope but rather on the levelling out) that I was asking everyone if they thought where the traffic would level out at. Sorry, if my elapsed time isn't correct I tried.

Lansing Kai Don

EDIT: P.S. I for one hope I will be retired and in a wheelchair and still posting!

Spooky

Spooky

Bokusatsu Tenshi

Join Date: Dec 2004

Bellevue, WA

KEA

E/Mo

I have Administrated many, many forums and sites in the past, a few for considerable lengths of time. I've been doing it enough to know, that in matters like these, there tend to be certain patterns that a community will follow.

In the early stages (pre-release), your community is going to be composed primarily of people who are dedicated to the game. Even if they can't play it, they remain students of it, and often get into numerous deep discussions regarding matters in, of, and around the game. These people will make up the 'core' of a community, and in essence, will define the character of those forums. If people come to a forum and see intelligent discussions going on, they're either going to decide that they want in, or "That's not for me!" and leave. The same thing can be applied to flamey, trolly forums. Some people like that kind of stuff. But all of that is shaped at this point .. things tend to be slow, but very consistent.

When release comes.. you might want to bunker down and brace yourself for the storm. A lot of new people will be finding out about the game .. people who will pick it up off the shelf because online play is free, because it looks cool, or just because a friend said it rocks. They're going to have a lot of questions, and the first place they're going to look is either the official site (thus leading them to fansites) .. or GameFAQs .. *shudders.* What you end up with is a massive influx of people with little experience in that community, and a lot of questions. You'll see the same thing asked a hundred times over, and a lot of behavior that is discordant to what the 'regulars' have become used to. That's not something you can really fault a new person for, mostly .. as it is something akin to getting into a pool. The water is really cold at first, but you adapt. Forums are the same way.. it takes time to adjust, and this is definitely the 'growing pains' stage. You'll often find that a lot of 'older' members will start to act or feel distant, sometimes even becoming bitter. Question threads that used to be answered with a happy emoticon eventually turn to "Read the bloody FAQ" after the Xth time around. That is just the way things go .. it's no different from 'old people' complaining about those 'noisey kids' and their 'crazy rock and roll.' This is certainly one of the most critical points in a forum's life cycle .. if people remain patient, and stress friendliness in their actions .. then slowly but surely, the people that seek questions will find their answers (and not feel rebuked for doing so) which they in turn, can give to the next person that needs them. If everyone manages to survive this stage with their sanity intact, we move along to..

The point where things settle back down. Like a week after a little kid's birthday party, we're not as excited about 'having' new toys, we're kinda used to playing with them now. What this means is that you'll see a focus shift back to the social aspects of the game, something like it was in the 'pre-release' days, only on a much more grandiouse, and more informed scale. This is usually the stage when you notice friends, or groups, or even 'cliques' becoming more visible. Because people now have the opportunity to play as they wish, should they need someone .. where to turn? The people you already know from a forum is a good place to start. Sitting around and talking with someone about something, and actually doing it are two very different things .. and moreso than they would have, people might realize "Hey, so and so is cool." So, things start to take on a more congenial nature. You'll hear people talking about their exploits, or organizing get togethers, things of that nature. Most of the life cycle will happen here.. until..

News of the next Expansion comes .. and we start all over again!
I don't have any doubts for the longevity of this forum, it's just a matter of being an oar in the water .. you're moving with the flow, but you're also directing it.

Davion

Davion

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Feb 2005

wherever the winds take me

R/Mo

Honestly? I don't think site has come anywhere near the point of maximum usage yet. There is a ton of room to grow yet and with all of the people already here adding to it, the only place it can go is up, up, and AWAY!! (underdog)


(oy can't beleive I flashed back on that one )

Weezer_Blue

Weezer_Blue

Elite Guru

Join Date: Feb 2005

Just a Box in a Cage

Hurry Up The Cakes [Oven]

Lively? Are you kidding? After release tons of people are going to flood into all sorts of fansites and forums asking newb questions! Hopefully all the people with the answers that make up 70% of the population here are still around when that happens.

Lunarhound

Lunarhound

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Feb 2005

Well said, Spooky. You should give that little speech its own seperate place on the site somewhere. I wouldn't mind being able to find it easily, if I ever need to reference or quote it.

Ranis Harlequin

Ranis Harlequin

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: Mar 2005

Vancouver, Canada

Perhaps we all need to take an 'oath of order and allegiance' to gwg:

-
I promise to never tell people what to do, only provide helpful suggestions. I will never say "READ THE F%#$&*G FAQ!!!!" or similar. I will continue to keep GWG in my 'favorites' folder, and click on it often and lots. I will un-newbanize as many players as possible, so they can in turn un-newbanize others to come. And most importantly, I will a keep a link to the "New Players Section" on my clipboard...always.
-

And with that, I depart in preparation...

spiritofcat

spiritofcat

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Mar 2005

Sydney, Australia

Order of the Sanguine Dragon [OSD]

E/Mo

I think Spooky's got it pretty right.
There'll be a huge inrush of newbies and the dedicated, educated long-time fans will get very annoyed and irritated with them, but after a while it will settle down and get to a state close to what it was before. Of course, a lot of the current regulars whi use the forum to help alleviate their withdrawal symptoms will finally be able to play the game and therefore won't be around as much but eventually they'll come back too.

Taranis

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Mar 2005

Is Spooky some kind of god or soemthing like that? Well said as usual...

Tur713

Tur713

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Feb 2005

Pink Animal Clan

E/Me

I know that I will stick with the forum and a lot of us will. Some of us who are here from the betas who are not admin might get well known among the forums. Like stated above, there will be a huge influx of people coming to the forums at release. I believe Spooky on what he said. Let's just hope we can all make it through the Times of Great Newbage.

Yes, Spooky is some kind of god.

Soiled Egg Roll

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Mar 2005

Ripon, Wisconsin

IVEX

Mo/

There will probably be always something that I don't know/understand, and this seems to be the best place to ask my questions. So I'll be staying .

MoldyRiceFrenzy

MoldyRiceFrenzy

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Feb 2005

Santa Rosa, CA

Confusion in The Ranks[tArD]

Mo/W

i think after the real game comes out there wont be as much to talk about really. like i mean there will be alot of talking and stuff but they will be mainly just questions or so unless u have a post that shows what we want for the next expansion or somthing it will probably have alot of people looking at this site but not as many posting ideas or comments

Badenstein

Badenstein

Academy Page

Join Date: Mar 2005

Ohio

I don't believe it will die at all. The only thing that will kill GWG forums is if there is a snobbish attitude that presents itself as many new players who really need help come here and ask seemingly "dumb" questions. I think there is a fine line between moderating a forum and being repressive in its moderation. Repressiveness will drive people away despite excellent discussions.

Taranis

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Mar 2005

There will always be those cluseless people who don't know how to finish a quest or where to find X and Y and item Z...

HotSnack

HotSnack

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Feb 2005

Well put Spooky, I posted something similar to what you said in an earlier thread, only mine had a tad more cynicism.

Since most of what I would have said is spoken for, I'll just condense my predictions;
You'll see a huge influx of new users. As shocking as it sounds, there are still a hell of a lot more prospective players who either never heard of GW or were not tempted to buy into the whole BWE thing. Granted some of these new players will be experienced and mature online gamers, and know the general standard procedures and etiquettes of fan forums (i.e. reading the FAQ). However most of them will be a fresh faced and confused lot, some will be newbs who really don't what to do etc, while some will be n00bs who would demand answers from one of the most frequently asked questions, and yet still think they are teh hax. Some of the old timey forum users will grow bitter by the influx of n00bs, soon they will no longer to be able to distinguish newbs from n00bs and will end up snapping at both. Afterwards they usually say their farewells and disappear forever off the face of the forums, either to hang out in their own guild forums, or a different forum so as to relive the 'old days'. After a few months things will start to settle down, as people focus on more important things such as debating that 'X class isn't broken, you just don't know how to play them' etc. Guru will never really be the same again. I'd imagine the standards of maturity will become more relaxed with the increase of new players, and become a forum not unlike TGH's. The worst case scenario is that Guru becomes a munchkin site, something unique to Guru due to its high level of in depth content.

Loviatar

Underworld Spelunker

Join Date: Feb 2005

the only thing needed (besides all the work of the admin/mod) is the willingness to answer the same question for the 50 th time in 2 days from 50 people who dont know what or where the search button is with a friendly answer

the admin take care of the trolls and the forum takes care of the guests and new members

the words are helpful PATIENCE

Inde

Site Contributor

Join Date: Dec 2004

Quote:
Originally Posted by HotSnack
uru will never really be the same again. I'd imagine the standards of maturity will become more relaxed with the increase of new players, and become a forum not unlike TGH's. The worst case scenario is that Guru becomes a munchkin site, something unique to Guru due to its high level of in depth content. The standard we place on this website is throughout. This means the forums are also under our standard, and no way will we ever 'loosen' our rules.

And in regards to vets. Look at us admin's reg dates. And then look at even the first users. Its far too less time to be considered a 'vet' on this forum.

DarkWasp

DarkWasp

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Mar 2005

Paradise

Agency Of Forbidden Fruits [Oot]

R/A

Laughs I'd have to agree with that.

HotSnack

HotSnack

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Feb 2005

Quote:
Originally Posted by Inde
The standard we place on this website is throughout. This means the forums are also under our standard, and no way will we ever 'loosen' our rules.
Perhaps you are right, I did not mean imply that admins will start to slack once the game is released, and I never said TGH's forums was necessarily a bad thing either.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Inde
And in regards to vets. Look at us admin's reg dates. And then look at even the first users. Its far too less time to be considered a 'vet' on this forum. It's not really a question of how long people have registered to consider themselves (to use your term) 'vets', rather to know just enough that they were here before release, and so knew what it was like 'before'. It is this knowledge, which will make some older posters irritated when the influx of new posters arrives.

Should people be regarded as 'vets' because they registered themselves a few months earlier? Of course not, and it's that same reasoning which is why post counts no longer show up in these forums, but that is a discussion for another topic.

Ellestar

Ellestar

Munchking

Join Date: Mar 2005

Russian Federation, Moscow

Ladder to Hell (ATM playing with Rus Corp)

Quote:
Originally Posted by HotSnack
The worst case scenario is that Guru becomes a munchkin site, something unique to Guru due to its high level of in depth content.[/list] What's wrong with that? And what's wrong with munchkins?

Darkmane

Darkmane

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Feb 2005

Dang Spook...

That was an awsome post, I can see your not kidding about administering sites. What you spoke of is so entirely true. Are you in PR because it was so eloquently articulated. I didn't want to quote it becuase it was so long, and I didnt want to only quote half of it and cut it up because it was so good. So if your one of those people that just scans over threads and reads this short post, go back up and read Spooky's--- awsome post.

Spooky

Spooky

Bokusatsu Tenshi

Join Date: Dec 2004

Bellevue, WA

KEA

E/Mo

Heh. No, I don't do any PR work, as i'm fairly convinced that no one in their right mind would hire me. I just do fansites, mainly. If memory serves correctly, I started my first one back in '96. Since then, when something comes along that catches my eye.. i've either created sites for it myself, or became involved to help existing sites (Like OG, prior to GWG.) It's something of a nomadic lifestyle, but i've certainly picked up a good deal along the way. Who knows - some day some of it might even be useful!

William the Silent

William the Silent

Academy Page

Join Date: Mar 2005

Verona, Wisconsin

The Consulate, [Ttgr]

E/

Well my take on this whole pre-release vs. post-release gwg activity is pretty simple and similar to others.

I believe that at the initial release, there will be a slight and I repeat slight decrease in activity from the users we have right now mainly due to the fact that so many of us will be spending all of our time actually playing the game for the first week or two so some of us may have our online time more focused towards gameplaying than forum posting. After the initial 24/7 rush of people playing the game I think we will all come back here to share experiences.

While at initial release some of our activity may decrease it's almost a given that there will be a MASSIVE influx of beginners looking for help and guidance. With a great number of them coming here I'm pretty confident that after the release the gwg forum activity will actually increase. To sum it all up, my whole perspective on this situation is that while SOME (once again SOME) of us may be a little less active in the first week or two after release that will be counteracted by the flocking of *beginners* to any and every forum they can find, thus giving a net increase in gwg activity.

note: As much as I would love to be highly active during the BWE's and the post-release rush I am incredibly crunched time-wise so usually I don't have any spare online time outside of actually playing the game. It'll probably be a week or so after the release for me to get back to the multiple posts per day standing.

HotSnack

HotSnack

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Feb 2005

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ellestar
What's wrong with that? And what's wrong with munchkins? It's a matter of what you perceive as a munchkin. To me a munchkin is someone who is more than happy to use less than legitimate means to be the best. Whether that's through hacks, bots or whining at the DM etc. The Munchkin card game pretty much sums up what I think of when I hear the word munchkin, although the actual practice of munchkinism will usually be a lot less 'fun' for everyone that the munchkin has screwed over.

Of course, you could argue that Guru does not support such things and you'll be correct. But like I said, it's a worst case, doomsday scenario whereby Guru earns a reputation for being the best place to optimise your build, but instead come on to copy flavour of the month type builds before exclaiming "OMG! I am teh hax!"

Again, worst case. So don't fret too much over it.

NelZelpher

Pre-Searing Cadet

Join Date: Apr 2005

Los Angeles

i dont think forum activity will die down after the game comes out. ppl will still have a lot of qs about the game since itll be new to most of us. so ya itll be good for a long while :P

Roken

Roken

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Apr 2005

Jacksonville, Florida (US)

Corpse Ecstacy[Crps]

N/R

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lansing Kai Don
I joined after a BWE and for some reason I got hooked and am unsure how often I will post when the release comes out. Especially if I have a PvE guild to manage. There are those out there like myself, who either work, go to school, or are stuck at some grandparents house, and they can't wait to get back home to log onto GW, so they have to read and post on the forums to survive. I know in my 6th period that I read these forums instead of do my programming work.

Tall Dude

Tall Dude

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: Apr 2005

California

The forums i think wont decrease at all.......hopefully......i mean, who wouldnt come to this forum??? This is the best forum ive ever been too!!!