Worlds at War system encourages Racism ?

Speedy

Speedy

Academy Page

Join Date: Jun 2005

Texas

Knights of the Alliance - KoA

Mo/W

I personally have no problem with the WaW system. It encourages competition between players from different regions of the game. However, it does contribute to some hostility. I, myself, have cheered for America when we defeat Korea/Europe that is about to take favor away from us. Heck, I've even cheered for Europe when Korea is one battle away from taking favor and Europe wins, or vice-versa. In a way, the system encourages hostility, but it also (at least to me) encourages us to respect the other regions.

Personally, I wouldn't mind if the real-life regions were all taken away and added in with some fictional regions of which Koreans, Americans, and Europeans would all be able to choose to stay and fight for their fictional region and not their real-life region. Of course, we would need some sort of language districts (like in the current European region), but this would take away all of the "racism" and hostility that's happening with the current WaW system.

Maybe I'm just ranting too much. It is getting a bit late here..

funbun

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Apr 2005

I forget. Really. I don't know.

Mo/

Cheering for your favorite team is not hostility.

If I cheer for the Chicago Bulls in a basketball game that that doesn't encourage hostility toward the Detroit Pistons. The hoistility come from immature people. People are the peoblem not the game. Look at the mirror, there is the problem.

Es Onizuka

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: Jun 2005

Canada

Masters of the World

W/E

I always see messages from players saying "f****** koreans" everytime the HoH status shows up and Korea is in favor of the gods. This offends me (I'm not korean) because it's not the korean's fault that they win. If I played in the Korean Server and America was in favor of the gods, I doubt koreans would be saying what we say to them.

Sekkira

Sekkira

Forge Runner

Join Date: Apr 2005

Canberra, AU

I better chuck out my mirror then. I heard those things cause plenty of problems...

Evan The Cursed

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Jun 2005

Not if you're a warrior or necro =)

ManadartheHealer

ManadartheHealer

Desert Nomad

Join Date: May 2005

Awaiting GW2

W/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Evan The Cursed
The whole thing is just utterly irrational.
Welcome to the world. Can I take your coat?

Evan The Cursed

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Jun 2005

Quote:
Originally Posted by ManadartheHealer
Welcome to the world. Can I take your coat?
Yes. And my hat, thank you.





And I still cling to the, perhaps naive, belief that rationale and logic will always, in the end, trump irrationality. It just usually takes a long, hard time.



Ahh, the naivete. How refreshing, ne?

funbun

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Apr 2005

I forget. Really. I don't know.

Mo/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Es Onizuka
I always see messages from players saying "f****** koreans" everytime the HoH status shows up and Korea is in favor of the gods. This offends me (I'm not korean) because it's not the korean's fault that they win. If I played in the Korean Server and America was in favor of the gods, I doubt koreans would be saying what we say to them.

You don't know what they are saying. Are you in Korea?

ManadartheHealer

ManadartheHealer

Desert Nomad

Join Date: May 2005

Awaiting GW2

W/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Evan The Cursed
And I still cling to the, perhaps naive, belief that rationale and logic will always, in the end, trump irrationality
I am so, so sorry

Zelc

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: May 2005

Quote:
Originally Posted by Evan The Cursed
And I still cling to the, perhaps naive, belief that rationale and logic will always, in the end, trump irrationality. It just usually takes a long, hard time.
Maybe after a REALLY long time, there would have been enough tries at it and it actually happens. Kind of like how if you try enough times, you'll eventually win the lottery .

ManadartheHealer

ManadartheHealer

Desert Nomad

Join Date: May 2005

Awaiting GW2

W/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Zelc
Maybe after a REALLY long time, there would have been enough tries at it and it actually happens. Kind of like how if you try enough times, you'll eventually win the lottery .
Only the lottery's odds are much better

kenris

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: May 2005

Chaos Horde

R/Mo

yep this system does encourage racism
everytime korea gets favor i hear people start cursing at the koreans
the few times europe gets favor, people start cursing at the europeans
just about everytime i go to tombs and end up fighting a european team, or a korean team, peope on my team, or people on the enemy team, start cursing at each other
that rarely happens if we face another american team BUT it almost always happens when we face a non american team
ive seen some people that truely seem to have started hating koreans since they started playing this game

i think they should just throw this system out, replace it with something else, or maybe modify it, make it where its not based on real areas in the world
but it should not stay as it currently is
i really doubt they wanted it to turn out the way it has

DrSLUGFly

DrSLUGFly

Desert Nomad

Join Date: May 2005

European Server or International

I don't think they can throw the system out, it's too deeply ingrained now. However they could minimize it's importance by introducing religious factions (the GW gods) and giving them serious rewards... perhaps a several month long process could reduce the nationalism and eventually replace it entirely without much notice and complaint.

ManadartheHealer

ManadartheHealer

Desert Nomad

Join Date: May 2005

Awaiting GW2

W/

Quote:
Originally Posted by DrSLUGFly
However they could minimize it's importance by introducing religious factions...
Eh, and religious factions would never start a fight, now would they?

Ilya Khan

Ilya Khan

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Apr 2005

Los Angeles, CA

-FdM-

Me/Mo

So today, I entered the ToA... and guess what I found?

'Korea has the favor of the Gods'

Person A : -------- ---- --- ----- Koreans!
Person B : ---- Korea!
...
Person 8F: --- ---- ------- Korea!

Yes, I am guilty of doing it myself. I would not call it Racism or Nationalism. It is just a spur of the moment sort of thing. I know that I am frustrated when I enter the ToA with a good 30 min or so for a smite run or two and then find myself chasing some idiot around the ToA. If you ask me, I think that (is this even possible?) we should form a kickass international team. I am pretty sure that it would 1) eliminate this problem and 2) bring us closer together!
If anyone wants to help me try this, just PM me with your IGN and I we can try winnin the HoH

Edge Martinez

Edge Martinez

Jungle Guide

Join Date: May 2005

NC

DKL

I like the system. I'm American and play on the American server. Is it racism? I don't care. Until they fix racism in government, the workplace, schools, etc., I sure as heck am not going to lose sleep over it on a video game.

I just wish Europe was more competitive. It always seems to end up as us vs. the Koreans.

DrSLUGFly

DrSLUGFly

Desert Nomad

Join Date: May 2005

European Server or International

to Martinez... it's a wholistic thing. You can't expect your area of society to be the last to change. It has to be the first to change! Myself, I narrowly avoided a beating yesterday due to being involved in an accident (i'm white in korea). Needless to say, the prospect of any increase in retarded nationalism or racism frightens me.

to Manadar... GW gods. I added it in brackets because I suspected that someone might connect it to RL religions... How bloody dangerous would that be? "Christianity has won a match in the HoH, to take the favor of the gods from Islam, Christianity must win 3 more matches."

sweet crap!

Vermilion Okeanos

Forge Runner

Join Date: Feb 2005

nationalism does indeed taste like poison...

what one should look for is patriotism..

Shadow_Avenger

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: May 2005

Stolen Dreams

R/Me

Quote:
Originally Posted by kenris
yep this system does encourage racism
everytime korea gets favor i hear people start cursing at the koreans
the few times europe gets favor, people start cursing at the europeans
just about everytime i go to tombs and end up fighting a european team, or a korean team, peope on my team, or people on the enemy team, start cursing at each other
that rarely happens if we face another american team BUT it almost always happens when we face a non american team
ive seen some people that truely seem to have started hating koreans since they started playing this game

i think they should just throw this system out, replace it with something else, or maybe modify it, make it where its not based on real areas in the world
but it should not stay as it currently is
i really doubt they wanted it to turn out the way it has
I would suggest that its actually the americans that need to sort out there attitudes then, as I have never heard any of this on the european server.

Nationalisim, is a crock, and is set up on false ideas. The majority of which is actually promoted and stems from Capitalism. Its Capitalism that breeds in equality and racism.

Like I stated before, if you want to let a minority spoil your game that is your choice, me personally I choose to ignor them, ignor them as I would a child that is being naughty, because the naughty child is only doing it to gain attention.

DrSLUGFly

DrSLUGFly

Desert Nomad

Join Date: May 2005

European Server or International

Quote:
Originally Posted by Vermilion Okeanos
nationalism does indeed taste like poison...

what one should look for is patriotism..
synonyms dude, synonyms...

Shadow: though I like and appreciate your stand, I disagree (but only a bit). Capitalist greed doesn't help (emphasis: greed, capitalism in itself is... well... a whole new can of worms) but the biggest problem is merely difference. I look very different from Koreans and thus face racism on a daily basis. Fortunately, Koreans are generally very respectful and not violent and so I very very rarely find myself in any kind of danger from racism, but its presence still bothers me.

I can read Korean, and before I bought my own account I played on a pc cafe account on a Korean server and occasionally (definately not often) they tended towards unkindness to obviously foreign players.

As for other kinds of racism in game, I've seen little actually. I have very little to complain about in regards to in game racism and nationalism... but the constant reminder of nation vs. nation bothers me.

Schorny

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Apr 2005

Quote:
Originally Posted by Navaros
Guild Wars has the word Wars in the title

wars are all about killing other people and committing all kinds of atrocities

anyone who does not have the stomach for seeing a few bad text words in a video game should not be playing a game with the word Wars in the title
Sorry, but I'm not a 12 year old boy. I'm grown up. I can argue with someone and not insulting him. I can fight someone and congratulating them when they win. I'm grown up enough to see the difference between a game and rl.

I don't want a 12 year old boy to call me names just because I'm from europe and he is from the US.

I really can't understand that. Of course, many people are dumb. But it is NOT OK to call people names, curse on them etc. just for nothing. I mean, if I see for example see europe hold the Hall and it says just one more win and then an american team resets the counter by winning: of course I say "ah, **** it" But I don't curse the europe team for loosing or the american team for winning.

It's like sports: you wouldn't want all 'fans' of the different teams gang up and fight each other, call each other names and stuff, would you?

So please grow up and understand that it is not OK to curse other people when they haven't done anything.

And yes, the system as it is, makes things worse
I hate it when you play Tombs and all you hear is "****ing european" and such stuff... The koreans are better - they only type korean and some of there letters look funny. But I also have seen european teams curse the americans.

It really make me sick. In a grown up world (If I refer to the word "grown up" I don't mean "older than 23" but "people with a grown up mind, that don't behave childish") the WaW System would be great. But these bad words flooding around, it is really bad...

I got tired of telling people to stop saying "**** these koreans" after they won the HoH. I did it a few times, but I'm sick of talking to such people.

I don't want to sound too negative: when playing with my friends, guildmates and most random groups - everything is fine. But I play tombs only with local chat off.

eventhorizen

Banned

Join Date: May 2005

Quote:
Originally Posted by Aloren
I don't think it's the worlds at war system that has the problem, but rather the human race in general. Any nationalistic/racist attitude has the capacity to turn down the wrong path. That being said, friendly competiton has been going on in the real world for a long time. The Olympics seem to be a petty good example of this.

I personally think of myself and those around me not be nationality, but rather as a human. I hate the idea of dividing a race by invisible borders/skin color/belief systems/etc..
Yet thats exactly how each every one us has our lives moulded. To be fair religion has kind of reached and past its stage of being a key discriminatory factor, as has skin colour, but borders?

Each and every one of us holds dear the ideals that all humans are born equal. Its what our most celebrated icons have taught us, and what our leaders and forefathers and creators of our society devoted their lives and efforts to improving upon. The constitution of the USA says something about all men being equal in the eyes of God. For 2000 years Western society was christian society, and the bible preached the exact same thing.

Yet where a person is born determines what kind of life they will have, what opportunities or hardships their life will encounter. Where a person is born directly determines how long they will live and their quality of life, it directly determines what diseases they will or will not die from.

You say you do not like to think to think of mankind being divided up by race or borders, but that is exactly the life we live, and considering Western society has been the richest, most powerful society since oh about egyptian times and that our countries have been DEMOCRACIES for 100's of years, whos fault is that?

Dont preach bullsh1t, thank you very much.

Christ67

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: May 2005

You all should listen to Lenny Bruce sometime. He had some quirky ideas about racism that deserve to be heard today.

DrSLUGFly

DrSLUGFly

Desert Nomad

Join Date: May 2005

European Server or International

Quote:
Originally Posted by Schorny
It's like sports: you wouldn't want all 'fans' of the different teams gang up and fight each other, call each other names and stuff, would you?
you mean like football? (soccer)

unfortunately skin color and religion are nowhere near being phased out as discriminatory factors. When I lived in Canada, I suspected that they were both on the way out... but once you cross the ocean and get real world news instead of just North American "world" news the picture is entirely different. Likewise, visiting a few non-white countries (if you're white) or any country where you're a visible minority also clearly shows that our species is still all chained up with fear and xenophobia.

As for religion... as long as it exists it will promote intolerance, this is a guarantee. Our civilization is nearly 10,000 years old, maybe older... we outgrew our need for religion like 600 years ago yet it clings to us like a diseased parasite. The sooner we grow up and be done with it the better.

Mayar third Keeper

Mayar third Keeper

Academy Page

Join Date: Apr 2005

Can anyone rember GW befor the WaW system? We were ONE Community and we were so tingly about GW and how it grows. But now we are just "Europen losers" "American dumbasses" and "f****ing Koreans"

The reference to Real life is the point. The whole system would change if they uncouple the WaW "realms" from the real world realms and give them ingame names, as mentioned above Grenths follower or such.

This would adjust the number of players on each realm and stop the RL obscenities. But this would not stop the challenge!

salja Wachi

Banned

Join Date: Jun 2005

Chicago

the Bleeding Edge

N/Mo

the answer to that is pretty simple, next time you see any of that garabge in chat take a creenshot and send it to A-net with a complaint. thre is no room in this game for ignorant people to spew racial, religious, or anything else ofensive to others. you would be doing a great service to the game but most of all to other people playing the game by sending a screenshot and getting these useless "people" banned.