Farm-Bot Invasion at Elona Reach International Dis1

Alleji

Alleji

Forge Runner

Join Date: Jan 2006

Lol and they're 55 monks. An ele is sooo much more efficient at farming Elona.

/taunts n00b botters

Matsumi

Matsumi

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Mar 2006

Quote:
Originally Posted by Wessels
Do you have the slightest idea who these people ( yes: people ) are ??
I don't think you're correct on this one, have you been to elona reach yet and checked it out? It's completely obvious that they're not people doing their job, so instead of making a big speech about how they're just people (which I'm sure some are, but not all), take a look. Hang out there for a while and notice the patterns and running into walls, and it will start to sink in a little.

jciardha

jciardha

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Sep 2005

International Districts

The Labyrinth of Night [LoN]

Me/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Exoudeous
they are all over the normal districts too

they better not mess elona farming up, im like reallllly close to getting fissure armor.
Fissure armor, hell. I farm Elona for the dune burrower jaws to give to people so they can complete their collector armor. There goes my charity if that goes to pot.

remmeh

remmeh

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Nov 2005

Apathy Inc [AI]

R/Mo

haha that toa screenie (p1) is golden.

Nivryx

Nivryx

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Mar 2006

Kenya

Mo/

thats so wierd....i was just farming elonas today with my ranger and noticed that there were a bunch of monks just standing at the merchant.....i suppose its human nature to take something great and try to ruin it (not talking about elona farming specifically, but refering to guildwars as 'something great')

God Apprentice

God Apprentice

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Mar 2006

Mo/N

Quote:
Originally Posted by Wessels
I'm pretty much fed up with comments like these . Do you comprehend why these pro-farmers are there???? Did you all ever stop and think
why gold is being sold on the net ???

Do you have the slightest idea who these people ( yes: people ) are ??

i suggest you read this article :

http://www.iht.com/articles/2005/12/...ess/gaming.php

in full.

he only reason these people are there is that it is their job . They gather gold for those of us purchasing that gold from the sites . If there wasn't a demand to purchase gw-gold those folks wouldn't be there in the first place ( or at droknar , augury etc. ) . If you read that article you can also see what they themselves earn doing this : a measly US$250 /month .
Selling GW currency for real world money is a VIOLATION of the End User Agreement License.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Wessels
Next question is : why do people want to purchase gold in the first place ??? I have yet to see anyone addressing this very basic question . Let's see :

- A-net introduced über-items ( greens ) and FoW armor to have some kind of "top -of- the game " rewards for dedicated players .

However ( and here's the reason gold is being sold ) : there is no accomplishment involved at all in acquiring these items . The only way to get your hands on FoW-armor or on some rare green is to farm those areas pretty much constantly ( no skill involved : going in- and - out all the time using same builds all the time ) to get "lucky" . This prevents people who play the game normally from ever getting their hands on those items .People who do normal questing, helping guildies etc. will never get FoW-armor because they don't farm constantly to get the materials or gold .
So you would rather there be a sort of caste system? Where there are a select few who can aquire the good green items good armor and be filthy rich, while the rest are left out? Lets not forget Anet wants this game to have some form of balance.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Wessels
And this regardless of how much they have played , skillpoints,xp etc.

They are being "penalized" for playing normally . Those items are available only to those who:

- do nothing but farm ( the distinction between these people and bot-farmers is very hard to make , only difference is they don't get paid for it and they don't offer it on the net )
-are so disgusted in the end they decide to purchase gold of the net .
Im not some major uber farmer but i dont feel penalyzed and disgusted that I would ever go buy gold.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Wessels
Check out deldrimor war camp local chat ( or TOA local chat ) , these places are filled with pro-farmers , and again: because they don't sell it for real cash on the net we accept it .Try getting someone to do an actual quest in those places !
I see ppl ask for ppl for DNKP all the time, and Anet has nothing against farming so what is the problem here?Now wait a sec in this it sounds like youre saying NERF FARMING TO BRING BALANCE.....

Quote:
Originally Posted by Wessels
If I ever see someone trying to "block" exits at droknar or any other place I'll pretty much tell him/her what I think of that in local chat .Those farmers are doing their job in ensuring a supply of glod because there is a demand for it .No demand = no need for pro-farmers .

So leave them alone .
....and now you're saying support farming? Or more please dont get rid of the bot farmers who trade this for real world currency since they will lose their jobs? Erm what is the point you are trying to clarify here? Trading for real world money once again is against the EULA


Quote:
Originally Posted by Wessels
The only way this can be remedied is to totally rethink the meaning of "accomplishment " .Would A-net care to explain to me what's so great ( in terms of skill , great playing etc. ) about going into UW/FoW time and time again , with exact same builds , not for doing quests but to harvest and farm ???

They have stated repeatedly they don't condone people soloing any area ( UW was prime example ) but at the same time they ensure the only way to amass materials or gold for FoW armor is to do exactly that.
This really looks like some kind of: ANet zomg nerf the 55 sorta thread

Its your money you bought the game. If you want to go and farm and get FoW armor good for you that is your accomplishment, if you dont want to and instead want to quest and beat the games story taht can be an accomplishment for you. Or perhaps learning a run youve never done. Please dont try to justify that the jobs of these bot farmers are a good thing. They are violating the EULA and cause ANet grief having to hunt them down

GloryFox

GloryFox

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Jan 2006

Good ol' USA, where everyone else wants to be

Now Plays World of Warcraft on Whisperwind

I found a way to spot some BOTs in TOA (many of you know this). If you invite a Monk Mo/x and walk outside they will immediately begin running their BOT program and start 55 monking the monsters outside. (No normal player will do this with a group from TOA) Also they will not respond to any chat questions whatsoever, so if you speak to them and ask questions they will not return with answers. Personally I am beginning to write down names and sending the information with screen shots to Anet. This BOT issue has to STOP. I earned my 15k armor and can’t stand it when people who farm less than me start getting fissure armor and the best items in the because they can afford it. No offense to people to make money ligit in the game.

Nater

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Nov 2005

Illusion Of Skill

W/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Stockholm
They make them, anywhere on the internet today you have chines hackers trying to get in to computers. I sat one day and traced the IP's that pingd my computer and 84 % where traced to china. China has the highest % of hackers vs. users today so making a couple of bot's is no problem.
The bot's you download is full of keyloggers, yes they steal your account and resell it or trancefer your possesions to some1 else and delete your characters, and you can do nothing since you where trying to run a bot.
For the chines it's big bussines to run bot's and sell the gold on ebay, it brings real dollars in to the chines economy and gives ppl a job.
Whats funny is the Chinese goverment cracks down on political propaganda the people have access to on the net, but let shit like this go unchecked.

lyra_song

lyra_song

Hell's Protector

Join Date: Oct 2005

R/Mo

Why bot farming in GW isnt as bad as other games: Instanced Zones

You cant get KS, or even PK by a bot farmer. They cant camp a specific bad guy, and deny you of an item.

Imagine if Guild Wars wasnt running isntanced zones...

eternal pho

Banned

Join Date: Nov 2005

The Licious Fame Farmers {TLG}

W/E

ok first off u guys, who the Hell cares about bots( theyre not doing any of us harm ) they dont affect your drop rate

and btw not all of them r bots...

jackie

jackie

/retired

Join Date: Dec 2005

On the Beach

Quote:
Originally Posted by eternal pho
ok first off u guys, who the Hell cares about bots( theyre not doing any of us harm ) they dont affect your drop rate

and btw not all of them r bots...
I'm just going to do ^_^ for this post.

For sure bots are everybody's friends. I always hang out with couple of them and chat in some peaceful place like Maguuma Stade. And the best is that they give free upgrade items for everyone in Droknar's Forge!

Nivryx

Nivryx

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Mar 2006

Kenya

Mo/

Quote:
Originally Posted by eternal pho
ok first off u guys, who the Hell cares about bots( theyre not doing any of us harm ) they dont affect your drop rate

and btw not all of them r bots...
it won't affect our drop rate...YET. anet could end up nerfing it if they can't bring down the botting any other way.

uberstu

uberstu

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: May 2005

Raging Warriors

it's kinda weird so many bots moved to elona. i still cant figure out how they can continue to run so many bots without fear of having the account closed and losing the cost of the account. really, can't anet see all these obvious bots? there is NO WAY they are human-control... at least not the mass of monks i saw.

Phoenix Ex

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Nov 2005

Mo/R

Its probably because there ARE humans watching the bots, and ANet can't really prove anything unless they msg the bot and get no response but keep moving at the same time.

But seriously, if ANET didn't nerf every way to acquire good money in the game , there would not be a need for those bots anyways. Not to mention the TRUE filthy rich people are those created by ANet's stupid HOD sword removal(but not entirely), rune traders reset, rockmolder nerf, FFS nerf...etc etc. Those who are lucky enough to mass stock on those items before anet removed them probably have 10millions+ gold, why aren't those ppl being blamed for inflation?

No, I don't support bots, but its annoying how people keep ranting about bots but don't care about the reason for them in the first place.

Fay Vert

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Apr 2006

R/

ANet could stop it in 5 seconds without needing to nerf any area. You don't need proof it's obvious to anyone that takes the trouble to go there and look.

natuxatu

natuxatu

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Apr 2006

Wisconsin

Rt/Mo

Sorry I had to create an account just to post the obvious. Bots aren't okay and a slap in the face to people who play it the right way. There is no excuse for them even if they don't effect me. That being said I'm going to go check it out for myself heh and yeah that screen shot was funny... and as the poster above said it looks extremely obvious.

Canadian Bacon

Krytan Explorer

Join Date: Jan 2006

Ontario, Canada

Kingdom of Tyria [KoT]

Wessels,

this thread is about BOTS not SWEATSHOPS. Yous eem to have the 2 confused.

I have no problem with "pro farmers" as long as they are real people. Sweatshops do suck though. Something could be done about that.

I speak for myself here, but i suspect there are others with me on this: as a casual gamer who doesn't enjoy farming in the least, I have absolutely 0 interest in obtaining FoW armor. None at all. The thought hardly crosse smy mind. As for greens, in my opinion green items were introduced to drive in-game prices down by introducing a max stats item that can be easily obtained. Since poeple farm them endlessly, the market becomes flooded, and that green's price drops (along with a gold or purple item of the same stats). All of a sudden, the casual non-farmer like me can pop into any populated area and offer to buy his desired green. In most cases, the green can be bought and equipped before lunchtime.

Having the best items isn't necessary to be good at GW, PvE or PvP. If people choose to by gold over the net, it is because they choose to take the lazy way (opening their wallet rather than opening up the head of a dwarf with an axe), not because they are "disgusted".

ArianeB

Academy Page

Join Date: Mar 2006

Arthur

E/Mo

I wonder if you could hack the bots? i.e. find a way to get on a team with one of them and then leech?

Probably not. My guess though is that eventually it will get nerfed the same way griffon farming got nerfed.

Watch for a new named minotaur boss with "devastating hammer" coming to an Elona Reach district near you.

makosi

makosi

Grotto Attendant

Join Date: Mar 2006

"Pre-nerf" is incorrect. It's pre-buff.

Requirement Begins With R [notQ]

Me/

Do the bot creators actually get a return on the capital employed? I mean do they get their money's worth from the runes/skills/armour? I checked dunes ID1 and its now a popular tourist location to point and laugh at the poorly programmed bots

Lady Lozza

Lady Lozza

Forge Runner

Join Date: Dec 2005

Oz

Angel Sharks

Me/N

The bots in Elona really are an amazing site. If you think there are people behind them just jump to ID1 and take a look. It will not take you long to change your mind. Watchout hydras, seems like Elona will not be a safe place to be farming in the future.

twicky_kid

twicky_kid

Furnace Stoker

Join Date: Jun 2005

Quite Vulgar [FUN]

The more Anet nerfs farming spots the more saturation you going to see in the left over spots.

To bots it really doesn't matter if its crap drops. 2 minute run at max and just leave the bot running. Sell everything that drops.

TheMosesPHD

TheMosesPHD

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Feb 2006

Oregon

Mo Mo Patty Blinks [MoMo]

R/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr Strangelove
I say let them keep it, elona has incredibly low profit potential, maybe 200 gold per run at most, and anti-farm kicks in very quickly. Unless, of course, they're using as crop rotation from troll runs, in which case I say burn em all. The farmers really do seem to pick the worst places to farm. Me, I take the frost giants and tengu just past the trolls in the shiverpeaks, or just clear most of the map outside dunes of despair.
That would make sense because I've always wondered where they go to reset the troll/avicara drops. You know they've got to be doing this because if anyone has ever farmed those trolls/avicara, you'll know that the first couple days of farming those guys is great but after that it turns into absolute trash. I now use the troll/avicara run to help reset the other stuff I farm

stupenduzzman

Academy Page

Join Date: Dec 2005

Mo/

Anet cant keep nerfing everything because soon there will be nothing to farm anymore

(please dont touch my mursaat farming spot ^^)

HawkofStorms

HawkofStorms

Hall Hero

Join Date: Aug 2005

E/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr Strangelove
I say let them keep it, elona has incredibly low profit potential, maybe 200 gold per run at most, and anti-farm kicks in very quickly. Unless, of course, they're using as crop rotation from troll runs, in which case I say burn em all. The farmers really do seem to pick the worst places to farm. Me, I take the frost giants and tengu just past the trolls in the shiverpeaks, or just clear most of the map outside dunes of despair.
Actually, on my VERY first elona run with my solo ele, I got a minatuar to drop a black dye. I can also kill the dune burrowers there (granted they die slowly due to healing spring, can't all be aggroed at once, and don't drop much).

lyra_song

lyra_song

Hell's Protector

Join Date: Oct 2005

R/Mo

I love the Elona run, and its sad that its come to this.

I consider it the most efficient farming run around. Its a 3 minute run with a total of gold in drops and white items from 300-800. A good 1 hour run will net you quite a lot.

Of course...i get bored after 5-6 runs. o.o

Lady Lozza

Lady Lozza

Forge Runner

Join Date: Dec 2005

Oz

Angel Sharks

Me/N

That's the thing about Elona, you can farm for half and hour and get enough out of it to not farm for the rest of the week. Yeah the drops aren't great, but it is so quick and easy that half an hour can yield a lot of runs.

I was hoping Elona would be somewhat safe because it was a mission area. Guess I was wrong

Age

Age

Hall Hero

Join Date: Jul 2005

California Canada/BC

STG Administrator

Mo/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Vlad Titanskin
You want to know something about those Monks in the SS is that is all they are made up for sole purpose of farming.They are giving Mo/W a bad name and build as I see lots of these standing in Draknor's Forge and Amnoon Oasis at level2 with presearing armor on.They will never make good Monks when being run through the game.This is one of the reasons the Monk superior runes are so high compared to others although Necros are catching up with the 55 Necro.

Reading futher.What is a bot program :?:

Ristaron

Ristaron

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Mar 2005

Canada, eh?

Legion Of Valhalla

E/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Wessels
I'm pretty much fed up with comments like these . Do you comprehend why these pro-farmers are there???? Did you all ever stop and think
why gold is being sold on the net ???

Do you have the slightest idea who these people ( yes: people ) are ??

i suggest you read this article :

http://www.iht.com/articles/2005/12/...ess/gaming.php

in full.

he only reason these people are there is that it is their job . They gather gold for those of us purchasing that gold from the sites . If there wasn't a demand to purchase gw-gold those folks wouldn't be there in the first place ( or at droknar , augury etc. ) . If you read that article you can also see what they themselves earn doing this : a measly US$250 /month .

Next question is : why do people want to purchase gold in the first place ??? I have yet to see anyone addressing this very basic question . Let's see :

- A-net introduced über-items ( greens ) and FoW armor to have some kind of "top -of- the game " rewards for dedicated players .

However ( and here's the reason gold is being sold ) : there is no accomplishment involved at all in acquiring these items . The only way to get your hands on FoW-armor or on some rare green is to farm those areas pretty much constantly ( no skill involved : going in- and - out all the time using same builds all the time ) to get "lucky" . This prevents people who play the game normally from ever getting their hands on those items .People who do normal questing, helping guildies etc. will never get FoW-armor because they don't farm constantly to get the materials or gold .

And this regardless of how much they have played , skillpoints,xp etc.

They are being "penalized" for playing normally . Those items are available only to those who:

- do nothing but farm ( the distinction between these people and bot-farmers is very hard to make , only difference is they don't get paid for it and they don't offer it on the net )
-are so disgusted in the end they decide to purchase gold of the net .

Check out deldrimor war camp local chat ( or TOA local chat ) , these places are filled with pro-farmers , and again: because they don't sell it for real cash on the net we accept it .Try getting someone to do an actual quest in those places !

If I ever see someone trying to "block" exits at droknar or any other place I'll pretty much tell him/her what I think of that in local chat .Those farmers are doing their job in ensuring a supply of glod because there is a demand for it .No demand = no need for pro-farmers .

So leave them alone .


The only way this can be remedied is to totally rethink the meaning of "accomplishment " .Would A-net care to explain to me what's so great ( in terms of skill , great playing etc. ) about going into UW/FoW time and time again , with exact same builds , not for doing quests but to harvest and farm ???

They have stated repeatedly they don't condone people soloing any area ( UW was prime example ) but at the same time they ensure the only way to amass materials or gold for FoW armor is to do exactly that.
I was unaware that bots were paid, or even had a need for money after they've been equipped with the proper skills and equipment to farm an area they're programmed for.

Spazztic2003

Ascalonian Squire

Join Date: Apr 2006

The Vanguard of Honor

W/

Gaile, any word on this? I've sent about 5 reports in. GROWING SICK OF THIS!

I know that Chinese farmers exist in every game, but this one is different because you guys are anti-farming and you don't want people running the same area! Ban the bots, or nerf the drops!

Ristaron

Ristaron

Desert Nomad

Join Date: Mar 2005

Canada, eh?

Legion Of Valhalla

E/

Quote:
Originally Posted by Spazztic2003
Ban the bots, or nerf the drops!
Preferrably the former! I'm sick and tired of being punished for the ignorance and lack of consideration of others.

Witchblade

Witchblade

Polar Bear Attendant

Join Date: May 2005

yeah sure bots in Elona.. i hope for their owner that Factions ll include sets crafted with Minotaur Horns

btw i dont wanna see another nerf of drops or a change in monster spawning cauz of those jerks.. just ban em..thats all
if drops are nerfed.. bots are winning since they run 24/7

Gros Albert

Gros Albert

Frost Gate Guardian

Join Date: Dec 2005

In an EB Game ^^

R/

[IMG][/IMG]



OMG...drok is worst...well....bot sucks...better make my own money than a program do it for me...

ghostlyranger

Lion's Arch Merchant

Join Date: Nov 2005

Quote:
Originally Posted by Matsumi
I don't think you're correct on this one, have you been to elona reach yet and checked it out? It's completely obvious that they're not people doing their job, so instead of making a big speech about how they're just people (which I'm sure some are, but not all), take a look. Hang out there for a while and notice the patterns and running into walls, and it will start to sink in a little.

i don't think you are correct too, it is much more like a dude is working for a local company to monitor all the bots.

and then the company will sell the golds to some well known gold trader site like ige.

natuxatu

natuxatu

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Apr 2006

Wisconsin

Rt/Mo

The fact is a person isn't doing all the work. Someone did the work to make the program but that's it. You can't call letting a program run while you do whatever you want work or play for that matter.

The bots need to be banned I can't see how anyone would argue otherwise. It's not allowed simple as that. Or the majority of people would have a bot running when they weren't playing the game. As for drops i think the point is that they aren't great... as it obviously is going through and selling everything in their inventory so black dye to drop would be worth 25g or 10g or whatever it goes for to merchants.

Maria The Princess

Maria The Princess

Forge Runner

Join Date: Mar 2006

Aequitas Deis

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ristaron
I was unaware that bots were paid, or even had a need for money after they've been equipped with the proper skills and equipment to farm an area they're programmed for.
a bot can tun 24/7. its a program that just does automaticly what its programmed to do (heal breese, prot spirit etc), so i "farmer" turns on the PC, runs the bot, and goes back to sleep, while the bot is doin money. few days, and you get 100k

Maria The Princess

Maria The Princess

Forge Runner

Join Date: Mar 2006

Aequitas Deis

Quote:
Originally Posted by natuxatu
The fact is a person isn't doing all the work. Someone did the work to make the program but that's it. You can't call letting a program run while you do whatever you want work or play for that matter.

The bots need to be banned I can't see how anyone would argue otherwise. It's not allowed simple as that. Or the majority of people would have a bot running when they weren't playing the game. As for drops i think the point is that they aren't great... as it obviously is going through and selling everything in their inventory so black dye to drop would be worth 25g or 10g or whatever it goes for to merchants.
sadly, at merchant any dye is 1g

Wretchman Drake

Wretchman Drake

Jungle Guide

Join Date: Sep 2005

Charr Carvings and [BeeR]

Every MMO has problems like this. I think recently WoW deleted over like 60,000 accts because of dupped items and hacking. Garbage with gold in games always happens like this. But instead of nerfing farming all together, they should just eliminate the possibilities of bots...

Maria The Princess

Maria The Princess

Forge Runner

Join Date: Mar 2006

Aequitas Deis

Quote:
Originally Posted by Wretchman Drake
Every MMO has problems like this. I think recently WoW deleted over like 60,000 accts because of dupped items and hacking. Garbage with gold in games always happens like this. But instead of nerfing farming all together, they should just eliminate the possibilities of bots...
at least a few mesmers spawing randomly....if youre a living person you can take em, if its a bot.... return to outpust

Miraculix B.

Miraculix B.

Wilds Pathfinder

Join Date: Jul 2005

in my kingdom cold

i dont know if this vid has already been around here. its about chinese goldfarmers.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ho5Yxe6UVv4

Poison Ivy

Poison Ivy

Forge Runner

Join Date: Jan 2006

Toronto

Hopping

Mo/A

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lady Lozza
But no one would seriously buy anything in Elona ID one. Why don't they just farm in their home dist, then jump to Droks ID for selling???
Because they don't have one.