16 Jun 2005 at 18:38 - 3
Well, I'm not big on the GW market, but I'll give it a stab...
Not max damage - not a big deal to some, but is seems that everyone insists on having max damage (even using a max weapon that's inferior to another, which is stupid). The fact that it's not reduces its price considerably.
The damage bonus is on the wrong side of 50 - not really the "wrong" side, but in the eyes of most it is worth considerably less than the "while > 50" counterpart.
I don't see the % chance for an attribute +1 modifiers to be anything special - don't know how others see this, but I would never buy a separate upgrade piece that does this and would overwrite them with more useful upgrades. (all IMHO)
Icy damage - adds a bit of worth to it
750g (take this opinion with a very large grain of salt)