Song Rui:Eviscerate, Executioner's Strike, Penetrating Blow, Tiger's Fury, Healing Signet, Sprint, Signet of Capture, Resurrection Signet.
Yes that is my current skillbar. Wouldn't it be great to let your party know your skillbar? You can finally kick that wammo with mending or the E/Me that uses echo fire storm. It would help both pvpers and pvers.
/signed
The ability to show your skillbar to your party.
Song Rui
S!carius
I think that this could be good for only one thing. Getting rid of solo monks joining 8 man groups for uw.
Kicking the wammo with mending may be useful in somecases, but sometimes mending can be quite usefull. Finding a group that doesn't want the cookie cutter build is hard enough, with this ability, there will be even more discrimination going on.
/NOT signed
Kicking the wammo with mending may be useful in somecases, but sometimes mending can be quite usefull. Finding a group that doesn't want the cookie cutter build is hard enough, with this ability, there will be even more discrimination going on.
/NOT signed
Song Rui
Edited by Ashleigh McMahon: Keep your bad comments to yourself.
Replicant
/NOTsigned
Song Rui, you're asking for a flame war by posting what you said about mending. it'd be like me kicking you out of my group cause you were bringing troll unguent.. theres nothing wrong with mending and actually helps out the Monks with helping neutralize degen and have a constant healing.. I personally always run Mending + Balth. Spirit, but i really don't care if you don't like it.
*edited to /NOTsigned*
Song Rui, you're asking for a flame war by posting what you said about mending. it'd be like me kicking you out of my group cause you were bringing troll unguent.. theres nothing wrong with mending and actually helps out the Monks with helping neutralize degen and have a constant healing.. I personally always run Mending + Balth. Spirit, but i really don't care if you don't like it.
*edited to /NOTsigned*
Sidra
/Notsigned. There is nothing wrong with mending, and some wammos are quite useful. Anyway. This is useless. It's just another way to discriminate and have builds stolen by forcing members to show their skillbars.
Edited by Ashleigh McMahon: Keep bad comments out, please.
Edited by Ashleigh McMahon: Keep bad comments out, please.
Song Rui
Laff. Troll Ungeunt > Mending. I'd never use Troll Ungeunt anyway. Only self heal a warrior should ever bring is healing-signet. Warriors need energy for their defensive stances. +3 Health Regeneration is NOTHING. Go ahead, keep talking about your godly skill, known as mending.
Song Rui
Oh come on. This game is all about cookie cutters. Otherwise we wouldn't have 5000+ wammos with mending and power attack. This is not an anti mending petition, I was using mending as an example seeing as so many wammo cookie cutters run it, and they are usually more of a burden than a help to the party.
Sidra
The suggestion would never go through either way.
Malice Black
/signed
good idea
good idea
Replicant
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Song Rui
Laff. Troll Ungeunt > Mending. I'd never use Troll Ungeunt anyway. Only self heal a warrior should ever bring is healing-signet. Warriors need energy for their defensive stances. +3 Health Regeneration is NOTHING. Go ahead, keep talking about your godly skill, known as mending.
|
have you ever played as a W/Mo? I have 27 Energy I do 2 Enchant Spells which Keep my Health and Energy bars maxed out.. I have no problem ever with energy so whatever problems you have with energy is your own fault... btw.. they made the Zealous Mod for a reason... if i ever do have problems with energy i switch to my zealous and normal attack... if i have things attackin me melee i put up bonetties and problem solved.
and i agree with the past people.
*retracts original /signed and switches it to /notsigned*
Edited by Ashleigh McMahon: Blooming hell, isn't this a flame bait.
Hockster
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Song Rui
Laff. Troll Ungeunt > Mending. I'd never use Troll Ungeunt anyway. Only self heal a warrior should ever bring is healing-signet. Warriors need energy for their defensive stances. +3 Health Regeneration is NOTHING. Go ahead, keep talking about your godly skill, known as mending.
|
Troll is a good self heal id you have points into expertise to reduce the energy cost. But you're a warrior, no expertise.
Nine or ten second stances with 45-60 second cooldowns? Stances are great if you know for a fact they won't be ended early. Unless you'r using ranger stances, which means putting points into your secondary attribute line. That also means you're less effective at dealing damage.
In case you don't get it, I'm not defending mending, even though in the right situation it is a very viable skill. Just don't paint yourself further into a corner by not seeing the whole story.
/not signed either
AydenV2
A nice /slase command for displaying your guild bar would be a welcomed addition I think.
Nothing fancy, just the names of the skills.
Nothing fancy, just the names of the skills.
Song Rui
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Replicant
have you ever played as a W/Mo? I have 27 Energy I do 2 Enchant Spells which Keep my Health and Energy bars maxed out.. I have no problem ever with energy so whatever problems you have with energy is your own fault... btw.. they made the Zealous Mod for a reason... if i ever do have problems with energy i switch to my zealous and normal attack... if i have things attackin me melee i put up bonetties and problem solved.
|
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Replicant
*retracts original /signed and switches it to /notsigned*
|
Edited by Ashleigh McMahon: Flame....
Song Rui
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Hockster
Wild Blow>Stances
|
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Hockster
Troll is a good self heal id you have points into expertise to reduce the energy cost. But you're a warrior, no expertise.
|
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Hockster
Nine or ten second stances with 45-60 second cooldowns? Stances are great if you know for a fact they won't be ended early. Unless you'r using ranger stances, which means putting points into your secondary attribute line. That also means you're less effective at dealing damage.
|
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Hockster
In case you don't get it, I'm not defending mending, even though in the right situation it is a very viable skill. Just don't paint yourself further into a corner by not seeing the whole story.
/not signed either |
minor
Stop the crap about mending and everything else plz; this is a good idea.
I have gotten so sick of asking or being asked to type out my skillbar, particulary in HA.
This would be a great option, theres so many ppl wasting time typing out skill bars and lying about it sometimes
.
/signed
I have gotten so sick of asking or being asked to type out my skillbar, particulary in HA.
This would be a great option, theres so many ppl wasting time typing out skill bars and lying about it sometimes
./signed
bilateralrope
In PvE this will be abused forcing people to run cookie cutter builds or nothing. However in PvP, it would be very useful to make sure everyone is running the build you asked them to instead of saying they are running your build, but instead running something else.
/signed on the condition that it only works in PvP outposts.
/signed on the condition that it only works in PvP outposts.
baz777
/signed
Agree, good idea
Agree, good idea
mariano
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Song Rui
Song Rui:Eviscerate, Executioner's Strike, Penetrating Blow, Tiger's Fury, Healing Signet, Sprint, Signet of Capture, Resurrection Signet.
|
/signed
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Song Rui
You can finally kick that wammo with mending or the E/Me that uses echo fire storm. It would help both pvpers and pvers.
|
Terra Xin
This has been suggetsed before, and the majority of people who responded answered like this:
/notsigned.
Look for the thread yourself, its here somewhere.
/notsigned.
Look for the thread yourself, its here somewhere.
Song Rui
I see that the greatest factor for anti signing is elitism and the ability to only run cookie cutters. Well guess what?
If a farm group is looking for an SS necromancer, they are looking for an SS necromancer. Not an MM. If you want to join their group, you must be a cookie cutter SS necromancer. Well? How is the skillbar issue going to affect anything?
You don't get to choose what you want to run here unless you are in control of the party.
In missions, anything goes. They don't really care what you're running. It doesn't matter here.
In PvP, you play to win. They can't afford to have a Shock Warrior running with Cleave because he hasn't unlocked Eviscerate yet.
If a farm group is looking for an SS necromancer, they are looking for an SS necromancer. Not an MM. If you want to join their group, you must be a cookie cutter SS necromancer. Well? How is the skillbar issue going to affect anything?
You don't get to choose what you want to run here unless you are in control of the party.
In missions, anything goes. They don't really care what you're running. It doesn't matter here.
In PvP, you play to win. They can't afford to have a Shock Warrior running with Cleave because he hasn't unlocked Eviscerate yet.
Hunter Sharparrow
I was going to agree for the reason that this would help teams create builds that work off each other. However that can already be done by simply telling your team what skills you have to bring and what ones you planned on taking. An option to show others your skill bar would probably create more problems than anything. There is enough descrimination in this game as it is and there is no room for changes that would only cause more.
/notsigned
/notsigned
dag_nefzen
/signed
Will save a lot of time. I don't want to be taking the same spirits as another Rt in the group.
I'm not even going to start with the Mending thing...
Will save a lot of time. I don't want to be taking the same spirits as another Rt in the group.
I'm not even going to start with the Mending thing...
Tarun
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Hunter Sharparrow
On a side note, check this site out.
Me thinks Gaile is a bit mad.... http://www.arenanet.beeplog.com/ GO GAILE!!!! All I can say is one thing towards Anet. Where will you be without us players? |
And for this topic.
/notsigned
Reason: People are already extremely picky and whiney about things (Look at a majority of PvP with the ranks and other crap), this idea would just filter in more of that crap to PvE.
Replicant
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Hunter Sharparrow
On a side note, check this site out.
Me thinks Gaile is a bit mad.... http://www.arenanet.beeplog.com/ GO GAILE!!!! All I can say is one thing towards Anet. Where will you be without us players? |
Hunter Sharparrow
Yup just found that out. Removed...
Dougal Kronik
For PvE
/NOT SIGNED
For PvP
/signed
/NOT SIGNED
For PvP
/signed
Kitty Soft
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Song Rui
I'd much rather have a wammo running Watchful Spirit + Balthazars spirit or using Purge Signet with Succor. Wammos like that are a much more helpful addition to the party. And I wouldn't just kick them, I'd give them tips and tell them to change a few skills. I've done it before, if they comply, they can run with us. But many times I am partyed with an E/Me using Fire storm and ruining all the aggro. This would give us a chance to HELP these people!
|
rezabm
Maybe Ctrl+Click on skillbar in outpost/town could list your skills names to team chat similar to Ctrl+click on your Health/Energy? And it should be easy enough to implement. It can help with putting a team build together a lot.
Evilsod
Well it would be nice to kick people for bringing skills that do nothing but screw up the rest of your group. Firestorm been the obvious example, as is the 55 monk, but surely if you suspect a 55 monk (they aren't exactly the most creative of Mo/Ws are they?) You kick them anyway! Mending was a bad choice, that skill can be quite useful in some areas, and also these late game areas you were talking about, eg, Mursaat ridden ones, the only thing that has enchantment removal there are the Ether Seals.
How often does a warrior bringing Cleave instead of Eviscerate happen in PvP exactly? Or was it in fact you.
/notsigned
However nice it would be to show your skillbar at the click of a button instead of typing it out, this would just make things worse when you took that 1 skill the leader disagreed with and kicked you. And exactly why should a Monk always carry Healing Seed? If you want to get the shit kicked out of you because you didn't bring any stances and ran that far away from the monk (even if you are luring) thats your own damn fault, don't rely on us to save your arse all the time, use your brain!
Also, Wild Blow appears on Jade Armours yes, Charr warriors and of course as you seem to have forgotten, Skeleton Berserkers.
How often does a warrior bringing Cleave instead of Eviscerate happen in PvP exactly? Or was it in fact you.
/notsigned
However nice it would be to show your skillbar at the click of a button instead of typing it out, this would just make things worse when you took that 1 skill the leader disagreed with and kicked you. And exactly why should a Monk always carry Healing Seed? If you want to get the shit kicked out of you because you didn't bring any stances and ran that far away from the monk (even if you are luring) thats your own damn fault, don't rely on us to save your arse all the time, use your brain!
Also, Wild Blow appears on Jade Armours yes, Charr warriors and of course as you seem to have forgotten, Skeleton Berserkers.
G.S.
And what prevents you to change your build after showing it to the team?
Oh no... imagine this... A warrior shows his build
and then presses K and puts Mending instead of Healing Sig! (I do not play a warrior and I'm not saying Mending is either good or bad 
)
I think it's a good idea... not for stopping mending wammos, but it would be nice... so I will
/sign
P.S. I know there is no such thing as W/R/Mo.
Oh no... imagine this... A warrior shows his build
Quote:
| Song Rui:Eviscerate, Executioner's Strike, Penetrating Blow, Tiger's Fury, Healing Signet, Sprint, Signet of Capture, Resurrection Signet. |
)I think it's a good idea... not for stopping mending wammos, but it would be nice... so I will
/sign
P.S. I know there is no such thing as W/R/Mo.
Eviance
Here is an idea - instead of KICKING the warrior for taking mending the monk should assure that person that they can keep them well healed and ASK them to change it.
And warriors have addrenaline based skills for a reason o_O I only use 3 energy skills and only use mending when solo farming and it helps. In a group I try to stick with only healing sig and addrenaline based skills - if I have an excellent monk at my back for HA or something I usually don't take any self heal at all no matter what class I play.
/signed for convienence but at the same time if it will encourage kickers /not signed!
This is a tough one!
And warriors have addrenaline based skills for a reason o_O I only use 3 energy skills and only use mending when solo farming and it helps. In a group I try to stick with only healing sig and addrenaline based skills - if I have an excellent monk at my back for HA or something I usually don't take any self heal at all no matter what class I play.
/signed for convienence but at the same time if it will encourage kickers /not signed!
This is a tough one!
Snow Board Guy
/signed
luv ur idea
luv ur idea
Kai Nui
Good idea, easy fast way to let my team members know what I have incase they have some suggestions.
Song Rui
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Evilsod
Mending was a bad choice, that skill can be quite useful in some areas, and also these late game areas you were talking about, eg, Mursaat ridden ones, the only thing that has enchantment removal there are the Ether Seals.
|
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Evilsod
How often does a warrior bringing Cleave instead of Eviscerate happen in PvP exactly? Or was it in fact you.
|
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Evilsod
However nice it could be to show your skillbar at the click of a button instead of typing it out, this would just make things worse when you took that 1 skill the leader disagreed with and kicked you.
|
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Evilsod
And exactly why should a Monk always carry Healing Seed? If you want to get the shit kicked out of you because you didn't bring any stances and ran that far away from the monk (even if you are luring) thats your own damn fault, don't rely on us to save your arse all the time, use your brain!
|
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Evilsod
Also, Wild Blow appears on Jade Armours yes, Charr warriors and of course as you seem to have forgotten, Skeleton Berserkers.
|
Now as dag_nefzen pointed out, it would help Ritualists and rangers in case they bring the same spirits.
Song Rui
bump...
Juk3n
Group leader = hi were doing missions and Bonus can u pip ur skill bar?
Me = yeah sure (pips)
Group leader = ahh, k. mm i think u should swap out 4 and 6 it might help out the group a little better.!
Me = yeah maybe, but so far this bar has been the most effective and is a generally strong bar for my class. btw can u pip ur skill bar?
Group leader = i dont have to pip my bar im the "leader" just change ur bar or we cant let u come with us.
oh yeah one more thing..People can just ASK YOU TO TYPE YOUR SKILL BAR so i guess signing or not signing really dosnt matter ^^
Me = Yeah about that..Shove ur skill bar up ur ass and take ur elitist team with it.
/Not signed. i use a very unconventional skill bar, but its very useful in all missions and 99% of the scenarios i get my self into. But i know people would be telling me to get lost if i had to pip them b4 each mission, so i'd rather surprise them with how good the skill bar is when we Rock to a master's reward after.
ps, for all those curious, i play w/r Troll-penetrating-dismember-disrupting-executuioners-Griffons-swift chop-Mel's resilliance(E) 13 axe mastery-11 str-10 wilderness, zealous weapon.
Me = yeah sure (pips)
Group leader = ahh, k. mm i think u should swap out 4 and 6 it might help out the group a little better.!
Me = yeah maybe, but so far this bar has been the most effective and is a generally strong bar for my class. btw can u pip ur skill bar?
Group leader = i dont have to pip my bar im the "leader" just change ur bar or we cant let u come with us.
oh yeah one more thing..People can just ASK YOU TO TYPE YOUR SKILL BAR so i guess signing or not signing really dosnt matter ^^
Me = Yeah about that..Shove ur skill bar up ur ass and take ur elitist team with it.
/Not signed. i use a very unconventional skill bar, but its very useful in all missions and 99% of the scenarios i get my self into. But i know people would be telling me to get lost if i had to pip them b4 each mission, so i'd rather surprise them with how good the skill bar is when we Rock to a master's reward after.
ps, for all those curious, i play w/r Troll-penetrating-dismember-disrupting-executuioners-Griffons-swift chop-Mel's resilliance(E) 13 axe mastery-11 str-10 wilderness, zealous weapon.
Ashleigh McMahon
I've just edited alot of peoples posts, removing bad(and pointless) comments.
If you don't like what someone has said, in the sense that they have offended you in some way or another, please use the report button(!) on the left, and don't take matters into your own hands.
Thanks
Ashleigh
If you don't like what someone has said, in the sense that they have offended you in some way or another, please use the report button(!) on the left, and don't take matters into your own hands.
Thanks
Ashleigh
Faer
Old thread, feature was implemented at least a hundred years ago. Bump & Lock for future archival purposes.
GG Anet.
GG Anet.