for the sheild the req should be betwen 8-11 and the mods, any are good id prefer +health (above 30) and -dmg stance or enchanted

as long as they are gold im good

for the axe id like 13-15% ^50, stance, enchanted
other mods dont matter, req should be same as sheild

if there are no axes (now im sad id like a sword with those req)