PC this 2 zodiac staff and this 2 axe (all gold items)

1)Defensive Zodiac Staff of Enchanting
Energy +10
Earth Dmg:11-22 (Req 10 Earth Magic)
Halves casting time of spells (Chance 10%)
Armor +5
Enchantments last 20% longer

2)Zodiac Staff of Enchanting
Energy +10
Cold Dmg: 11-22 (Req 9 Water Magic)
Halves casting time of Healing Prayers spells (Chance 19%)
Enchantments last 19% longer

3)Cruel Dragoncrest Axe of Enchanting
Slashing Dmg: 6-28 (Req 13 Axe Mastery)
Damage +15% (while Health is above 50%)
lengthens Deep Wound duration on foes by 33%
Enchantments last 19% longer

4)Hevy Gothic Dual Axe of Enchanting
Slashing Dmg: 6-28 (Req 8 Axe Mastery)
Damage +19% /while health is below 50%)
lengthens Weakness duration on foes by 33%
Enchantments last 19% longer

they all suck

plz more opinions

i think number one isnt so bad (i know its req 10)

1 salvage (single modded)
2 salvage (single modded, mod doesnt match the req)
3 ~20k maybe less... not a popular axe and req 13
4 I'd salvage personally but wait for more opinions on that one