Did ANet make staffs useless?
Isaac Lunoa
It seems to me as though staffs are completely useless now that +5 energy swords and axes are widely available (technically they were useless before, but you needed a HoD sword, which isn't common). If you look at it, a 20/20 Insightful Staff of Enchanting, Defense, or Fortitude would be the same as a +5 energy sword or axe with the same mod and a 20/20 focus -- but with two less energy. Can anyone clear this up?
RotteN
insightfull isn't the only staffhead around ... so no, staffs aren't useless, infact, many casters will still use staffs with +60HP/+10armor/... (any other combo that doesn't include an insightfull head)
VGJustice
Staves and Wands are not totally useless. You can't attack if your monk has a sword (not that wanding things does much damage). So, you have to be careful about using your spacebar, because there's a new risk of accidently moving right next to your enemy group. Which would be bad.
So, it's a toss up between getting 2 more energy or being a little bit safer. An experienced caster wouldn't care so much, but an inexperienced one would find this troubling.
So, it's a toss up between getting 2 more energy or being a little bit safer. An experienced caster wouldn't care so much, but an inexperienced one would find this troubling.
Canadian Bacon
I have always prefered staves over wands and HoD swords, and I don't plan on changing that.
Burakus Lightwing
I use a +60 staff on my ele. I don't feel it's useless. I would never think about equiping a sword with him and I'd rather have the extra +30hp over the +5 energy.
Retribution X
Personally, I'd pick the sword, Because my monk looks chic with a katana, but, suit yourself.
Also, I've NEVER needed to target an enemy in PvE with my monk, cept in pre.
Also, I've NEVER needed to target an enemy in PvE with my monk, cept in pre.
Mandy Memory
staff = +5 energy(+5 armor, +30 health) 20/20 recharge/cast and +1 attributes
sword = no damage +5 energy 20 enchanting(or +5 armor) 20 recharge or 20 cast and +1 attribute
or = no damage +5 energy 20 enchanting(or +5 armor or +30 health) 20/20 recast/recharge
So yes its better in the cases where you use enchantments and want 20/20 recharge, but it lacks in the area where you want +1 attribute, beacuse you cant get that on a sword.
sword = no damage +5 energy 20 enchanting(or +5 armor) 20 recharge or 20 cast and +1 attribute
or = no damage +5 energy 20 enchanting(or +5 armor or +30 health) 20/20 recast/recharge
So yes its better in the cases where you use enchantments and want 20/20 recharge, but it lacks in the area where you want +1 attribute, beacuse you cant get that on a sword.