09 Nov 2005 at 01:02 - 50
My R/mo had trouble completing this mission with henchmen until I made a few changes and left the tanks at home. I previously had my points in markmenship, beast mastery, and smiting prayers. Dropped markmenship and divided the points between the other two, with a couple left over.
This was awhile back, and I'm not playing this character at the moment, so I can't remember the staff I was using. Took my level 20 cat as usual, and had charm animal, comfort animal, scourge healing, bane signet, holy strike, banish, smite, and judges insight in the bar.
Took Lina, Alesia, Reyna, Orion, and Dunham (plus the cat). Mission went like a charm. Took the advice of others on the timing, and left one enemy standing besides Josso and the priest.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Jumped right to the Doppelganger with the same build, just to get a feel for it. Of course the cat didn't show up. Just rushed in, unloaded the smites, and the doppelganger went down like a big tree in way under a minute. Couldn't believe it.
Anyway, as far as Thirsty River goes, and as others have said, there are a lot of different combinations to bring to the mission. With the henchmen tanks, I could almost but not quite take it. I think the addition of Dunham here did the trick.